News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is running on fumes by Miner49er on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:46AM (#29499630)
Maybe it's a result of wealth inequality and monopolization? If capital gets concentrated into less companies and less individuals, then it makes sense that investing and productivity will also be concentrated into less things. It will be focused on areas that those companies focus on and into areas that those individuals care about.

Take a look at the Nasdaq Composite. Of the 2700 companies in it, six tech companies make up 41% of its entire market cap [0].

[0] https://www.statista.com/chart/22343/nasdaq-100-top-tech-com...

Re:America is running on fumes by old-gregg on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:35PM (#29500373)
> Maybe it's a result of wealth inequality and monopolization?

Well, the author did compare the current rate of innovation to the dawn of the 20th century, when (according to him) we had plenty of new ideas. But wealth inequality in 1900-1920 was comparable to, if not higher, than today. The raise of the middle class in the US didn't happen until after the WW2.

Re:America is running on fumes by johndubchak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:57PM (#29500673)
Additionally, and admittedly without evidentiary support, we could argue that two biggest suppliers of capital investment for innovation used to come from business and Government and largely still do.

However, business has focused on short-term gain for investors and concentrating wealth into the hands of its upper Executives.

Government, at least in the US, has worked itself into a position of partisanship such that deadlock and preventing the other side from doing anything seems to be more important.

These are both short-sighted views and approaches. Scientific discovery takes time, requires consistent investment and a longer-term vision. Quite honestly, I don't think it's a radical view to take to blame the current climate of business and Government in the US for many of the issues we see elucidated here. That being said, the solution is as complex as the problem and would require a major restructuring of both the economy and our Government, IMO.

Re:America is running on fumes by salt-thrower on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:55PM (#29501367)
I think you're spot on with this analysis. I would add that the gridlock in the U.S. government isn't just happenstance, either. An ineffective government benefits Capital (at least in the short term), and thanks to lax lobbying and campaign finance laws, Capital is able to buy enough politicians to ensure that any legislation which would challenge the status quo dies before it reaches the President's desk. Gridlock serves the political and economic elite well, so they're invested in keeping it that way.
Re:America is running on fumes by granshaw on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:00PM (#29500720)
I wonder if a big difference between now and the start of the 20th century is precisely the insane focus on short term return, what with the feedback loops being so much quicker and visibility so much higher
Re:America is running on fumes by johndubchak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:19PM (#29500944)
Great question. It is partly what I suggest, I think...
Re:America is running on fumes by NotSammyHagar on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:22PM (#29502433)
I don't know what you mean "the government" worked its way into a period of partisanship. Sure there is terrible deadlock. One party has moved to an extreme and is trying to dismantle democracy so that it can force things it's way. Only one party has gotten to the situation that previous presidents and leaders in the party are almost uniformly against the future next president from that party.
Re:America is running on fumes by johndubchak on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:11PM (#29503677)
In my eyes, the partisanship is the deadlock. I didn't want to make it a political discussion or turn it into a flame war over blaming one party over another. Both parties, or members on each side, have a vested self-interest in maintaining that deadlock. That's really all I meant.
Re:America is running on fumes by sul_tasto on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#29501433)
Our contemporary “captains of industry” don’t build universities, cultural centers or museums the way they did in the guided age.
Re:America is running on fumes by b9a2cab5 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:45PM (#29501993)
Instead they invest in scientific R&D in areas they care about (i.e. anti-aging, Alzheimer's research, long-shot AI, space, etc)

Arguably this is better for humanity than building another museum that's going to decay 50 years from now.

Re:America is running on fumes by sul_tasto on Thursday December 09, 2021 @09:23PM (#29505741)
good point
Re:America is running on fumes by MomoXenosaga on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:43PM (#29501964)
Education is no longer the ticket for poor people to escape. The rich invest in getting their kids to university. We are creating a self-sustaining nobility again.
Re:America is running on fumes by zepto on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:50AM (#29499685)
> It will be focused on areas that those companies focus on and into areas that those individuals care about.

I think it’s not about what anyone cares about. It’s about what’s competitive. Even those at the top of the wealth pyramid are subject to these forces.

I think (extreme) wealth inequality is partly a consequence, rather than a cause her.

Creating a global competition through literal economic globalization and the collapse of distance brought about by the internet means we have the entire world competing in a small number of linked domains, rather the than many independent competitive realms that existed before.

Re:America is running on fumes by dv_dt on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:19PM (#29500163)
In systemic feedback loops, issues can be both cause and effect. As is the case for wealth inequality here imho.
Re:America is running on fumes by zepto on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:11PM (#29501573)
It’s part of the feedback loop but it’s not a cause.

Intervening to alleviate inequality directly won’t change the other dynamics.

