News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Causality1 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:00AM (#28074658)
Nevertheless, the officer insisted that Spriestersbach was actually Castleberry and took him to jail. He was fingerprinted and had his photo taken, generating records that could have been used to prove he wasn’t Castleberry, the Innocence Project asserts.

It's beyond me how anyone has one iota of faith in the US judicial system anymore.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by jstummbillig on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:01PM (#28076440)
It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work.

The justice system mostly works (relative to what its designed to do and the system it evolved out of, which you might both disagree with, but let's not complicate this). By the nature of what it handles (humans) and what you are (human) it will look abhorrently cruel when it fails. And, as with any system, it will definitely continue to fail as long as it is in place.

Assessing an acceptable failure rate is kinda hard – but realistically there has to be one or you will just have to do without any system at all.

So, more interestingly, the thing to look out for is whether a) there are institutions that report on system failures and b) we learn from those failures and correct them at all. As far as I can tell that generally happens in democratic countries.

The next thing to look at is the speed in which we do those corrections. Could they be quicker? Sure. However, it seems like democracies are a tad slow about everything to people everywhere. Or, put differently, we are all wired a little bit too impatiently for how our democracies are currently designed.

I feel that's good thing, constantly scrutinising our systems, keeping them on their toes and improving as we go.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by rabboRubble on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:33PM (#28076900)
the issue for me isn't that a mistake was made, the issue is that the parties responsible for the mistake conspired in secret without official record to cover up their error, and left the man dumped in a homeless shelter with fifty cents.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:12PM (#28079049)
This happens "all the time". Taking responsibility is not 'in vogue' nowadays. (Prime examples are the lasts president. Obama was big on cracking down on whistleblowers. Orange explicitly claimed many times that managing stuff is not his responsibility, he has people for that.)
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by jstummbillig on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28077212)
Agreed. What happened here is absolutely horrific.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by RIMR on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:51PM (#28077138)
They failed him repeatedly. This wasn't a one-time screwup, this was a systemic failure across multiple organizations.

And when they realized they had wronged this man, they did whatever they could to sweep it under the rug and avoid consequences, or reparations for their actions.

The system doesn't just "look abhorrently cruel", it IS abhorrently cruel, and this incident is a clear example of that.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by majormajor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:58PM (#28077248)
So let's look at this. There were people who screwed up. Then they covered it up.

The key question is "what sort of system makes it harder to cover things up?" because the people element of people not wanting to get in trouble or have their mistakes visible isn't going to go anywhere.

You also need to have the non-mistake, non-cruel cases visible, to see if things are changing for the better or worse, rate-wise.

A "less cruel" system isn't a particularly specific or well-defined thing to strive for if it's not specifically trying to address those human failings, since people can still be cruel.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:18PM (#28077487)
The US uniquely shields officials in these cases which promotes coverups. That’s a specific, systematic, and correctable failing of the US justice system not simply normal human issues.

How hard it is for the coverup to work is largely irrelevant IMO.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by majormajor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:54PM (#28080466)
What's unique about it?

The incentive also seems backward here: if there's a shield protecting you even in case of screwup, you are incentivized to cover things up less than otherwise.

Protection from initial mistakes, like "blame free retros," is generally heralded as a way to promote fixing root causes and reduce political coverups.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:03PM (#28080582)
Protecting an initial screwup is fine, protecting the coverup is what I take issue with.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:16PM (#28079104)
Not uniquely. It's not uncommon for people in official capacity to have immunity from lawsuits relating to their work.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:54PM (#28079662)
Usually it’s protection from the initial mistake not the coverup, the US protects both.

Though I am interested if you have some other examples.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:20PM (#28108814)
Does it? I mean if the coverup becomes proven in criminal court, then are they still protected? I thought the problem with coverups is that they are very hard to prove, and when some of them eventually get uncovered, then the department simply treats it as some small irrelevant internal affair. Hence legally QI still stands.

Though of course it's strange that these half admissions of coverups are not treated sufficiently seriously by the courts.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by 8note on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:30PM (#28080167)
Wouldn't a lack of shield promote coverups?

The only loss for the officials here is embarassment

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:04PM (#28080592)
You can shield people from a mistake without also shielding them from a coverup.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by wombatmobile on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:28PM (#28079287)
We don't have a US justice system.

We have a US legal system.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:58PM (#28079706)
Or a "punishment" system, given the elected sheriff/DA motivation to be "tough on crime".
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by wombatmobile on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:08PM (#28081253)
Well, it goes both ways, depending on circumstances and resources.

