I have built and run my own infrastructure from the ground up, and I've been made to transition to the cloud.
The experience hasn't been great. It may simply be sour 'grapes' because, after all the expertise a whole generation has built up learning UNIX, and all the internet protocols (DNS, ARP, Email, reading RFCs, networking, routing) we get told that all that old stuff is just 'legacy,' and that we should retool around amazon's proprietary services instead.
Some of us old timers argued against this only to be shouted down by people who don't even understand TCP/IP.
The current generation couldn't invent the internet. You know why, cos they would never have the patience to spec it out like the old timers did. Go read a few RFCs and try to imagine a scrum team today putting as much thought into an up front design.
Today we'd just cruft together an MVP, solve only the interesting parts (or more likely the easy parts) and then move on, letting dashboards which lie to cover it up.
Many of us have been taking shots at those 'big boys' since the start of this trend.
Now that because of recent events and we have a chance to be heard you're telling us to be quiet. Why?What are you afraid of?
This is a staggering bit of revisionism. As someone who was around at the time, I remember that many RFCs were written based on already-working code. They had some advantages: nobody much cared what they were doing, so they didn't have to answer to multiple levels of management, and they clearly gave almost no thought to security from bad actors, but if you think there aren't people today--including at those very cloud providers you disdain--doing work at least as well-thought-out as those early pioneers, you haven't been paying any attention at all.
I'll stay off your lawn, but maybe take off those rose-colored glasses and stop pretending the past was rosy.
Not that that is a bad thing, but just something to think about.
There's no need to design security in the system when you literally know everyone who is using it. And everyone who was using it had the same goals in mind.
So, I don't disagree with the sentiment -- people today would probably do it a little bit differently; however, I do disagree with the expression -- people designing these protocols weren't naive. They were trustful because they had to be.
In the early days of building something new, nothing works without trust; not the Internet... not Bitcoin... not a nascent venture... nothing.
Because when TCP and it's predecessors were invented there were only a few computers in entire world. In initial ARPAnet there were only 4 hosts (In September 1973 there were 42 computers connected to 36 nodes)
But each computer had many users. That's why there were so many ports, because the thinking was there will be big computers with many users each running their own internet connected clients and servers.
That was true even in the beginning of 1990's, when I want to high school, I had access to Unix shared between 2000+ people.
Throughout the 80s, 90s, and early-to-mid 2000s, there was a certain level of trust in the claims people made about PBs (Personal Bests) and WRs (World Record/Ranking). There was no practical way to record, host, or especially upload literal hours of footage (VHS footage) of a run you did. Even if you did somehow achieve all of the above, it would be a grainy, low quality video which is hard to see, maybe with a stopwatch nearby so people can verify your claim. People would be watching this through RealPlayer, if they could watch it at all!
So what do you do in such a situation where people have no practical or easy means to verify claims? You build credibility off of how active you are with other members of the community. You post and comment on forums about what strategies you're trying, what difficulties you're dealing with, and what new information you might have uncovered through trial and error. You don't prove your work, you prove your worth. Your standing is evidence of your claim.
To me, this is a great example of "personality-credit" communities that's existed online; Usenet and BBS aside. The mentality has largely faded away with improvements to bandwidth and services like Twitch and YouTube, but considering the technological challenges of what someone in say, 1993 would be dealing with in trying to prove they just set a new record can really give a glimpse into what things used to be like.
Yes, of course. Not really any different from the Internet we have today, though.
New cloud products are targeted at new companies and services.
If a company has already invested all of the R&D into building self-hosting and they've got it running properly with well-defined and measurable economics, it doesn't really make sense to upend it all and rebuild in the cloud.
But for new services, embracing hosted platforms is a proven accelerant for development. Skip past the solved problems like hosting, get straight to work on the interesting problems your business is trying to solve.
> The current generation couldn't invent the internet. You know why, cos they would never have the patience to spec it out like the old timers did.
Oh please. This is just "back in my day" ranting about "kids these days" and how you think one generation is superior to the other. Give it up.
Yes, there was also, at various points and times, specs and big-picture thinking, sure.
The fact that the people who could invent the Internet mostly work for a few giants doesn't mean they no longer exist in the current generation.
Your experience with UNIX isn't worthless, but it's worthless to anyone who's working "further up the stack" than you. If you feel like your skills are degrading then you need to find a job somewhere that's actually building infra that shops will build on top of. Your skills aren't day-to-day anymore and that's a good thing. Your generation made all that junk turnkey in the way that you probably think about dealing with Ethernet frames. Taking my first AWS job literally obsoleted all my system's knowledge -- super humbling experience -- it wasn't completely worthless but none of the problems I've spent years working out solutions even existed anymore.