Re:America is running on fumes by redisman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#29500229)
Wage growth has flatlined for 30+ years!

What happened to the middle class and the American dream? There it is.

Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:42PM (#29500466)
Average total employee compensation has significantly increased over the past 30 years once you factor in employer contributions to health insurance premiums. Essentially our collective raises have been eaten up by increased healthcare costs. Now we do get some tangible benefits from that in terms of expensive treatments which weren't even available 30 years ago. But there's also a huge amount of waste and inefficiency.
Re:America is running on fumes by danaris on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:44PM (#29500507)
> Average total employee compensation has significantly increased over the past 30 years once you factor in employer contributions to health insurance premiums.

Putting it that way is very misleading, though. The "total compensation" has increased only because health care costs have increased massively, and health insurance has increased to cover it. (Or vice versa; causality's tricky in a system like this, and there are definitely feedback loops.)

Re:America is running on fumes by lotsofpulp on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:54PM (#29500634)
Which is a function of the amount of healthcare delivered greatly increasing (and/or potential to be a recipient of increased amount of healthcare in the event of an emergency).
Re:America is running on fumes by danaris on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:07PM (#29500812)
No, it's really not. The costs of healthcare have increased massively in the last 2 decades or so without a concomitant increase in the quality of care.
Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:22PM (#29500978)
It depends what you're looking at. For example new chemotherapy drugs have slightly extended average survival periods for certain cancers. But they're tremendously expensive, and that drives up insurance premiums for everyone. Are those drugs worth it? Ultimately the answer is subjective based on how we value human life.

One could also argue that those drugs should be cheaper, but without the profit motive they likely wouldn't have been developed in the first place. And socialized funding of drug development hasn't worked out well either.

Re:America is running on fumes by greedo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:49PM (#29502037)
The primary chemo drug I was treated with in 2005 was over 50 years old. Yet it still cost me approximately $100k.
Re:America is running on fumes by mandmandam on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:00PM (#29501449)
Drug development is heavily, heavily subsidized by taxpayers.

Ghouls have managed to privatize the profits, but every drug, technique and device ever developed is standing on the shoulders of giant public funding.

Re:America is running on fumes by sleepybrett on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:45PM (#29501254)
Except that many minimum wage jobs do not provide health-care coverage.
Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:08PM (#29501545)
Due to the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare), more minimum wage jobs provide healthcare coverage than did so 30 years ago. Most employers are now required to offer that to all full-time employees regardless of wage level. There are still gaps and affordability problems but overall coverage is now more available to such workers.
Re:America is running on fumes by lovich on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:39PM (#29502614)
Luckily for the employers they can just schedule you for 30 minutes less than full time!

I went years post Obama care passing where I would be working 75 hours a week but with no healthcare because each job would cut me off at 38.5 hours on the dot. Managers would walk out and escort you to the time clock if you were coming up on full time hours

Re:America is running on fumes by redisman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:47PM (#29502013)
Ok so it’s been eaten by inflation. That’s exactly the point
Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:16PM (#29503056)
Inflation is only part of the cost increase. More healthcare services are now being delivered than 30 years ago. If your grocery bill goes up because you're eating more food that's not inflation, it's increased consumption.

The problem is that now many workers are paying more and actually getting less. They're essentially subsidizing healthcare for the indigent and patients with expensive chronic conditions. Personally I think those subsidies ought to be funded by progressive income taxes, but that's a matter of debate.

Re:America is running on fumes by goodpoint on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:24PM (#29501014)
Average income is completely unrelated to inequality.

0.1% of the population is getting richer and 95% of the population is getting poorer.

The middle class is quickly disappearing, the low-income class is growing fast.

Re:America is running on fumes by marcusverus on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:06PM (#29501529)
> 0.1% of the population is getting richer and 95% of the population is getting poorer.

Do you have any data to support this? Fed data shows household wealth doubling for the bottom 50%, just since 2008. Households in the 50-90th percentiles also nearly doubled.

https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/dataviz/dfa/distr...

Re:America is running on fumes by dantheman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:37PM (#29500402)
More people have moved up and out of the middle class, than down and out. I'd argue taxes and the bloat in industries such as education, healthcare, and real estate are the driving causes -- all heavily regulated and subsidized by the government.
Re:America is running on fumes by micromacrofoot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:02PM (#29500739)
are you really blaming healthcare bloat on the government and not the colossal for-profit industry that the vast majority of healthcare is funneled through?
Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:13PM (#29501596)
The US healthcare system has just enough private ownership to allow private interests to profit from it, just enough public involvement to get taxpayers to pay for it, and just enough regulation in the right places to conceal who pays for treatment and to disconnect incentives.

