No politician, at least in the U.S. mainstream, is going to commit political self-destruction by going after farmers and making animal meat illegal. What will likely happen though is once the big restaurant chains and grocery stores start selling lab-grown meat that is better quality and cheaper than animal meat, the market for cheap animal meat will dry up. We'll have politicians trying to "save beef jobs" just like they are trying to save coal jobs today, due to more efficient and environmentally-friendly alternatives taking over the market. But unlike coal, consumers can still choose animal meat (you can't exactly choose your power plant), so it might be a long transition due to that market demand. Expect the Arby's and ilk to continue to tout how they use "real meat" with hypermasculine advertising for a long time to come.
And to some extent, they have a point. But of course they don't invite you to eat natural whole plant foods instead of meat.
For example, goats eat almost any plant, including many natives. Unless you think humans are going to be able to eat chaparral.
The fact is that modern edible agriculture is heavily dependent on fossil fuel and mined fertilizers. Until we solve that problem, it's better to stop growing too many plants, let native vegetation regrow and set loose the troops of goats and chickens.
People have this idea that plants and vegetables are clean..they're not
Also, even that 86% isn't "free" - it's not all pasturing, and it takes a lot of effort, energy, and equipment to get hay, inedible by-products of human-edible crops, etc. from the field to animals' mouths.
[0] https://www.cgiar.org/news-events/news/fao-sets-the-record-s...
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Diet-Small-Planet-20th-Anniversary/dp...
Two things. Firstly, those are 16 Calories that would otherwise quite literally go to waste. They would be metabolized by bacteria, used to grow a bacterial mat in a compost bin, and then be released into the air in the form of CO2.
Secondly, I'm not sure what 8g of protein per edible gram of protein produced means. Ruminants like cows convert carbs and other compounds into protein by hosting gut bacteria. Without a cow or chicken or something in between, these amino acids would have to come from somewhere else. Same with B12.
I personally suspect the real ratio is less than what’s being cited just because I’m a cynic, but there seems to be some logic to it no?
Animals get feds lots and lots. Here's a description of finishing cattle, from a beef marketing perspective:
https://www.highlandcattleusa.org/content/Grain%20Finished%2...
Casually talks about feeding cattle their weight (or 2x) in corn over the last 3 months of their lives.
I think that’s the central point of this thread where folks are talking past one a other.
In a hypothetical scenario where animals are more or less only eating food that humans can’t, it makes a lot of sense (from an environmental if not ethical standpoint) to include animals in the mix of foods people eat.
The impression I get is that in reality, animals grown for meat consume quite a bit of human-edible food (or food that could be trivially replaced with human-edible varieties), although I have no idea of the actual percentage.
The plants that cattle and many other livestock eat - including grasses, corn, and other feed crops - contains protein. The exact amount depends on the plant, its age, and growing conditions, but it's often 10 to 15% by mass. Cows apparently consume about eight grams of protein for every gram of protein that makes it to humans' plates, with the rest of the amino acids presumably making up inedible organs and/or being used for bodily functions while they're alive.
I disagree. Average caloric and protein efficiency is 7%–8%. For beef specifically, it is only 3%. I don't know how efficiently a cultured meat factory could convert grass into beef, but I bet it could do a better.
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/10/1...
No one doubts that chicken is more efficient than beef. I have not argued that beef is the best animal.
> Animals are extremely efficient at converting inedible food to edible nutrition.
Animals are pretty inefficient at converting plants to calories, e.g. see https://learn.uvm.edu/foodsystemsblog/2014/07/10/meat-vs-veg...
Most of the energy spent getting grains to the table is in transport/processing. If you just compare the production, grains are way more efficient than animals.
Even though I'm sure goats are better than cows, they aren't as efficient as plants at producing calories, and in all cases you still have to process and transport them.
However if you've got some data showing otherwise I'm open to being convinced here.
> Until we solve that problem, it's better to stop growing too many plants
I think this is making perfect the enemy of the good. Plants use less water, produce substantially less GHG emissions, and so are still a net major win on environmental terms vs. the status quo.
