News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by blendergeek on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:45PM (#28638410)
I have a slightly more cynical take on this than it seems most of Hacker News does.

Facebook had found a way to monetize it's iOS app without Apple getting a 30% cut.

Apple decided to cut that off to prevent Facebook from making money without Apple taking their cut. The fact that Apple can sell this to users as "privacy" is all the better for Apple.

At the end of the day Apple is still a corporation. They are beholden to shareholders, not privacy advocates. Apple will maximize profits and has found a way to cut off revenue to competitor and breed goodwill at the same time.

Judging by this comments thread, it is working very well.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by ohashi on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:04AM (#28638500)
Apple's revenue stream isn't as tied to internet advertising as any of its large competitors. They sell products. And also an ecosystem around those products.

The two for one of hurting competitors and making customers happy is about as good a play as they could make. It makes making the 'right' decision easy. Blocking facebook from tracking everything we do online is a win most people can appreciate, except Facebook (and potentially some advertisers taking advantage of it).

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by robocat on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:31AM (#28638939)
> Apple's revenue stream isn't as tied to internet advertising

Actually a significant percentage of Apple’s profit comes from free-to-play iPhone games, which contain a lot of adverts.

Grabbing some figures from different sources:

* “Apple reported a profit of $23.6 billion in its second quarter, on record sales of $89.6”

* “According to the ruling, gaming apps account for approximately 70% of all App Store revenue. That 70% is generated by less than 10% of all App”

* “Barnes calculated that the App Store had hefty profit margins, which increased to 78% in 2019”

* “Apple's App Store had gross sales around $64 billion last year”

78% of 64G$ is ~50G$, and 23.6G$ x4 is ~95G$, so let us say that 50% of profits come from the App Store.

I would guess that at least 25% of Apple profits come indirectly from in app advertising for apps related to in-app-purchases. You know, those annoying adverts in free games, that are mostly nothing like YouTube adverts, because the highest payout for the adverts is by advertising gambling and pay to play games. The adverts pay well because the in app purchases pay developers well, and Apple takes their cut from that.

Note that Apple do not provide a clear breakdown of App Store profits compared to iPhone sales profits: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-profitable-is-apples-a...

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by viktorcode on Friday September 24, 2021 @05:43AM (#28640333)
Games that run advertisement don't pay Apple a single cent out of their ad revenues.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by celticninja on Friday September 24, 2021 @07:26AM (#28640976)
but they will generate advertising revenue for Apple. Just like the developer gets cut of the advertising so does Apple. The developer isn't paying but the advertisers certainly are.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by sidlls on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:07PM (#28646572)
How do you figure? 100% of in-app advertising goes to the split between the ad provider and the developer. Apple doesn't get 1 cent from that (unless the ad comes from Apple, obviously).
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by charwalker on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:58PM (#28647732)
It's a loop. The ads don't make Apple money but they market games that profit off in app purchases. Apple gets 30% of those purchases so is incentivized to enable these ads and participate in making them more effective like providing metrics.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by mzkply on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:18AM (#28642736)
Apple gets a cut of a Google ad in an iOS app?
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by dangerface on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:20AM (#28643641)
Its not advertising revenue unless the revenue is generated by selling advertising.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by vxNsr on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:33AM (#28642114)
Btw, I recently (as in 2 months ago, before the epic ruling) downloaded one of those apps (bec I was given a $40 incentive to spend $10 in app) and they used PayPal not apple to sell their in app coins. I thought that was interesting, that they got around the apple censors.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by helsinkiandrew on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:53AM (#28639061)
> I would guess that at least 25% of Apple profits come indirectly from in app advertising for apps related to in-app-purchases

With that logic you could say that nearly all Apples profits come indirectly from advertising as they trigger people to buy hardware, apps and services.

If people spend x hours and $10 a month on in-app purchases on their favourite game and that game was taken away, many would just spend the time and $10 on another game - ie Apple will always get their share, the ads just help decide which app developer gets the rest.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by dillondoyle on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:48AM (#28643197)
Apple does run a very large ad network themselves in the app store. They tried to run their own 'traditional' ad network and failed, so I agree with parent this is a business decision.

The article has multiple mentions of an upcoming broader Apple network? Is there any solid information on that?

They could win big $ if they rolled out a universal ID and controlled the infra/bids. Similar to their login button, it could be a more privacy focused UUID that users can revoke or maybe partition. Would love to see their marketing sell this as groundbreaking privacy lol

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by deadmutex on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:54AM (#28639065)
> Apple's revenue stream isn't as tied to internet advertising as any of its large competitors

I am curious what your take on this is:

https://9to5mac.com/2021/08/25/analysts-google-to-pay-apple-...

