Animals are a low efficiency method of converting plant material into meat, both in terms of calories and protein mass input/output. So with scale, eventually lab-grown meat should become much cheaper than traditional meat. At the same time, it will be higher quality. Sterile production will eliminate E. Coli, salmonella, antibiotics... Input nutrients will be tightly controlled. Environmental pollutants and parasites will be kept out.
Traditional meat will still be available, but it will be an expensive and morally questionable luxury product, like "foie gras" today.
No politician, at least in the U.S. mainstream, is going to commit political self-destruction by going after farmers and making animal meat illegal. What will likely happen though is once the big restaurant chains and grocery stores start selling lab-grown meat that is better quality and cheaper than animal meat, the market for cheap animal meat will dry up. We'll have politicians trying to "save beef jobs" just like they are trying to save coal jobs today, due to more efficient and environmentally-friendly alternatives taking over the market. But unlike coal, consumers can still choose animal meat (you can't exactly choose your power plant), so it might be a long transition due to that market demand. Expect the Arby's and ilk to continue to tout how they use "real meat" with hypermasculine advertising for a long time to come.
And to some extent, they have a point. But of course they don't invite you to eat natural whole plant foods instead of meat.
For example, goats eat almost any plant, including many natives. Unless you think humans are going to be able to eat chaparral.
The fact is that modern edible agriculture is heavily dependent on fossil fuel and mined fertilizers. Until we solve that problem, it's better to stop growing too many plants, let native vegetation regrow and set loose the troops of goats and chickens.
People have this idea that plants and vegetables are clean..they're not
Also, even that 86% isn't "free" - it's not all pasturing, and it takes a lot of effort, energy, and equipment to get hay, inedible by-products of human-edible crops, etc. from the field to animals' mouths.
[0] https://www.cgiar.org/news-events/news/fao-sets-the-record-s...
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Diet-Small-Planet-20th-Anniversary/dp...
Two things. Firstly, those are 16 Calories that would otherwise quite literally go to waste. They would be metabolized by bacteria, used to grow a bacterial mat in a compost bin, and then be released into the air in the form of CO2.
Secondly, I'm not sure what 8g of protein per edible gram of protein produced means. Ruminants like cows convert carbs and other compounds into protein by hosting gut bacteria. Without a cow or chicken or something in between, these amino acids would have to come from somewhere else. Same with B12.
I personally suspect the real ratio is less than what’s being cited just because I’m a cynic, but there seems to be some logic to it no?
Animals get feds lots and lots. Here's a description of finishing cattle, from a beef marketing perspective:
https://www.highlandcattleusa.org/content/Grain%20Finished%2...
Casually talks about feeding cattle their weight (or 2x) in corn over the last 3 months of their lives.
I think that’s the central point of this thread where folks are talking past one a other.
In a hypothetical scenario where animals are more or less only eating food that humans can’t, it makes a lot of sense (from an environmental if not ethical standpoint) to include animals in the mix of foods people eat.
The impression I get is that in reality, animals grown for meat consume quite a bit of human-edible food (or food that could be trivially replaced with human-edible varieties), although I have no idea of the actual percentage.
The plants that cattle and many other livestock eat - including grasses, corn, and other feed crops - contains protein. The exact amount depends on the plant, its age, and growing conditions, but it's often 10 to 15% by mass. Cows apparently consume about eight grams of protein for every gram of protein that makes it to humans' plates, with the rest of the amino acids presumably making up inedible organs and/or being used for bodily functions while they're alive.
I disagree. Average caloric and protein efficiency is 7%–8%. For beef specifically, it is only 3%. I don't know how efficiently a cultured meat factory could convert grass into beef, but I bet it could do a better.
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/10/1...
No one doubts that chicken is more efficient than beef. I have not argued that beef is the best animal.
> Animals are extremely efficient at converting inedible food to edible nutrition.
Animals are pretty inefficient at converting plants to calories, e.g. see https://learn.uvm.edu/foodsystemsblog/2014/07/10/meat-vs-veg...
Most of the energy spent getting grains to the table is in transport/processing. If you just compare the production, grains are way more efficient than animals.
Even though I'm sure goats are better than cows, they aren't as efficient as plants at producing calories, and in all cases you still have to process and transport them.
