News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:15AM (#27457825)
> This is 100% a way to extract more money from consumers, especially non financially stable consumers, while lying to all of our faces

Isn't this hyperbolic? I split time between at least two cities. Being able to pay as I go represents a real saving in cost, time and attention.

Sometimes buying is better than renting. But sometimes there are economies of centralization. AWS isn't a scam on companies too poor to buy servers.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:32AM (#27457944)
It's the same argument that BMW made, and it's just as faulty here. They said that instead of paying $500 upfront for heated seats, they will be available as an annual unlock for say $100/year. Since they know an average owner keeps a new BMW for only 3 years, this is a saving for new buyers - isn't that great??? I hate this argument with a burning passion though, it's turning ownership into subscription only to extract more money in the long run.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by NikolaNovak on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:10AM (#27459716)
I'm sorry, is that an actual thing? There's a car with built in hardware system that costs annual service to unlock - not content (XM/Sirius/Whatever), but actual heated seats?

And people buy this?

I am beyond incredulous and want to pinch myself. Offering Apple/Android play as subscription was bad enough and an automatic deal-breaker, but this is just ludicrous.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:13AM (#27459735)
BMW is selling this as a great solution to fleet cars - say your company buys 100 cars for your employees - this way everyone gets a "base" spec car at a low cost to the company, but if an employee wants a sport mode or adaptive cruise control they can just pay to unlock it from their own pocket.

Like, it makes sense to a lot of people. BMW loves this, corporate fleets love this. But as it slowly becomes standard we all lose.

Also, Tesla sold exactly this for a while(don't know if they still do) to hit their $35k promise of a Model 3 - the car had heated seats installed, but you had to pay a one time $1000 fee to Tesla to unlock them.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by StrictDabbler on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:40AM (#27461304)
I see two futures here.

Future 1:

I'm working for a company and I buy the heated seats upgrade.

Eight months later I'm looking at moving to another company and I'll lose that value. Maybe that affects my decision.

So I'm paying for my own employer-lock-in loyalty perks? Am I a moron? No, so I negotiate away part of my salary, or my healthcare, to have the nicer car.

Future 2:

You get heated seats on certain luxury car brands as long as you have an American Express platinum. Just like airport lounge access.

I'd bet on Future 2.

They're both dystopian.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:56AM (#27461491)
I mean, it will be like everything else - companies which really want to spoil their employees and who buy BMWs as fleet cars, will order them with every subscription option covered and just eat the cost. So the CEO doesn't have to worry about his 7-series not having heated seats.

But I can also totally see situations where if the choice is between say....a Ford Mondeo or a BMW 3-series, the company can go "you can get the BMW, but we're not paying anything for options - if you want them, that's on you".

>>Eight months later I'm looking at moving to another company and I'll lose that value. Maybe that affects my decision.

If it's a subscription, then that value is lost anyway. You can probably get a partial refund for the unused months before you return the car.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by StrictDabbler on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:22AM (#27461774)
Agreed about C-level execs, of course.

Another poster said it's a $300 one-time payment. So you're losing that when you leave. Figure on a bunch of options and it's a lot of money.

I'd want it tied to me, not the vehicle. I paid for heated seats on my last BMW. You're charging me again? For DLC?

If I could pay for heated seats forever I could see it. It's just software, you're putting the same seats in every car, now we have a value.

So of course that will never happen.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:06AM (#27461582)
Paying a one time unlock fee and paying a subscription on a hardware feature are vastly different things. You might still disagree with both, but they are different.

Heated seats are a pretty standard upgrade that people will pay for, so I'm not sure that it makes much difference whether it's a physical upgrade or a software unlock, and there are valid reasons Tesla might choose a software unlock.

But charging a subscription fee on heated seats on a non-rental car is outrageous.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by kwhitefoot on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:19AM (#27461727)
It's not necessarily as different as it seems. When you buy a second hand Tesla from Tesla it can happen that a feature that the previous owner had has been disabled. Tesla has in fact been accused of disabling features of cars that were not sold through them.

Does the 1000 USD upgrade buy the feature or merely enable it for the time that the owner owns the car?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:34AM (#27461913)
Charging a new owner to unlock the feature again is slightly different than charging the original owner a subscription.

However, I still see selling features as a software upgrade strictly as an alternative means* of selling upgrades. So the upgrade should be tied to the car, not the owner. The added bonus here would be that a second owner could unlock features that the initial owner didn't want.

*i.e. Tesla might decide it's better just to put the heated seats in all cars rather than manufacturing cars with and without.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ParkShark on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:05AM (#27460922)
It’s actually $300 one time payment.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jsight on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:42PM (#27463350)
Tesla has done that kind of things a number of times. In earlier Model S versions, you could get a software locked battery for less money. You could then pay to unlock the capacity.

On the current Model 3 SR+, the rear seats are not heated, but you can pay to have the software unlock them. Its a few hundred dollars, I think.

For both the Model 3 LR and the Y LR, there is an available one time $2k USD upgrade to provide enhanced acceleration.

And obviously, the "FSD" package is a software fee that generally requires no hardware changes. It does get you access to some new hardware, though if needed.

But I think people see this differently if it is a one time fee vs a subscription fee.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by effingwewt on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:57AM (#27460815)
This is complete bullshit, it started as a normal feature. My 2009 328i has heated seats I've never once had to pay to activate.

No one in a fleet vehicle pays for their own 'upgrades', man.

DLC on cars and people are here defending it, I lost my shit over games doing it. We went from pay once for the game, maybe another expansion thay doubled your vanilla game. Now every company nickles and dimes us to death. Does no one remember banks being shit on for that in the 80s-90s?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:15AM (#27461031)
Wait, which part of it is bullshit? I have a feeling there is some terrible misunderstanding here.

>>My 2009 328i has heated seats I've never once had to pay to activate.

Yes, what's your point?

>>No one in a fleet vehicle pays for their own 'upgrades', man.

In modern 2021+ and higher BMW models in the US, they do, man. That is literally BMW's payment model on NEW cars. Don't know why you'd assume I'm talking about a 2009 model.

>>DLC on cars and people are here defending it

So far I had like 40 replies to my comment with maybe one or two people defending the practice. Is it really worth getting upset over it(the people commenting, not the practice)?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by surfingdino on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:57AM (#27459240)
Indeed. I sold my car, but I am still paying for one of the subscriptions I had on it. Can't cancel, but can settle early (4 months left on it). It's a clever way to add to the cashflow for those companies.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by alexanderchr on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:20AM (#27459025)
But the fact that you paid for the heated seats upfront increases the value of the car when you resell it. Likely by more than what you saved by renting?

