Actually I would put the blame squarely on AMD and Qualcomm for making themselves dependent on TSMC - especially AMD who have turned themselves into a "fabless manufacturer" and are now experiencing the consequences...
I'd argue that they need to pay significantly more than other customer in order to get such preferential treatment.
In a short-sighted view of things, you only need to pay slightly more. If AMD is willing to pay $1 and Apple is willing to pay $1.01, you make more profit selling to Apple. However, as this article shows, you might end up losing the other business if you offer Apple such preferential treatment. If Apple isn't going to use all of your capacity year-round, you don't want to alienate the other companies whose orders you rely on.
I think Apple likely has to pay a significant premium for getting access to the latest and greatest to the detriment of competitors. It's not in TSMC's interests to become too dependent on Apple. If AMD and Qualcomm mutiny and their orders start boosting Samsung's foundries with more money for R&D, TSMC could find itself 1) competing against a better-funded Samsung foundry; 2) with one customer that now has leverage over TSMC and getting paid less.
If AMD and Qualcomm move all their orders to Samsung, it provides Samsung with the money to reinvest in its chip business. If they're able to make long-term commitments to Samsung, that's bad for TSMC since it will allow Samsung to invest knowing it will make a profit (just as TSMC has been able to do that with Apple's commitments).
Likewise, if the two other giant chip design companies move to Samsung exclusively, that leaves TSMC in a tough negotiating position with Apple. Before, Apple would have to compete against AMD and Qualcomm for capacity. Now if AMD and Qualcomm have made long-term commitments to Samsung, TSMC becomes really reliant on Apple and Apple will know that TSMC has capacity they can't sell elsewhere. Sure, MediaTek and others exist, but it swings the power away from TSMC and toward Apple. Let's say that Apple was using 40% of TSMC's capacity, AMD 25%, Qualcomm 25%, and MediaTek 10%. Now AMD and Qualcomm make long-term commitments to Samsung. Apple knows that TSMC's orders have dropped 50% and that gives Apple a lot of power.
Giving Apple the best to the detriment of AMD, Qualcomm, and others is a risky play for TSMC. They'll definitely want to be getting very well compensated for it, not merely slightly more. They'll want to make sure that what Apple is offering is enough to offset the substantial risk of angering competing chip design companies who might look for fabs elsewhere.
It's hard to predict the future; and the whole point of a foundry and why TSMC has been so successful is because they refused to play that game. They kept their options open and flexible rather than betting on a few key chips, and they've repeatedly pointed out how the very diversity of their customers has meant they always have some customer willing to be a guinea pig for some new tech.
Losing diversity is a cost; it undermines their very business model. From a business perspective you'd hope they really made apple pay through the nose for that cost, and not just acquiesce because they're a significant customer.
I'd say it's at least plausible that TSMC miscalculated here, and didn't think AMD and Qualcomm (and perhaps others) would dare.
To be clear: they might still get lucky (and AMD/Qualcomm unlucky) - it's not exactly news that new process nodes sometimes fail or are delayed, and if Samsung turns out not to be able to deliver, they'll be able to reacquire that diversity with little trouble, surely. And if they can replace AMD/Qualcomm with other leading edge customers they might not even really be losing much of that diversity they value so highly.
So, this is a frying pan versus fire situation. I don’t think AMD and Qualcomm are doing themselves any favors here.
Another large customer (that will be jumping ship to TSMC) is Nvidia, and clearly Samsung isn't supplying any of apples core SOC's anymore, so what is Samsung providing to apple that's valuable enough to make apple it's largest customer?
For all we know, TSMC is taking all that 3nm Apple money and putting it into producing new 3nm fab lines, which would honestly be better for everyone in the long term (except Intel, I suppose).
Further, Samsung and TSMC routinely spend many more billions on capex every year. Both companies not only have many billions stashed away, but also have the means to finance them without relying on Apple. For instance, Samsung's capex in 2020 was nearly $30B; TSMC ~$25B, vs Apple's $7B.
Sure, Apple is a big consumer of the latest nodes, but the process nodes will advance with or without Apple or Apple's money.
[1] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/tsmc-collects-huge-prepaym...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Micro_Devices#Litigat...
"n 2005, following an investigation, the Japan Federal Trade Commission found Intel guilty of a number of violations. On June 27, 2005, AMD won an antitrust suit against Intel in Japan, and on the same day, AMD filed a broad antitrust complaint against Intel in the U.S. Federal District Court in Delaware. The complaint alleges systematic use of secret rebates, special discounts, threats, and other means used by Intel to lock AMD processors out of the global market. Since the start of this action, the court has issued subpoenas to major computer manufacturers including Acer, Dell, Lenovo, HP and Toshiba.