Go all public and expand Medicare and move to a single-payer system like Canada and the UK. Or go all private by killing Medicare altogether, fixing Medicaid as a public backstop, and heavily regulating pricing and doctors' salaries and insurance premiums like Germany and Switzerland. But anything is more humane than the weird mix the US has come up with.

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway0a5e on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:46PM (#29501275)
They go hand in hand. Ever heard of "regulatory capture"?

The government is very involved in restricting the supply side of healthcare.

Re:America is running on fumes by micromacrofoot on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:47PM (#29502019)
Oh sure, but when people blame "the government" it's usually a thinly veiled suggestion that "less government" is the solution.

The money that pushes this regulatory capture comes largely from health insurance companies, which might be the most vile industry I'm obligated to interact with on a regular basis. This is an industry that for a long period of time would refuse to cover health conditions simply because you were born with them.

Re:America is running on fumes by etchalon on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:14PM (#29500892)
It's a fairly standard argument, that makes absolutely no sense.
Re:America is running on fumes by ido on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29500538)
Aren't taxes lower than they used to be?
Re:America is running on fumes by tharne on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:03PM (#29500753)
Only at the federal level, which is not the majority of taxes for most people. State taxes and local property tax are significantly higher than they used to be in most places in the U.S. Other things like sales tax, fees, permits, fines, etc. have all likewise increased substantially.
Re:America is running on fumes by shkkmo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#29501418)
> Only at the federal level, which is not the majority of taxes for most people.

You are gonna have to cite some sources for this because my understanding is that total federal taxes is the majority of total taxes, if only by a slim margin.

Re:America is running on fumes by handrous on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:15PM (#29501624)
My guess, without looking at the data, would be that this is one of those things that's true if you don't count FICA (i.e. Social Security + Medicare) as a tax, but false if you do count those as taxes.
Re:America is running on fumes by evan_ on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:10PM (#29500842)
but have state and local taxes gone up enough that they've counteracted the drop in federal taxes?
Re:America is running on fumes by tharne on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:22PM (#29500982)
In my case, yes, though obviously that depends on where you live. You can also make the argument that it's better to have low federal taxes and high state and local taxes than to have the reverse, since it's much easier to leave a high tax state or town than it is to immigrate to another country.
Re:America is running on fumes by goodpoint on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:25PM (#29501030)
> More people have moved up and out of the middle class, than down and out

Citation needed.

Re:America is running on fumes by marcusverus on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#29501711)
In 1971 the middle class made up 61% of the population. By 2016 the number had declined to 52%. Of the 9% who left the middle class, 5% rose into the 'upper class', while 4% fell into the lower.

https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/09/06/the-america...

Re:America is running on fumes by ryandvm on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:34PM (#29500345)
Moving out of the country is the new American Dream
Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:44PM (#29500508)
Is there any evidence that people are striving en masse to leave America? It seems like the vast majority of the world is trying to get in.

The US has the 5th highest median income in the world, so I don't think mass exodus is likely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:15PM (#29500902)
> It seems like the vast majority of the world is trying to get in.

This is a common trope but only kinda-sorta true.

It's definitely true that there is no sign of mass exodus. Net immigration number remain positive (3% ish) but they are well below historic highs, and currently declining YoY. See e.g. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/net-...

It's interesting I think that per capita Canada (e.g. another "new world" immigration target) has fairly consistently been much higher, and is currently near 2x. The approx 10x population size dwarfs this in total numbers though (https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/CAN/canada/net-migrati...)

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:17PM (#29501655)
I would imagine that the net immigration rate indicates immigration policy of the host country and not the external demand to immigrate, but even if it did indicate that the demand to enter was declining that doesn't refute that the absolute demand is relatively low compared to other countries (Shaq might be getting shorter but that doesn't mean he's short), which is to say that my original claim isn't just "kinda sorta true" but rather, "strictly true".
Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:16PM (#29502363)
> ... and not the external demand to immigrate,

It's got to be a mix of both, no?

> that my original claim isn't just "kinda sorta true" but rather, "strictly true".

I don't think we are really disagreeing. My point was that the common trope about US being the only place everyone wants to go has never really been true, but that especially by net amounts, it has been and remains a popular immigration target, albeit not as much as it has in the past.

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:12PM (#29503002)
> It's got to be a mix of both, no?

Not as far as I can tell. The rate of immigration is the lesser of “how many people are willing to migrates the host country” and “how many migrants the host country will accept” and I would be shocked if the latter number was not many multiples of the former number.

> My point was that the common trope about US being the only place everyone wants to go has never really been true

I’ve heard some outlandish things under the rubric of American exceptionalism, but I’ve never once heard anyone—not even my most nationalistic acquaintances nor Fox News/etc—say that the US was the only place anyone wants to go. Who are the people who believe/espouse this?

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:51PM (#29504779)
> Not as far as I can tell.