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by ohashi on Friday September 24, 2021 @05:06AM (#28640121)
Free money. They don't even have to develop the ad business.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by parthdesai on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:45AM (#28643983)
> Apple's revenue stream isn't as tied to internet advertising

It's tied to China instead, an outstanding example of human rights. Yay Apple :)

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonh on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:58AM (#28639721)
Apple has been vehemently against tracking their users from the start. Steve Jobs was adamant about it, it's even why they ditched Google Maps and developed their own mapping service starting in 2009. So Apple has a very long history to back this up, and have sunk billions of dollars into avoiding commercial entanglements that compromised their user's data.

Imagine if Apple had gone heavily into tracking back in 2009, as a lot of analysts predicted they would. They'd have been giants in the tracking industry. Imagine how much the detailed social graph of Apple users for more than a decade must be worth? They would have hauled in tens, maybe hundreds of billions. They walked away from all of that on principle.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by HeyZuess on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:52AM (#28638736)
I would say that a lot of this is about domination of the chat space. FB has the most used messenger app, and iMessage is a predominant feature of Apple.

FB is also an easy target at the moment, so Apple can use them to sell the "privacy" of their product.

That and I think Tim Apple has a bone or two to pick with Zucks.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by rsuelzer on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:37AM (#28638969)
It is hard to dominate the messaging space when Apple does not offer messaging service to android users.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by HeyZuess on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:52AM (#28639052)
Do they need to dominate the space, or does Apple just need to dominate their own space? I would suggest that the high usage of iMessage is also a driver for new customers to come on board with iOS and remain there.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by dbatten on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:39AM (#28642185)
"Remain there" indeed.

As anyone who has ever switched from an iPhone to an Android device will tell you, iMessage makes the process extremely painful, and in totally unexpected ways. You get your new Android phone set up, and suddenly find that you're not getting messages from any of your friends that have iPhones... because those messages are being routed over iMessage instead of SMS.

So you do a bunch of Googling or contact support for your phone manufacturer or wireless carrier, who directs you to an Apple tool for de-registering your number from iMessage. You go through that process, but it takes days/weeks for your de-registration to finally make it through "the system" to everybody's iPhones so that messaging with your friends on iPhones finally starts working again.

Did Apple do this intentionally? No, probably not. Could they solve this problem? You bet they could. But why solve something that makes switching to Android a nightmare?

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by lamnk on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:09AM (#28643498)
I remember reading from the Epic vs Apple debacle that Apple decided to not open iMessage for Android phones since 2013:

https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/9/22375128/apple-imessage-an...

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonklitj on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:20AM (#28639509)
This right here. I think a lot of people don’t consider jumping ship at all, primarily because of iMessage (no source, just personal experience).
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by kaba0 on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:43AM (#28639644)
That’s mostly a US thing. Where apple doesn’t have big enough market share, it doesn’t work and people use alternative chat programs (messenger, whatsapp, telegram)
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonklitj on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:23AM (#28639854)
True! Having moved from Denmark to the US makes this very apparent. In DK everyone uses Facebook Messenger.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by amatecha on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:02AM (#28639742)
Yeah, I know tons of people who won't even consider anything other than iPhone, and their first response is "then I won't have iMessage!"
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by kergonath on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:46AM (#28639998)
I have literally never heard anyone say that. IMessage is a nice thing to have, but other than the blue bubbles has almost zero effect on communications. SMS text messages work fine and are free. Same for WhatsApp and FB Messenger.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by imchillyb on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:16AM (#28642707)
> other than the blue bubbles has almost zero effect on communications. SMS text messages work fine and are free. Same for WhatsApp and FB Messenger.

That is simply, objectively, untrue.

There are so many falsities with your statement I don't know where to begin.

Lets start with money transfer. I often use applepay right in iMessage to split bills between parties right at the table. I iMessage them the bill and their portion, and right there through iMessage they reimburse me through apple-pay, right to my bank.

During the last major Hurricane in FL, iMessages would send while SMS and all TEXTING would not. Cellular services were down. Texting was down, but iMessage worked just fine with a WiFi connection.

My interactions on iMessage are saved to iCloud. Prior to switching to Apple devices, in 2016, my work phone was damaged beyond repair at a construction site. All of my texts were saved on device, and not recoverable. This does not and cannot occur on iMessage saved to iCloud.