…or maybe that was your point?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:28AM (#27459069)
Indeed. BMW's argument to this is that all cars will have all equipment built in - it will all be unlockable by subscription. Want adaptive cruise control? $200 a year. Heated seats? $100 a year. Sport modes for the engine/transmission? $400 a year. etc etc etc.

It annoys me to no end because it means you are paying(in the cost of the car) to have all of this advanced tech in the car, but you can't use it without subscription. What if I get a modder to enable it anyway? Am I now a criminal? What about the environmental impact of lugging around hardware that you don't want or need, just in case you or the next owner wants it?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by geonic on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:21AM (#27461753)
It's an interesting question. I bought the car. Ownership transferred to me. What if I decide to rewire some of the electronics and unlock heated seats or some other paid extra?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:44AM (#27462040)
I imagine they will make an argument that while you own the hardware, you are breaking the terms and conditions of their software. You never paid them to unlock the heated seats in software. Of course that argument fails if you get it modded so there's an extra button on the side and it just provides power to the seats, bypassing the rest of the system. It's going to be a fun legislative challenge once someone inevitably brings it to court, I'm sure.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by adolph on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:09PM (#27465151)
Then the next lines of defence will be warrantee negation, OEM parts locking, sensor/actuator distribution (like seat-thermo tied to airbag weight sensor), safety regulation either directly or through failed inspection scams.
[dead]
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by StrictDabbler on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:28AM (#27461847)
I love renting BMWs. They feel like I'm just running along the road. I love that experience.

Then I bought a BeaterMW because I needed a car, didn't want a loan, and had access to garage space.

It was a wonderful and labor-intensive two years of driving pleasure followed by a lump of metal out front I still haven't gotten rid of.

It took a very particular set of requirements to make that a win.

I would never recommend a BMW to anybody.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by kcanini on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:11AM (#27459723)
What are your favorite vehicles?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by mikro2nd on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:27AM (#27459832)
No favourites, really. To me they're "just transport" and cars bore me to tears, but the most comfortable drive I can recall was a Honda (model long since forgotten).
[dead]
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by GavinMcG on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:49AM (#27461404)
The insults aren't necessary and aren't a good fit here:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bluedino on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:46AM (#27460036)
My Jeep has features I can 'unlock' for a one-time fee. $500 will give me navigation, they constantly email me with offers of $75, $150 off
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jaywalk on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:53AM (#27461450)
With navigation, that fee pays for licensing the map data. Much more legitimate than paying to unlock hardware that's already installed.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ridethebike on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:33PM (#27466730)
>> They said that instead of paying $500 upfront for heated seats, they will be available as an annual unlock for say $100/year. Since they know an average owner keeps a new BMW for only 3 years, this is a saving for new buyers - isn't that great?

So what exactly is the problem here?

Isn't having the choice between several options a good thing from consumer point of view? Isn't extracting more money a whole point of company to exist?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Friday June 11, 2021 @06:40AM (#27471534)
>>So what exactly is the problem here?

I suppose I have an ideological problem with cars being sold this way. I see them as something that you own entirely once you paid for them. The idea that the car physically has heated seats installed but you can't switch them on without paying a fee to BMW is literally offensive to me on some higher level.

I don't know how to explain this better, I just don't want to live in a world where we buy things but never actualy own them. Yes, I am aware that computers and their software has operated like this for a long time now - doesn't mean that I accept this in cars.

>>Isn't having the choice between several options a good thing from consumer point of view?

To use another example - imagine if property developers built only 6-bed houses to streamline their construction process, but 4 out of these bedrooms were walled up and inaccessible by default. But hey, don't worry, you can pay an annual fee to the developer to unlock these bedrooms! Surely that's great for customers, because you only pay for what you need. Kid moved out to college and you no longer need their bedroom? Stop paying the extra fee, some guys will come over and brick up the door again. Isn't consumer choice great?

My point is - consumer choice isn't always the best outcome for everyone, including consumers. And I believe this is a false choice anyway, because BMW isn't aiming to offer this as a $500 one-time unlock OR $100 annual fee - it's just the annual subscription. Just like you can't just buy a standalone copy of Photoshop anymore, it's been replaced with a subscription model entirely.

>>Isn't extracting more money a whole point of company to exist?

I mean, it can be, but in a capitalist competitive market hopefully there will be competition that doesn't do that - and if it actively turns people away from buying BMW products then this whole idea fails at its intended purpose - can't extract more money from your customers if people don't become your customers in the first place.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:11AM (#27459325)
They said that instead of paying $5000 upfront for a server, they will be available as an annual unlock for say $1000/year. Since they know an average owner keeps a new server for only 3 years, this is a saving for new buyers - isn't that great??? I hate this argument with a burning passion though, it's turning ownership into subscription only to extract more money in the long run.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jtbayly on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:47AM (#27460043)
This is very different because you didn’t buy a server. If you were talking about a leased car instead of a purchased car it would be a bit more comparable, but still wouldn’t work. Because with a lease you have the option to buy it in the end.

Even a rental car doesn’t quite match, since you are in a particular car.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:12AM (#27461637)
A rental car would at least make sense though. You're already paying a cost for temporary access to the car, adding on extra features doesn't seem outrageous.

It could improve availability of those features because a rental company could order a fleet with those features on all cars in their fleet and then customers who want it would be able to pay the surcharge, instead of being constrained by the portion of the fleet with those features installed.

Of course it would likely just be used as a way to increase rental car prices.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:18AM (#27461714)
Why don't they increase those rental prices anyway?

A company will aim to charge the most it can to its customers.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:28AM (#27461846)
Customers will pay more if they think they're getting more in return.

If they can increase the rental prices without extra features, then they can charge even more for extra features.

Ultimately it comes down to the business's own calculus of costs, prices, and demand.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:50PM (#27463437)
So it comes down to the customers not having the knowlege of what they are getting.

Sell something without the extra costs and will people pay more? In the housing sector in the UK that's certainly not the case -- people didn't value freehold over leasehold until lots of media coverage, despite the information being right there for all to see.