It depends a bit if you have absolute quotas, or thresholds/scoring.

> some outlandish things under the rubric of American exceptionalism,

I was unclear, apologies. The idea isn't that nobody goes anywhere else, obviously. The idea, which I have heard many times in the US, is that once someone has decided to immigrate, all else being equal they would obviously choose the US. Clearly most times all else isn't equal; but it also doesn't seem to be true...

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:02PM (#29505232)
> The idea, which I have heard many times in the US, is that once someone has decided to immigrate, all else being equal they would obviously choose the US

Fair enough, but even still I’ve never heard that even among “Fuck yeah, ‘merica” types.

Re:America is running on fumes by rich_sasha on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#29501422)
The few times I thought about moving to America, the thing that ultimately put me off wasn’t healthcare, guns or food, but the utterly hostile immigration process.

It seems that until you get a green card, the state barely tolerates your presence.

So nothing to do with the fundamentals, for me anyway.

Re:America is running on fumes by dnautics on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:08PM (#29501549)
well, if I'm not mistaken -- the US' immigration process awfulness pales in comparison, to, say the UK. I believe AUS/NZ have inherited similarly complex, kafkaesque systems. I don't know for sure, because I only have experience with the UK's (and failed to get in despite having a PhD AND having a job with money set aside waiting for me); but I have worked side-by-side with H1B holders who said "it was bad but not that bad".
Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#29501710)
The Canadian immigration system, especially if you qualify for the skilled workers program (which most engineers do), is pretty decent overall, and much much better than the awful and outdated US system. I've looked at immigrating to the US and decided it's largely impossible. This largely explains Canada's immigration edge - it certainly isn't societal issues. I'd much sooner have immigrated to the US given the pay and tax differences.

I've actually heard good things about the AU system too - apparently Canada considers AU&NZ their biggest competition in attracting immigrants.

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#29502029)
> it certainly isn't societal issues

That seems to be pretty variable; I've met people on both sides of that border that decided against the other one for "societal issues" of various types.

Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:46PM (#29502699)
If you're poor, Canada is a pretty good deal. If you're middle-class, it's ok. If you're upper-middle-class (top 10% in income) it's better to be in the US.
Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:57PM (#29502829)
> If you're upper-middle-class (top 10% in income) it's better to be in the US.

It's not all about income, and it's really as simple as that. IIRC marginal tax rates in some parts of US are higher than some parts of Canada. So, as usual, it depends.

On average I don't think you are wrong, btw - but it's hardly cut and dried.

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:33PM (#29504607)
> "and it's really as simple as that."

Probably obvious, but : and it's really not as simple as that.

Re:America is running on fumes by rich_sasha on Friday December 10, 2021 @10:11AM (#29510774)
Thankfully I never had to navigate (much) the UK process. Sorry to hear about your torments...
Re:America is running on fumes by dzonga on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:46PM (#29513810)
well one positive thing about the UK immigration system after brexit it's now much easier and straighforward. sort of points based. much clearer, no h1b lottery to deal with like you would if you were trying to get in the states.
Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:24PM (#29501750)
It seems that until you get a green card, the state barely tolerates your presence.

And good luck even getting to that point. If you have a family, you'll have to live without them for upwards of 10 years while you work alone in the US waiting for your number to come up in the lottery.

Re:America is running on fumes by mensetmanusman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:45PM (#29503369)
Pew research estimated ~700 million are interested were the borders to be completely opened.
Re:America is running on fumes by gruez on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29500531)
How does this square with the fact that the US is the #1 destination for immigrants?

https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/top...

Re:America is running on fumes by spacedcowboy on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:50PM (#29502050)
Well, if they're immigrants, they're not part of the "American dream" corpus, right ? Americans are dreaming of moving out, is what was said.

America still has more to offer than a lot of the world, but it's not some shining peak in a valley of despair - it's more "middle of the table, some good, some bad". If you're here already, it's easy to look out, see, and decide to move where it's better, if you can.

Me ? I'm a Brit, been living here for the last almost two decades. I came here for the money and the weather, nothing more. Recently, the weather is a bit crap; the money's still good, but once I get to where I can FIRE, I'm out of this country. There's plenty of places better.

Re:America is running on fumes by nostrademons on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:16PM (#29502365)
The American Dream has always been intimately tied in with the immigrant experience. People would leave their homes in Europe because they dreamt that America was a land of freedom and opportunity. It was a term largely setup in opposition to the rigid social structures of 19th-century Europe.

Arguably the American Dream is very much intact, it's just that it's mostly brown & yellow people achieving it. I have a lot of friends who left their home country because there were no opportunities for them there, and now have the suburban house with a yard, 2 kids, white picket fence, neighborhood Trick'or'Treaters, good savings, and vacations whenever they need a break. They work very hard for what they have, which has always been part of the American Dream, but they get a good life in exchange for it.