This is all just off the top of my head, and these are features that are desirable and utilized in iMessage, and not available through sms.

Objectively speaking, your statement about iMessage is just plain wrong.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by cglong on Friday September 24, 2021 @05:12AM (#28640162)
I saw someone once say that if they don't have a blue bubble, they're not worth talking to.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by kergonath on Friday September 24, 2021 @07:17AM (#28640916)
That does sound like an arrogant arsehole if serious, though that’s the kind of things one would say in jest around here. Not sure how prevalent that is, if sincere. Even in the UK, where Apple has a near-50% market share AFAIK, it means not communicating with half the population, which sounds impractical.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by vxNsr on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:35AM (#28642144)
I’ve heard it to, it’s mostly about seeing the delivery receipt. I think that’s why apple refuses to implement RCS.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by random314 on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:45AM (#28639015)
Except imessages get uploaded in its entirety to the Chinese government, FB messages don't.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by HeyZuess on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:58AM (#28639085)
Does FB exist in China?

Yes iMessage can be decrypted by the Chinese government. But China is a much different arena than the rest of the world, it is an almost totalitarian state by default.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by random314 on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:44AM (#28643958)
FB doesn't exist in China because they don't want to upload their user data to the Chinese government.

And it's not like Chinese government "can decrypt". Its not encryption if you share the key in plaintext. All imessages in china are scanned by the government.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by na85 on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:10AM (#28638527)
>Apple decided to cut that off to prevent Facebook from making money without Apple taking their cut. The fact that Apple can sell this to users as "privacy" is all the better for Apple.

Whatever. As long as it's damaging Facebook it's a net win for society.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by danmur on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:20AM (#28638592)
I agree, even though it feels a bit icky. I'm sure Apple have their eye on that advertising money in some way but anything that damages Facebook is highly likely to be a net positive.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by kergonath on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:38AM (#28639939)
> I agree, even though it feels a bit icky.

Giving the users the opportunity to make an educated decision feels the opposite of icky. This in itself is unambiguously good. Now, other aspects of Apple’s behaviour are less great, but let’s keep some perspective: asking for user consent should be the legal bare minimum.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by danmur on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:26AM (#28640601)
I meant it feels icky to approve of anything Apple does :P.

EDIT: just to clarify, I 100% agree it's a great change, it's just that "right thing for the wrong reasons" situation. But it's a very good change and I hope it continues.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by kergonath on Friday September 24, 2021 @07:18AM (#28640921)
> I meant it feels icky to approve of anything Apple does :P.

Oh, right. Sorry, I misread :)

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by Voloskaya on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:05AM (#28643445)
> Judging by this comments thread, it is working very well.

Good. A company's motives don't matter. Companies are just reinforcement machines that go where they think money is.

If they release a "privacy" feature, for whatever hidden motive, and users flock to it, they will infer that there is money to be made here and continue in that direction, which is good for us. It makes no difference what their reason to move there was in the first place.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by jeremyis on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:03AM (#28638487)
This doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. Google also makes a lot off their apps and circumvents the App Store. Airbnb too. Apple is doing what it thinks is best for its customers. Perhaps people will pick iPhones over Android due to Apples strength with privacy.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by brokenmachine on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:15AM (#28638844)
Google pays Apple billions to be the default search engine for iphone. They've paid their way into good graces.

Privacy on iPhone, that's a laugh! The only company ever to ship phones with an automated, unverifiable on-device scanning/reporting to authorities system. As we know, CSAM is just to get the foot in the door, of course.

Fuck Apple and their locked-down consumer hostile disposable garbage, and while we're at it, fuck Facebook for just about everything they do. I have no need for either of those garbage companies.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by realityking on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:23AM (#28639526)
> The only company ever to ship phones with an automated, unverifiable on-device scanning/reporting to authorities system.

Nitpick but so far this hasn’t shipped.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by Despegar on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:19AM (#28638880)
If Apple wants a cut, they can just change the terms of the developer agreement so they get a cut from advertising revenue. The more Facebook earns, the more Apple would earn.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by r00fus on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:52AM (#28638735)
Your cynical take would make sense if you think Apple would somehow get that 30% if Facebook were allowed to collect this data. Apple gets nothing either way.

Apple isn't holding Facebook hostage, it's simply allow FB users to relinquish giving Facebook their usage patterns for free.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by yarcob on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:21AM (#28639179)
Facebook might pivot towards other monetization strategies when their cross-platform web tracking ads don't work anymore.

