A team of Romanian/Bulgarian/Polish big guys will take care of your squatter problem for less than 1000 Euros. There's likely people of other nationalities doing this, I wouldn't know, I only dealt with these three and they operate everywhere.
And no deaths or major injuries, of course, that's just bad business.
Sadly there's no easy app for connection.
Any use of violence need opposing and competing forces in a market to work.
Judging by the quality of service, it obviously doesn't work when the government has a monopoly of legal violence.
As you mentioned, having people doing it illegally is prone to the creation of a black market. Black markets need to stay hidden so they'll have lower standards and generally a worse experience for everyone involved. If there wasn't any control on these "big guys", eventually someone would come up with a way to broadcast these "big guys" reputation. Someone could easily hire some other "big guys" to keep the other ones in check.
Having a legal and black market operating side by side can mean more quality and variety for the black market. The drug market is a great example where in places a legal market exists the black market can offer better prices, better quality and a variety of strains the commercial growers cannot.
We don't need a black market, we just governments not to get in the way in what they consider legal or not. I think you're advocating for small independent producers vs big monolithic ones (which sounds great, I'm in!). In a world where licenses don't cost half a million, that can be a legal market as well.
> The black market can have higher standards From my anecdotal European experience this hasn't been the case. Eg. If I think about cannabis in Netherland, what you can buy in a coffee shop is generally much better than any black market deal you can find in all of Europe. You can get cannabis from Amsterdam in the rest of Europe as well (amongst the dozen fakes) but it will cost much more.
In a black market you have a higher risk of getting scammed, lower quality and no controls. Online marketplace with reputation systems help a lot but it's still not like buying on Amazon.
The barrier to entry is higher because you have to setup the tools to act anonymously (eg. Tor, cryptocurrencies), you have to worry about stealth and you're running the risk of going to jail. The quality / price ratio goes down pretty quickly. Sure, you're not paying taxes and you don't have to do accounting, but I think the negatives are more expensive than that.
I heart afganistan has no such monopoly, opportunity!
The US governments have a monopoly on violence and sanction self defense and defense of property.
I think in order to avoid open conflict from law enforcement, these types will try to avoid residing at the scene of the crime. Instead, they will rely on referrals for repeat business, while keeping things on the down low.
Who cares about the old lady stealing sweets from the reception candy dish during a bank robbery on a mafia bank?
You might say it was a medieval take on the military-industrial complex.
It keeps getting proved over and over that first world, well off countries can't pay or train or subjugate other cultures into civilized engagement with the world or even their own people. Nation building is an awful joke of a policy, and at some point people have to figure their own shit out.
There are legal and illegal immigration and asylum possibilities all over the world, or you can take up arms against corruption and tyranny. It sucks, but being born doesn't entitle you to anything unless there's a culture and civilization to make good on those entitlements.
Taking up arms is thr easy part mate, there is no shortage of thay going round. creating a functional society is the difficult one.
To pretend this can be easilly achieved is just folly
Then, one day, a small group of thieves starts entering and assaulting stores, trying to extort people and robbing others on the streets, threatening more violence if people don't cooperate better. You try calling police, but they either don't show up at all or only do so late and never investigate anything worth a damn (remember, they collude, and they're likely colluding with your newly arrived local thugs).
So, your neighbors and you organize together and ambush these thugs the next time they come along with their attempts at violence. You catch and badly beat a few of them then toss them out into a public area where an ambulance can pick them up. It sends a clear message, the extortions stop.
Is this ideal? Nope. It's awful, but you want peace for your business, community and family, and what other recourse do you have? Should you and all your neighbors just spew platitudes about ideals of law and order while being assaulted regularly? Or should the whole neighborhood, as you say, apply for overseas asylum and wait months or years for a response (likely negative)? Maybe they should abandon their homes and everything else of their culture to illegally flee, letting the country sink further into chaos?
They mostly won't do these things. because they want a peaceful home that is their real home, and with legal options having been marginalized, communities and groups sometimes really, no-shit-no-other-option have to take matters into their own hands.
