My experience with a dermatologist (in the US) ended up being the same as you anticipated it being. Trying to book a new patient appointment myself I was getting quoted availability 2-3 months out.
I was able to get that sped up a bit by having my primary doctor refer me (which my insurance didn't require) and set up the appointment on my behalf. But even then, it ended up being almost 6 weeks out.
I've also had to book GI appointments in a few different locations, and have had some get me in within a week and others that had a multi-month wait.
And some insurance plans in the use are HMO plans[1], which generally have the requirement of going through your primary care doctor for everything and requiring a referral from them to see other physicians.
The biggest gripe I have about the US healthcare system is how impacted it is by employer decisions. Having decent coverage today doesn't mean the coverage will stay decent, even if you stay with the same employer. I've had awesome insurance unexpected swapped out for crap insurance due to an acquisition, had good plans that I took into account when determining whether to take a job disappear the year after during open enrollment season, had the "same" plan change year to year in subtle but impactful ways (like keeping per-person deductibles the same, but adding a condition to meet a minimum family-level deductible in addition to any individual before you actually hit the threshold).
And an industry - not a service - aiming to find and charge the highest prices in a market where the buyer cannot refuse the service.
If you have good work based coverage, our care is excellent. Fast access, and low out of pocket costs.
I do want to improve it for everyone, but I have 0 complaints about my personal access to health care. I cannot imagine living in Canada and being put on a 8 month wait for something important but not urgent...
Mostly of the 'making fun' is due to the fact that millions of US citizens have no or little health care and choose not to have treatment because they can't afford it, are limited about what treatments they can have, or have it and are made homeless or live under huge debts.
Just about every country which has some kind of health care system also has private health care/insurance that means you don't have to wait for treatment or have more choice about what, when and where things happen. Because of the competition of the 'free' healthcare systems these policies are usually much, much cheaper that the US.
I work in a company that gives me private medical insurance (which means I might get treated a little early for a non urgent condition, perhaps in a swanky private hospital) but feel good that people that can't afford it won't die, and that I can quit my job and not worry about getting ill.
“There is a deep group of rural american's who refuse health care, even when provided by their job at extremely low cost.”
Particularly the part about those with insurance not seeking care. The articles cited are concerning vaccine takeup rates, which reasonable people can differ.
"Worse healthcare for you and your family because you are privileged" is not particularly compelling to the roughly half of Americans you are yelling at.
You'll reach a lot more people without that kind of language. I for one almost instantly dismiss anyone who talks like that. I didn't even read the rest of your post.
The word "privileged"? That's apt. Most on HN are privileged.
Or is it the way that statement was posed as a question? It's probably not the most diplomatic way opening a post but it's far from being offensive.
I don't know why you're commenting, since you're not the original commenter, and your very comment shows how you already recognize the generic accusation-of-privilege to be the problem (and how the word privilege is heavily coded with political affiliations and a whole pile of antagonistic/moralizing dogma at this point). You already knew how and why it would be inflammatory.
You recognized the problem, and opted to try to reframe it in more favorable terms to deny the possibility for improvement.
If the original commenter wants to reach across that Red Tribe / Blue Tribe divider and have an actual discussion (or even convince a neutral 3rd party of their views), their first sentence (and general tone) is quite counter-productive, and you know this.
This is a multi-user forum not a peer2peer chat client.
> and your very comment shows how you already recognize the generic accusation-of-privilege to be the problem
No, I'm saying the accusation of privilege is correct and it's not a problem to point out to people on here that we are privileged. Because we are.
> You already knew how and why it would be inflammatory.
If you're in the top 10% and can't stand being called privileged then the problem isn't the tone of the accuser, it's the person receiving the comment. The sooner privileged people stop acting like the victims, the sooner we can start fixing the worlds actual problems.
> their first sentence (and general tone) is quite counter-productive, and you know this.
Actually I was arguing that it's not counter-productive. It was the point of their post and a point very much worth making.
I've seen both sides of the social scale and we are definitely not on the side that should be getting offended when people should "privilege" ;)
We have pretty long wait times in the US for elective surgeries as well. Not as bad as canada, but it can take a bit to get you scheduled for a hip or knee replacement.
The fact they pay less for some procedures is irrelevant
Many doctors either do not see or see limited numbers of patients on medicare. This means that wait time is longer for these folks.
You are arguing real hard/loud, but it doesn't sound like you have talked to actual doctors about the issue.
Do all doctors take it? No, but I feel like they are in the minority and frankly, if a doctor doesn't take it, I feel they are more motivated by money than caring for their patients.
