News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by stormdennis on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:50PM (#27922732)
America shouldn't be allowed to extradite and prosecute people who have not committed crimes in America. They'd never allow it in reverse. Also the justice system there doesn't inspire confidence.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by anonymousDan on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:27PM (#27923111)
I agree. There was a horrendous incident recently in the UK where an American woman drove the wrong way up a particular road and ran over a teenager. Somehow she was spirited out of the country and now the US refuse to extradite her.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:32PM (#27923171)
You’re talking about Anne Sacoolas. There’s more to it: she’s a spook, and she fled on board of US military plane, lying about having diplomatic immunity.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by rhino369 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @11:35PM (#27926913)
She had diplomatic immunity. There is a lot of bad reporting in that case.

The US always puts it diplomats back on a plane ASAP after that sort of incident. My buddy in the foreign service ran someone over while on a tour and they did exactly the same thing. Back on the next flight out.

It sounds callous, but the person would otherwise become a scapegoat for the US.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:55AM (#27927942)
Indeed, the US tends to protect its criminals from justice, as long as they work for the government. It’s not callous, though, it’s just bullying. The “scapegoat” argument could make sense in a few countries without proper judicial system, but obviously doesn’t make sense with European countries.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by rhino369 on Friday July 23, 2021 @12:59PM (#27932933)
The "scapegoat" argument makes sense here too. Mrs. Sacoolas was seen as a personification of Trump's foreign policy. People were calling for her head, for an crime that generally doesn't even receive jail time (in the UK or USA).

People don't normally get incensed over non-DUI car accidents.

People were out for blood because her husband and allegedly she worked for US intelligence agencies. If she was just a tourist who forgot which side of the road she was supposed to drive on the case would just be in the local papers.

You can see it in this thread on hacker news. THEY WERE SPOOKS! STRING EM UP. Uh, no, they were working on a joint intelligence mission with the UK. The vast majority of intelligence workers are analysts and support staff not little green men.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:20PM (#27934565)
No, people wanted blood because she avoided all responsibility by lying about diplomatic immunity and fleeing the country. Nobody would say a thing if she did have a minimum of dignity and didn’t behave like a professional criminal.

The only reason for mentioning her being a spook is how she used that fact to escape.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by gadders on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:32AM (#27928502)
There's pretty good evidence that she didn't have diplomatic immunity at the time of the incident:

https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2019/10/the-foreign-...

(And say what you like about Craig Murray, he was an ex-diplomat so should understand the rules around immunity).

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by rhino369 on Friday July 23, 2021 @12:44PM (#27932752)
Both the State Department and the UK High Court agreed she did.

The US and UK even changed the rule to remove diplomatic immunity from spouses of people at that base after the incident (but not retroactively), which proves she did have it at the time.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:23PM (#27934603)
I’m not aware of High Court determining that. I’m aware of American court proving that she didn’t. The State Department doesn’t have any reason not to lie, given that they facilitated her escape.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by anonymousDan on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:38PM (#27923233)
Yes - my understanding is she was the wife of a spoon and didn't have diplomatic immunity? I agree perhaps there is more to it, but still it leaves a bad taste in the mouth.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:42PM (#27923314)
She (and US officials I think?) lied that she was a diplomat’s wife and thus had immunity. The fact that she’s herself a spook - and thus didn’t have immunity - was discovered later, during the trial.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by f38zf5vdt on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:30PM (#27923912)
For non-native English speakers, spook is vernacular for government intelligence agent (spy).
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by microtherion on Thursday July 22, 2021 @05:03PM (#27924299)
… or a caucasian, or an Asian, or an Afrian-American, or an Australian, or a heroin addict: https://greensdictofslang.com/entry/a23ap7q

Clearly, the parent comment's interpretation is correct in this context. The only other use I've encountered was #3, I believe in James Ellroy novels.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by mdda on Friday July 23, 2021 @12:02AM (#27927061)
FWIW, for the International audience, the (excellent) UK series "Spooks" was renamed "MI-5" - it was all about the domestic intelligence services in the UK, and (IMHO) worth looking for on NetFlix...
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by anonymousDan on Thursday July 22, 2021 @05:56PM (#27924854)
I stand corrected, thanks.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by argonaut on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:57PM (#27924226)
There are conflicting reports on her diplomatic immunity and whether she was still employed as a spy (she was definitely employed by the US govt at the time, and as a spy in the past). So it's not as simple as saying she didn't have it or she lied about it. Looks to me like a complicated legal matter.