However if you've got some data showing otherwise I'm open to being convinced here.
> Until we solve that problem, it's better to stop growing too many plants
I think this is making perfect the enemy of the good. Plants use less water, produce substantially less GHG emissions, and so are still a net major win on environmental terms vs. the status quo.
That is not what that graph shows. That graph purports to count all energy 'inputs' into the system, including human labor. This is not about 'how many calories did the cow / pig eat, versus what it produced'.
Here's an example.
Consider wheat grass. Both a cow and a human can eat this grass. However, the human can eat the seed, the cow / pig / goat can eat the entire plant. If you burn the entire wheat plant, and count the calories released you will get some number. Let's call it Y. If you count the calories in the seed that we eat, it'll necessarily be less, let's say X.
Ideally, if we're going to produce Y calories in the grain, humans ought to be able to consume as close to Y calories as possible in order to get the total benefit. Since humans can only eat X, and X < Y. Then it makes sense to feed Y-X calories to a low maintenance animal (so not beef), and then eat the animal. This will yield some number N < (Y-X) that humans can consume. This also provides a complete protein, fats, and other nutrients not found in grain (B12, which is not found in plants period, for example, thus preventing yet another synthesis process).
X + N < Y, but it is much closer to the actual amount of energy in the grain plant than just X. And then we'd need to count the energy expenditure getting the B12 and Vitamin D produced and distributed as well. And then the supply chain risk costs. All these things have costs that never get considered.
And survive in a very complex and hostile environment, adapt to changing conditions, procreate, and build all the structure and tissues and organs that requires. That's a lot of energy that bioreactor-grown steak doesn't have to expend. At scale, and with some genetic optimization thrown in, can we do better? I don't know for sure, but I don't think it's an impossibility, given that most of the current meat supply is already grown in factories.
It's very strange to me, because growing up, we'd eat everything. But I married into an American family, and I'm often picking stuff off the bones they throw out. We were raised to eat everything, even the marrow.
> That's a lot of energy that bioreactor-grown steak doesn't have to expend
Sure, but the bioreactor is (1) heavily affected by supply chain issues, (2) dependent on an external source of energy, (3) requires complex chemical inputs that have to be synthesized themselves oftentimes. No one takes into account the whole thing.
Also, monoculture is always going to be less resilient than an actual population of cattle, or pigs, or chickens. But, I guess this is a problem that affects the whole industry.
Humans eat like 5% of the actual plant matter we harvest. The rest is composted which just releases more greenhouse gases. If you feed it to a pig, then you at least get that car on released after feeding a human.
The 'plant based' push is once again feelings without science.
There's this weird thing with some speciality produce clashing with EU regulations on food prep at the moment. Not to mention unpasteurised milk. It could end up in that basket. Strange clubs of weirdos meeting up to butcher and eat an animal, and everyone else thinking that's completely disgusting.
"`Jesus,' Molly said, her own plate empty, `gimme that. You know what this costs?' She took his plate. `They gotta raise a whole animal for years and then they kill it. This isn't vat stuff.' She forked a mouthful up and chewed."
To me (and I suspect a lot of others here on HN), the idea of getting a mined diamond is just lunacy. Why on earth would I pay twice as much for something that is literally the same at the atomic level?
And yet enormous numbers of people still do. I'm lucky to have a wife who is a scientist (she would've slapped me upside the head if I had wasted money on a mined diamond), but there are a lot of women out there who would be very upset to receive a lab-grown diamond.
So while I very much agree with what you're saying here, and it just seems crazy to me that anyone else wouldn't, I do wonder what percent of folks will continue to demand "real" meat even when lab-grown is superior along all dimensions.
What we have going on right now is killing us.
I'm surprised I don't need a Monsanto license to bake bread at home.
E.g. producers of lab-grown meat has an interest in:
* Pushing for taxes or reduced subsidies on "natural" meat with environmental reasoning. This will get easier the more people switch.
* Pushing a "our meat never had a face but is still real meat" angle.
* Undercutting on price.
* Providing "impossible" meat. E.g. cuts that are impossible, compositions that are impossible. Species that are impractical or annoying (e.g. quail and many other birds have so little meat relative to bones that while they're tasty they're a nuisance to eat - lab-grown meat can potentially be "better" than natural meat that way), or meat with other ingredients embedded directly in the meat. Marketing "old meat" as "old fashioned", boring and lower quality.
