That convenience shouldn't have to be traded for the huge vulnerability of allowing replay attacks.
Door keys suck. Ignition keys suck more. The worst is the middle years of both immobilizers and physical keys.
Source: I can use 4 different keys to open 1 car right now. In fact, I only realized this after I locked my keys in the car and tried a few spares at the shop. A little jiggle and they all work
1: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/12/launch-code-for-...
My car has an optional subscription that would let me unlock it with my phone -- I didn't sign up for that subscription, but I bet that it's active on the car's side and if there's a remote vulnerability, it's exploitable whether I've signed up for it or not.
[0] https://everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=1520430&displaytype...
Or better yet, an S&G digital safe lock. If it is good enough for missile launch codes it is good enough for my civic. Replacing an S&G lock body is far cheaper than any car immobilizer.