- terribly redundant content (as in, I see multiple times the exact same content from different accounts)
- content ripped off and reposted from original creators by spam accounts
- complete destruction of the original Instagram app to try to force-feed Reels down your throat
TikTok looks so simple when you use it because everything just works. Using Reels makes you realise all the ways there are to fuck it up!
If you don't make it easy for your users to post good content, of course you're going to make a boring app.
TikTok was built around this flow. Its community culture expects the content to be in a certain format and will self-moderate via metrics such as likes, comments, views. The UX of the app itself is built around this content. There are no distractions.
Instagram on the other hand has a very different community, with different culture and expectations. The content creators on Instagram may not be as familiar with the content that is conducive to the Reels format. The UX of Reels on insta is also an add-on feature. You're not opening instagram to interact with Reels, you have different intentions. Whereas when you open TikTok, you are there for one reason, so the app is built around that one flow.
Why does every company feel the urge to copy this and also fail so badly at this
Reminds me of how people would deride Instagram for copying Snapchat stories, yet far more people probably use Instagram stories than snapchat and are perfectly satisfied with the UX despite it being a blatant copycat.
I just think that's only because "the algorithm" prioritizes shorts at the moment to try and push them and make folks even bother making them. Once YouTube starts acting neutral towards them I don't think they'll hold up.
I've never come across a short intentionally and after seeing quite a few I haven't tried to find further ones (and outside of mobile it's quite difficult to do so).
That said of course, I'm probably not in the demographic shorts plays to either.
I never entered any search term and it figured out I'm into AI, startups, tennis, attack on titan...
Follow Tom Silva, Mr Barricade, Soft Pourn, Woodshopdiaries, Scott Hanselman. This will get you a bunch of interesting content. It might not be what you want, but it's definitely not makeup tutorials.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Game_%28Star_Trek:_The_Nex...
[0] https://techcrunch.com/2021/06/03/tiktok-just-gave-itself-pe...
Can you say WORTH IT?
Heh.
Anxiety attack
I find it fantastically stupid.
Once I saw the aggressive marketing for it in the play store I knew this was something we now have to deal with. And so we do.
Even if not, its programmers or their bosses determine what millions of users will see (and by extension think), which may change arbitrarily.
I know this may be old-school thinking but why can't we reserve the internet to utilities and non-algorithmic spoon-feeding?
It doesn't actively make you dumber, you make yourself dumber abusing it, and it's designed specifically for you to abuse it.
I would say that the highly tailored experience of the TikTok algorithm would make a propaganda op quite easy to detect. The algorithm is so ridiculously good, that you would instantly spot a propaganda video, or notice when your feed begins to skew from what you like to see.
Ahh, so the Guardian had some leaked moderation documents[1] implying there was an active moderation keeping them from being viewed. Buzzfeed said they did their own experiments and found no evidence that videos about Hong Kong were being removed[2].
I see no reason why both of those can't be true: if you control the algorithm, you don't need to delete anything, you can control with fine granularity how viral it's allowed to go. I guess that's a conspiracy theory, but for myself, I'm very skeptical that any media company operates in China with what most of us would call political neutrality and free speech.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/sep/25/revealed-...
[2] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanhatesthis/tiktok-us...
I honestly don't know anyone that actually wants to see political content on TikTok (though, if you seek it out, you will find it.) It's simply not what the platform is for.
I wouldn't put it past tech giants in democratic nations not to tweak their algorithms to push their own political agenda, much less tech giants in non democratic nations.
It's too powerful a tool not to abuse, I know it, and you know it too.
Would you notice it if they slowly ramped it up? How would you know whether it's grassroots or planted by the CCP?
How exactly would you propagandize a stream of improv skits, or dance videos, or pet videos? Every user's feed is extremely specific and deviations, even small ones, are easy to notice.
But haven't seen that in months.
But otherwise I don't think they promote propaganda actively.
But the difference between FB/Twitter and TT is the kinds of suppression they do. TT will remove anything that might remotely offend the sensibilities of the CCP.
There is. Tiktok China also got rid of all the political content because of the superior censorship algorithms.
Otherwise, I just don't see China risking one of the most promising gems to have come out of its internet technology industry in a long time.
Social networks isolate people by only showing them content they agree with. It’s like french kissing yourself in the mirror.
We are 9 weeks online and growing with 2k+ users. Would appreciate your intake (invite code LV005). Cheers
Liking or retweeting some police abuse video has about the same impact as liking a picture about famine in Somalia, the dopamine hit is just stronger.