Maybe that clears things up about perspective from within a highly functional, lawful country that had decades or centuries before you were born to become like that, letting you simply enjoy it and criticize others who aren't so lucky yet.
I'm not criticizing the people who find themselves in shitty situations. I'm criticizing your statement that the civilization I am fortunate enough to live in is "privilege." It is a carefully guarded and deliberately constructed civilization designed precisely to defend individuals from mobs and strongmen. That is a right, not a privilege, secured by violence and death and sacrifice.
When there is no rule of law, might makes right. Securing civilization from lawlessness universally starts with blood and death and is a horror show. It's that, or leave for a better place. By staying, you're giving power to the exploiters. Worse, you're giving them the means to abuse and exploit more people, and more generations of people.
There are no good or easy choices in such situations. You kill, you leave, or you perpetuate the hellscape, inflicting it on your local society.
The idea of the state having a monopoly on violence is the foundation of all successful civilizations. The idea being that if there is no monopoly, the right and responsibility to use violence falls to individuals, and when individuals are wielding violence without consequences, rule of law is meaningless.
Staying isn't just a casual preference for most people, it's a basic economic necessity and an emotional attachment to the idea of not giving up and ceding one's home to abusive people because things got tough.
People aren't normally thinking in some abstract sense that "I should leave this country and stop giving abusive social elements the means with which to perpetuate themselves". They're more often thinking. "This is my home and where my family is from, why should I flee everything I know instead of fighting back however I need to?".
So stuff like people being declared dead incorrectly, identity fraud. I'm also reminded of an incident in the Netherlands that lead to the fall of the current (still acting; it's complicated) government, where the tax agency was somehow convinced people had fraudulently received particular subsidies and decide to get the money back plus interest, which it turns out tax agencies are very good at.
Good luck finding anyone to beat up there. You can scare people but you can't intimidate red tape.
The history of Scientology versus the IRS suggests otherwise.
You'd have to band together with other people like you to stop them. I guess you'd also need some mechanism for restraining the worst impulses of the mob we've just organized, like a governor restrains a steam engine. We could call it a "government." I bet it would be a hit.
You can't solve violence without violence.
Failing to differentiate between these things makes me wonder are you some sort of animist?
Unless you are claiming that cutting someone's paper is equal to cutting their skin?
They get sued, it often becomes very violent, because to have the balls to seize the property of someone who s in short vacations you need to be quite violent yourself, children are always involved and well meaning outrage artists always point out the poor children being sent back to the streets etc.
I live in Hong Kong now where real estate is "a dream". You can rent anything with just a pile of cash and 30 minutes because if you dont pay rent they know the police just enter, throws everything out and put you in jail awaiting trial.
I d recommend France to try, not sure what we d truly lose.
Working to reform suboptimal laws may be difficult, but it is a better investment than handing your money to organized crime.
it is, but this investment is costly, because it takes a lot of time and effort, with no real guarantee of success, and when you are eventually successful, other people could easily free-ride off your investment (since it's a non-excludable outcome).
So what a "rational" actor would do is wait for someone else to expend their resources doing this, while they themselves pay to gangs/organized crime to obtain their own property back in the mean time.
Also, real organized crime immediately flips on you when people notice their loud obvious daylight crimes and there is blowback.
Once you decide to go outside the law, you take responsibility, do your research and prepare as best as you can.
See, these people don't exactly want to be criminal gangs, they just want a quick Euro for little risk.
So, your house and you want to kick out squatters - yeah, sure. Someone else's house and you want them to break in - no way, we're not insane.
Most of the time.
If you deal with some crazy cunts, they can burn your house down.
Generally why the legal way is preferable. But if you're desperate, you can look at alternatives.
Try offering them something else.
Where does this not lead to people paying more money to go beat you down if you try and evict them?
I think you meant to write "ceded". To seize is to grab hold of, to cede is to give away.