In a situation where there's a monopoly/cartel, the consumer that actually looks at the total costs and benefits can lose out because there aren't enough knowlegable customers to make an old fashioned business viable, but in industries with low barriers to entry and low network effects it's not a problem.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:05PM (#27465101)
I honestly don't understand what you're getting at.

In the above comment you seemed to suggest that companies would already be charging more for rental cars if they could.

So I pointed out that consumers might be willing to pay more for a rental in return for a higher perceived value in the form of extra features being enabled.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by drewg123 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:13AM (#27461014)
I'd be surprised if nobody has hacked these systems.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by erhk on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:59AM (#27458526)
This is already happening with property ownership being coagulated in cities. How is this a surprise
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:28AM (#27458705)
How is that the same?

It's as if you bought your house, but had one room walled off with the developer saying "for only $100 a month, we will open that room up for you! isn't that great? you only pay for it if you need the extra space!"

Except that obviously the room is there whether you pay the subscription or not, you paid for it in the cost of the house.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:12AM (#27459334)
I was looking at a house the other day, it said "option to continue rental of garage". That's not a new house by any means (1800s or so I think), nor is it in some modern hippy city with new ways of doing things.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by andyzweb on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:08AM (#27459694)
Maybe not bought but we rented a house where the owner padlocked 2 bedrooms shut and said if we wanted to use them it was an extra $200 a month to use them as home offices.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:21AM (#27459790)
That's......beyond dumb. Like, if you don't pay him the extra $200, he's not extracting any extra value from these bedrooms. It's not like they can be rented to someone else in the meantime. So.....why do it in the first place?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:32AM (#27460523)
A bit weird but there's at least an argument that there's some wear and tear associated with using the rooms and, presumably, the landlord thought that the slightly cheaper/smaller apartment--with a possible upsell--was more rentable.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jaywalk on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:55AM (#27461475)
If the rooms aren't used, they won't experience any wear and tear and they won't have to be cleaned again for the next renters.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jtbayly on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:48AM (#27460058)
Because he doesn’t lose anything, but has the possibility of gaining something.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by yardie on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:22AM (#27461117)
He's definitely losing something. Property taxes are based on area and number of rooms. They could have found a tenant looking for the right number of rooms in their budget.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jtbayly on Friday June 11, 2021 @07:22AM (#27471800)
Or he advertised 1, 2, and 3 BR and took the first that came along.

You are assuming demand is equal for all of those. It might be in some places, but not others.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by adolph on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:16PM (#27465228)
Unused capacity might be claimed as a business loss?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by andylynch on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:56AM (#27458895)
Good point. Here in the UK the big developers seem to be getting more and more creative in generating post-sale revenues, be it from escalating ground rents, property management fees, captive ISPs, or £3 towel rentals for the sky pool.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:14AM (#27459342)
That's only a problem because people buying them don't factor those costs into the equation. Effectively the company is arbitraging based on laziness of the general consumer to do the calculations
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:38AM (#27457986)
> instead of paying $500 upfront for heated seats, they will be available as an annual unlock for say $100/year. Since they know an average owner keeps a new BMW for only 3 years, this is a saving for new buyers

For someone who only occasionally needs heated seats, this is value adding.

I agree that forcing everyone into a subscription is coercive. But there are a lot of people for whom the flexibility of a subscription creates more value than it costs. Rejecting it ex ante because of its financing model is overly simplistic.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by mnahkies on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:47AM (#27458051)
With a SASS product you're paying for ongoing access to a service with continuous improvements and a cost to the company to continue providing you.

With heated seats the hardware to provide the functionality was either fitted or not, once it leaves the factory it's static and so it seems pretty unreasonable to me to charge an ongoing fee for the privilege.

A world where my car gets micro-transactions to turn on the AC or heaters etc scares me.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:52AM (#27458094)
> you're paying for ongoing access to a service with continuous improvements and a cost to the company to continue providing you

Why wouldn’t this apply to an autonomous driving service?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Silhouette on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:38AM (#27458779)
Is there any public record anywhere of any auto manufacturer anywhere that is implementing or proposing to implement autonomous driving as a service? Isn't that almost an oxymoron?

If your self-driving system requires some centralised service to operate properly, it can hardly be fully autonomous under all conditions. How can it react immediately to an emergency situation if it's not running locally?

And if you're not talking about that but just ongoing development work and making updates available after the sale, there's nothing that means that has to be a mandatory service. Either the original version works properly or it doesn't (and in this case, if it doesn't, it shouldn't be allowed on the roads and the regulators should eat the vendors alive). Any subsequent updates that somehow improve the "quality" of the system could be made available at an extra charge, just like new products or new versions of software in a million other contexts, without any need for compulsory ongoing payments where the system stops working if the customer stops paying.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Danieru on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:28AM (#27458340)
Because the hardware and sensors are all local, installed on the car from the factory. There is no economic advantage, just a business advantage
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:30AM (#27458349)
To add to this - I'd be ok with VW charging for software updates after the first 3 years, like they do with maps. But the hardware and software that shipped from factory should work in perpetuity, period.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by cwilkes on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:12AM (#27460998)
> But the hardware and software that shipped from factory should work in perpetuity, period.

There’s a cost to VW to keep that system running. They have to staff SWEs that can write security patches, have to maintain outdated methods to update the software, etc.

And this isn’t really optional for VW to do it as if there’s a problem on a 2000 pound vehicle moving at 60 miles per hour things can get deadly quickly. For example what if there was a way to get into the car’s computer via the map software that was last updated 4 years ago? Maybe a hacker could then turn off power steering? Yes that is a hypothetical but there’s always problems with software and they need to get fixed when the consequences of not fixing them are high.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by gambiting on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:12AM (#27461641)
But that's a legislative problem. I imagine at some point we'll get to a future where you can't enable autonomous self driving unless you have an approved patch 1.7X to your autonomous driving suite. Anything earlier than that is not allowed on public roads in autonomous mode. We're nowhere near that future though yet.

Like, going back to my maps example - if I never pay VW for a map upgrade, my 10 year old satnav system will absolutely mislead me and try to direct me in places which could be potentially dangerous. And like....so what? The system that was installed from the factory still works, that's the point.

These current systems that we have are all just glorified cruise control systems - and whatever you have in your latest Merc/BMW/Audi/Volvo/whatever will continue to work until the car itself falls apart. As far as I can see VW isn't proposing anything different - other than the payment scheme for it.