You're confusing people building products with people building infrastructure -- the devops role makes this messy because you're usually "using" infra tools like a dev rather than building them. If you're working on foundational elements then literally nothing has changed. If you're shipping products then absolutely retool around a cloud provider, the infra isn't your secret sauce and if you have to move back on prem because of cost it will be good problems to have.
I mean this completely sincerely, take a job at a company that's providing hosting/services to people. All the old timers with deep deep systems knowledge are gods.
Even though I'm on the side of the "UNIX graybeards" here, this is a super-great point. We do need to recognize that it is a great time to be building networked applications, precisely because the younger ones these days don't need to understand TCP/IP or anything else related to infrastructure.
I confess that I got caught up in the hype as well and built quite a few "multi-AZ" apps that I thought would help me get to five nines that much faster. (for non-cloud folks, that's 99.999% availability, which was something to pursue before the cloud.)
Of course, when those abstractions break, those same younger ones are completely helpless, and my single-server apps have been running non-stop for years at traditional providers except for a few minutes for reboots following updates. I've never had a multi-hour outage, especially one that's completely out of my control where I can only point a finger at AWS and say, "sorry, it's not my fault."
Not to mention the amount of garbage in the cloud, the constant learned helplessness that we have to endure even knowing that the situation could have been avoided or even mitigated/solved if the access to the box was possible.
The status-quo of the cloud is uninspiring to say the least...
I look at the components of a system and think "what happens if this is turned off // breaks in an unusual way // goes slow", and ensure that the predicted effects are known and acceptable based on the likelihood of failure.
That's the same whether it's an AWS managed DNS service, storage bucket, or a raspberry pi on my desk. As a systems engineer I know what that component does, what happens when it doesn't "do", and ensure the business knows how to work around it when it breaks.
If your business can't cope with an AWS outage (even if it's not as efficient) then you've got problems.
Plan for failure, and it doesn't take you by surprise.
Often at work I see code implementations that "work" in that they usually work but can fail. I'm not a great engineer by any means (I'm actually an economist that stumbled into code), but I believe that one of the reasons I've been able to gain a good reputation at work is specifically because I design with that principle in mind.
Losing skills you worked on for years is just part of this space. We are continually building on new abstractions so that we can focus on building solutions.
This really feels like a rant of kids these days. SCRUM doesn’t mean you can’t do upfront design.
4 Microsoft SQL Servers (new hardware for 2 of them) 11 IIS Web Servers (new hardware) 2 Redis Servers (new hardware) 3 Tag Engine servers (new hardware for 2 of the 3) 3 Elasticsearch servers (same) 4 HAProxy Load Balancers (added 2 to support CloudFlare) 2 Networks (each a Nexus 5596 Core + 2232TM Fabric Extenders, upgraded to 10Gbps everywhere) 2 Fortinet 800C Firewalls (replaced Cisco 5525-X ASAs) 2 Cisco ASR-1001 Routers (replaced Cisco 3945 Routers) 2 Cisco ASR-1001-x Routers (new!)S
Virtualization aside, we haven't abandoned basic infrastructure, but centralized it in the hands of a few huge, expert providers. IMO this is a good thing, and was both necessary and natural as the Web grew to offer more and more opportunities to more new professionals. In detaching HTML from HTTP from ARP, etc. we gave rise to entire new professions like full-time UX (which arguably the Old Guard was never good at beyond a small audience of academics and engineers), or various flavors of front-end developer, or serverless ecosystems.
The Web and associated technologies advanced so quickly it was impractical for a single IT or network department to know all of it anymore, and some of the newer webapps wouldn't have been possible if that same team or company had to also manage all of their own basic infrastructure like it was the 90s still.
Now you can be a front-end only shop, or a UX consultant, or a network engineer who never has to touch HTML, or, or, or... maybe big enterprises always had and could always have all of those in-house, but the division of labor has been a huge boon for small businesses and startups and nonprofits, who just don't have the same resources.
As someone who grew up configuring zmodem and running BBSes and having to (mis)configure NetBIOS all the time, I am so, so glad I never have to worry about OSI layers and such ever again. It's boring to me, and the experts at it are SO much better at it, might as well let them handle it. Especially when the cost of that outsourcing is often like <$100/mo. Well worth both the time and money... and sanity. The division of concerns lets you focus on the things you're either interested in and/or good at.