While I don't agree with the idea in the comment.c this person is speaking from experience (supposedly). They should be allowed to share it, and their viewpoint
That's not true. No mention of 48h anywhere. Only place i found it is here: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F35254
"Le préfet rend sa décision dans un délai de 48 heures, à partir de la réception de la demande." which roughly translate to "The prefect renders his decision within 48 hours of receiving the request."
We have a family house that was squatted on the coast during last winter. We asked the squatters to leave (while redacting a letter to the prefect) and they too believed the "48 hour" stuff. The police did not however, and made them leave quite quickly (less than a week).
Please see https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/ce-que-vous-devez-sav... and https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/logement-squatte-pour...
The 48 hours are a generally applied rule for the squatters to be differentiated from, say, burglars. Because otherwise someone forcibly coming into your house while you are there could not be arrested at all.
The ones you mention is for the preéfet to statute about the expulsion.
> We have a family house that was squatted on the coast during last winter
I honestly pity you. I know of two families whose house was squatted and it took months for them to get back their house (in a terrible state); They never got anything from the quatters (nor from the insurance in one case).
Plus, the home you're buying is on land that's next to a bunch of utilities which are there because generations have worked towards them. Should you be able to hoard all of this (hospital, public transport, etc) just because you're "investing in housing" (which in most part is just sitting on empty houses to sell it to other people that need these utilities)?
This is why vacant home ownership should be taxed to oblivion: you're profiting off something that isn't yours. The only reason the home is appreciating is because the land you're on is gaining value because it's either:
- Most livable land
- Has utilities
- Has people living there that make the city attractive
And owning a home participate in none of this without taxes. Not only that, your incentives are aligned with preventing people from building more houses so yours appreciate, which is a net negative for the city.
Blows the door lock away with the hammer and proceeds into the premise. I would love to know what happened afterwards, but I can imagine.
If you want to get back to your house, police is going to stop you because you are entering by effraction when someone is lawfully permitted to stay in a place that belongs to someone else.
These squatters will sue you. They have the right to live somewhere, so your place is as good as anything else.
They have children, so they have more rights than you for your house.
They can destroy everything, and you should be happy to get back a ruin.
Like I said, I truly love my country but this is one of the few things that drive me completely crazy and where I understand violence of people getting back their house (like the Romanian dude)
From reading other points in the thread it seems like owning a home for investment in France is an extremely risky proposition.
The amount of people owning property and the size of the real estate market says otherwise. Squatting is just one of those things with an over-sized media footprint.
You usually buy to rent. renting is ultra-complex in France as well but at least you know what you are getting into.
> Squatting is just one of those things with an over-sized media footprint
Right until the moment it hits you. Have you had been squatted? No? So how can you have an opinion on the impact to someone?
Yes, I know. Renting is part of "investing".
>Right until the moment it hits you. Have you had been squatted? No? So how can you have an opinion on the impact to someone?
I'm not talking about personal impact, I'm talking about social and economic impact. Just go look at the numbers for squatting in France. It's statistically irrelevant. By your logic we should all be very concerned about things that nearly never happen. That's not a sane way of living. By the same token people should only be able to discuss things that have personally happened to them. Which is nonsense.
And?
> I'm talking about social and economic impact
With this approach we should not invest whatsoever in rare diseases. Or help disabled people because they are less useful for "social and economic impact".
Just look at the number of rare diseases, or disabled people. They are statistically irrelevant. Screw them.
If what the talking point is just trying to sinisterize "private ownership of real estate" that still doesn't make sense as an approach. It just gets squatters and promotes violence through greviances unresolvable through the legal system like how prohibition leads to drug gang fights.
Or they will simply steal it from someone else.
Or, ultimately, pass a contract with the power company.
As for the locks, changing them is the first thing they do.
There is even a web site "how to squat for dummies" (the title is different) where they explain in simple words what to do to have a successful squatting.
There is even a web site
How about you get your friends oversquat the squatters? Who are they going to sue now?
