News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is running on fumes by ryandvm on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:34PM (#29500345)
Moving out of the country is the new American Dream
Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:44PM (#29500508)
Is there any evidence that people are striving en masse to leave America? It seems like the vast majority of the world is trying to get in.

The US has the 5th highest median income in the world, so I don't think mass exodus is likely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:15PM (#29500902)
> It seems like the vast majority of the world is trying to get in.

This is a common trope but only kinda-sorta true.

It's definitely true that there is no sign of mass exodus. Net immigration number remain positive (3% ish) but they are well below historic highs, and currently declining YoY. See e.g. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/net-...

It's interesting I think that per capita Canada (e.g. another "new world" immigration target) has fairly consistently been much higher, and is currently near 2x. The approx 10x population size dwarfs this in total numbers though (https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/CAN/canada/net-migrati...)

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:17PM (#29501655)
I would imagine that the net immigration rate indicates immigration policy of the host country and not the external demand to immigrate, but even if it did indicate that the demand to enter was declining that doesn't refute that the absolute demand is relatively low compared to other countries (Shaq might be getting shorter but that doesn't mean he's short), which is to say that my original claim isn't just "kinda sorta true" but rather, "strictly true".
Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:16PM (#29502363)
> ... and not the external demand to immigrate,

It's got to be a mix of both, no?

> that my original claim isn't just "kinda sorta true" but rather, "strictly true".

I don't think we are really disagreeing. My point was that the common trope about US being the only place everyone wants to go has never really been true, but that especially by net amounts, it has been and remains a popular immigration target, albeit not as much as it has in the past.

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:12PM (#29503002)
> It's got to be a mix of both, no?

Not as far as I can tell. The rate of immigration is the lesser of “how many people are willing to migrates the host country” and “how many migrants the host country will accept” and I would be shocked if the latter number was not many multiples of the former number.

> My point was that the common trope about US being the only place everyone wants to go has never really been true

I’ve heard some outlandish things under the rubric of American exceptionalism, but I’ve never once heard anyone—not even my most nationalistic acquaintances nor Fox News/etc—say that the US was the only place anyone wants to go. Who are the people who believe/espouse this?

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:51PM (#29504779)
> Not as far as I can tell.

It depends a bit if you have absolute quotas, or thresholds/scoring.

> some outlandish things under the rubric of American exceptionalism,

I was unclear, apologies. The idea isn't that nobody goes anywhere else, obviously. The idea, which I have heard many times in the US, is that once someone has decided to immigrate, all else being equal they would obviously choose the US. Clearly most times all else isn't equal; but it also doesn't seem to be true...

Re:America is running on fumes by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:02PM (#29505232)
> The idea, which I have heard many times in the US, is that once someone has decided to immigrate, all else being equal they would obviously choose the US

Fair enough, but even still I’ve never heard that even among “Fuck yeah, ‘merica” types.

Re:America is running on fumes by rich_sasha on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#29501422)
The few times I thought about moving to America, the thing that ultimately put me off wasn’t healthcare, guns or food, but the utterly hostile immigration process.

It seems that until you get a green card, the state barely tolerates your presence.

So nothing to do with the fundamentals, for me anyway.

Re:America is running on fumes by dnautics on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:08PM (#29501549)
well, if I'm not mistaken -- the US' immigration process awfulness pales in comparison, to, say the UK. I believe AUS/NZ have inherited similarly complex, kafkaesque systems. I don't know for sure, because I only have experience with the UK's (and failed to get in despite having a PhD AND having a job with money set aside waiting for me); but I have worked side-by-side with H1B holders who said "it was bad but not that bad".
Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#29501710)
The Canadian immigration system, especially if you qualify for the skilled workers program (which most engineers do), is pretty decent overall, and much much better than the awful and outdated US system. I've looked at immigrating to the US and decided it's largely impossible. This largely explains Canada's immigration edge - it certainly isn't societal issues. I'd much sooner have immigrated to the US given the pay and tax differences.

I've actually heard good things about the AU system too - apparently Canada considers AU&NZ their biggest competition in attracting immigrants.

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#29502029)
> it certainly isn't societal issues

That seems to be pretty variable; I've met people on both sides of that border that decided against the other one for "societal issues" of various types.

Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:46PM (#29502699)
If you're poor, Canada is a pretty good deal. If you're middle-class, it's ok. If you're upper-middle-class (top 10% in income) it's better to be in the US.
Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:57PM (#29502829)
> If you're upper-middle-class (top 10% in income) it's better to be in the US.

It's not all about income, and it's really as simple as that. IIRC marginal tax rates in some parts of US are higher than some parts of Canada. So, as usual, it depends.

On average I don't think you are wrong, btw - but it's hardly cut and dried.

Re:America is running on fumes by ska on Thursday December 09, 2021 @06:33PM (#29504607)
> "and it's really as simple as that."

Probably obvious, but : and it's really not as simple as that.

Re:America is running on fumes by rich_sasha on Friday December 10, 2021 @10:11AM (#29510774)
Thankfully I never had to navigate (much) the UK process. Sorry to hear about your torments...
Re:America is running on fumes by dzonga on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:46PM (#29513810)
well one positive thing about the UK immigration system after brexit it's now much easier and straighforward. sort of points based. much clearer, no h1b lottery to deal with like you would if you were trying to get in the states.
Re:America is running on fumes by CountSessine on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:24PM (#29501750)
It seems that until you get a green card, the state barely tolerates your presence.