The US legal system is a commercial system. By that, I don't mean to say it is corrupt. Rather, the participants in the system require representation i.e. lawyers, and lawyers charge for their time, by design. Consequently, access to outcomes of the legal system is a function of the financial and social resources of the participants.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by satellite2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:10PM (#28079009)
I assume the shame would be proportional to the cruelty inflicted to the wrongly incarcerated, and in the US public figures love to show how cruel they are with deviant people.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by eptcyka on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:30PM (#28079315)
Maybe a better fix would to make admitting and fixing mistakes was cheap and relatively cheerful?
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28077225)
>It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work.

It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his cheap internet virtue points depend on his not understanding it.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by bendbro on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:06PM (#28077336)
> It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work

I think this is my largest hatred. People's first action after something bad happens is not to discover why it happened, but rather to express outrage that it happened. In my ideal society they would be excluded.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by mLuby on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:10PM (#28077388)
Outrage is fine as a motivator if it leads to investigation, and that investigation may lead to action.

What's not okay is skipping the investigation step, to jump straight from outrage to action.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by manmal on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:21PM (#28079173)
Get ready to exclude 90% or so of the general population then?
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by shadowgovt on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#28075753)
Mostly because these stories are incredibly rare. The Innocence Project does excellent work to try and prevent people like this from falling through the cracks.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Causality1 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:18PM (#28075830)
The stories are rare. We don't know how rare the events are. What percentage of people do the Innocence Project manage to review? It's certainly not everyone.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by goodpoint on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:45PM (#28078599)
Absolutely not. The high imprisonment rate and the number of people imprisoned without a process is a clear symptom.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by dehrmann on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:34PM (#28076027)
And if everyone who dropped the ball on this got a year in prison for it, they'd be even more rare.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by mekoka on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:37PM (#28076966)
Once you start punishing players for dropping the ball, the game becomes to not receive the pass.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:47PM (#28077088)
We never seem to have this problem for any field other than law enforcement or military. In other professions, if you mess up aggressively, there are repercussions professionally.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by luckylion on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:30PM (#28077639)
There are? Like when Goldman Sachs needed a bailout ... and then used half of it to pay bonuses to their execs that had gotten them into the mess in the first place? Or politicians mismanaging things, only to be re-elected or, worst case, switch to a cushy job on the board of some corporation?

I'm not sure there are that many professions where you get exiled or go to jail for failure.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by slapfrog on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:19PM (#28079144)
If doctors or lawyers fuck up bad enough, losing their license is one possible, if rare, outcome. Those professions are still very popular.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pempem on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:17PM (#28080733)
I hear you but I also feel like this is already happening. Not only did everyone in this chain, for 2 years, say "its not my problem, I'll push it forward", when it had to be reviewed they did it secretly without recompense for the harm caused.

They received the pass and then pretended it never happened

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by toiletaccount on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:21PM (#28076726)
thats a good way to gum up the system so nothing ever gets done.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by gowld on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:45PM (#28077835)
Then people will be empowered to enforce community standards instead of being held back by a State force that doesn't do its job but prevents them from doing theirs.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by KerryJones on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:20PM (#28075854)
There are organizations dedicated to handling the repeated abuse of mental health facilities in similar ways here -- not the legal aspect, but the mental health. "Incredibly rare" feels like it's playing into the narrative of "oops, this is rare".

So, I would argue, "one of many": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosenhan_experiment

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by slackfan on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:08AM (#28074803)
This could have happened anywhere in the world, the US is hardly unique.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by ModernMech on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:06PM (#28077338)
The US is definitely unique in that it confines the largest number people against their will in the world, in terms of both per capita and raw population numbers. That context cannot be lost when examining the cruelty of the system. It's obviously at an extreme end of the spectrum, so treating it like "any other country" doesn't hold up.

The system is designed to target and exploit vulnerable, poor people and turn them into productive assets. Once it has them, getting them out can be incredibly difficult because they become so profitable. Our penal system is not designed for rehabilitation but for profit generation.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by tonyarkles on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:10PM (#28075728)
Here's, among others, one of the absolutely wild examples from Canada: https://lop.parl.ca/sites/PublicWebsite/default/en_CA/Resear...

Multiple people convicted by evidence provided by a quack of a doctor used as an Expert Witness by the crown.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by tunesmith on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:48PM (#28076251)
Therefore what? Bad thing happens in the US, yes that's true, but well, that same bad thing happens in other places too, so therefore.... what?
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by mucholove on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:40PM (#28077003)
I love this attitude. In life, so many people are happy to reference themselves to a very poor standard. For mang Dominicans, it’s OK in the case of Dominican Republic to be the third country in Latin America for so many statistic—automobile accidents, coronavirus deaths, you name it. This is unacceptable to me. Pick the highest bar—and if the highest bar isn’t good enough—set a new standard.