Re:America is running on fumes by armenarmen on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:58PM (#29500689)
It doesn’t, but it sounds clever on Twitter
Re:America is running on fumes by UncleSlacky on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:40PM (#29503311)
Re:America is running on fumes by gruez on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:28PM (#29503855)
yeah, the link in my comment already covers this. I deliberately didn't mention that because a bunch of the top countries seem to be countries with questionable labor practices involving migrant workers, eg. UAE, kuwait, or saudi arabia, or are microstates. The fact that microstates top the list also points to a flaw with the % capita methodology. Is Liechtenstein really the best country to move to?
Re:America is running on fumes by redisman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#29502032)
It’s a lot easier to achieve the dream when you’re moving from a poor country (large delta). For Americans social mobility has grown increasingly difficult
Re:America is running on fumes by vineyardmike on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:55PM (#29502092)
While i'm not sure i agree with the parent, i know a lot of people who left the US and a lot of people who arrived, so i think i can square the circle.

1. People leave worse places (by some metric, usually poverty or opportunity) to come to US since its big and rich and full of potential. That is why immigrants come here. Its the richest big nation with lots of jobs. You can try to move to china or brazil or india which have massive populations, but the jobs pay better here. You can move to Switzerland or some EU nations that have higher avg salary, but the COL is high and immigration is even harder with less lucrative job openings available.

2. People leaving aren't the immigrants who arrived (not including returning to old country). People who "have the american dream of leaving" are the middle class white kids who don't see their own growth into top 10% of society (because they perceive their social mobility decreasing or gone), and see the exploding debt and health costs across america (often they haven't experienced directly), so they want to move to a socialized nation and "free healthcare". This is almost always a white euro nation, not eg. china or inida. Do they move? Not always.

TLDR. People still want to move to america, but some americans are basically chasing some ideal/privilege they think they can get better elsewhere.

Re:America is running on fumes by cultofmetatron on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:37PM (#29512826)
as an expat and son of immigrants myself, I guess i'm uniquely qualified to answer that.

Economic opportunities in america are great if you're willing to work your ass off and smartly. Smartly is the keyword to avoiding exploitation. That said, the wages here are way higher than in other countries. Here in Colombia, the minimum wage comes out to around $250/month. People here don't have much choice given the language barrier and lack of skills for the international market. Their skillset and ability to endure absolute crap gives them an edge when they immigrate to the US and get paid relatively descent wages for their work.

Now I'm on the other end. I have skills as a software engineer, fluency in english and connections. Those are all things I can take with me to maintain the smae wage I'd be making in america in a country where the average wage is a fraction of what I make. Thus I get to live like a king.

TLDR: both sides are moving to maximize their living potential and they increase for different reasons.

Re:America is running on fumes by autokad on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:45PM (#29501245)
immigrants don't want to live here. They want to take the money and leave.
Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#29501709)
Maybe that's what immigrants think when they first arrive, but very few actually move back to their home countries. Despite the negatively pushed by the media elites, most of the USA is still a pretty nice place to live.
Re:America is running on fumes by tharne on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:04PM (#29500772)
If that were true, why is it so rare? Even during bad periods in the U.S. there's never been significant levels of out migration, the way you see with other countries.
Re:America is running on fumes by clarkmoody on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:52PM (#29500613)
Obligatory link to WTF Happened in 1971? [0]

TL;DR: many of these economic problems are tied to disconnecting the currency from gold, which screws up interest rates and incentives throughout the economy.

[0]: https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:05PM (#29500781)
> many of these economic problems are tied to disconnecting the currency from gold,

By tied, you really mean correlated. There is at minimum no consensus on the idea that this was causal.

Re:America is running on fumes by larsiusprime on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29500530)
This is basically Thomas Piketty's conclusion, but Rognlie shows that most of the outsized returns to "capital" are actually from housing/real estate once you properly factor in depreciation of capital assets:

https://www.brookings.edu/bpea-articles/deciphering-the-fall... https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2015a_r...

Re:America is running on fumes by estro0182 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:52AM (#29499719)
I was just going to comment with something similar, but more focused on the individual's inability to think creatively because they're just trying to survive on an increasingly inflated-away income. Poverty has a profound effect on creative thinking, and increasingly more of America creeps towards poverty. The author throws one sentence out there on this, then moves on to top-down excuses for lack of innovation.
Re:America is running on fumes by bjtitus on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:36PM (#29500394)
The problem with this theory is that the current top-weighting is not all that much higher than during previous historical periods. There's a decent overview [0] covering the historical S&P 500's highest concentrations of the top 10 stocks which ranged from a low of 17.5% in 2014 to a high of 25.5% in 1980. It's a little under 30% today. Needless to say, the returns over the decades following 1980 were some of the most consistently positive in history [1].