For example, Facebook offers you to pay to "increase the reach" of your posts. This happens for example when you try to post a message to a Facebook group. If you want to make sure all members see the message, you have to pay.

This is a way that Facebook monetizes without tracking (targeting is based on people who opted in to join a group) and the users pay directly in the app (allowing Apple to get their 30% for the in-app payment).

With Apples changes, Facebook (and others) might focus more on strategies like that.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by annadane on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:02AM (#28639744)
> For example, Facebook offers you to pay to "increase the reach" of your posts. This happens for example when you try to post a message to a Facebook group. If you want to make sure all members see the message, you have to pay.

That actually sounds incredibly cynical, and criminal

Edit: Would the person who downvoted me within literally a minute of posting this please explain why?

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by javagram on Friday September 24, 2021 @08:27AM (#28641429)
I didn’t downvote you, but perhaps it’s because you didn’t back up the word “criminal” with a source. What law does it break if facebook doesn’t send your post to everyone in the group?

If you wanted to send a letter to all of your friends in the traditional post, you’d have to pay 58 cents per person to do so, the business model hardly seems unusual.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by yarcob on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:09AM (#28642589)
I thought the same thing when I found out about that, but it kinda makes sense.

Facebook tries to show you the most "interesting" posts. If you are a member of many groups, there are probably too many posts in your groups to show all of them in your newsfeed. So Facebook just picks whatever they think is interesting.

Or the poster can pay to have everyone see the post.

Anyway, I prefer this monetisation strategy to creepy tracking.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by annadane on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:51PM (#28647013)
That actually does make sense in a newsfeed way. I had this mental image of a person physically reading the group (being in the group specifically) and just not seeing any posts by x because x didn't pay to play
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by KoftaBob on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:08AM (#28642559)
This reads like someone starting with the conclusion that Apple did this to prevent Facebook from making money without an Apple cut, and then looking hard for evidence to support that.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by soheil on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:22AM (#28639194)
Wait, what's the alternative? FB pays Apple 30% of what exactly? Its ad revenue? How is that in any shape or form feasible for Apple to demand from FB, logistically? If there is no clear way for Apple to force FB to pay it has no reason to find an excuse to hinder FB's tracking activities on iOS for monetary reasons.

The world is also not black and white. Just because Apple is not beholden to privacy advocates, but instead its shareholders, doesn't mean it gives 0-fucks about privacy concerns. Of course Apple cares about privacy if it helps it sell more iPhones without lowering its profit margin.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by 93po on Friday September 24, 2021 @12:05AM (#28638502)
What services or products do Apple and Facebook share that make them competitors?
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by blendergeek on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:09AM (#28638817)
Apple and Facebook both provides means for other apps to monetize. Facebook provides it's ads SDK and Apple provides in-app purchases/subscriptions.

While these may seem like totally different markets, Apple and Facebook are directly competing for the same dollars here.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by 93po on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:06PM (#28648338)
I guess I see that. If I'm an app developer I am choosing between selling my app or placing ads in the app, and I'm directing revenue to either Facebook or Apple depending on that decision.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by random314 on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:47AM (#28639026)
iAds. The 2.5T behemoth is looking for new revenue streams.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by viktorcode on Friday September 24, 2021 @05:41AM (#28640322)
Only the privacy changes go way beyond Facebook.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by celloductor on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:23AM (#28638904)
if Apple wanted money I'm sure they could've struck a deal with FB just like how they made a pact with Google to put them as a default search engine.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by anshumankmr on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:14AM (#28639152)
What would they have made FB into? Default social network? Google provides a value addition for most people which is better search results than its competitors and they keep paying Apple for the privilege of being the default search engine. Facebook provides no such "value". There is no such thing as the best social media app. Twitter, Facebook, Whatsapp, Reddit, Hackernews etc provide different services to people.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by swiley on Friday September 24, 2021 @08:55AM (#28641663)
Smartphone Apps are universally shit.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by random314 on Friday September 24, 2021 @01:44AM (#28639012)
Apple doesn't want a 30% cut. They want a 100% cut.

Watch as Apple rolls out "privacy compliant" ads api that will route all ads through apple.com and block out other advertisers. Apple wants to be the only Ad company on iOS.

Notice the hypocrisy of providing privacy for your internet shopping behavior while dumping your imessages to CCP without a thought as well as your albums to any government entity.