News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by jstummbillig on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:01PM (#28076440)
It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work.

The justice system mostly works (relative to what its designed to do and the system it evolved out of, which you might both disagree with, but let's not complicate this). By the nature of what it handles (humans) and what you are (human) it will look abhorrently cruel when it fails. And, as with any system, it will definitely continue to fail as long as it is in place.

Assessing an acceptable failure rate is kinda hard – but realistically there has to be one or you will just have to do without any system at all.

So, more interestingly, the thing to look out for is whether a) there are institutions that report on system failures and b) we learn from those failures and correct them at all. As far as I can tell that generally happens in democratic countries.

The next thing to look at is the speed in which we do those corrections. Could they be quicker? Sure. However, it seems like democracies are a tad slow about everything to people everywhere. Or, put differently, we are all wired a little bit too impatiently for how our democracies are currently designed.

I feel that's good thing, constantly scrutinising our systems, keeping them on their toes and improving as we go.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by rabboRubble on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:33PM (#28076900)
the issue for me isn't that a mistake was made, the issue is that the parties responsible for the mistake conspired in secret without official record to cover up their error, and left the man dumped in a homeless shelter with fifty cents.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:12PM (#28079049)
This happens "all the time". Taking responsibility is not 'in vogue' nowadays. (Prime examples are the lasts president. Obama was big on cracking down on whistleblowers. Orange explicitly claimed many times that managing stuff is not his responsibility, he has people for that.)
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by jstummbillig on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28077212)
Agreed. What happened here is absolutely horrific.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by RIMR on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:51PM (#28077138)
They failed him repeatedly. This wasn't a one-time screwup, this was a systemic failure across multiple organizations.

And when they realized they had wronged this man, they did whatever they could to sweep it under the rug and avoid consequences, or reparations for their actions.

The system doesn't just "look abhorrently cruel", it IS abhorrently cruel, and this incident is a clear example of that.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by majormajor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:58PM (#28077248)
So let's look at this. There were people who screwed up. Then they covered it up.

The key question is "what sort of system makes it harder to cover things up?" because the people element of people not wanting to get in trouble or have their mistakes visible isn't going to go anywhere.

You also need to have the non-mistake, non-cruel cases visible, to see if things are changing for the better or worse, rate-wise.

A "less cruel" system isn't a particularly specific or well-defined thing to strive for if it's not specifically trying to address those human failings, since people can still be cruel.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:18PM (#28077487)
The US uniquely shields officials in these cases which promotes coverups. That’s a specific, systematic, and correctable failing of the US justice system not simply normal human issues.

How hard it is for the coverup to work is largely irrelevant IMO.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by majormajor on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:54PM (#28080466)
What's unique about it?

The incentive also seems backward here: if there's a shield protecting you even in case of screwup, you are incentivized to cover things up less than otherwise.

Protection from initial mistakes, like "blame free retros," is generally heralded as a way to promote fixing root causes and reduce political coverups.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:03PM (#28080582)
Protecting an initial screwup is fine, protecting the coverup is what I take issue with.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:16PM (#28079104)
Not uniquely. It's not uncommon for people in official capacity to have immunity from lawsuits relating to their work.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:54PM (#28079662)
Usually it’s protection from the initial mistake not the coverup, the US protects both.

Though I am interested if you have some other examples.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by pas on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:20PM (#28108814)
Does it? I mean if the coverup becomes proven in criminal court, then are they still protected? I thought the problem with coverups is that they are very hard to prove, and when some of them eventually get uncovered, then the department simply treats it as some small irrelevant internal affair. Hence legally QI still stands.

Though of course it's strange that these half admissions of coverups are not treated sufficiently seriously by the courts.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by 8note on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:30PM (#28080167)
Wouldn't a lack of shield promote coverups?

The only loss for the officials here is embarassment

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by Retric on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:04PM (#28080592)
You can shield people from a mistake without also shielding them from a coverup.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by wombatmobile on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:28PM (#28079287)
We don't have a US justice system.

We have a US legal system.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:58PM (#28079706)
Or a "punishment" system, given the elected sheriff/DA motivation to be "tough on crime".
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by wombatmobile on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:08PM (#28081253)
Well, it goes both ways, depending on circumstances and resources.

The US legal system is a commercial system. By that, I don't mean to say it is corrupt. Rather, the participants in the system require representation i.e. lawyers, and lawyers charge for their time, by design. Consequently, access to outcomes of the legal system is a function of the financial and social resources of the participants.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by satellite2 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:10PM (#28079009)
I assume the shame would be proportional to the cruelty inflicted to the wrongly incarcerated, and in the US public figures love to show how cruel they are with deviant people.
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by eptcyka on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:30PM (#28079315)
Maybe a better fix would to make admitting and fixing mistakes was cheap and relatively cheerful?
Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28077225)
>It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work.

It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his cheap internet virtue points depend on his not understanding it.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by bendbro on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:06PM (#28077336)
> It is beyond me how people intelligent enough to hang around HN can pretend to have no understanding of how systems work

I think this is my largest hatred. People's first action after something bad happens is not to discover why it happened, but rather to express outrage that it happened. In my ideal society they would be excluded.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by mLuby on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:10PM (#28077388)
Outrage is fine as a motivator if it leads to investigation, and that investigation may lead to action.

What's not okay is skipping the investigation step, to jump straight from outrage to action.

Re:Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two ... by manmal on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:21PM (#28079173)
Get ready to exclude 90% or so of the general population then?