[0] https://www.yahoo.com/now/top-heavy-stock-indexes-nothing-09...

[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/2526/sp-500-historical-annual-re...

Re:America is running on fumes by specialist on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:09PM (#29502279)
Prior monopolies invested. Because of tax code. And corporate remits were limited. Probably a few other reasons.

All those guard rails were eliminated. So current monopolies do stock buybacks.

All that excess idle wealth, too much capital chasing too few investments, has to go somewhere. Causing asset bubbles. Stocks, real estate, cryptocurrencies, artwork.

If we want more investment, we have to address idle wealth. Disincentivize hoarding wealth. Keep the money moving. Reduce the impedance mismatch between funds (too big) and investment opportunities (too small); like apply the YC strategy far and wide.

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:02PM (#29500740)
There’s an angle that a lot of these discussions tend to miss. We are running out of easy energy. The step change in civilization we observed in the past 200 years was because we found an abundant source of energy.

Ideas don’t build sky scrapers energy does. If you don’t believe me you can look up the per capita energy consumption per American and observe that it is basically stagnant since 1970. Which is also curiously the date since when the American dream started to fade.

We got around this by outsourcing some activities to economies with a low energy intensity, loading up on debt and improving the energy efficiency of our devices. But these cannot result in the kind of step change improvements that we got used to over the last century.

Why have we seen such amazing progress in computing and the internet ? Moores law allows us to extract twice as much compute for the same energy every 18 months. The energy burned by a transistor scales with its area. This is nothing short of miraculous. It’s as if your car doubled its mileage every 2 years. This has allowed computing to cheat the stagnation in energy we have been seeing elsewhere. When compute gets cheaper transporting information gets cheaper as well as it is computers that transport the information. Hence the biggest growth industry continues to be technology and the internet. Batteries or solar panels do not double every 18 months. Batteries have barely moved in comparison. The newer iPhones feel heavier after they made the battery bigger.

There was a fear for a time that “Peak Oil” would lead to some kind of a total collapse. The reality is more of a slow burn stagnation as we wring the oil out of ever deeper deposits.

The much heralded green transition got a dose of reality this year in Europe as they realized how reliant they are on natural gas to not freeze to death.

Building tens of thousands of Nuclear plants is far from trivial although it is in theory possible.

We will in general struggle to maintain the standards of living we currently have especially as we expand it to the broader population. This is a harsh truth many don’t want to confront. Perhaps the elites realize this and have decided to squeeze every last drop out of the orange so they can experience the growth that was once the norm for all first worlders. The elites being the top 2-5 %.

The entire third world that was looted and colonized is also now stepping up to claim its fair share of global resources. The more they develop the higher energy prices will go. And yet it is inevitable.

Hence I struggle to see how first world living standards will not stagnate even in the presence of interesting new technologies and breakthroughs. The meta verse might be the answer as a simulation of prosperity may be cheaper than actual prosperity. It might also explain why everything is moving into the virtual world. Energy constraints apply a lot less here.

And don’t get me started on Climate Change.

Re:America is running on fumes by dntrkv on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:36PM (#29501149)
> If you don’t believe me you can look up the per capita energy consumption per American and observe that it is basically stagnant since 1970

I think the more likely explanation for that is optimization. Look at cars as an example. In the first half of the century, we built cars without much of a focus on fuel economy. As we scaled up the amount of cars we produced and in turn, the oil resources we consumed, we began to optimize the efficiency of these cars. Compare a car from 1970 and 2020, and you see a much more reliable, efficient, safe, comfortable car. So the per capita consumption has been reduced by using less gas and also having to replace the cars less often while providing a better quality of life.

There are similar stories across every industry.

So I don't see how looking at our per-capita energy-use as a major contributor in this discussion. That's not to say energy prices have had no effect, but I could make the opposite argument that energy prices have forced us to innovate past burning things we find in the ground.

As far as renewables go, I'm not an expert in this space, but it seems like we have the technology and resources to implement a reliable green energy grid. We just don't have the political will to do so.

If we had the political cohesion to muster up an equivalent to the Interstate Highway System project, but for energy generation/transmission, it would propel us into a new era.

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:41PM (#29501188)
How much more efficient can a car become ? It’s not as much of a change as going from horses to cars.
Re:America is running on fumes by dntrkv on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:55PM (#29501369)
Average efficiency of a car in 1970 was 11 MPG. Today we are at an average of 25 MPG (and that's only because gas is still too cheap) and many non-electric cars get up to 40 MPG. Newer electric cars like the Model 3 are at about 130-150 MPG.