Sure, we will have failures—but we need to push the envelope and do “good” not “better than worse”.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by staticman2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:58PM (#28076405)
Don't get me wrong, i find this story outrageous, but whether our system is doing comparatively well or comparatively poor seems like useful empirical information.

For one thing, if another country handles things better, that shows humans are capable of improving their system.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by tunesmith on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:15PM (#28076633)
Ah yes, that does help. Too often I see people make statements like that and it just comes across as fatalistic, like an attempt to dissipate the will of others to do anything about it at all.

I wonder what the other countries are that do better, and what they do differently. Maybe there should be a mandated evidence review every x years, irrespective of sentence.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by ars on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:33PM (#28081431)
So therefore humans are humans.

If it was unique you can point to what makes it unique - but if it happens everywhere, then it's because humans are humans.

If you don't understand the source of the problem you have no change of fixing it.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pempem on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:25AM (#28075034)
Then really its a global problem we need to figure out.

Every day on HN we have debates about the trading of privacy for data for a more secure world. This is an indication that our efforts are broken, because people. But also that those people held a lot of different roles, in a diversity of offices across our judicial system.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by SavantIdiot on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:45AM (#28075342)
How can you possibly make such a claim with any supporting evidence that it could be "anywhere"?

EDIT: Confused "anywhere" with "everywhere". I'll take my F in logic today and show myself out.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by TheFreim on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:51AM (#28075435)
Does someone need to provide a source proving that mistakes happen outside the United States?
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by sophacles on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:06PM (#28075676)
Actually, I think your doubt needs some sources. The foundational principle is that there exists at least one of:

* a human that has never once made any mistake whatsoever

* a system composed of humans who are mistake capable but the system itself actually makes no mistakes.

Such a thing seems impossible - if you can point to the existence of such a thing, your doubt is worth entertaining, otherwise it's just contrarianism.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by lozenge on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:41PM (#28079462)
Here's one (sort of) from the UK.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal

Hundreds jailed or fined due to a faulty computer system blaming them - no other evidence - Post Office covered it up repeatedly - victims still not fully compensated.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by DecoPerson on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:19AM (#28074955)
I have faith in a situation like this being far less likely to occur in Australia.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by UnpossibleJim on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:02PM (#28075622)
https://www.mondaq.com/australia/crime/893326/imprisoning-th...

There isn't a large Innocence Project (though a small one has popped up and should be supported) in Australia and there are overzealous prosecutors in Australia, just as in a lot of places (though the competition in America seems to be exceptionally strong). Faith is nice and all, but it doesn't free the innocent. There's a link to support Australia's innocence project, maybe tithe.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by hilbert42 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:29PM (#28075963)
It's not yet as bad but it's becoming more and more like the US every day. Australian politicians rarely create original law, they either ape laws from elsewhere or are forced into copying laws from the country they're trying to do trade deals with. Thus Australian law is becoming more and more like that of the US.

For that matter, things won't improve in any anglophone country until they ditch the adversarial system for the inquisitorial one that has a better chance of getting to the truth of a case. But don't hold your breath, that won't happen anytime soon.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by satori99 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:01PM (#28075589)
Don't be too sure. Very similar things have happened in Australia before, and no doubt will again

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornelia_Rau

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by wil421 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:57PM (#28076393)
Here you go. IIRC Australia hasn’t been side kind to it’s Indigenous population.

https://obriensolicitors.com.au/case-studies-unlawful-impris...

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by drno123 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:43PM (#28076176)
With the current lockdown and incoming martial law, it seems that you already live in a dystopian universe.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by zepto on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:32AM (#28075131)
Why? I see no reason to believe Australia’s social problems aren’t as bad as as the US.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pstuart on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:18AM (#28074950)
It's a legal system, not a justice system.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by hilbert42 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:49AM (#28075406)
As one is taught in philosophy 101 the Law and Justice are not the same and it's always been thus.

One way of at least improving the situation would be for laws that would allow for the victim to sue both the State and public officials separately. If police and other public servants could not hide behind the protection of State and could easily be sued for negligence then they'd be much more diligent. It wouldn't make things perfect but it'd only take a few instances of public servants finding themselves out of pocket to the tune of their life savings for things to improve significantly for the better.

There's no doubt that democracy is badly impacted by such events, and it's little wonder that people continue to lose faith in their governance whenever this happens. Anyway, I hope some smart lawyer will make the State pay very early for its irresponsible and horrendous error and that Spriestersbach is awarded the large compensation that he deserves.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by harpiaharpyja on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:21AM (#28074971)
I'm not sure what point you're trying to make with that statement.