Also, as for hacking risk - this is a massive risk on nearly all new vehicles on the road today and very little is being done to address it. VW charging for autonomous driving capability has little to do with that.

And to add another example - there's a famous case where a woman's car has caused $180M worth of damage, as it has caught fire while being transported inside a cargo ship. Turns out there was an outstanding recall on that vehicle due to....fire risk. So initially insurers wanted to put all blame on her, since she didn't have the vehicle fixed despite the recall. But they all got nowhere, because there isn't currently any law that says you have to get your vehicle fixed when a recall is issued. Similarily, the manufacturer isn't obliged by law to make sure any recall is followed, so they were off the hook as well.

What I mean to say is that these hypothetical situations are interesting to talk about, but with the current state of tech and law none of it is an actual concern.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jusssi on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:54AM (#27458495)
I think we're not anywhere near a level where a car could drive fully autonomously just with the local hardware, without a detailed data set of all the roads and real-time updates on conditions. That data set needs to be continuously maintained.

Also, they'll probably need a liability insurance for cases when their autonomous car inevitably gets in a situation where it has to choose between killing it's passengers or killing someone outside the car.

Of course, they could offer a pricing model where all that is paid up front, but I doubt it would be very attractive.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:43AM (#27459527)
One argument in favor of subscriptions is that they align the interest of the consumer and the company. With an up-front payment model, the company has no particular interest, besides customer loyalty/reputation/etc., in providing continued updates/support for older models. (Which is sometimes enough--as with Apple in many cases, but often is not as with many IoT devices.) With a subscription model they do so long as subscription revenue exceeds costs.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Danieru on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:50AM (#27459568)
Cool, so they would refund the full price of the car if people are no longer happy with it? Or would the 20K+ car just serve as strong vendor lock to be exploited in subscriptions?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:13AM (#27459737)
That assumes that the subscription is for the entire car. But that's pretty much what a lease is. And that's what a lot of people do. They pay a premium for a new car that they're only locked into for 3 years or so.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:16AM (#27461689)
And its a great model for people who want a known payment of $x and don't want to take on the risk/reward of deprecation, maintenance, resale, etc.

Unlike with say housing, which sits on land which appreciates in value at a rate and has a high cost of moving (monetary and personal), a typical car for the majority of people is a means to an end which just sits their and deprecates. The cost of changing to a new car is a few minutes reprogramming the radio and seats.

Ultimately what most people want is transportation which costs a reliable x¢ per mile at a given level of convienience, reliability and comfort.

Cars are hardly a winner takes all business or one with little competition - there's at least a dozen major manufacturers.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by cwilkes on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:06AM (#27460929)
> With heated seats the hardware to provide the functionality was either fitted or no

I don’t understand this argument. Would it feel different if you had to install the FooBar component to get it to work? That the act of having to do something physically can then justify the additional cost?

I’m all for a rental market like this. It no longer means that in the used car market there’s 100 different cars of model XYZ to look at as there’s 2^n different combinations of options to consider. All of that model are the same and then you unlock features.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:16AM (#27459354)
> A world where my car gets micro-transactions to turn on the AC or heaters etc scares me.

It's the HN community that have created this. If I have an EC2 VM, I have to pay Amazon a micro-transaction for every dns request they serve and every time I as much as ping my box

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by toast0 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:09AM (#27458207)
Tesla seems to be doing a lot of continuous development and the costs for that have to come from somewhere.

If a car company would charge me per day for heated seats, that would work for me, I don't use them that often. If they make me pay per year and they're installed in the car already... They've given me a nice electronics challenge, which adds value?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by t0mas88 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:23AM (#27458669)
It's more nuanced to me then "the hardware is there". Because by that reasoning you should be able to take any empty airline seat for $ 5 since the flight is already going and will only use 0.00something extra fuel with you in the seat. And yet airline pricing is a big data science project at each of them.

If VW spends 700 million on making self driving they want to get more then that back. They can do so by charging everyone 10k more for the car, but it would make the car expensive and decrease sales volume requiring an even higher price. Or they can come up with some other model where users with less budget pay less while those that can afford it pay more. In that case you need to make it so that those that pay more get more benefits, and their idea for that is charging by hours of usage.

I'm not sure I'm happy with that as a customer, but the model isn't crazy.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by datameta on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:27AM (#27459063)
The difference is that you own the vehicle and everything in it. Whereas in taking a flight you pay for roughly the combined value of limited seating, plus service by the flight and ground crews, plus fuel expended by the plane.

Therein lies the rub.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by rsj_hn on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:32AM (#27458736)
> For someone who only occasionally needs heated seats, this is value adding.

No, for someone who only has a 3 year lease on a BMW, this may be value adding (or value subtracting).

The money you save by not paying for heated seats when you buy the BMW does not go into your pocket when you sell the BMW without heated seats, as whoever buys the BMW from you will pay less for a BMW in which heated seats are free than one in which heated seats cost $100/year.

For a car with a 20 year life, you'd profit if 1 year of heated seat rental costs less than 1/20 the price of heated seats if bought up front. This is true whether you own the car for 1 year or 3 years or 20 years. It does not matter how long you personally plan on owning the car.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by PeterisP on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:26AM (#27459059)
On the other hand, the fact that you paid for the heated seats does not necessarily mean that the next owner won't need to pay for them - the manufacturer can tie that subscription and 'unlocked features' to the owner; I seem to recall reading an article here on HN some months ago about some resold car which got the "unlockable extras" disabled for the new owner.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by hef19898 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:25AM (#27459051)
As most new cars are leased, at least Europe for premium brands, anyway, I think that won't be an issue. BMW will sell your on, not you.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by rsj_hn on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:22PM (#27463142)
> BMW will sell your on, not you.