That is not what that graph shows. That graph purports to count all energy 'inputs' into the system, including human labor. This is not about 'how many calories did the cow / pig eat, versus what it produced'.
Here's an example.
Consider wheat grass. Both a cow and a human can eat this grass. However, the human can eat the seed, the cow / pig / goat can eat the entire plant. If you burn the entire wheat plant, and count the calories released you will get some number. Let's call it Y. If you count the calories in the seed that we eat, it'll necessarily be less, let's say X.
Ideally, if we're going to produce Y calories in the grain, humans ought to be able to consume as close to Y calories as possible in order to get the total benefit. Since humans can only eat X, and X < Y. Then it makes sense to feed Y-X calories to a low maintenance animal (so not beef), and then eat the animal. This will yield some number N < (Y-X) that humans can consume. This also provides a complete protein, fats, and other nutrients not found in grain (B12, which is not found in plants period, for example, thus preventing yet another synthesis process).
X + N < Y, but it is much closer to the actual amount of energy in the grain plant than just X. And then we'd need to count the energy expenditure getting the B12 and Vitamin D produced and distributed as well. And then the supply chain risk costs. All these things have costs that never get considered.
And survive in a very complex and hostile environment, adapt to changing conditions, procreate, and build all the structure and tissues and organs that requires. That's a lot of energy that bioreactor-grown steak doesn't have to expend. At scale, and with some genetic optimization thrown in, can we do better? I don't know for sure, but I don't think it's an impossibility, given that most of the current meat supply is already grown in factories.
It's very strange to me, because growing up, we'd eat everything. But I married into an American family, and I'm often picking stuff off the bones they throw out. We were raised to eat everything, even the marrow.
> That's a lot of energy that bioreactor-grown steak doesn't have to expend
Sure, but the bioreactor is (1) heavily affected by supply chain issues, (2) dependent on an external source of energy, (3) requires complex chemical inputs that have to be synthesized themselves oftentimes. No one takes into account the whole thing.
Also, monoculture is always going to be less resilient than an actual population of cattle, or pigs, or chickens. But, I guess this is a problem that affects the whole industry.
Humans eat like 5% of the actual plant matter we harvest. The rest is composted which just releases more greenhouse gases. If you feed it to a pig, then you at least get that car on released after feeding a human.
The 'plant based' push is once again feelings without science.
There's this weird thing with some speciality produce clashing with EU regulations on food prep at the moment. Not to mention unpasteurised milk. It could end up in that basket. Strange clubs of weirdos meeting up to butcher and eat an animal, and everyone else thinking that's completely disgusting.
"`Jesus,' Molly said, her own plate empty, `gimme that. You know what this costs?' She took his plate. `They gotta raise a whole animal for years and then they kill it. This isn't vat stuff.' She forked a mouthful up and chewed."
To me (and I suspect a lot of others here on HN), the idea of getting a mined diamond is just lunacy. Why on earth would I pay twice as much for something that is literally the same at the atomic level?
And yet enormous numbers of people still do. I'm lucky to have a wife who is a scientist (she would've slapped me upside the head if I had wasted money on a mined diamond), but there are a lot of women out there who would be very upset to receive a lab-grown diamond.
So while I very much agree with what you're saying here, and it just seems crazy to me that anyone else wouldn't, I do wonder what percent of folks will continue to demand "real" meat even when lab-grown is superior along all dimensions.
What we have going on right now is killing us.
I'm surprised I don't need a Monsanto license to bake bread at home.
Animals are a low efficiency method of converting plant material into meat, both in terms of calories and protein mass input/output. So with scale, eventually lab-grown meat should become much cheaper than traditional meat. At the same time, it will be higher quality. Sterile production will eliminate E. Coli, salmonella, antibiotics... Input nutrients will be tightly controlled. Environmental pollutants and parasites will be kept out.
Traditional meat will still be available, but it will be an expensive and morally questionable luxury product, like "foie gras" today.