* Pushing a "do you know where their meat has been? We know where ours has been" angle.
I don't think a ban will happen until a ban is mostly pointless. That is, I think lab-grown meats have to succeed first, and then when most people have stopped caring because they mostly eat lab-grown meats, it's possible a ban would get sufficient support.
However, there will be a few shifts. Any meat that is unrecognizable as cuts of meat - hamburgers, sausages, etc - will be 'cut' with factory meat as a means to cut costs (assuming factory meat will become cheaper than livestock, which I'm confident it will with scale), similar to how it's now filled with water, MRM and other fillers, or how a few years back there was a big controversy in the UK when it turned out ground beef contained horse meat.
It'll be awhile before legislation catches up to make it mandatory to indicate the source of the meat.
But, if this scales up, I think total meat consumption will only increase.
If you eat a burger now, with lab-grown meat not really available, are you behaving immorally?
If you eat an animal in (say) 10 years' time, when lab-grown meat is readily available, are you behaving immorally then?
If you eat an animal in (say) 20 years' time, when that involves quite a lot of effort (finding a butcher who sells it, paying the price premium, etc). Are you behaving immorally then?
If you eat an animal after they ban killing animals for food, is that immoral? (i.e. is it the law that makes the action immoral?)
At what point does our (presumably moral) action of eating meat become immoral? Is that up to us as individuals, or is it up to our churches, or government, or what? Who makes this decision, and how is that communicated, and is it retroactive?
I see it as immoral now, and immoral in twenty years. It is just socially accepted. Most of the meat-eating people I know don't even try and justify from a moral standpoint. They usually say "I know it's wrong, I just like meat". So in twenty years they will say "I knew it was wrong, it was just how life was back then".
Based on this, I would bet that our current domestic meat animals would go extinct relatively quickly. There are some people who try to preserve various breeds in what are essentially zoos, but I can't imagine them operating in perpetuity.
1: https://www.livestockconservancy.org/index.php/heritage/inte...
But land has many other alternative uses. Until we value every one of those alternative uses less than we value preserving nature itself, we'll tend to use the land for something else.
Of course it depends on the land in question. Any land that is currently good for grazing and nothing should immediately be freed up once grazing stops being economical. Unfortunately, the land like that is not the most biodiverse -- it's rocky scrub, not forest -- but I'll be happy to see it added to the set of lands we don't want to mess with.
There’s also the whole infrastructure and supply chain dedicated to the breeding and raising of various meat sources. What will happen to them?
Our economy and workplaces are significantly different from what they were when horses were replaced by cars.
The 21st century isn't special and we weren't born a quarter century ago. The economy and our workplaces will continue to evolve, as they have since the beginning of time.
I think you're vastly underestimating how much work there is left to do.
The big issue is the slaughterhouses, which would obviously die out but which also may be the only big employeer around, kinda like the steel mills used to be. The farms raising feed are not likely to employ a lot of people.
Can you list them?
Perhaps, if those statues were originally erected in honor of their diet, and to remind the vegetarians of the time who was in charge.
I know the false equivalency isn’t really your point, but come on.
But fair criticism, it's not an equivalence. I was struggling to find a decent example.
Though I can totally see a PETA stunt of pulling down a statue of Elvis because he ate meat.
Oh most definitely.
I get it, and I really debated whether it was worth posting and opening the whole can of worms. From an American POV, I figured the can was already cracked and it was worth airing it out all the way rather than let it sit. It’s a sore spot.
Gotta say I think the wider point about how things we take for granted today may be viewed in the future is a good one, and can be applied across our social/economic relations. I for one hope to be considered a barbarian by our ancestors.
I'm all for replacing TJ statues with ones honoring better human beings.
Even Abraham Lincoln's statue got torn down in Portland, OR last year. Not because he was a slaveowner but because he oversaw expulsion of Native Americans from their land and executed 36 Native prisoners. I would not assume that any president's statue is safe from public ire.
Maybe the same will happen with meat. Veal, foie gras, shark fin, octopus, endangered animals, etc. Most of the blame will fall on producers, but “carnivorous” over eaters like Ron Swanson from parks and rec might age poorly.