It does not matter who sells the car. What matters is whether:

(the price of used car with heated seats that must be paid for) - (the money already made from renting out heated seats) > (price of a used car with heated seats that are free)

The identity of the seller does not alter this equation at all, nor can it flip a loss to a gain.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by hef19898 on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:38AM (#27470036)
The seats are in, as a leased car it never belonged to you, but rather BMW. Now, it is up to BMW how they price the seats for you. And how they price them when selling the car of after you returned upon leasing end.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by rsj_hn on Friday June 11, 2021 @02:47PM (#27477066)
Yes, that is true for any seller. But they must find a buyer. E.g. sell those seats at market prices to some willing buyer who has a choice of buying a cheaper BMW with no heated seats or a more expensive BMW with heated seats that do not require a subscription or even another luxury car with a different heated seat pricing model. This is a crowded market. And BMW will sell the car at the market clearing price or it will hang onto excess inventory, so it matters very much whether the value obtained from heated seats without a subscription is greater or less than the price of the subcription over the useful life of the car, regardless of how long a particular owner holds the asset. That will affect the selling price of the car regardless of whether BMW or someone else is selling the car.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by soco on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:55AM (#27458112)
Occasionally needing? As in, one year they are needed and another year not? Because I can't see this argument working otherwise - heated seats cost 100$ a year, period.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by estaseuropano on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:28AM (#27458342)
I would buy this argument if they sold the initial car at a loss - but they don't do that. You paid for that feature when you bought the car, then you pay again to use it. This is just rent seeking.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by lonelyasacloud on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:08AM (#27459305)
> You paid for that feature when you bought the car, then you pay again to use it.

Short answer.

No, not really; a manufacturer can't simply lump the price of all the unused stuff onto the base price. It would hand the low end to their competitors.

Longer answer.

Assuming that the manufacturers are not operating as a cartel (which is a different discussion), a manufacturer simply adding the total cost of all non-activated equipment and services onto the base price would be competitive suicide in the low(er)-end market. So no sane manufacturer would ever do that - they don't need to.

Instead, as long as the manufacturer's cost reductions through simplified design, production, inventory etc., plus the upselling revenue are greater than the additional hardware and licensing costs. Then they can, at least in theory, include heated seats, air conditioning, self-driving and whatever extra crap they like for no, or very little, additional initial outlay to the base model purchaser.

Of course, purchasers (and the planet) will pay for it in degraded acceleration, braking and fuel economy if extra weight is involved. Perhaps I'm pessimistic, but given the number of pointless SUVs and Trucks on the roads, it's hard to imagine that'd be a concern to the average purchaser.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:53AM (#27459590)
In fact, you can see how this plays out in the computer market.

While binning goes on with desktop and commodity server processors, by and large manufacturers can't play too many games with building in unused capacity.

However, at the high-end, especially mainframes, you absolutely have features like capacity on demand and pricing by workload and there was even more of this sort of thing in the past.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ovi256 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:31AM (#27457934)
> I split time between at least two cities

Please don't bring up minority use cases when discussing the average or modal use case.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:39AM (#27457990)
> don't bring up minority use cases

There are a lot of minority use cases with cars. I suspect there are more, in aggregate, minority uses than there are cases in the mode. In any event, there is a massive non-extortive beachhead for this model, as deminstrared by Uber and Zipcar et al.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Nullabillity on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:48AM (#27458851)
Uber is a great example of how this model ends up awful for both drivers (who get awful working conditions and usually end up making a lot less net than promised) and customers (who get an awful experience, end up paying a lot more than they would otherwise, and still aren't making progress towards getting rid of that extra expense).
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by sokoloff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:50AM (#27459197)
As a consumer, Uber has been a massive win for me. We own two “daily” drivers, but going downtown or to the airport in an Uber is convenient and cheaper than parking downtown or at the airport. On trips to other cities, Uber is often way cheaper than cabs.

I’ve never found Uber worse than cabs and maybe 1 in a 100 Ubers is dirty or smelly, reminding me of how awful cabs used to be about half the time. Many drivers seem about as happy as random workers in other industries but some seem quite a bit happier with their arrangement with Uber than most service workers seem to be.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:18AM (#27459372)
Uber is certainly a win in almost all cities - I can count on one hand the times I've had an issue with them (once in Singapore, once in Kenya), and I've used uber far more than legacy cabs (where I can think of all manner of issues - probably 1 in 6 or 1 in 7 journeys)

Uber relies on the drivers underselling themselves though, which isn't good for society, but is great for the individual rider.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by relativ575 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:25AM (#27459820)
As a somewhat frequent user, Uber's rides have always been good experience for me. Never awful. One of nicest things is you can use it in many countries, from the same app. Taxi is a scam in a lot of places.

The complaint I have is that Uber pickup is sometimes unreliable. They may cancel after being connected, or they didn't wait at pickup points and left without contacting me.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Nullabillity on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:06AM (#27460221)
To be clear: my criticisms are primarily about taxis vs car ownership. Uber just cranks the taxi problems up to 11.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:58AM (#27459626)
For me, living in an ex-urban area, I'm entirely car dependent so these services don't really matter when I'm at home. But I know a couple who moved to SF and gave up their cars and their lifestyle clearly wouldn't be possible without Uber and Zipcar.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by afarrell on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:59AM (#27459250)
To call something a "scam" says there is no honest use-case. Pointing out competing use-cases is directly refuting that.

> In a swipe at Tesla, he said that by charging hourly fees, VW would make autonomous driving more accessible than “a car with a five-digit surcharge.”

Especially if VW isn't actually "taking a swipe at" Tesla but instead going after a different market.

It is like saying calling a bagel a counterfeit bowl of cereal.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by tnzm on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:14AM (#27459344)
Why? Does it threaten your sensibilities?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by turminal on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:12AM (#27458234)
>AWS isn't a scam on companies too poor to buy servers.

Do the math and see how using AWS just doesn't make sense at the scale most companies operate.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by adflux on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:44AM (#27459533)
>AWS just doesn't make sense at the scale most companies operate You are delusional if you think "most companies" operate at a scale at which they can support their own datacentres
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by turminal on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:58PM (#27467647)
I am not delusional and colocation is a thing.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by berkes on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:28AM (#27458711)
Are you saying that if I did the math, I'd move my company to a more expensive heroku (I did), onto another, cheaper VPS provider (I did, Linode, DO, rackspace even, for other companies) or onto self hosted&maintained hardware (this hasn't been cost effective for me for decades)?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by turminal on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:27AM (#27459066)
There's a point between being too small to use up a single beefy server and being big enough to go cloud scale, where colocating a few servers and maintaining them makes sense financially in most scenarios. For companies smaller than that renting a cheaper VPS probably makes more sense.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bsenftner on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:13AM (#27459339)
If you're any form of hi-compute, the cloud is insanely expensive and a no-brainer for colocation, even for as little as one server. If your service requires more than the average CRUD serving of media, the cloud quickly becomes far far too expensive.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by whoknew1122 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:33AM (#27459902)
It's all fun and games until that co-lo goes down and with it your entire business.