Wait until they learn about Stand Your Ground laws... [1]
[0] https://www.ibdna.com/paternity-testing-ban-upheld-in-france...
The regulations (in French) are here: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F14042
So the judge can simply say no and the (legal) father is now on the hook. And furthermore, the legal system will manufacture a criminal if the legal father decides to test his own DNA with the one of his alleged (for whom he is financially responsible) child.
Preventing someone from attempting to prove their own innocence is similar to the witch trials of old and a grotesque violation of human rights. Any sovereign legal system preventing defending ones innocence through modern forensic means, has little grounds to protest if as a result their legal system is openly mocked and ignored by other countries that do support defending self innocence.
The fact that a supposed modern nation with elected officials elections should have a miscarriage of justice this grotesque seems akin to a theocracy or monarchy that decides at arbitrary the outcomes of legal proceedings without any actual consistent basis for ensuring justice is upheld.
I think it was after a survey on cheating and promiscuity, but I'm not sure of this since this was just something I heard of from other people and I can't find much from a quick search on the internet.
The reasoning is that the priorities of the child come before the priorities of the father, so in order to protect the stability of the family you are not allowed to know.
As to who supports this, a lot of women seems to be in support of it (they have nothing to gain from opposing it) and all the people who seem to 'think of the children'.
Some politicians claim to be against allowing the paternity test on the ground that it is against the values of the republic since it's an aknowlegment of the importance of relations blood, genetics, and race(ism), but these are the words of politicians so they don't mean much.
This specific case was met with outrage in France, despite the fact that the law was applied correctly (whether a law that allows to judge actions depending on your mental state is correct is another story).
I really highly doubt that the original squatters continuously inhabited the place, as though they were clinging to a new Kia in a radio contest.
I mean unironically the people affected by it should do this.
If you are in Trou-les-Bains then nobody cares.
In particular, the fact that the authorities must reply in 48h was shown as a progress. The problem is that if they do not reply, it is equivalent to a denial of right (your request to evict the squatters has been automatically rejected)
Crazy life in the countries without rule of law.
Squatting is simply stealing. Sorry but I have exactly zero compassion for people who come to my apartment, that I bought with hard earned money, and fuck it up. This is one of these cases where violence is the normal reaction.
I hope that people who support squatters give out their salary and live under a bridge - this would be a true alignement with their beliefs. Otherwise this just hypocrisy ("people should be able to live where they want, except in my house")
What are they going to do? Complain about it?
Before an owner takes any action, they had best know what type of squatters they are dealing with. Some would be likely to set fire to the place on the way out (or not leave; perishing amongst the smoke and flames) if they are subjected to enough anguish.
I think the situation is hardly understandable for someone outside of France.
All that would need to do is provide the squatters some written notice informing them that this building was selected for testing a non harmful experimental rodent deterrence prototype the purpose of which is to minimize the presence of known plague vectors. (High/low frequency devices are often used for this and similar purposes). By notifying the “residents” in advance, it establishes that they are made aware that the owner of the property, although not actively seeking the removal of their presence from the premises at this current time has given them fair warning that these devices will be installed and made operational at the provided date and they are not actually being asked to leave. The legitimate justification behind the use of the property for this purpose is to afford maintenance and safety upkeep on said property by minimizing financial losses incurred while income from the property through other means is not possible due to it being forcibly prevented from generating income due to the presence of the squatters.
Perhaps the rebuttal to this approach are zoning laws favoring the sole use of the property as purely no residential.
Another unrelated risk that the squatters open them self up to is for the owner to contact multiple strict by reputation inspection agency that is likely to find some reason why the area should be not approved for renting to individuals due to safety reasons while those flaws are amended. During this and before the owner could establish communication with several repair companies seeking quotes on the repairs needed to meet the livable standards again but document that the repairs are not currently possible due to the potential financial legal liability of performing construction while the building is physically occupied. If a building inspection agency classifies the building as unsafe for residents then anyone choosing to stay there with children would be technically liable for child endangerment and would be at risk of being reported to the French equivalent of the child protective services.