Whenever people bring up gay marriage legality, I think it’s also important to show this graph. https://xkcd.com/1431/
Expect live meat to be overwhelmingly abhorred before you see a ban.
It might not be a coincidence that he was targetted as being perhaps the most racist genocidal President.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_twenty-dollar_bi...
All that not to mention, it's ridiculous to be putting someone who didn't think the US should have a central bank on the US's money.
Statues, money, and the like are how we communicate to the world and ourselves reminders of those whose lives we find worth emulating. As our morals change and we start to find things like slavery, forced death-marches and ethnic cleansing abhorrent, is it really wrong for us to update our imagery of whose lives we should emulate? At least to stop idolizing those people who were most notable for, or even raised arms in insurrection in support of, those acts?
He's the reason the Democratic Party exists, sure that's worth something…
It's also not clear to me that, its whole ~200 year lifespan considered, the Democratic Party has put its average in the green relative to historical atrocity (nor, for that matter, have the GOP).
Just because they ate meat? Maybe not, but they may not look kindly on those that did large scale killing with less than humane practices. I could see this individuals being more likely to be "Cancelled."
Maybe those that fought vegans or fought against animal rights activities?
Those opposing change for the better or were active participants in things we in the future see as bad.
Remember that most people cancelled were active participants, rather than passive bystanders going with the flow.
I should clarify. I'm not criticising cancel culture. I'm interested in how the shift in morality happens and how it propagates, and what that means for us now. Is morality retroactive? Am I an immoral person because I eat meat, even though it's common practise now?
It's easy to judge someone for complicity in the mass murder of countless animals when you have the luxury of having been saved from that choice by more advanced technology.
It already is lost among many people today so that's not a stretch in the slightest. There are an egregious amount of people that use the morality of the present to judge the decisions of the past when the whole system and culture was different. All simply because these people were spoon-fed and told "this is bad because of 'x'" without explaining from a mindset of why people thought the way they did at the time. I mean the simple fact that there is a concept of "leftism" is enough to state that there is an ideology that someone can measure you against on how "woke" you may or may not be. It's exactly no different than the Catholic church setting up a mock trial to determine if you are a heretic! Except it's not a centralized theology. But clearly it has enough adherence that there are some aristocrats that are willing to kowtow to the belief system.
We can kind-of see this now with seafood, where "wild caught" is more expensive than farmed.
You can make cuts that are bigger than they currently can be. You can adjust composition, fat content, potentially embed flavourings directly into the meat, or combine types of meat, or create types of meat that doesn't even exist today.
So I'm sure it will take time, but there's also a fairly good chance what will win people over will be that it'll be possible to provide products that just doesn't exist from "natural" sources.
People just form an emotional attachment to ‘natural’ things.
I also think this is a lot less likely to happen with meat. With diamonds part of the value is in signalling status. As such there is little incentive for customers to want to participate in driving down the price.
With lab-grown meat there will eventually be a number of outright benefits.
Lab-grown meat will no-doubt eventually become a common ingredient once it is economically viable. However it'll likely start off in highly processed foods where consumers are not especially discerning or seeking to signal status through consumption. This would include products like ready-made frozen meals and fast food.
It may eventually enter fine dining, but it won't obtain market dominance in our life times. People just get too set in their ways as they age, for instance the elderly in Japan drive demand for Whale meat. Older people tend to have the disposable income required for fine dining.
For the longer term I'd think it would be more like cannibalism which humanity likely widely engaged in early on but very few would even consider today.
Just gross and icky and "you'd eat an animal!!!??" (disclaimer, I eat lots of meat).
It's also entirely possible that lab grown meat becomes prevalent and simply coexists with raising animals for food for the foreseeable future.
So if there is vat-grown pork but they never manage to get the beef quite right, will it be acceptable to eat cows but not pigs? I guess that's the slope.
So yes, this has to be a slippery slope ;)
There are a lot more vegetarians and vegans than just PETA. It looks like around 5% of the US and hitting 10% in many countries (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegetarianism_by_country). Many parts of India have very high vegetarian rates.
> How long will it be between the introduction of lab-grown meat until killing animals for food is banned?
