It's not particularly obvious why insurers don't seem to care, though there have been some rulings where they didn't need to pay because stealing a car like this wasn't technically stealing under the insurance policy.
Link? This seems so wild.
Fun fact: they usually go to sleep (i.e., way more battery life) based on an accelerometer detecting no motion, because legitimate use would always be hand-held. To take advantage, put it on a table or hook (but not too close to your front door, perhaps) instead of keeping it in your pocket while home.
I guess sleep mode is really more about preventing relay attacks, with improved battery life being a side effect.
Or better yet, an S&G digital safe lock. If it is good enough for missile launch codes it is good enough for my civic. Replacing an S&G lock body is far cheaper than any car immobilizer.
That convenience shouldn't have to be traded for the huge vulnerability of allowing replay attacks.
Door keys suck. Ignition keys suck more. The worst is the middle years of both immobilizers and physical keys.
Source: I can use 4 different keys to open 1 car right now. In fact, I only realized this after I locked my keys in the car and tried a few spares at the shop. A little jiggle and they all work
1: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/12/launch-code-for-...
My car has an optional subscription that would let me unlock it with my phone -- I didn't sign up for that subscription, but I bet that it's active on the car's side and if there's a remote vulnerability, it's exploitable whether I've signed up for it or not.
[0] https://everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=1520430&displaytype...
I've got an early 80s SAAB that handled this in a more straightforward way. The driver's door lock plunger will not go down while the door is open, forcing you to lock it with the key (or reach around from another door, and then lock that.)
It would make sense to do that if it detected the fob inside the car. But it does it no matter what.
That's not a feature.
> To lock all doors, with the driver door closed, press and hold 7•8 and 9•0 at the same time. You do not need to enter the keypad code first.
https://www.ford.com/support/how-tos/keys-and-locks/securico...
German cars do have a rolling code, especially BMW with EWS2 around 1996'and it's a nicely documented system to break.
With that said, it would be fun to dump older car firmware to see how simple the security was, previous to 1996, most cars ECU firmware were litereally on eproms.
There are also communities and such dedicated to bypassing this, not for theft but for engine swapping and car modification - having an annoying security system that can disable the starter or fuel pump sucks when you engine swapped your car.