In November 2009, Intel agreed to pay AMD $1.25bn and renew a five-year patent cross-licensing agreement as part of a deal to settle all outstanding legal disputes between them."
Unfortunately by that point the damage had been done. Fabs are an extremely expensive, normally lower margin, business. Risk averse companies probably can't get into that game. Even with Apple they appear to have focused on something of a partnership with TSMC rather than their own fab.
But at the same time, they were then unshackled as you said; As time went on and they could move more volume to TSMC it wound up helping them out immensely.
It's kinda worth remembering too though, that even at their 'peak' in the early 2000s AMD was 6-12 months behind Intel on process tech if you go by releases. Given the trouble Intel has had keeping up one could only imagine where AMD would be now.
They don't have to, but buying production equipment for their manufacturing partners (in return for guaranteed pricing and production levels) is the norm at Tim Cook's Apple.
Apple dont buy production equipment for TSMC, or Samsung Foundry. Zero.
To add to the other examples given here, Apple actually owned the manufacturing equipment for the first generation retina panels, even though it was housed in factories owned and operated by Sharp.
Undoubtably that's why Apple gets such preferential treatment from TSMC and other suppliers.
There is a good chance Apple lent TSMC the money - although the actual transaction would probably not simply be lend at x%, but be designed to be taxation efficient for both parties which might involve other parties or securities.
The consequences being if you don't like what your fab is up to, you can switch fabs. Doesn't sound too bad. GlobalFoundries, the former AMD fab, has all but given up on smaller nodes at this point, but AMD switched to TSMC for CPUs and a mix of TSMC and Samsung for GPUs. On the other hand, Intel had problems with their fab for several years, and is only now starting to consider using other fabs, when their process seems to be starting to work.
Yes, designing chips to fabricate on different lines is more work, but it's something AMD has intentionally done and it has benefits over running your own fab, especially when your own fab has trouble with node shrinks.
It's not as simple as high margins but controlling most of the stack. If all Apple was doing was charging more, we'd see comparable quality devices at lower cost but we don't and it's not uncommon for e.g. a Samsung flagship to cost more despite being slower (or narrowly beating the previous generation, depending on launch timing). What we're seeing instead is that Apple has both consistent goals on their execution (e.g. not Google and Qualcomm working at cross-purposes which make sense for their individual businesses) and captures more of the revenue.
That's a lot harder to catch up with and gives Apple consistent enough revenue that they can do things like effectively floating TSMC a great loan or pay more per unit since they don't need to justify it based on the profits from a single layer. Dell can't pay for their processor R&D using the money you spend on Spotify or Steam.
AMD is not the savior here, nor any other TSMC customer. Intel completely squandered its lead, and now we really need to hope they can catch up and remain competitive. We shouldn't allow TSMC to take total control of the market.
It's like a restaurant reservation for a very regular "VIP" customer. They may get really special treatment, because they're probably spent enough to earn it. And everyone else schleps in line.
Really there's nothing wrong with that. It may be annoying, but someone is paying way more and consistently for that table.
I know the few places I frequent often, I get a table mostly right away if anything is available, regular staff knows what I want, more or less, and I get what I expect, mostly because I have a relationship with the vendor.
I tip well. Chat everyone up, etc.
You don't think Apple or TSMC does this?
I've been in that type of relationship in that industry. That's really how it kind of works. It's not even the most $$$$, but relationship and longer term leverage.
They don’t even have to do that. They just have to place orders that are sufficiently larger than any of TSMC’s other customers’.
Also large minimum orders, and probably a bunch of the payment upfront or somesuch.
And uh yeah: AMD and Qualcomm do have the order sizes to do that.
On MacBook laptops from ~2011, a green light would indicate when the webcam was in use. But the magical part of this was that when it was off, you couldn't see the LED at all, so it looked like this light was shining through the metal bezel at the top. This was achieved by drilling extremely small holes in the frame above the LED, small enough that they're barely visible without magnification but having enough of them that light can easily pass through. It's a striking effect, if you notice it.
To do this, they apparently bought so many high-precision lasers just for this feature that it created a shortage for other companies that needed them: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-11-03/apples-su...
(Presumably this would help by giving them access to the IP so they could contract other factories to manufacture them as well, since Apple has the up-front cash to do it)
Again, I can't find the article so who knows if it's true, but it sounds very, very Apple to do that.
http://www.asymco.com/2011/10/16/how-much-do-apples-factorie...
https://www.engadget.com/2019-05-06-apple-sapphire-glass-sup...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj5NNxVwNwQ Arthur W. Astrin, sort of father of WiFi, hired by Apple to develop and incorporate 802.11b into their products. Spend most of 1998/99 flying West Coast-Taiwan twice a week (coordinating iBooks/iMacs manufacturing).
