And the author's initial response was to leave the easter egg in, but to just fix the bug in it, since this behaviour was never intended (the intent was to trigger the easter egg on error condition, the bug was that it also triggered on manpath lookups).
Later in the thread the author mentions they eventually removed it completely after "some reflection", but they don't really expand on their reasons.
Were people annoyed? Was the author pressured? Was that the reason?
For me, the point of an Easter egg in software is to make people who discover it smile without getting in their way: make a few people's days a little brighter. The nature of this one was that it wasn't all that likely that people would notice it - you had to run man without non-option arguments at the right time and you also had to know enough about ABBA for the output to remind you of the lyrics. For six years I heard barely a peep about it, and I'd pretty much forgotten about it myself, then suddenly it turns up on Stack Exchange and is all over the internet. Somebody on HN suggested that maybe this was the fewest bits needed to encode a widely-distributed earworm. The Register later had a comment thread on it full of ABBA puns. I'd only ruin it if I decided to be an arse about it; for a formerly-obscure silly bit of code, it isn't going to get any better than this anyway.
Four years later, it still occasionally crops up and I get an ABBA earworm for the next day. I'm not sad about that!
Of course there may be some that have been using the existing behavior as a convenient way of telling if it is 00:30, but they have so far apparently remained silent.
As xkcd says (https://xkcd.com/1172/), "every change breaks someone's workflow".
Elton John - "Rocket Man": released April 1972
ABBA - "Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!": released 1979
So maybe it's more recognizable, but definitely not more recent.
Aside from that, the joke of printing this phrase at 00:01 only works with the ABBA song, because it refers to a man after midnight...
ABBA - Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! (A Man After Midnight)
> Half past twelve [00:30] and I'm watching the late show in my flat all alone, how I hate to spend the evening on my own
The chorus later continues
> Gimme Gimme Gimme a man after midnight
Of course a more reasonable approach would be to grep the source code.
> This issue has been fixed with commit 84bde8: Running man with man -w will no longer trigger this easter egg.
Running man with no arguments still triggers it. I also must have missed the part where someone "pushed their view".
https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/man-db.git/commit/?id=84bd...
https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/man-db.git/commit/?id=b225...
Yeah, this is what they wrote:
>After some reflection, I've removed this Easter egg. It'll be gone in the upcoming man-db 2.8.0.
One could also do like the nano developers did and add a straight forward configure flag to disable Easter eggs, which some distros then dutifully set for their nano packages.
Gimme gimme gimme. Gimme some more. Gimme gimme gimme. Don't ask what for.
If they want a cute reference every invocation, fine. If they want a cute reference in a bizarre edge case, well maybe. Still poor taste. I don't like to think what it will take, but sooner or later the people demanding that programs do what they are documented to do are going win the battle. They have technical correctness on their side.
Good on the maintainer for being responsible.
Where is the boundary between responsible and harmless fun?
Perhaps I should be careful not to edit this comment in case someone's test pipeline curls it and checks the content.
NPM turned out to be the source, with (this time) an American cultural reference: https://github.com/npm/npm/issues/20439
I would much prefer 1 January 1970, 1 January 2000, or some other date that is clearly a placeholder.
I wonder if AI’s will create Easter eggs in their creations? Would they see them as a form of play, or only as a form of waste? What would that say about the eventual differences between a human and an artificial mind?
Sadly while many people enjoyed it, others were annoyed by it. And the author has now removed it.
I find it hard to relate with people who not only would be annoyed by something like this, but are annoyed about it enough to push their view on the internet to the point that the author feels the need to remove it.
In my view, the best response to those people? Update it to a more recent, or perhaps a more recognisable reference. Perhaps "Rocket Man".