And good luck even getting to that point. If you have a family, you'll have to live without them for upwards of 10 years while you work alone in the US waiting for your number to come up in the lottery.

Re:America is running on fumes by mensetmanusman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:45PM (#29503369)
Pew research estimated ~700 million are interested were the borders to be completely opened.
Re:America is running on fumes by gruez on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29500531)
How does this square with the fact that the US is the #1 destination for immigrants?

https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/top...

Re:America is running on fumes by spacedcowboy on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:50PM (#29502050)
Well, if they're immigrants, they're not part of the "American dream" corpus, right ? Americans are dreaming of moving out, is what was said.

America still has more to offer than a lot of the world, but it's not some shining peak in a valley of despair - it's more "middle of the table, some good, some bad". If you're here already, it's easy to look out, see, and decide to move where it's better, if you can.

Me ? I'm a Brit, been living here for the last almost two decades. I came here for the money and the weather, nothing more. Recently, the weather is a bit crap; the money's still good, but once I get to where I can FIRE, I'm out of this country. There's plenty of places better.

Re:America is running on fumes by nostrademons on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:16PM (#29502365)
The American Dream has always been intimately tied in with the immigrant experience. People would leave their homes in Europe because they dreamt that America was a land of freedom and opportunity. It was a term largely setup in opposition to the rigid social structures of 19th-century Europe.

Arguably the American Dream is very much intact, it's just that it's mostly brown & yellow people achieving it. I have a lot of friends who left their home country because there were no opportunities for them there, and now have the suburban house with a yard, 2 kids, white picket fence, neighborhood Trick'or'Treaters, good savings, and vacations whenever they need a break. They work very hard for what they have, which has always been part of the American Dream, but they get a good life in exchange for it.

Re:America is running on fumes by armenarmen on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:58PM (#29500689)
It doesn’t, but it sounds clever on Twitter
Re:America is running on fumes by UncleSlacky on Thursday December 09, 2021 @04:40PM (#29503311)
Re:America is running on fumes by gruez on Thursday December 09, 2021 @05:28PM (#29503855)
yeah, the link in my comment already covers this. I deliberately didn't mention that because a bunch of the top countries seem to be countries with questionable labor practices involving migrant workers, eg. UAE, kuwait, or saudi arabia, or are microstates. The fact that microstates top the list also points to a flaw with the % capita methodology. Is Liechtenstein really the best country to move to?
Re:America is running on fumes by redisman on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#29502032)
It’s a lot easier to achieve the dream when you’re moving from a poor country (large delta). For Americans social mobility has grown increasingly difficult
Re:America is running on fumes by vineyardmike on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:55PM (#29502092)
While i'm not sure i agree with the parent, i know a lot of people who left the US and a lot of people who arrived, so i think i can square the circle.

1. People leave worse places (by some metric, usually poverty or opportunity) to come to US since its big and rich and full of potential. That is why immigrants come here. Its the richest big nation with lots of jobs. You can try to move to china or brazil or india which have massive populations, but the jobs pay better here. You can move to Switzerland or some EU nations that have higher avg salary, but the COL is high and immigration is even harder with less lucrative job openings available.

2. People leaving aren't the immigrants who arrived (not including returning to old country). People who "have the american dream of leaving" are the middle class white kids who don't see their own growth into top 10% of society (because they perceive their social mobility decreasing or gone), and see the exploding debt and health costs across america (often they haven't experienced directly), so they want to move to a socialized nation and "free healthcare". This is almost always a white euro nation, not eg. china or inida. Do they move? Not always.

TLDR. People still want to move to america, but some americans are basically chasing some ideal/privilege they think they can get better elsewhere.

Re:America is running on fumes by cultofmetatron on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:37PM (#29512826)
as an expat and son of immigrants myself, I guess i'm uniquely qualified to answer that.

Economic opportunities in america are great if you're willing to work your ass off and smartly. Smartly is the keyword to avoiding exploitation. That said, the wages here are way higher than in other countries. Here in Colombia, the minimum wage comes out to around $250/month. People here don't have much choice given the language barrier and lack of skills for the international market. Their skillset and ability to endure absolute crap gives them an edge when they immigrate to the US and get paid relatively descent wages for their work.

Now I'm on the other end. I have skills as a software engineer, fluency in english and connections. Those are all things I can take with me to maintain the smae wage I'd be making in america in a country where the average wage is a fraction of what I make. Thus I get to live like a king.

TLDR: both sides are moving to maximize their living potential and they increase for different reasons.

Re:America is running on fumes by autokad on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:45PM (#29501245)
immigrants don't want to live here. They want to take the money and leave.
Re:America is running on fumes by nradov on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:21PM (#29501709)
Maybe that's what immigrants think when they first arrive, but very few actually move back to their home countries. Despite the negatively pushed by the media elites, most of the USA is still a pretty nice place to live.
Re:America is running on fumes by tharne on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:04PM (#29500772)
If that were true, why is it so rare? Even during bad periods in the U.S. there's never been significant levels of out migration, the way you see with other countries.