I doubt that it will be about banning animal meat anytime soon. However, I think we might see many countries start to tax the environmental cost of meat which will make it quite expensive. This is unlikely in the US, but I could certainly see it in many countries whose politics are different.
> Will we get to the point where statues of now-famous people are pulled down because they ate animals? Assuming some variant of "cancel culture" exists then
I think this isn't a useful thought right now and just feeds into the "cancel culture gone mad" ideas. Few people have been canceled. Yea, Harvey Weinstein has been canceled...for rape. Kevin Spacey has been canceled...because of sexual assault against underage boys. Most people who seem to complain about being canceled are sitting on Fox News taking home giant paychecks. Tons of people encouraged riots at the Capitol and are making millions off it.
Yes, at some point in the very distant future, we might decide that killing animals for food isn't an acceptable behavior. A hundred years ago, a man couldn't be guilty of raping his wife. 200 years ago, a lot of people owned slaves. 60 years ago we had racial segregation. 40 years ago, it was acceptable to say that gay people deserved to die from AIDS. Things change.
But it's not like it's going to happen overnight. It's not like 2017 came along and Harvey Weinstein was like, "omg, is rape wrong now? Things change so quickly and I didn't know!" Attitudes will probably change over decades or centuries.
Like, we've spent hundreds of years getting to the point of "Black people are equal and you shouldn't be racist" and people still often aren't getting canceled for racism. I've seen posts of police officers covering up explicitly racist tattoos saying that in the current climate they feel like they need to be careful. It's been over half a century since the Civil Rights Movement, but now they're like, "oh, I guess I might get in trouble for being explicitly racist in a position of power." The idea that someone would be canceled for eating an animal in our lifetime seems unlikely. It certainly won't happen as some surprise.
> Will we see clever re-interpretations of religious texts dealing with the eating of animals?
In Judaism, a lot of people hold the belief that we won't eat animals in the messianic era (when the messiah comes). People are only allowed to eat animals because Noah saved them from the flood. Before the flood, people weren't allowed to eat animals. Part of the messianic era is that it's supposed to be how the world is meant to be.
This idea isn't a left-wing Jewish idea either. I would note that it's not widely known in the Jewish world and usually more known by orthodox people who do eat meat. Judaism often has a lot of things that might be a little less official, but nonetheless have some weight and resonance.
I think we also see some of this in Christian stuff. I feel like Christians like Isaiah 11:6's "the lion will lie down with the lamb" (yes, I know that technically that's not quite the animals in the text, but it is how I often hear it said by English-language Christians). I think the idea that predators might not be predators in some world-to-come isn't something that has to be creatively reinterpreted.
> Will we get religious divisions between different interpretations?
Yes. I mean, we have religious divisions over really tiny things. This is certainly larger than a lot of religious divisions we've seen.
> Will some people refuse to accept the general moral stance on eating animals because their religious text says it's acceptable?
Do religious texts say it's acceptable? Jewish texts certainly do - and they have a lot to say on how. However, rabbis have modified it over the centuries. Chicken was once acceptable to eat with dairy and now it isn't. I think the big thing for the Jewish community would be that many rabbis would say that lab-grown meat is more in the spirit of how we're supposed to live combined with the fact that it's likely to be so much cheaper than kosher meat tends to be. Given the likely price difference, even people who might be in the "it's fine to kill and eat animals as prescribed" are likely to be buying the lab-grown meat simply because it will make meat accessibly priced. In fact, chicken was deemed to be "fleishig" so that people could have an affordable "meat" for Shabbat meals (the category of "meat" from a Jewish perspective is slightly different from "animal" and doesn't include fish...it's a long story outside the scope of this comment). I think Judaism also evolves around community standards that do change. The Bible condones all sorts of capital punishments, but the rabbis rid the religion of them all a long time ago.
I can't really speak for other religions, but if lab-grown meat becomes available at a cheap price, has better food safety than the current system, can offer better consistency and taste, and causes slaughtered-meat to become niche and a lot more expensive...even if you don't have qualms about killing animals, do you want to pay for it?
Manufactured goods are so cheap because we can manufacture them. Growing animals is hard. It requires a lot of labor, a lot of land, a lot of water, a lot of carbon emissions, a lot of food, etc. I'm sure there will be some market for "real" meat for a long time, but it will likely get expensive. Manufactured meat is likely to get pretty efficient and cheap.
