News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by mdasen on Thursday November 25, 2021 @02:29PM (#29344208)
> they simply have to pay (slightly) more than other TSMC customers

I'd argue that they need to pay significantly more than other customer in order to get such preferential treatment.

In a short-sighted view of things, you only need to pay slightly more. If AMD is willing to pay $1 and Apple is willing to pay $1.01, you make more profit selling to Apple. However, as this article shows, you might end up losing the other business if you offer Apple such preferential treatment. If Apple isn't going to use all of your capacity year-round, you don't want to alienate the other companies whose orders you rely on.

I think Apple likely has to pay a significant premium for getting access to the latest and greatest to the detriment of competitors. It's not in TSMC's interests to become too dependent on Apple. If AMD and Qualcomm mutiny and their orders start boosting Samsung's foundries with more money for R&D, TSMC could find itself 1) competing against a better-funded Samsung foundry; 2) with one customer that now has leverage over TSMC and getting paid less.

If AMD and Qualcomm move all their orders to Samsung, it provides Samsung with the money to reinvest in its chip business. If they're able to make long-term commitments to Samsung, that's bad for TSMC since it will allow Samsung to invest knowing it will make a profit (just as TSMC has been able to do that with Apple's commitments).

Likewise, if the two other giant chip design companies move to Samsung exclusively, that leaves TSMC in a tough negotiating position with Apple. Before, Apple would have to compete against AMD and Qualcomm for capacity. Now if AMD and Qualcomm have made long-term commitments to Samsung, TSMC becomes really reliant on Apple and Apple will know that TSMC has capacity they can't sell elsewhere. Sure, MediaTek and others exist, but it swings the power away from TSMC and toward Apple. Let's say that Apple was using 40% of TSMC's capacity, AMD 25%, Qualcomm 25%, and MediaTek 10%. Now AMD and Qualcomm make long-term commitments to Samsung. Apple knows that TSMC's orders have dropped 50% and that gives Apple a lot of power.

Giving Apple the best to the detriment of AMD, Qualcomm, and others is a risky play for TSMC. They'll definitely want to be getting very well compensated for it, not merely slightly more. They'll want to make sure that what Apple is offering is enough to offset the substantial risk of angering competing chip design companies who might look for fabs elsewhere.

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by ricw on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:00PM (#29344488)
Apple is 20% of TSMCs revenue. That’s enough to make such demands. On top of that they’re likely also paying top dollar.
Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by emn13 on Friday November 26, 2021 @03:56AM (#29348508)
Risking the future of your business for a 20% customer sounds like a tricky proposition, and moves like this have real risk for TSMC.

It's hard to predict the future; and the whole point of a foundry and why TSMC has been so successful is because they refused to play that game. They kept their options open and flexible rather than betting on a few key chips, and they've repeatedly pointed out how the very diversity of their customers has meant they always have some customer willing to be a guinea pig for some new tech.

Losing diversity is a cost; it undermines their very business model. From a business perspective you'd hope they really made apple pay through the nose for that cost, and not just acquiesce because they're a significant customer.

I'd say it's at least plausible that TSMC miscalculated here, and didn't think AMD and Qualcomm (and perhaps others) would dare.

To be clear: they might still get lucky (and AMD/Qualcomm unlucky) - it's not exactly news that new process nodes sometimes fail or are delayed, and if Samsung turns out not to be able to deliver, they'll be able to reacquire that diversity with little trouble, surely. And if they can replace AMD/Qualcomm with other leading edge customers they might not even really be losing much of that diversity they value so highly.

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by bradknowles on Monday November 29, 2021 @12:01AM (#29376566)
Apple is also the biggest customer for Samsung, outside of Samsung themselves. And they have preferential contracts with Samsung, too. Enough that Apple has required the Samsung chip manufacturing subsidiary to operate with Chinese Walls between them and the other Samsung businesses, and sometimes Apple gets preferential treatment over those other Samsung businesses.

So, this is a frying pan versus fire situation. I don’t think AMD and Qualcomm are doing themselves any favors here.

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by emn13 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:19AM (#29390379)
Do you have any link or data to back that up? Obviously, Samsung isn't entirely open about who's paying it how much...

Another large customer (that will be jumping ship to TSMC) is Nvidia, and clearly Samsung isn't supplying any of apples core SOC's anymore, so what is Samsung providing to apple that's valuable enough to make apple it's largest customer?

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by tooltalk on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:20PM (#29344654)
Apple is not known for overpaying. Apple is however a significant volume customer and volume customers usually enjoy a huge discount that smaller customers don't get. So in addition to preferential allotment, Apple is probably paying less for the same node.
Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by danudey on Thursday November 25, 2021 @06:22PM (#29345972)
Apple may not overpay, but if they're willing to pre-pay multiple billions of dollars that's a huge incentive for a company like TSMC, who gain the ability to instantly (well, "instantly") launch capital projects, rather than having to wait for three years of revenue to roll in first.

For all we know, TSMC is taking all that 3nm Apple money and putting it into producing new 3nm fab lines, which would honestly be better for everyone in the long term (except Intel, I suppose).

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by tooltalk on Friday November 26, 2021 @04:19PM (#29354227)
Sure, Apple's prepay financial arrangement might have some outsized influence in smaller, riskier, or declining businesses, such as GTAT or JDI, but there is nothing special about pre-pay, especially in this market and this particular industry. Top fabless makers from Qualcomm, to nVidia, to AMD, to TSMC are flushed with money and are desperately competing for capacity. In fact, TSMC recently disclosed that they received over $3.8B in such prepay, or "temporary receipt" from various customers for their future nodes [1].

Further, Samsung and TSMC routinely spend many more billions on capex every year. Both companies not only have many billions stashed away, but also have the means to finance them without relying on Apple. For instance, Samsung's capex in 2020 was nearly $30B; TSMC ~$25B, vs Apple's $7B.

Sure, Apple is a big consumer of the latest nodes, but the process nodes will advance with or without Apple or Apple's money.

[1] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/tsmc-collects-huge-prepaym...

Re:TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm m... by TrainedMonkey on Thursday November 25, 2021 @03:56PM (#29344910)
Not sure I totally buy your point, but it does sound interesting/intriguing enough for an Asianometry video: https://www.youtube.com/c/Asianometry/videos