I think justice should be considered the entire purpose of a legal system. And if it isn't working, it should be fixed.

Accountability sounds like a good place to start. If an official causes harm to another person through negligence or otherwise they should be held accountable to the same standards as anyone else.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pjbeam on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:36AM (#28075198)
I think that's the point of the above comment.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by SerLava on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:36AM (#28075197)
They're just saying our legal system doesn't try to consistently create justice.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by shadowgovt on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:24PM (#28075913)
It definintely tries (that's sort of the point of it).

... but it doesn't always succeed for multiple reasons. One of the most common being that it's not always possible to grant all parties justice. Sometimes, courts have to evaluate a zero-sum situation and decide how cost will be shared, so there's no way to move forward without constraining someone's rights. And people's definitions of "justice" vary, and are far more often grounded in emotion than coherent philosophy... It's not always even logically possible to grant all parties justice.

The useful distinction to keep in mind is that the legal system will follow the law, but whether the outcome of that is "justice" is a subjective evaluation more than a measurable concept.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by samatman on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:37PM (#28076071)
> It definintely tries (that's sort of the point of it)

This is probably argument from definition (unclear) but in any case, it's a statement which needs backing up.

To cite a usual boogeyman for such discussions, the Soviet court system under Stalin wasn't at all interested in justice.

It's not clear to me that the incentives in the US court system align with justice more than accidentally. As in, sometimes the guilty go to prison, as a side effect of the prosecutor's office needing to clear their docket and present good numbers to keep their budget up. Very occasionally, the innocent are cleared of crimes, and even more occasionally than that their lives aren't ruined in the process; defense attorneys want to look good as well.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by munificent on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:39PM (#28076997)
> the Soviet court system under Stalin wasn't at all interested in justice.

And, to play Devil's advocate, most of those in power under Stalin would likely have claimed and honestly believed that it was a justice system and that it was using its might for the greater good.

Outright sociopaths who simply don't care about harm are rare. When systems cause more harm than good, it's usually because well-intentioned participants fall prey to other human flaws:

* Dehumanizing and believing that some groups are simply less worthy of care than others.

* Biased data or beliefs about who is harmed and who is helped.

* Principle-agent problems where the ones making the decisions don't see or own the consequences of them.

* Emergent properties where no individual member of the system wants a result, but the system as a whole ends up producing it because of its structure. Sort of the beauracratic equivalent of crowd crush.

The reason I'm pointing this out is because I think when non-totalitarian systems fail to help, it's usually for the same reasons. It's not because of psychopathic monsters. It's mostly that primate brains were never designed to operate at the organizational and power scale we have created. The fact that it works at all is a miracle.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by tunesmith on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:55PM (#28076344)
I think it's more valid than an argument from definition. At its most cynical, a legal system is at least an attempt to disguise brute power as reason. So even then there's an allowance that reason and fairness should have precedence over brute power - they just try to dress it up. So if that concept of reason and fairness being important didn't exist, they would just do away with the song and dance.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Clubber on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:30PM (#28075975)
The worst part is it took 2 years and outside lawyers to rectify the situation. It's as if the justice system doesn't even care if it gets it right or wrong, it's just a mindless machine. "I don't care, not my job."
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by smachiz on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:58PM (#28076397)
If you read the article, it wasn't outside lawyers. He was freed because one of the doctors in the mental facility (who originally declared him incompetent) had a change of opinion and actually tried to verify his claims and realized he was telling the truth.

The innocence project is just trying to clear his name, after he went to live with his sister in Vermont.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Clubber on Friday August 06, 2021 @12:13AM (#28083258)
>If you read the article, it wasn't outside lawyers. He was freed because one of the doctors...

I can't read the article because it's behind a paywall. I said he needed outside lawyers to rectify the situation. Just because he was freed doesn't mean his life is back in order. I suspect he has an arrest record, criminal conviction and a record of time served to contend with. Not to mention he hasn't worked in 2+ years. I'm sure his credit is toast. What happened to the place he used to live? I don't know if his voting rights have been restored. I would imagine a google search for his name would bring up at least one article on his conviction for employers to be deterred. Imagine what your life would look like if you just vanished from civilization for 2 years. The punishment is a lot more than just the incarceration.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by skinnymuch on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:43AM (#28087045)
He was homeless with mental health issues. Obviously not the mental health BS the state said he had.

This does not change the crux of your post, just some of the points.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by tartoran on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:54PM (#28076339)
This could be fixed with punishment for the responsible party.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by jimothyjames on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:40PM (#28076129)
because it's the only one we got