At least the US State Dept position is that she did have diplomatic immunity.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by rjsw on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:53PM (#27925311)
And if she was still a spy that should have been declared to the UK.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by bagacrap on Thursday July 22, 2021 @08:32PM (#27926003)
what is the point of diplomatic immunity? surely it's not intended to grant the right to murder/manslaughter
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by MichaelZuo on Thursday July 22, 2021 @08:47PM (#27926094)
That’s exactly the point since otherwise there would be more opportunities for false flag attacks on, or by, diplomats overriding a non absolute immunity.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:58AM (#27927961)
That might the point for some third world countries, and the US, which openly protect their criminals (usually war criminals) from justice.

With more civilized countries, the idea is that the person accused is still being tried, but in its country court, with the assumption that if they are guilty, they will get sentenced anyways.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by hermannj314 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @08:05PM (#27925831)
In 1985, the US extradited John Demjanjuk to Israel for crimes he committed in Poland.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by rwmj on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#27922859)
Are you saying that (alleged) accounting fraud against a company based in the US isn't a crime in America?
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by ris on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:29PM (#27923126)
Has a US company that deals with a Chinese one be considered to have committed a crime in China if the Chinese decide they have broken one of their laws? And in such a case what are peoples feelings about extradition?
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by kube-system on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:44PM (#27923334)
Usually when countries disagree significantly on law, they just don't sign extradition agreements. It takes at least two countries to make this decision. The US has not signed such an agreement, and thus, it doesn't matter what China thinks.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by buran77 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:41PM (#27924037)
> when countries disagree significantly on law, they just don't sign extradition agreements

That isn't about "compatibility" of the laws. The US has extradition treaties with pretty much all of their allies but the conditions are mainly dictated by the US given their stronger position.

No country's laws condones war crimes and yet no international court even tried prosecuting any case of suspected war crimes committed by the US military because of things like this [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Service-Members%27_Pr...

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by kube-system on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:56PM (#27924214)
I'm not talking about disagreements in the minutia of law. I'm talking about "disagreement" of law in a broad context. Extraditions to the US, even from countries with which the US has a treaty, are not always honored.

My point is that it's not a one-way street. Countries extradite because they think it's in their best interest.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by buran77 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @05:08PM (#27924370)
> Countries extradite because they think it's in their best interest

Indeed and that was my point. Treaties are signed despite significant disagreements in the law, that's not the driving factor you made it out to be earlier. The EU and the US historically disagreed significantly on things like the death penalty or drug related crimes yet the extradition treaties were readily signed. But interests are better served by avoiding retaliation.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by kube-system on Thursday July 22, 2021 @05:12PM (#27924421)
There are multiple factors and law is absolutely one.

The fact that the US has the death penalty is a commonly cited reason that other countries deny or hesitate to extradite.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by Lendal on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#27922856)
The article makes it sound like the victim was HP, an American company, based in America. Did I misinterpret something?
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:34PM (#27923186)
It shouldn’t matter: jurisdiction depends on where the crime was committed, not on alleged victim’s nationality.

This only happens one way, with extradition to the US, thanks to worldwide bullying.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by throwawaycuriou on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:46PM (#27923363)
As a US resident, if I rolled a large boulder downhill and fatally crushed a small child across the Mexican or Canadian border, would I be liable to extradition?
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by mjw1007 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:36PM (#27923974)
There have been cases of US citizens literally shooting and killing Mexican children over the border, and extradition was refused.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hernandez_v._Mesa

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by pkaye on Thursday July 22, 2021 @07:27PM (#27925549)
That is because the shooter was a border patrol agent and they get qualified immunity.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:07AM (#27928031)
Again, this is something that only happens one way: if any other country was arbitrarily claiming immunity for their agent who murdered someone in the US, like the US did here, the US would carpet bomb them.

The morally correct way would be probably to go full Mossad and either kidnap, or disappear the perpetrator, but that can’t happen for political reasons. Same reason why Blackwater terrorists avoid consequences.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by watwut on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:49AM (#27928595)
How does that makes it better?
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:50PM (#27923427)
I’m guessing not, as the general rule is that US doesn’t extradite it’s citizens.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by pkaye on Thursday July 22, 2021 @07:24PM (#27925534)
The US does extradite to other countries depending on treaties. Recently there was two to Japan.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/business/carlos-ghosn-esc...