FB takes a lot of heat here vs Twitter perhaps because Zuck seems creepy but Jack Dorsey detoxes for one week in Africa but Instagram were quick to take down those threatening posts with PII but I was told Twitter asked for all sorts of government ID and then auto closed all the cases saying it's all within their terms and conditions. If any social media needs to disappear I think Twitter should be first in line.
It really grinds my gears to have to watch 90% of a 60 sec video to be able to replay text at the end of something else. Other social apps fail with this as well, e.g. Snapchat, Instagram.
I'm curious how intentional the design decision is, perhaps trying to maximize time spent on the app? Interesting though how FB and Twitter do not follow the design pattern.
ByteDance's overwhelming revenue is from non-TikTok sources, i.e., all JinRiTouTIao, DouYin, and other minor properties. The title wants you to think it related to TikTok as it was one of the most controversial news pieces in 2020.
TikTok's financial success is still very uncertain.
ByteDance is facing a weak BIDU (note Alibaba do not have much Ads business, and Tencent has a different walled garden), while here they are facing FB & Google in US.
I would take that bet any day of the week and twice on Fridays. TikTok has a massive, growing user base with engaging content on a platform that people generally like. I find it hard to believe they would succeed so massively in their app design and recommendation algorithms and then fail at monetization, which at this point is the trivial part.
I don't know what BIDU means.
For any spectacularly failed startup, there have been ardent supporters who uttered words no less enthusiasm than yours.
When I say their future are uncertain, I mean that it's more uncertain than one might expect, based on DouYin's success in China. One evidence I raised, is that competitors here are much stronger.
Plus, you might not believe it, CCP is more friendly to big tech than US government...
But yes, had to delete the thing a year ago to avoid addiction ... a back-handed compliment, I know.
Fun, but a complete time-sink ...
I started following people from India and it will only show me content from India.
I unfollowed everyone, and started following indian people in USA, and it started showing me content from that.
I started following people in America, and it started showing me similar content.
It wouldn't show any new trends or new/different content.
Unfortunately now the copy cats like youtube shorts have me hooked and i cannot uninstall youtube because i use it for so many more things.
Is there any good reason to focus on the misuse of a technology?
Facebook removes what they deem 'hate speech' and some controversial things during emergencies, like minsinformation about vaccines.
TikTok actively suppresses all sorts of information.
Go ahead and put up Toks of Hong Kong protests, Tienanmen square or Uyghurs incarceration.
Mostly - this suppression is just the natural business language of Chinese owners, but it's also direct and indirect pressure from the CCP.
That's not very comparable to what Facebook is doing.
That said, it's a decent app.
So how long until the users get screwed (again)?
Especially when the content and algorithms itself is or can be easily manipulated or gamed.
So how long until the users get screwed (once again)?
Exactly. We've been here before haven't we?
How many more social networks do you need to join just to say the exact same thing? Of course. You're the one shilling it everywhere on this whole thread, when the news is for early 'investors' preparing for a gigantic IPO for massive returns. That's the news they want to hear.
As for the users; well who cares about them, they (Bytedance) don't care about you. As long as you keep generating great shareholder value for them it is another social network with a different internal flavour. Nothing has changed.
So I will ask again: How long until the users get screwed (once again)?
How are you expecting TikTok to "screw" its users? And what's the big deal with users just leaving the platform if this does happen? I really don't see the big issue here.
Typical of some of the HN crowd, like yourself who create illogical and baseless comments without any evidence to support it.
Thus, your claims can easily be dismissed.
I'll put it in a very simple TikTok format for you: TikTok is just the same as any other social media platform which is fundamentally in the interests of the investors (they want to IPO with a massive return on investment); Not you or the users. Why do you think I quoted 'used' here? [0]
> How are you expecting TikTok to "screw" its users?
They already did [1][2], which is my point. Therefore, I do not have any confidence that they will change or how they are any different to other social media platforms. Yet you continue to deny such basic things like 'censorship' [3] even when another user pointed out a source [4] that included leaked information about TikTok's own suppression actions; completely debunking your vacuous claim.
> And what's the big deal with users just leaving the platform if this does happen?
That's not my problem. Another platform will just take its place and screw over their users over the interest of the investors (If they take capital).
So far with all your responses, you have provided ZERO evidence to your claims. I will ask one more time: 'How long until the users get screwed (once again)?'
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27550851
[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-56815480
[2] https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/25/22301704/tiktok-92-millio...
I don't have it on my phone, but I truly see it as the pinnacle of the stupidly addictive social media app and it scares me because it means that Chinese companies are just as capable as us to spin the next Facebook and distribute propaganda to the next generation.