I think it's less about whether religions will continue to support killing animals and more about whether anyone will want to pay for it. "Hey, here's this $1 lab-grown burger that you know will be consistent and delicious and here's this $20 bespoke cow-slaughtered burger." The fact is that most people aren't going to want to pay a premium for the cow-slaughtered burger.
--
Personally, I'm a vegetarian and have been for 15 years. I'm also Jewish. One thing I will note as a difference between semi-religious Jews and non-Jews is the difference in meat consumption. Many Jews, even if they aren't that religious, still won't mix meat and dairy and many won't eat non-kosher-certified meat. I have lots of friends who haven't been to a religious service in years, but still kinda do this out of a certain cultural thing or inertia. One of the things that this means is that they often don't eat meat with most meals. Meat is something they eat 2-4 times per week. By contrast, I'll have lunch with non-Jews where burgers, pizza with meat toppings, salads with chicken, etc. are the norm. Meat is a part of almost every meal.
The difference isn't a moral one: my non-vegetarian Jewish friends don't think eating meat is wrong. Eating meat is simply inconvenient and expensive for them. So they eat meat with a minority of their meals. The fact is that it's likely that slaughtered-meat will become expensive and inconvenient compared to manufactured-meat. Taco Bell or your local pizza place isn't going to spend a lot more money on slaughtered-meat if they can get a wonderful, consistent product at a cheaper price.
Regardless of whether slaughtered-meat stops being a thing or not, it will likely become a much smaller part of people's diets. This will be very important as we deal with global warming. Even if you're the type of person that's like, "I will always love a real steak on a grill and that's going to be every Saturday in the summer," the fact is that you're likely to also be eating a lot of lab-meat when you grab something at Burger King or getting deli-meat for sandwiches.
I think people like thinking about "zero", but for me lab-meat is about the 90% of "well, I just wanted some meat texture and protein in my meal." I'm hoping it'll take off and we'll see a huge reduction of our dependence on slaughtered-meat and the environmental impact it causes. I think it'll take time, but I think it's hard to bet against manufacturing efficiencies.
There's sort of a verse that deals with it. The context is in eating meat sacrificed to idols, aka immoral meat. It's not clear on what that means, where it's eating meat in a ceremonial service or buying meat in the marketplace that was resold donations to a pagan temple. Romans 14: 1-9
>>Accept the one whose faith is weak, without quarreling over disputable matters. One person's faith allows them to eat anything, but another, whose faith is weak, eats only vegetables. The one who eats everything must not treat with contempt the one who does not, and the one who does not eat everything must not judge the one who does, for God has accepted them. Who are you to judge someone else's servant?
>>To their own master, servants stand or fall. And they will stand, for the Lord is able to make them stand. One person considers one day more sacred than another; another considers every day alike. Each of them should be fully convinced in their own mind. 6 Whoever regards one day as special does so to the Lord. Whoever eats meat does so to the Lord, for they give thanks to God; and whoever abstains does so to the Lord and gives thanks to God. 7 For none of us lives for ourselves alone, and none of us dies for ourselves alone. If we live, we live for the Lord; and if we die, we die for the Lord. So, whether we live or die, we belong to the Lord. For this very reason, Christ died and returned to life so that he might be the Lord of both the dead and the living.
I'm not Christian any more, but generally the spirit is more "your brother needs to be vegan, don't convert him or argue with him and do your best to strengthen his faith." Each person must do what he feels God has commanded him to do in his own way.
The new heaven and new earth is a radically different experience. Its not just lion laying down with lamb, its that "we shall neither marry nor be given in marriage, and be like the angels" which Jesus said in answer to people disbelieving in a ressurection. It's a total break from humanity in a sense, and trying to emulate it has led to a lot of cults engaging in self-destructive behavior.
> It's not like 2017 came along and Harvey Weinstein was like, "omg, is rape wrong now? Things change so quickly and I didn't know!"