The clinic then fucked up billing, overcharged us, and it took another few months for all of this to get sorted out.
The first part of this story isn't too different from the Canadian[1] system, the second is a pile of unnecessary stress added on top.
Between mine and my employer's share, our 2-adult health insurance costs ~$15,000/year, by the way. And what do we get for it? Months long waitlists and clowns that can't even get billing right the first few times.
This may indeed be the Rolls Royce of healthcare, in the sense that it costs a mountain of money, finds expensive ways to break down all the time, and spends half its time in the shop.
[1] Actually, each province in Canada is responsible for running a provincial healthcare system.
I've been getting bloodwork done at my physician's office for two years and Labcorp started sending me bills again. Same insurance, but they just randomly stopped filing with them until I spent long enough on the phone for a few of my hairs to grey.
When I was younger, I got a nasty infection after my wisdom teeth were removed. The ER bill, which was close to $5k for a doctor to look at me for roughly 5 minutes and write me a prescription for antibiotics and some pain meds, bounced between health and dental insurance for months, both saying the other should pay for it, before they kicked the can to my parents.
My mom had connections in the hospital's administration, so she was able to get it coded properly for health insurance to pay it. But I am probably the only person in this thread who can say "my mom is on a first-name basis with the people who can get billing issues resolved by the next day." Everyone else gets to sit on the phone for hours trying to sort it out, hoping that insurance will show mercy or that the hospital will bother recoding, or at least give them a bill they can stomach.
> The first part of this story isn't too different from the Canadian system, the second is a pile of unnecessary stress added on top.
IMO the cost in stress and time of the American system is under-appreciated. We pay way more than other advanced states and have to deal with a whole bunch of companies, all of which seem to be either incredibly incompetent or actively trying to screw us, every time we actually need healthcare, which is precisely when we really don't need more stress or to have extra demands on our time. It's awful.
Are you factoring in premiums? Once you factor premiums from both sides (employer and employee), healthcare in the USA is far from low out-of-pocket. Good family coverage is on the order of $2,000 or so a month.
That's not even getting into the garbage plans offered at some places. I've had plans that covered visits to exactly one region hospital system, any other hospitals needed preauthorization, and even those had the potential for rejected claims.
Which brings up another often missed point. When dealing with the lower cost plans, there's a huge risk of having a claim denied. I know for a fact that at least one major insurance provider has a policy to deny every claim and make the hospital rejustify it. If the hospital fails to justify the claim (to the insurance company standards), either the hospital system has to eat the cost, or they bill the patient instead. This is used to get around those "out-of-pocket maximums" cheap insurance is sold on. So you may only have to pay the first $8,000 of the bill, but that only applies to the first $8,000 of what the insurance company agrees is covered.
My out of pocket + premium for my entire family is MUCH MUCH MUCH less than I save in taxes by being an American over European. Pretend health insurance is a "tax" and add it to your total tax rate. Now compare your total tax rate with someone in Germany/Sweden/Norway making similar pay. For most developer type jobs, I think you are going to find that even a $2,000 a month insurance plan a steal.
There’s also the moral cost of participating in and supporting a system extorting the less fortunate.
“Not my problem” is where we are divided - and pay an extraordinary price, becoming complicit in the extreme violence of poverty.
But the further you fall down the income ladder, the worse the American system is.
* There is a base rate of 14.6% from your gross that split between the employer and employee. The split is not important for our calculation as it will come out of the same budget an employer has for one employee I guess.
* Public insurance providers can demand an additional contribution that was on average additional 1.3 percentage points. The highest I could find is 2.5 percentage points extra.
* There is an upper limit. You only have to pay for your first 58050€ ($67564) a year. For everything you earn above that you do not pay more.
* Family members that do not work or do not earn more than 450€ per month are included for free
So that means from the money your employer has available to pay you a maximum of (14.6 + 2.5) * 58050 / 100 = 9927€ ($11556) a year or 827€ ($963) a month.
This isn't sustainable for me in the long run and I'm definitely considering leaving the US because of it.
Regardless of your delusion, let's not forget the fact that most of those employer-provided policies come with a shitton of asterisks.
Sadly this opinion underlies a lot of America's problems.
The top 50%ish get coverage through jobs that is mostly fine.
The bottom 25% get heavily subsidized plans (often free) from both state and federal programs.
There is a hole there in the middle, but it may be possible to tweak a few programs without throwing out everything. This is basically what ACA tried to do with the backing...