As the transition to electric cars accelerates, our energy use will see a significant decline. Transportation makes up 35% of our total energy use in the US. Going from an average of 25 MPG to a conservative 50 MPG will have major impacts on our energy sector.

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:43PM (#29503347)
Electric cars are only a fraction of transportation energy costs. Electric trailer trucks and electric airplanes are far less feasible because of the poor energy density of batteries.

I’m also talking about the cost of the car itself. Sure there are improvements but they are not improving at the rates they used to.

An electric car is still too expensive for a lot of people around the world.

Re:America is running on fumes by adrianN on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:19PM (#29500949)
We're not running out of easy energy at all. Renewable energy is quite easy and we'll never run out while the sun has hydrogen left. Economic growth has increasingly been decoupled from increases in energy use (at least in developed nations).
Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:21PM (#29500963)
The energy is there but it’s too expensive to extract store and distribute compared to Saudi Arabian oil. Hydrocarbons are not just a source of energy. They are also a storage mechanism that can also fuel their own transportation and distribution. There’s probably not enough rare minerals on the earth to build enough batteries to take care of all global transportation, electricity and heating let alone future needs.

Nuclear - fission and then fusion are the only way out.

Re:America is running on fumes by WorldMaker on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:34PM (#29503939)
Rare Earth minerals? Today's batteries are wonders of using cheap, easily available "junk". Lithium the ingredient so important and prevalent it's in the name (Lithium-Ion batteries) is the third element on the Periodic table and per-boring chemistry reasons assuredly also the third most common in the universe since the big bang. Nickel is so common we named one of the most boring and cheapest units of US currency after it. Cobalt was a pretty/shiny "waste product" of Nickel and other mining, with a long history of being used for pretty blue paint.

None of those things are "rare earth minerals" by almost any definition and are relatively plentiful. Definitely none of them are in the zone on the Periodic table specifically named the "rare earth metals" either (though those are often important in magnetic machines like MRI scanners, so maybe you are confused about what part of the electromagnetic field batteries are typically working with?).

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:07PM (#29504885)
We need more Nickel than the known global reserves to make enough batteries to replace just transportation.

https://youtu.be/DU6gWZav2T8 (46 minutes into this video. Whole video is an eye opener)

Re:America is running on fumes by adrianN on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:26PM (#29501776)
I don't think you want to use our current battery tech to store large amounts of energy. I'd go with hydrogen or perhaps synthetic methane instead, because we can reuse much of the existing natural gas infrastructure.
Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:22PM (#29503120)
Hydrogen is a potential solution but it’s very difficult to store and transport.
Re:America is running on fumes by adrianN on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:20AM (#29507315)
It's a little more difficult to store and transport than methane, yes. If that turns out to be a deal breaker, you can always upgrade the hydrogen to methane using atmospheric CO2. You lose a bit of efficiency, but perhaps that's cheaper than upgrading the storage and transport infrastructure.
Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:17AM (#29509467)
These steps reduce the efficiency of the fuel.
Re:America is running on fumes by adrianN on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:07AM (#29518596)
Yes, I said that. Efficiency doesn't matter, only cost matters. They correlate, but they're not the same.
Re:America is running on fumes by Stranger43 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:32PM (#29502547)
you done need rare earth minerals to store energy at a massive scale you need more of those https://www.electricmountain.co.uk/ but those aren't cheap, wont be build by private industry, and is so ancient a technology that the startup scene will play no part in it.

Otherwise you are right the really big problem right now is that we don't have a suitable replacement for oil that wont also change society in ways nobody is willing to deal with yet.

Fission is not going to be small and safe enough to really replace oil, fusion does not yet exists in the real world, so were probably stuck with renewable untransportable energy infrastructure for any future growth.

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:19PM (#29503087)
Here’s some math

Electric mountain is pumped hydro electric storage. It can store 9 gigwatt hours of electricity.

The UKs total energy consumption is 1650 Terawatt hours. Let’s say you need to store 4 days worth of energy to account for any shocks. That’s 22 terawatt hours of energy.

You’d need to build 2500 electric mountains to store just 4 days of UK energy consumption. And 4 days is a dangerously low buffer for when things go wrong.

Re:America is running on fumes by mensetmanusman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:46PM (#29503389)
We aren’t running out of easy energy, $/kwhr solar is now the cheapest energy source ever developed by humanity.

Had the west actually supported building things instead of supporting NIMBY-isms, we would be even faster on our way to TWhr installations.

Re:America is running on fumes by thewarrior on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:04PM (#29503596)
Cheapest source of generating electricity. Storage, distribution and conversion costs not included.
Re:America is running on fumes by Miner49er on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:18PM (#29500933)
This is a really interesting way of looking at it that I hadn't considered.
Re:America is running on fumes by keewee7 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:56PM (#29500658)
>Take a look at the Nasdaq Composite. Of the 2700 companies in it, six tech companies make up 41% of its entire market cap

That is not saying much. NASDAQ Composite includes everyone and their grandma.