Within my lifetime (I'm in my 50's) it used to be acceptable to pat girls on the bottom in public, pressure them into sex, rape them if they were drunk enough to not be able to say no, and a whole slew of other nasty behaviours that we now rightfully consider completely unacceptable. The whole Jimmy Saville thing in the UK - the stories coming out of how his demands for young girls to molest as payment for gigs were met by "respectable" organisations - sounds crazy now. Yes, this has changed fast, and caught a lot of people by surprise. I'm not defending any of them; they deserve everything they got. It was always "wrong", and they knew it, but society tolerated it to a certain extent so they could get away with it. Until they couldn't, thankfully.
> Jewish texts certainly do - and they have a lot to say on how.
Thanks for the detail, it's really interesting. I'm don't have much knowledge of Jewish practices. I'm glad to hear that there's some adaptability there. In most of christianity there's a strong element of "god's word doesn't change" - morality is unchanging and immutable, laid down in the bible. There's a strong opinion that atheists cannot be moral because we don't have an objective moral code to follow. This is where I find the fascinating part of the religious aspect - what happens when society's morals change? To a certain extent we can see it with gay marriage - most of the vatican is gay but the catholic church still condemns homosexuality. But this is more about politics than morals - the majority of catholics live in countries where homosexuality is not culturally acceptable, and the church downplays the whole question in countries where it is acceptable. The anglican church faced this crisis a few years ago, kinda, the African bishops did not want to accept gay marriage, the European and American bishops politically had to.
But I think the eating animals question is different, as most people publicly eat meat at the moment. It's not something you can be "in the closet" about and pretend doesn't happen (though I guess that will eventually happen - small groups getting together to kill an animal and eat it secretly). Which is why I think it's going to be more interesting to watch. It's possible that in 30 years we'll have the whole "have you ever eaten an animal?" thing going on, but I doubt it because the vast majority of people have eaten animals at the moment.
There is no need to fight a culture/moral war - they will simply raise the prices of meat and add some nice marketing around the benefits of lab-grown alternatives.
I find it odd that people who truly believe in evolution, and that humans are just smarter animals, and that animals are also capable of sensing pain and emotion, can be deeply concerned (rightfully) about things such as trans rights, gender discrimination, etc. for humans (that are very high on "Maslow's hierarchy"), and yet are perfectly content to pay for meat they know was the product of an industry which is pretty horrific in its treatment of billions of cows, pigs, etc. a year.
Similarly, I have friends who regularly rail against the "wealthy" and how it's immoral to have so much money when people are suffering in poverty. Then the same day will go spend $200 on a handbag or $20 on a cocktail or $1000 on a weekend getaway to Hawaii without blinking, knowing full well those unnecessary purchases cost as much as several meals or vaccines for those less fortunate people that the "rich" should be taxed to help.
How do so many people act contradictory to their stated positions? Are they dishonest with themselves? Haven't thought it through? Or do people just want the world to be a better place... as long as it's not an inconvenience for them personally?
All of the above plus performative outrage / signaling. I'm definitely a healthier person after getting off social media and honestly just caring a lot less about my stances on things and whether they're perfect and holy.
This. So much. Facebook was destroying my mental health.
If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around, does it make a sound?
What do you think happens to animals in the wilderness? Do you think they live a happy life, retire and have a peaceful death among the loved ones? The answer is no, they get brutally murdered by a bigger animal. Did you ever have a cat and witnessed how they can torture a mouse?
That's just the world we live in. I can't change it, and no one can, it's just how it works. Am I supposed to cry in the corner about this unfortunate reality? So yeah, I'm perfectly fine with killing animals for food, as long as it's not done in a dumb way ie. making them go extinct, or in some sadistic manner.
So I guess the answer to your question is that I try to have a realistic worldview and not just what sounds nice. The universe doesn't care about hypocrisy, morality or principles. It's really good to organize a society around it and it's good to have principles, because we have to somehow live with each other, but that's not what it's about.
So if you assume that at some point in the future everyone becomes Synthianian (Synthian?) for moral reasons, is it immoral to eat plants now?
Whatever you call it, it is just highly obnoxious behavior that uses rethoric to defame the target. It works and people will use it until it doesn't.
Anyway, after Hitler blew his brains out, he was "canceled", and that went just fine. It's a tool that works for positive ends just as well.
There are countless examples of products where competitors have tried to approach the quality of a market-leader, and almost got there, but not quite.
Meat is also a good example of a product where humans are exceptionally good at detecting minor variances in quality. Objectively speaking, these are variances that shouldn't matter, but somehow xkcd 915 still emerges.