The US health care system is by the far the most complex of any nation state and punishes the losers the worst. It strikes me as something badly in need of disruption. And it's not like we're talking about removing private health care entirely -- if that's what you're scared about?
> And it's not like we're talking about removing private health care entirely -- if that's what you're scared about?
I'm personally concerned with the 50 Stalins sort of sentiment surrounding health care. We legislated the current system into existence and its outcomes are perfectly predictable. Why not fix the causes instead of trying to legislative more effects and doubling down on government interference yet again?
The problem isn't regulation. Many other countries are far more regulated in the health care industry and operate a private market just fine. In fact some might even argue that some of the problems with the current US model is a lack of regulation.
The problem I've observed isn't a lack of competition, it's that all of the competition play by the same broken rules. You basically have an industry where people need your service. It's not luxury, it is literally life and death in many cases. People have to use your service, whatever it costs. And you then allow those companies to regulate themselves, companies that will almost always put profit ahead of welfare. That is never going to turn out well. But because libertarianism is very much a core part of the American ideology, whenever the question of how to fix the problem arises you argue that the market needs to be deregulated further. Basically just doing more of the same, as if it will suddenly fix things despite decades of proof that it hasn't already.
Now I'm not going to pretend that other counties have a perfect system. But I do believe the only way you are going to get a health care system that works for everyone is for voters and politicians to want something that is, at least on the surface, very "un-American".
> I'm personally concerned with the 50 Stalins sort of sentiment surrounding health care.
And here lies the problem. People are so brainwashed into thinking any form of social health care is communism and bad. Quite frankly, it's ridiculously misinformed. In fact most of the rest of the developed world has a social health care system AND private health care, capitalism, etc too. On this particular occasion you can actually have your proverbial cake and eat it.
> Why not fix the causes instead of trying to legislative more effects and doubling down on government interference yet again?
Because you're fixing the wrong thing. You're looking at a broken faucet causing water to leak constantly, and instead of fixing that faucet you go and break more faucets thinking that should some how change the behaviour of the first faucet. Then when the flow of water gets too expensive you then start arguing that it's not the leaking faucets at fault, it's the water rates instead. If this weren't a political problem then I'm sure most on here would throw their hands up shouting "learn some basic root cause analysis!"
Maybe at your specific doctor. But there are many, you could try another?
There’s no way to pay for better/faster treatment if it’s publicly covered.
EDIT: Edited to clarify I'm speaking specifically about Canada as there is some confusion in the replies.
I can't speak to the situation in Canada, but in the UK this is not true. You can get private insurance and go to private doctors.
This is an outright lie, here in Uruguay and in Chile both with social Healthcare you can enter onto different private plans and that will expedite surgeries, doctor meetings etc
It is something that depends on a country per country basis
Easy there, cowboy. Based on the conversation, I believe OP is still referring to Canada, not every country with socialized healthcare.
“Assuming CAN is like NZ…”
“It’s (Canada) not.”
They do let you pay for a private hospital room though oddly enough.
If you want to know what truly excellent health care is like, visit Mayo Clinic. Because of the concentration of doctors in one location, I saw around 12 doctors in a week. That would have taken a year or more through the regular medical system.
[1] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/these-3-charts-show-how-...
Even the low out of pocket costs are vanishing with the introduction of the newer high deductible healthcare plans.
I think something a lot of people don't realize is that their care plan is often dictated by the insurer and employer, not their doctor. Your employer and insurer negotiate annually on your coverage with little input from employees. What medicines and treatments are covered is dictated not by the doctor.
Our care might be excellent but the administrative burden is not.
> Fast access, and low out of pocket costs.
Have you ever had to challenge a bill? or find out that the provider you used sent your labs to another provider that was out of your network and now you owe the other provider full price?
> I cannot imagine living in Canada and being put on a 8 month wait for something important but not urgent...
And you don't need to mimic their process. You can have single payer and privatized medicine. If you're wealthy or a company wants to offer a premium insurance then so be it. There will be a market for those "speed lanes" if you want.
One way to think about it is that there are low wait times on the US because nobody can afford the care. You can skip the queue because all the poor people are kicked out of line.
then you're stuck with your work. Because other work might not provide the same coverage. It's not too bad for programmers because they are spoilt for choice. For many other people it becomes servitude.
Where "excellent" includes shorter length of life, and over-testing, over-diagnosis, and over-treatment (each of which causes harm) because you've got to have something to show for all that insurance spending.
You have some outlier coverage if your story is factual.
The reason a doctors visit is 0-$20 and an ER is $500 is because the insurance company is trying to steer you towards the more cost efficient treatment place.