Speaking from someone who moved a SaaS operation from co-lo to AWS. Everyone (especially the C-suite) was much happier.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by adflux on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:12AM (#27460990)
Always fun to see people compare bare metal costs to actual running cost of cloud infrastructure. For some reason such advocates always think the system administrators work for free, the network will always work, the machine will never break, the machine will not need to be replicated etc etc etc
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by berkes on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:37PM (#27464692)
To drive home an argument a co-owner of an old hosting company I had, calculated the costs for replacing a single HDD.

Everything from buying the HDD, to his hours to the parking ticket at the data-center. He convinced me and the point was clear: a single failing HDD would costs us more than renting similar computing power for over 6 years. We had two such failing HDDs in three years prior.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by mavhc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:20AM (#27458649)
Most companies have 1 server
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:36AM (#27459110)
Iron is cheap nowadays. It's the upkeep that kills you.

This "1 server" is equivalent to at least two part-time admins to ensure smooth operations. No biggie if said server just hosts a static website, big deal if runs mission critical processes.

That's the part too many "self-hosting" advocates conveniently leave out. A correct TCO calculation must include this cost (and proper risk assessment) and only then can a comparison be made.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bsenftner on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:17AM (#27459371)
Maintaining a server is one of the big scary nothings that prevents many from learning the reality of how basic and elementary it actually is. Giving/having the process developers semi-knowledgeable about devOps helps significantly. But it is not hard, and not hard to learn from zero.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:38AM (#27459500)
We're talking about businesses here, not your private amusement, though.

As a business you need to ask yourself: and who pays for the time it takes to educate at least two employees on this "basic and elementary matter"? If it really were so "basic and elementary", how come even critical infrastructure regularly falls victim to the most primitive of ransomware attacks?

Misconfigured email and network access settings, vulnerable, out of date software stacks, non-existing contingency plans, lack of monitoring, no escalation strategy, etc. etc. Billions are lost each year due to this.

It's very easy to underestimate the actual complexity of the task in its fullest whilst overestimating one's own abilities because "it's not hard to setup NGinx and service stack XY on a random x64 box".

Anecdote from personal experience: tasked an applicant for a DevOps position with comparing two systems we could choose from for a backend service. The systems came in the form of installation packages and docker-images respectively.

Having had no experience with Docker at the time, I thought it'd safe my team a great deal of time to have the "new guy", who knew Docker inside out, deal with it.

A week later we had two results: 1) a usable comparison of the two systems and 2) an e-mail from the cloud service who informed us that the machines we rented were performing DDoS attacks on a foreign company...

New guy had forgotten to properly secure the test machines he had set up and it took hackers all of 72 hours to find and hijack them. Luckily it only took a few clicks to wipe the offending boxes, but it served as a warning for what happens if you take the whole "big scary nothings" too lightly.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bsenftner on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:49AM (#27459554)
It certainly helps if one begins with experienced engineers. I am not talking about personal projects, I am discussing funded startups. If your team has not run servers on their own in the past, get a different team. It is not as if there is not a giant population of grey beards with this knowledge seeking work...

I accept your points, but far too many inexperienced devOps are given keys that should not have them. From your Docker story, it sounds like poor decision making on your behalf. Just because a developer knows Docker does not mean they know how to expose that securely to the public - far too many devs believe that's not their job.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:30AM (#27459865)
> Just because a developer knows Docker does not mean they know how to expose that securely to the public

While that's certainly true, I think you missed the part where the guy specifically applied for a DevOps position.

The "Ops"-part wasn't optional and exposing a test system to the public in the first place is a big fail in and of itself obviously.

But that's besides the point: the point was that operating even a single server is more complex than many people tend to admit and you just confirmed this statement.

I also don't understand how you jump from "it's not hard" and "big scary nothing" to "funded startups" and getting a "different team" preferably consisting of knowledgeable "grey beards". Which is it? Is it simple enough to learn on a rainy weekend or do you actually need dedicated trained and/or experienced professionals, because far too many devs are unsuitable for this?

I have trouble following your train of thought tbh.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by lbriner on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:09AM (#27459713)
I'm not sure which companies you are talking about here. I work for a small startup and between us, we have plenty of experience of maintaining servers but that doesn't mean I would bet my company existence on me not forgetting to setup the firewall correctly.

It also doesn't account for all of the out-of-hours stuff we need to do. Even with a hosted solution and a lot of paid-for services like Cloudflare, we still have to check out every unusual error email, everything that seems out of the ordinary.

If you are 200+ people, great, you probably already have a team to manage this. If you are small like 90% of companies then you won't and I want to spend my time on the things I am expert in.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:08AM (#27459692)
>It is not as if there is not a giant population of grey beards with this knowledge seeking work...

Really? There is a giant population of senior experienced engineers looking to do basic a lot of basic sys admin stuff? And they're willing to work for peanuts, right?

By the way, I totally agree with your basic point. The developer probably downloaded some images from a random public repo. As you say, far too many devs think security is someone else's problem and then get upset when the security person blocks their app going into production.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by whoknew1122 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:42AM (#27459978)
If something were truly basic and elementary, you should be able to do it after reading a book or passing a multiple-choice test. Now you're saying "if your team isn't experienced, get a more experienced team." Seems like we're moving the goalposts here.

If it were so basic, the DevOps person they hired should've been able to do it after taking a 6-7 hour docker course.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by owl57 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:05AM (#27459287)
And, if instead of a dedicated server you rent some combination of AWS services, you suddenly don't need admin or need a cheaper one?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:23AM (#27459401)
With services in particular you indeed don't need one.

No need to ensure the software is up-to-date, no worries about hardware outages, no need to monitor the system, etc. etc.

The person working with a rented service infrastructure can focus on what makes them money: the process.

With self-owned hardware you need contingency plans, setup, maintenance, redundant ISPs, UPS, extra electrical setup (many offices automatically turn off power to all outlets after office hours to safe electricity and reduce the risk of fires), and much more depending on the required tasks and their importance.

If you want to know what happens if you cheap out on that because "it just works" anyway once it's been set up and operated by an underqualified and overworked person, look no further than the recent ransomware incidents.

Some of them could've been easily avoided had the IT infrastructure been up to snuff. Way too many businesses and public entities still treat IT as a necessary evil that can be handled casually, not realising their dependence on it.