Also, there is no correlation between goodness and vegetarianism:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler_and_vegetarianism
> For the sake of the experiment, let's assume the sci-fi writers are right, and eating animals will eventually be considered immoral.
Also, is it vegetarianism if you only eat lab-grown meat? It's still meat, right, so you're still not vegetarian. Or is it the "not eating animals" that makes you a vegetarian now?
I tend to think that (e.g.) Iain M Banks is right, and that eventually eating animals will be considered immoral (and not the same as vegetarianism). You may disagree, and that's fine - everyone has an opinion.
The interesting question is not whether the future will consider this immoral, but whether if it becomes immoral in the future that applies retroactively and makes it immoral now? Does morality change over time, or regardless of time?
I grew up in the '70's so I've seen the change in morality first-hand, but that all kinda caught us by surprise. It's going to be interesting being more aware of the change in morality around this.
That's the point of ethical veganism/vegetarianism, yes.
The culture has about as much chance of coming into existence as the fact that we discover unicorns. So why should we take him seriously?
Banks himself said that the Culture has no chance of being created by actual humans, that people would need to change in order to create it. But as a thought experiment for "what would a technological Utopia actually look like?" I think it's a very valuable contribution. There are very few Utopias that I've read about that I would actually want to live in - the Culture is probably the most attractive of any of them.
In this respect, the advent of lab-grown meat does pose the question of whether it's morally acceptable to eat animals. As far as I'm aware, only SF authors have considered this, because that's the kind of thing they do. A technological change has triggered a moral conundrum - this is the stuff that good SF ponders. It's not necessary to get the details of the technology right, or to correctly predict it. It's enough to get us thinking about this stuff before it happens.
Could you tell me any case where statue of famous people were pulled down because they used cotton products made by slaves?
eating meat is not equal to agitating for keeping slavery. so I think meat eaters are safe :)
on the other hand, hardcore people who insist on killing animals without consideration for alternatives could be condemned later after 50 years or something, but I think it's fine. bigger problem is when people keep insisting on immoral things without consideration of alternatives.
overall it's really interesting to see such a big focus on "cancel culture" in this comment.
If it got to the point where it was mandated, we'd probably be in some form of dystopia where everything was in the pursuit of either survival (animals no longer exist or are possible to eat) or sort of a planned world where our governing or elite classes mandate their virtue on everyone, and it would lead to a lot more lifestyle changing that not eating meat. I think the latter is fairly likely, China for example seems to be doing pretty well at a basic form of that.
You do not need to hear any kind of moral guardian to do and conduct yourself knowing that every single person is responsible of the actions they make and though I am not responsible for those starving children I am responsible for many of the atrocities commited for the burgers I ate.
It is not about virtue, it is taking responsibility of your own actions and checking your own ethic to decide if it is correct or not.
I don't agree that easting meat is an atrocity. I think it devalues words to use them like that. I think a lot of veganism is the same reaction to the existence of suffering a lot of religions have had or deal with; it's a form of going to the desert as a monk or mystic to escape the contradictions of the world. That is up to everyone, but the difference here is the monks want to make the entire world the desert now.
For the sake of the experiment, let's assume the sci-fi writers are right, and eating animals will eventually be considered immoral. This is an extreme stance at the moment (hello PETA) but let's assume it will eventually be accepted as the only moral stance.
How long will it be between the introduction of lab-grown meat until killing animals for food is banned? Is this a generational thing (so older people still consider eating animals to be acceptable, while younger people do not), or is it a country-wide thing (countries move to ban eating animals one by one, driven by a general shift in moral attitude), or what? How does this change in morality propagate through society?
Will we get to the point where statues of now-famous people are pulled down because they ate animals? Assuming some variant of "cancel culture" exists then, will that act retroactively and currently-lionised people get cancelled because they are carnivores, even though the current culture that they exist in considers it acceptable?
Will we see clever re-interpretations of religious texts dealing with the eating of animals? Will we get religious divisions between different interpretations? Will some people refuse to accept the general moral stance on eating animals because their religious text says it's acceptable? How does this interaction between objective religious morality and subjective secular morality work?
It's going to be really interesting to watch this unfold.