Yes you can go to the ER for a sprained ankle, but often you can wait until the next day and go to the doctor for better treatment for 1/10 the cost.
Incentivizing you to make more budget friendly choices if capitalism. We like capitalism here right?
I like to think we like objectivity.
Your analogy about ERs is based on situations that aren't emergencies, so I'm not really sure how to square that with reality.
Even following that analogy, you shouldn't delay medical attention to save money, and the insurance company shouldn't be dictating or steering any part of your medical treatment, period.
Incentives only work when you have good information and time to make decisions. When you're in an emergency situation, you can't hop on your phone and shop around for the best deals on trauma surgeons and ambulance rides, and frankly that shouldn't be the expectation.
The media, pundits, and politicians only focus on the sticker price, not what people are actually paying, which is often much lower. http://greyenlightenment.com/2021/10/17/why-healthcare-is-so...
We hear about patients being stuck with $6000 bill but did said patient actually pay 6k? Absolutely not, even if uninsured.
also they ignore the role of employer healthcare, or how the NHS is paid for by higher taxes, so Americans are effectively paying less for healthcare in this regard.
So much misinformation and misleading info in the healthcare debate, driven by partisan politics.
They paid $1500, then, while in any other country, it would have cost, maybe $50
Currently, the industry is also facing a labor shortage, so this is making the scheduling even harder. A family member in high school was diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea (affecting school performance! You only get 8 semesters to mess up!), and it has been (so far) 8 weeks and we still don't have a formal intake for medical equipment. We have a prescription. We just can't get the equipment supplier to process the prescription and send it to us. I ended up paying out of pocket (and doing some crazy shit) to get a machine and supplies. Note: this is with doing what is basically a part-time job squeaky-wheeling everyone I can to try to get things happening. It is the worst.
Blue collar medical workers are quitting in droves because the work sucks and it has garbage pay, and you see the executives making huge salaries. And you get yelled at by people like me trying to make the system move faster. I try to stay friendly, but... I have lost it a few times. Of the seven people in my family, five of us have chronic medical issues.
I was just talking the other day with a friend wishing there was a medical consultancy I could hire. I give them my health insurance info and family demographics and all of the healthcare shit we need done, and then they find the providers, make appointments, file reimbursements with insurance/hsa/fsa tell me how much to put in fsa/hsa each year, deal with the full time job of having a family that needs to deal with the totally bonkers american medical system. They get some commission of whatever comes back to me, and also just some baseline monthly payment for service. PLEASE GOD LET THIS BECOME A THING. Or, you know, a not insane medical system.
The cost have gone up a lot.
The idea of a same-week appointment, especially as a new patient, seems like fantasy to me.
We have the worst of both worlds.
Where I live, 95% of medical practices belong to 2 networks. Step two after consolidation is reduce costs. Long story short, if you don’t have cancer, you’re looking at 90+ days for an appointment.
Dermatologists are a little different in that they can make money selling bullshit spa services. So you may see more variance by region as being cut out of hospital networks isn’t as big of a deal.
Hopefully you don’t end up with a medical condition that exhausts your PTO and you get kicked off insurance. My neighbor’s go fund me staved off foreclosure for 6 months when his wife had cancer.
1) The conservatives (political right) have eroded public health care any chance they can, such as through cutting budgets to any health-related service over the course of at least the last 20 years. They do this so that they can stand up in front of people and argue that “Wait times are long! If you let us implement private health care you could simply pay for better service!”
2) Even with the reduced budgets and constant attacks by conservatives, if I limp in to emerg with severe pains I’m getting looked at immediately and might be successfully out of surgery by the end of the hour. On a smaller note, I just had this convo this morning: “Can I book an appt to get my prescription refilled? I know the Dr has to talk to me before writing it” “For sure. I can get you in Nov 28th. Are you completely out?” “Yes I am, I miscalculated and I’m concerned.” “Ok, I’m putting you in for tomorrow afternoon. Does that work for you?”
Negative gains I may say. In my experience of the Canadian healthcare and US healthcare systems, the latter, IF you are well insured, feels like a Rolls-Royce whIle the former is like driving a Lada in Pothole City.
I remember the first time I called my provider in the US to book an appointment with a dermatologist. She said "Wednesday", I said "What month?" I couldn't believe it was that same week. I used to wait 2-3 months in Canada. And I had to first get a reference from a ER/generalist doctor.
Also don't forget the US spends on medicare/medicaid/VA about the same % Canada spends on healthcare.