Our professionals haven't gotten worse. The stack has gotten much deeper.
> The current generation couldn't invent the internet.
Come on now, this is an overdone, lame argument and I can't believe you're seriously suggesting this. Do you also lament the fact that kids these days can't bind their own books? The point of tools is to be built upon, not to sit around marveling at your own genius. If you build a good tool, the folks that come after you don't have to think about it. That's how you make progress.
As an old fart myself, this is very cheap argument. Old generation wasn’t superior. Old generation couldn’t invent transistor, how useless we are!
You always move up the stack as tech progress and that’s a good thing.
Is there anything about this particular incident that is new that contributes to your position?
Maybe we run in different tech circles, but I feel like the "on-prem vs. cloud" has been litigated fairly extensively here and elsewhere. In fact, as you said yourself:
"Many of us have been taking shots at those 'big boys' since the start of this trend."
I haven't found it too helpful when dealing with AWS and the serverless trend, whose popularity is really just based on price and economics, not technical superiority.
Serverless turns every simple system into a distributed system with the number of failure modes now multiplied by ten.
That sounds like fun.
I do know how to use serverless for the record, I just think it's an overhyped, overpriced waste of time.
Rather than a late-night panicked run to the smoking server, now we can just shrug and wait a few hours and it fixes itself. Most websites aren't that critical, and it's nice not having to lose sleep over devops issues.
Since Amazon failure modes are so varied, it's impossible to make the above tweaks fully automated. There'll always be a new way the cloud can misbehave, and often your service can at least maintain partial service by being nimble enough.
They take care of all the infrastructure for ya, and if something breaks, you just twiddle your thumbs while they twiddle the dials.
Of course this sort of laziness is not a valid approach if you're a huge enterprise or running some live-saving project that needs seventy nines of uptime, but for non-critical websites, it's a great sigh of relief...
It is even more, making downtime's responsibility somebody else's problem. You can now simply point to AWS is down, AWS is slow, AWS is causing error, and there is nothing we can do about it :). And as long as management knows everyone is having the same problem they are perfectly fine with it.
If you accept that then it means that we need to investigate and scrutinize the whole supply chain of any product before trusting it and it would also mean that any company switching even the smallest part of their supply chain would require us to reevaluate their product.
When we buy things (either products, services or software) we consider the company selling it to be responsible for the whole and deferring responsibility to a vendor is basically just saying that you were either promising more than you knew could deliver or that you did not do a good job picking vendors.
Some of the reasons are no one wants to be seen using old tech; stuck being the last COBOL dev. So there's a big incentive for developers and their managers to be using the latest tech; it looks good on the devs resume and grants them job security in the field, and it makes their managers look like they're sharp and on top of new technology.
Also, recruiting people familiar with AWS services is often easier than finding someone versed in on-prem tech. And for companies in less than desirable locations, this helps remove a staffing issue since it can all be done remotely.
And when something goes wrong on-prem, the CTO is expected by the rest of the C-suite to fix the issue. When it's a reputable 3rd party, he can absolve both himself and his team of responsibility.
Everything up until this sentence makes sense in a twisted sort of way, but that's the part I don't get. When did we absolve companies from their choice of vendors? If I buy a service and that service does not work then the company selling that service does not get to blame their vendors, that they chose, just like they don't get to blame individual devs that they hired.
>just like they don't get to blame individual devs that they hired.
When the vendors become a symbol, a public utility status or practically the only choice. And this isn't a Tech company thing. It can be applied to all other industry. You can fire and hire another Dev. If you are looking at cloud vendor, you only have AWS, Azure and GCP to choose. For lots of reason the latter two may not be an option due to competition or features. And AWS is the best you can get, are you sure the Dev they have are the best they can hire?
The first, I can agree with, but the latter two are definitely not the case. If they were a public utility they would be regulated as one and if they were they only choice there would not be companies online during these outages. The site you are writing this on is an example, an online service with a pretty large (although not massive) following that is online enough to be the place where all the people who work at companies that depend on cloud services come to discuss their outages.
It is not whether they are one as in business or one as in politics that has to be regulated. They are utility like as people treated it as one and it behaves as one. Many things goes down with it with AWS just like many things goes down with the grid.
HN is comparatively tiny and simple. Doesn't requires any of the features on AWS. And has no reliability requirements like SaaS. HN doesn't even use CDN. Even though I am not a cloud advocate for 99% of cases it makes zero sense to build a SaaS with your own Server.