Made HP very happy:
>so I called up HP and I said "I need a spectrum analyzer. It needs to be at least three gigahertz,", and it would be nice if it was programmable. So, they whipped up something and next day the salesman shows up with this.. they call it HP Basic Language Computer. So we built 1, 2, then we ordered 10 then 50. All of a sudden HP started coming. The salesman became my best friend. <Laughs> In fact, I think I was the largest order that year for the spectrum analyzer at HP
We are talking small car unit prices here.
Afaik they did the same for iPhone camera modules with Primax, who went from small time accessories and gadgets manufacturer to one of Taiwan titans.
Apple used to buy up the flash memory in advance. Leaving competitors to pay more for smaller yield or inferior quality.
It doesn't always work. Apple once invested a huge amount in making sapphire glass for their watches. I can't remember the company name but they failed completely at delivering to Apples required spec and the deal was scrapped (leaving the supplier to face massive debts).
Apple says something along the lines of “we guarantee to buy x million chips this year, y million next year. We know it’s expensive to build that capacity, so here’s a few billion up front”.
That’s an offer few can make and nobody else is willing to make.
Maybe a more fair version would be for the federal government to socialize each of these players, and decide that they will pay a premium for slow, hot, American-made parts.
If that sounds ridiculous, meditate on why you think capitalism/markets have a negative connotation when they are in fact producing great outcomes - amazing chips (M1 series) and competitive pressure on Intel, AMD, and Qualcomm to eventually deliver similarly competitive chips.
Unbridled capitalism gets a bad rap, but that’s a relatively new innovation. You can have a well-regulated market produce even more fabulous outcomes; don’t blame corporations for those outcomes, blame politicians and the voting public.
Edit: a theme I see repeated over and over, on hacker news of all places, is people making excuses for businesses operating in competitive markets. Making excuses is bad for consumers, it’s bad for competition, it’s bad for society. Stop making excuses and ask business to work harder. Android users deserve fast processors, and it is 100% Qualcomm’s fault that they don’t have them. Intel PC users deserve fast, low-power processors, and it is 100% Intel’s fault that users don’t get them, or have to go to AMD/Apple for them. Apple’s success is proof positive that AMD, Qualcomm, and Intel have been insufficiently vigorous and innovative in their competition, which in manufacturing products also involves the surrounding business practices needed to ensure access to fab capacity.
>> You can have a well-regulated market produce even more fabulous outcomes...
Can you cite an example of this?
At a much smaller scale, I have had contracts with various vendors to provide “stuff” associated with services they provide to us.
In one case, they had a facility dedicated to my company’s needs, with tooling maintained by my company. The contractor has an SLA to achieve different levels of operational readiness.
What Apple is doing is no different, except they are buying 8-9 figure tools or loaning lots of cash at favorable terms.
I certainly wouldn’t shed many years for Qualcomm, which has an actual monopoly on modems. Their lack of strategic competence isn’t Apple’s sin.
I'm not sure that's true these days, but, even if it is true, plenty of other companies could _raise_ it easily enough. It might make less sense for other companies, though. Like, realistically, if AMD is beating Intel already (and, for the moment, they largely are; Alder Lake is niche for now), what does being a little earlier with 3nm buy them? Is it worth the money? Perhaps not.
It's even less clear that it would be worth it for Qualcomm. For them, it's hard to see that there'd be any return; they have a captive audience already.
How many companies can easily raise $200 billion?
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/27/apple-q1-cash-hoard-heres-ho...
This extraordinary claim that it's easy to raise 200BN is backed up by no argument or evidence?
The claim that it's more worthwhile for Apple than it is for a CPU company to have CPU production exclusivity is backed up by no argument, logic or evidence?
What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
Although most would argue that lower end architectures are perfectly fine replacements, so Apple gets an edge here but can't be said to be a monopoly.
I don't have the nessesary background to know which one is applicable, but I think monopoly is not the right one.
An early example.
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2005/11/21Apple-Announces-Lon...
A more recent example.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-corning/apple-award...
If you go back to the time when Apple was looking at single sourcing all their SOC production at TSMC, you'll see TSMC's CEO publicly saying it would make sense to dedicate a Fab to a single customer.
>The world's leading foundry chip maker Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. Ltd. is considering operating single-customer wafer fabs, according to chairman and CEO Morris Chang.
"I think that they are going to be larger customers, and now it makes complete sense to dedicate a whole fab to just one customer and hold that – to hold fabs in fact to just one customer."
https://web.archive.org/web/20120728040723/https://www.eetim...
I think the reason that Apple is always first in line at TSMC is that they bought TSMC a Fab.