The rest is just Pareto's principle in action.

Re:America is running on fumes by narcraft on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:51PM (#29500593)
It's almost certainly not a result of wealth inequality and monopolization
Re:America is running on fumes by honkycat on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:53PM (#29500620)
Lol I came here to say this.

For many people, there is no comfort. For many people there is no hope for a future.

99% of Americans may be running on fumes, but the 1% are running on plutonium.

Re:America is running on fumes by memling on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:42PM (#29501201)
> For many people there is no hope for a future.

What is the object of that hope? I.e., what are people hoping for in the future?

(Yes, this is a bit of a vague question that requires a lot of speculation. If you're willing, humor me?)

Re:America is running on fumes by ridgeguy on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:28PM (#29501793)
I'll try -

Top level: reliable access to a home, food and clean water, education, medical care, employment. Doesn't cover everyone's want list, but to many of us, a future without those feels a lot different from one with them.

Re:America is running on fumes by mensetmanusman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:50PM (#29503430)
That’s an interesting direct question, because it definitely depends on one’s worldview.

E.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hope_(virtue)#Overview covers a religious view, but I would also be interested if there were writings by secular folks in the current context of complete nihilism (which seems to have the ‘don’t ask that question’ approach to life).

Re:America is running on fumes by honkycat on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:48PM (#29501295)
A safe and secure world for their children to flourish in.
Re:America is running on fumes by sjwalter on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:41PM (#29506471)
I think that's part of the problem. I think we're already living in incredibly safe times, and a focus on even more safety and security is what's causing some good chunk of the malaise we're all experiencing.

I want my kids to increasingly face more insecurity and unsafety. This way they become more and more resilient and able to deal with the future without me.

Re:America is running on fumes by honkycat on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:24AM (#29507339)
"the suburbs dream of violence. Asleep in their drowsy villas, sheltered by benevolent shopping malls, they wait patiently for the nightmares that will wake them into a more passionate world."

I want you to reach out to someone who has experienced violence in their community and ask them how it made them a stronger more capable person. There are plenty. They probably will not be the "real man" you are envisioning.

The worst people to meet on the battlefield in the past? It wasn't the "resilient" professional soldiers who lived through tough times. It was the kings and princes training in comfort, decked out in their armor worth a fortune surrounded by their expensive personal guard. Everyone else suffered.

"hard times make hard men" is not a coherent worldview. It is propaganda to cast "other" people as effete in order to convince you some other group of people are "real men". You know. The ones who do all the exact same shit as the "girly men" but are also willing to sell you overpriced supplements and coffee.

"I want my kids to increasingly face more insecurity and unsafety." What a joke. I hope your children are never unsafe and you never have to learn what a foolish thing this is to say.

Re:America is running on fumes by sjwalter on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:27AM (#29527596)
I never said violence.

It's like this: I'm originally from Ontario. Every year, a few drunk teenagers drown while boating. It's a big tragedy, and I'd hate it if it happened to my kids.

Now, Ontario's politicians respond predictably to this, every year: A call for more safety. This comes in the form of stricter regulations and more enforcement. Now what it means is that whenever my family and I take the boat out for a spin, more than half the time we're stopped by police boats who have to check yes, we have our safety gear, no we haven't been drinking, no that's not pot you smell.

And yet, a few teenagers die drinking while boating that same year.

We'll never live in a zero-risk world, and what I desire is an acceptance of that.

My kids ride dirtbikes and hang out with livestock and shoot guns. They do all manner of dangerous things. More kids and more people should all do this and stop living in some dreamworld where the government makes them safe.

Re:America is running on fumes by beauzero on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:04PM (#29501511)
Death is their only challenge.
Re:America is running on fumes by guerrilla on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:40PM (#29501925)
I'm always up for an anti-capitalist take but I should remind you that Bell Labs was the spawn of an actual and massive monopoly. You'd have to explain that.
Re:America is running on fumes by cturner on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:00PM (#29500718)
fewer
Re:America is running on fumes by iriri8 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:57PM (#29500679)
Of course it’s wealth inequality

Wealth is agency

Those who have it have diverse opportunities for agency at their disposal

Those that don’t have paycheck to paycheck and inflation concerns

When are the science minded going to look beyond cultural ephemera and realize the emotional depths at which relativity impacts life

Ignorant people can’t know to fight for healthcare if they’re never allowed to experience good healthcare

It’s such a joke this culture would call itself science minded while clearly building a traditional wealth caste

Re:America is running on fumes by dantheman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:35PM (#29500380)
Maybe it's the mountains of regulation and just general nonsense.