The specifics differ on a case-to-case basis, but in general it's a terrible idea for a small non-IT business to operate their own IT infrastructure. The solution doesn't have to be "cloud" or SaaS either. Hiring a competent 3rd party to deal with the specific implementation and operation for you is just as good even said party is "Bob's Business IT Services" and not AWS or Microsoft Azure.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by deathanatos on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:48AM (#27461390)
> With services in particular you indeed don't need one.

> No need to ensure the software is up-to-date, no worries about hardware outages, no need to monitor the system, etc. etc.

> The person working with a rented service infrastructure can focus on what makes them money: the process.

No, that's just not even remotely true. VMs, managed services all require updates that are pushed to the end user of the service. Downtimes happen, and dealing with those are pushed to the end user of the service by cloud providers far too often. I have countless support tickets at all levels of the cloud stack of back-and-forth on issues, many as simple as "how about serving 200s, not 500s?"

I wish managed services were a rainbows and unicorns world of "I give you cash, you give me magic computer thing that scales and never goes down" … but that just isn't the case today for many cloud services. (I think about the one service I'd be willing to pin such a medal on is S3. It comes remarkably close, but even there, I've had an incident where we had an outage due to S3 that took much back & forth with support to finally get an engineer on their side to look at it.)

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:31AM (#27461884)
I think we're talking about very different things here.

When I say "No need to ensure the software is up-to-date, no worries about hardware outages, no need to monitor the system, etc. etc." I don't mean these things don't need to happen at some point. The idea is that it's not you, as in the customer, who's responsible for this.

If I book a Redis-DB of a given size, I don't have to care about its software version, proxies, what OS it's running on, how big the VM is, what the specs are, and so forth. That's what I'm getting at.

It's far higher level than individual VMs and it doesn't mean downtimes don't happen either. It simply means it's not you, the customer, who has to troubleshoot and fix them.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by deathanatos on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:03PM (#27477781)
> If I book a Redis-DB of a given size, I don't have to care about its software version, proxies, what OS it's running on, how big the VM is, what the specs are, and so forth. That's what I'm getting at.

And what I'm getting at is that you do. While there might exist managed services that don't require this, many managed services nonetheless do. E.g., AWS RDS regularly has updated versions, and it is somewhat up to the customer to schedule them & apply them, and downtime happens during that. RDS is relatively pain-free, and is higher on my list of "would use again" for that reason. But take something like Azure AKS: it's a "managed" service, but upgrades are very much not pain free. I have to manually schedule them, and manually apply them, and deal with fallout (which is often, IME).

> It simply means it's not you, the customer, who has to troubleshoot and fix them.

Again, I disagree. When S3 had its outage, I had to debug why certain requests weren't happening, I had to capture sufficient request IDs to prove to AWS that S3 was in an outage for us, and only then did we get the proper support, and eventually, attention from engineering. My company had to pay an engineer to do that. Sure, I'm not literally debugging S3 actual, but that doesn't mean an engineer isn't needed on the consuming side. Same story with an example with ACR where we were receiving 500s: it took not only capturing 5xx requests & their time of occurrence, it took multiple back and forths to convince Azure that the 5xxs were on their side. (Both of these incidents also demonstrated a real fundamental lack of alerting on the side of the companies managing these services. Our monitors on their services very clearly indicated outage. S3's excuse was that it was "just" our bucket. But the point is that they have no insight into the actual service the end user is perceiving even after the customer raises the support ticket.)

Just recently I was SSHed onto an AKS VM to try to help Azure understand why packets weren't making it from their Virtual network into AKS. Data, from one Azure service to another! (And we didn't figure it out, either; we ended up changing what we were doing anyways, and so the investigation became moot.) And this demonstrates another issue I've hit, a bunch, is that interactions between managed services are also impossible to debug: you end up with two separate services both claiming it isn't them that is out of spec, but nonetheless the end result doesn't work, and nobody on either side has the competence to actually debug the problem.

If you want the downtime to end, it becomes you, the customer that has to debug & troubleshoot these things. And that is a cost that must be accounted for when weighing managed services vs. unmanaged ones.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:20AM (#27459385)
You just need an extra developer who's an expert with various AWS services to make sure you're using them correctly

However as all developers are AWS experts (at least according to their resume), you have to pay that price regardless

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by WJW on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:01AM (#27459645)
You don't exactly need to be an expert in object storage to stick a file into S3 and download it again some time later, just as 99% of SQL queries don't need a full blown DBA to write efficiently. (In fact, most queries are so simple that most shops have automated them with ORMs and the like)

It is always the 1% of difficult stuff that hits you, but it is very rarely the correct call to optimize for that 1% instead of for the 99% of uses.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by owl57 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:26AM (#27459827)
Yes? Neither you need to be an expert in file systems to stick a file on a server. And, yes, 99% of the time you don't need a DBA, just install Postgres on said server and go ahead with ORM.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:37AM (#27459937)
Unless that file is to be read by 1000 users simultaneously - that's where the fun begins ;)
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by owl57 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:19AM (#27461082)
Agree, when you have thousands of simultaneous users, it could be time to think what the hell are you doing.

But the number sounds a bit off… I have fuzzy memories of some fun around that many concurrent requests with Apache 1.3 — that is, one process per user. Doesn't the fun begin quite a bit higher with just any more modern software?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by qayxc on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:40AM (#27461995)
> Doesn't the fun begin quite a bit higher with just any more modern software?

You tell me, I'm not a sysadmin:) I can only attest to the fact that without any kind of RAID or suitable hardware setup (RAM for caching, fast networking etc.), even a dozen people accessing the same file can be very problematic (provided the file is large enough).

As for the use case: digital content creation comes to mind. Sharing assets globally especially in times like these when more people are working remotely is such use case.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by avereveard on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:19PM (#27463731)
a RDS instance is way less labor intensive that properly roll your own backed up, automatically updating server that can be snapshotted at your will and can be upgraded and restored with no downtime, I've spent about six day in five years of continuous operations to keep it running, and that'd probably be two dozen postgres upgrades I'd had to roll and test manually if I went the unmanaged route

Now it isn't cheap, but the five year ownership cost difference compared to iron doesn't cover a month of my salary, so.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by nix23 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:28AM (#27457911)
>AWS isn't a scam on companies too poor to buy servers.