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by trasz on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:47AM (#27927904)
Very, very rarely. I’m guessing in this case extradition was deeply profitable to US for some reason.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by relativ575 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:36PM (#27923986)
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by hayzeus on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:16PM (#27925031)
"Asking for a friend."
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by dragonwriter on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:45PM (#27924087)
> jurisdiction depends on where the crime was committed

No, it doesn't. Sovereignty is inherently unlimited. Jurisdiction depends on the law of the party seeking to exercise it. Bringing someone before the court with jurisdiction may sometimes require external cooperation, but the terms of that are products of diplomacy; there's no hard and fast universal rules.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by toyg on Thursday July 22, 2021 @05:34PM (#27924629)
This is a maximalist view of sovereignty that happens to be common in very few countries on the planet, namely the ones not afraid to use violence against anyone stating the opposite: the US, China, Russia, and a handful of rogue states.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by dragonwriter on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:13PM (#27925003)
> This is a maximalist view of sovereignty that happens to be common in very few countries on the planet

Its actually obligatory under treaties of near universal acceptance; though of course nations are free (and some do) choose not to exercise jurisdiction beyond their borders outside of those areas where treaty requires it. Though I think the more common choice is to apply jurisdiction both to citizens/nationals irregardless of location for at least some offenses as well as general jurisdiction over national territory.

Its true that some countries, like the US, are more inclined than others to assert non-obligatory jurisdiction over acts by foreigners on foreign territory.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by toyg on Friday July 23, 2021 @09:50AM (#27930619)
> Its actually obligatory under treaties of near universal acceptance;

Of course - such treaties, in order to be ratified by as many countries as possible, go for the minimum common denominator, which must be able to accomodate the views of such maximalists too.

Also, to be fair, the ranks of these maximalists tends to change with the fortunes of military power. France and UK, for example, used to be much more aggressive in claiming entitlements.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by dfadsadsf on Thursday July 22, 2021 @07:27PM (#27925553)
Japan just convicted two people that helped Ghosn escape to Lebanon. They were extradited from US.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by favorited on Thursday July 22, 2021 @07:31PM (#27925574)
For a crime they committed in Japan.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by chrisseaton on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:59PM (#27923549)
> America shouldn't be allowed to extradite...

America aren't extraditing him - the UK is extraditing him.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by teh_klev on Thursday July 22, 2021 @04:59PM (#27924254)
Sure, but a bit nit-picky. The extradition process being fought against in court was initiated by the US government.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by chippy on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:04PM (#27924928)
having the biggest economy, army, navy and airforce in the world means whats allowed is relative to that power
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by Ostrogodsky on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:21PM (#27925058)
I am not sure if you are arguing if that is how it is or how it should be.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by sjaak on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:54PM (#27922771)
You’re right of course. But as always. The strong do what they can, and the weak suffer what they must.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by adventured on Thursday July 22, 2021 @10:42PM (#27926618)
Oh yes, those poor weak British. History has been so unkind to them, torturing them so in their forever weakness. If only they were, just once, in a great position of power.
Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by sjaak on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:56AM (#27928627)
My point was more general. The US exercises their power and that is not surprising: it is a fact of life.

Case in point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Service-Members%27_Pr...

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by acover on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:56PM (#27922797)
Edit: ignore me, I didn't know what I was talking about.

Irrelevant information: The us has extradition treaties with many countries.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition_law_in_the_Unite...

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by mjw1007 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:04PM (#27922871)
It does, but the question is whether the US would extradite one of its citizens for crimes they'd allegedly committed _while in the US_.

I don't see anything on that Wikipedia page that says it would.

The more usual case for extradition is for returning fugitives who have left the country where they allegedly committed the crime.

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by acover on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:25PM (#27923080)
Sorry, I misunderstood.

> The treaty has been claimed to be one-sided[3] because it allows the US to demand extradition of British citizens and other nationals for offences committed against US law, even though the alleged offence may have been committed in the UK by a person living and working in the UK (see for example the NatWest Three), and there being no reciprocal right; and issues about the level of proof required to extradite from the UK to the US versus from the US to the UK.[4]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK–US_extradition_treaty_of_...

Re:Autonomy founder Mike Lynch can be extradited to US by capableweb on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:03PM (#27922862)
> You are wrong

What do you mean "wrong"? They expressed an opinion, not a fact.

That you shouldn't be able to be extradited to a country you have nothing to do with, is something I agree with as well, but I wouldn't say it's "true". What is true today is that many countries have treaties to allow them to basically kidnap citizens of other countries. If you think that's good/bad, you should argue for one of those viewpoints, not necessarily if it's true/false.