If a restaurant ran out of some menu item for a few days because a supplier didn't have a good harvest, eh, it happens. If a bookstore doesn't stock a certain book, no big deal. Grocery store self-checkout broken yet again? Oh well. Band got too drunk and can't perform? Reschedule it. No snow at the slopes? Climate change.
In the real world, shit happens, and most of it isn't critical.
If you offer a 99.999% guarantee and your customers pay for it, well, you better deliver -- subcontractors or not. But many businesses don't need to do that and a few hours of downtime a year is just a minor inconvenience. To go from "a few days of downtime" to "a few hours" is really easy; just about any provider can offer that. To go from "a few hours of downtime" to "a few seconds" is a huge investment and not worth it to many folks.
Heck, if that was even possible... "everything is green" dashboards... :-)
"We need this new fancy dashboard to monitor our other dashboards in one place, more accurately!"
This is a community of highly technical users expressing legitimate frustration and concern that the biggest player in cloud hosting is
a) having a service impacting event, and
b) the status page says everything is up
That's why people talk about the beneits of alternate hosting arrangements. If the status page said what was happening, there would be no need to ask "is AWS down?" the status would be clear.The problem isn't the cloud, the problem is all of the web properties going down all at once, exacerbated by the fact that AWS charges a premium for any viable cross-region / multi-cloud architecture (given its relatively high egress fees). This is discounting the inter-dependence among AWS services themselves, some of which aren't multi-region (afaik).
Engineers like to build stuff. Historically, running your own infrastructure and configuring servers from the ground up were the building blocks of the internet. These new cloud services took away those building blocks and they had the nerve to charge for it.
In the real world, there are more interesting problems to solve than setting up and maintaining your own servers so it isn't really a complaint. It's actually more fun to get the hosting stuff out of the way and focus on the problem at hand.
HN comments are basically notorious for exaggerating the downsides of hosted services while overplaying the ease and benefits of DIY. A lot of the comments here are similar to the famous Dropbox comment thread where users couldn't understand why anyone would want to use Dropbox when they could simply set up a complicated self-hosted rsync contraption to sync their own files.
> You’re either so new to this stuff to have no experience to remember the days before cloud
I do, and it was much more peaceful.
Everything you can do on "in the cloud" you can do in colocation. Which in the long-run is cheaper, more secure* and it's yours! Including the data.
There are caveats, network, component failure. Investment in to these and you can have a pretty king setup.
The cloud enabled magnitude of email spam, brute-forcing, botnets, security vulnerabilities and much more. Operators are lazy don't want to combat it. Providers are bias, then again you can say that about any business.
People flock to the cloud like it's the greatest thing, when all your buying in to is a expensive price-plan for a company who will happily knock you off their service if you somehow brush up the wrong way and then charge you for a closed account.
I do laugh when something goes wrong for FANG. Partly, I'm cynical and want to see the world burn, but it's also these companies exploit their userbase, their staff and the environments resources. When Facebook locked themselves out of their own offices due to the BGP issue, now that's funny.
My colocation costs are:
$5000 covers for a three-year 1Gbit 2u server racking space in two different DCs. Where I have full-control, as many services as I desire, allowed to host what I desire and where the internet space is actually mine. It may be a small cube of internet but I know it's my network, my traffic.
Cloud is whitewash for me, I won't buy in to it. It has it purposes and if your happy with it, fine. But for me Colo for life.
Also, you should consider renting out space on your cube.
You could even design APIs around the internet protocols so they can create their own DNS records, mailboxes. Wait...
Now, how many people think they can do better than Uber?
1) Like any utility, the cloud is predicated on the assumption that it never goes down. If AWS itself goes down, it causes knock-on effects more most mid-sized (i.e. 1 region, multi-AZ) services on their platform, so we can't have it.
2) If we're going to have to accept downtime (1) then yes, it IS time we rethink the cloud--either how we can achieve no downtime, or how we achieve fault-tolerance in some other way.
Seriously, those commenting “oh boy! Time to rethink this whole cloud thing!” You’re either so new to this stuff to have no experience to remember the days before cloud, you’re trolling because you’re high on nostalgia remembering the good ol’ days (perhaps with some “member berries” https://youtu.be/mPs8-ZBSjok), or you’ve just straight up forgotten what it takes to build and run your own infra from the ground up.
And to those who happen across this comment before posting your own: please contribute something to the discussion beyond the above. Thanks.