It often is, for small and medium business (traditional ones) it's often cheaper to rent DC-Space and buy some servers yourself...but hey if you pay and don't do the math, that's your problem.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by lbriner on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:12AM (#27459728)
I have done the maths lots of times and by the time you add up all of the support costs as well as the initial investment and setup, it is rarely, in my opinion, worth it for a small business to even consider doing anything other than renting platform as a service (or SaaS if they can).

I ran a cloud platform production system for 6 years with multiple replicas of all systems and it cost around £400/month, a tiny amount compared to even a single person to manage your own servers.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:09AM (#27458209)
Physical co-lo is only cheaper if your time is worthless (ditto for Linux-on-the-corporate-desktop, or anything else that’s nominatively gratis).

My current SaaS gig runs in Azure (App Services and containers - no VMs nor “serverless”) and being completely free of the need to do sysadmin work is just so nice. When I was colocating my own rack about a decade ago there was always something that needed my attention, be it security updates, some new unexpected error in the syslogs, RAID drive failing, etc - that I’d need to commute to the DC an hour away or pay the DC’s helping-hands fees. Back when I was younger it was fun and valuable to gain those experiences, but right now I’m a west-coast SWE and no employer wants me to spend my time doing sysadmin/SRE work when my time is literally worth ten times more doing product work and letting MS’ Azure staff keeping things humming along.

For high-availability, AWS/Azure/GCP all the way! There’s no way a micro-ISV SaaS vendor can compete if they have to burn cycles doing unprofitable infrastructure work.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jjav on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:28AM (#27458338)
> Physical co-lo is only cheaper if your time is worthless

Physical colocation is nearly always cheaper than AWS for most use cases.

Exceptions are when your usage is so tiny that it doesn't need even a single full-time server, and, when your usage is so erratic that provisioning for the spikes doesn't make sense.

For everyone else, you're paying a very large premium for AWS over what it'd cost to buy and operate some servers.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:25AM (#27459410)
Oh certainly if you want some beefy server with graphics cards, tons of memory etc, running 24/7, it's probably cheaper to co-locate. A g3s.xlarge costs $13k for 3 years with amazon, I suspect kitting your own server out and hiring 1U of space and a 1G internet access port would be much cheaper over the 3 year contract and not run into nasty bandwidth surprises.

The benefit of AWS-style comes in at

1) Flexibile workflows (I need the grunt on mondays, but not the rest of the week)

2) Tiny workflows (I just want a couple of $5/month VMs in different cities and some DNS to host a couple of toys)

Now if you have the $8/hour self drive, that's great if you use it once a year on a 10 hour trip to a holiday destination. It's awful if you use it for 2 hours a day.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ForHackernews on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:49AM (#27459558)
Again, you're completely discounting the ops time involved in "operate some servers" - how many devops/SRE folks do you need to employ to do that? And 24/7 on-call?
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jjav on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:20PM (#27463115)
I need the exact same devops team I have today. No big difference to them where the boxes sit and who owns them. It's the CFO who sees the bigger difference.

I do save the few staff hours needed on physical maintenance of racking, cabling and replacing hardware. But at typical startup scale that's not much work. In the past I've done it myself on the side. As the company gets larger it takes dedicated staff, but at that point the comparable AWS bill is so large I could pay their full year salary on a single month of AWS bills.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by sofixa on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:41AM (#27458799)
Or when you need anything more than to run a few very basic services ( like a PHP app with apache and mysql).

AWS have managed services for a lot of different things, which save a lot of time on maintenance. Object storage? Message queue? Any type of database? ML? etc. etc. etc.

And of course, there's the scalability. With on-prem it's a careful balancing act of buying enough capacity to have space to expand but not too much to waste it, and you have to regularly keep an eye out lest you hit a limit with multi-week lead times ( e.g. you're out of storage, and buying a new shelf can take weeks to be usable).

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by nix23 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:10AM (#27458968)
Look, i never said aws good/bad, i just said do the math and don't trow your money blindly at some IaaS/PaaS/SaaS etc.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by pythonaut_16 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:26AM (#27461807)
That's really the only answer. Do the research and the math for your own business/use and see if AWS is a better value than colo or your own hardware.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by nix23 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:03AM (#27458930)
That why i wrote "medium business (traditional ones)", the HW stuff can be done by the DC peoples, one HD as spare (online) and one offline, if HD fault, send email "please exchange HD 5". If you can safe 20k a year it's even probably worth your time...well 60 minutes of it...but maybe not if your one of those rock-star programmers ;)
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ghaff on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:32AM (#27459453)
A lot of people turn subscriptions and pay per use into a tiresome religious argument. I don't want to pay an upfront for-all-time fee for everything I use. Sometimes I want to buy outright. Sometimes I want to rent for a period. And sometimes I want to pay per use. It depends on the thing in question, my usage patterns, and the amount of money involved. (And it can change over time.)
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by mananaysiempre on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:07PM (#27462308)
The issue with price discrimination (economic terminology) is that it not only brings the lower end down, but also the higher end up. Think of economy-class airline travel, where how much you pay is essentially determined by how much mental resources you’re willing to spend on planning.

That is assuming businesses are content with only getting the same revenue in the new pricing model and before you factor in issues like “people can’t count money” and “pretty much anything can get gradually normalized, and an undercutter’s market pretty much everything will”. For example, I honestly don’t know what I’d do if I wanted to buy a TV right now... Probably buy a normal underpriced surveillance node and spend the time to isolate it from public networks, but still, that’s depressing.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by croon on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:30AM (#27457928)
> Sometimes buying is better than renting. But sometimes there are economies of centralization. AWS isn't a scam on companies too poor to buy servers.

Your example doesn't apply. You don't rent a server from AWS, you pay for their services. If the AWS cost was just getting you a VPS, then you would have a point.

I'm not saying AWS is (always) a good deal, but the cost is quantifiable, compared to buying a server or renting a VPS where all the extra ops work isn't (easily).

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by sofixa on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:47AM (#27458053)
Well, in this case, you're renting access to VW's autonomous driving service, which presumably comes with constant updates and improvements and humans behind to intervene in case of necessity ( à la Waymo).
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by croon on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:58AM (#27458139)
> Well, in this case, you're renting access to VW's autonomous driving service which presumably comes with constant updates and improvements

Yes, which can be bought elsewhere, which was the entire point.

> and humans behind to intervene in case of necessity ( à la Waymo).

I have no idea, does it?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by aktuel on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:36AM (#27459108)
You can buy it, but not use it. That's a really great deal for elsewhere.