If you stare at the playing field long enough there are always legal checkmate moves in every game no matter how inconsistent or ridiculous, even the French legal system. There appears to be a pattern of justice miscarriage in the French legal system possibly calling into question whether or not any other nation should ever honor any French extradition request as long as they hold laws as silly as this and preventing someone from seeking to prove with modern forensic science whether or not they are innocent of the accusation of genetic paternal responsibility.
The flowers in their “bouquet of evidence” are less than fragrant.
EDIT: what makes this particularly ridiculous is the timeframe you mentioned: 48 hours. I mean it would be a totally different thing if we were talking about squatting places abandoned for years. Yes you can make an argument about private property etc, but it's a different planet: if somebody squats my only house in which in paying a mortgage, that can easily put me in financial jeopardy. What should I do? Stop paying my mortgage? Squat another house myself?
You still have to pay taxes on property, as well as all the utilities you have a contract for.
You are also completely responsible for the safety of the house. If something happens to someone (inside the house to the squatters, or outside to a bypasser), you as the owner will be responsible.
The law protects squatters in their freedom to live where they see fit.
The law also theoretically protects the owners. The problem is that there are so many exceptions (children, ...) and requirements (negotiating with the squatters, ...) that what you get after months (some were apparently luckier) is usually a ruin and you are expected to be ecstatic about the fact that you got your house back.
The people who support this situation are despicable. Especially because I do not see them giving their house away and living under a bridge to live their dream of complete freedom.
When we will have meetings for the next election, I will ask the candidates about their opinion on squatters, and if they support them in any way, their home address so that can hop in, burn it to the ground and expect them to clap because freedom and equality.
EDIT to your EDIT: the problem is with houses people own as their primary ones (and come back from vacation to an occupied house), and the ones they use occasionally(week-ends, vacation, or rent).
If there is a building that is abandoned I do not see much problems outside of insalubrity and health/security risks.
Does the policy goes to the house if there is "anonymous" tips of drugs, child abuse?
Will they be able to sleep with heavy/trash metal music directed to their windows 24/7 at realistic concert levels :-)
So many ideas, so many questions....:-)
I didn't know this word -- apparently it's an older English (but still current) French word for what we usually call "burglary" or "breaking and entering" in English now. I might say "Someone breaks into an apartment/house..." in this context.
They are not idiots. They are passing the issue (inability of some people to access housing) from them (the government) to some other individuals.
It's some form of unorganized taxation.
Please live with your beliefs and get the squatters in your house. You would solve that problem of poverty at once.
You trying to get in is violence and they will call the police to protect them. And the police will protect them as the lawful inhabitants of your house.
Maybe invite all your friends too?
It is always simple to make other people do what you claim is right.
I am glad that you don not get emotional when you are robbed of your property, good for you. Well, except if you were never robbed - which can explain this.
To do otherwise incentivizes bad behavior. Worse, it externalizes the problem from a societal one (building more housing) to an individual.
If not you should - this will protect the poor.
BOOM!
That's where the law is chefs kiss... perfection. Nobody should own more than one home. Someone else taking over the secondary residence is the best outcome for the community.
Someone gets by effraction in an apartment/house, stay there for 48 hours and they are good to stay forever.
If this is your primary apartment, the local government (préfet) is supposed to issue an order to get the people out. They do not (because plenty of important reasons - important for them of course). Police usually try to negotiate with the squatters.
If there is a small child with the squatters getting them out is not possible at all. Except if you find them a replacement apartment. And they accept it.
If this is not your primary housing, then you are completely screwed. Thee is almost no way to get the people out. We have from time to time in the news information about people who are trying to get their house back for years.
If you try to move them by force, they will sue you and you pay 40,000 € plus prison. They can be sued for up to 12,000€ (and prison - this has never happened)
I love my country, but the brain-dead idiots who passed these laws should be publicly pointed to, with their home address, so that they can kindly invite the squatters to come when hey are on vacation.