Soldered-on RAM and flash, while almost impossible to upgrade, is way more reliable. No vibrations means way less mechanical stress.
And RAM may be reliable but when it's replaceable it means I can upgrade it and use the device for longer instead of having to buy a new device.
I really don't like the idea that manufacturers MUST provide easily replaceable parts. That will affect product weight and dimensions.
Anyways, repair shops are dealing with chips all the time, so I see no problem of chips being changed, swapped and, if manufacturer provides list of supported RAM chips - those can be changed too.
So do emissions standards, and they also effect performance. But as a society we realise we are better off with them than without.
Forcing a repairable device reduces waste and is, in my opinion, better for the vast majority of consumers.
You generally don’t want to run flash near full. That shortens it’s life.
It depends, software bugs or different workflow cam cause your storage or battery to fail faster, then you need to throw away the entire device because things are impossible or expensive to repair.
There is no need to micro manage how a device manufacturer designs their products as long as they offset the pollution they create by either paying the local governments to dig more landfills or recycle their own products or send it over to someone who can recycle.
There are still open problems on how to measure the pollution but it's a more flexible approach than a repairability score.
Markets are not perfect, so why does regulations need to be perfect? They just need to be better than the alternative.
Except a rating like that doesn't actually indicate expected average device lifetime at all. It's common knowledge Apple devices are low on repairability, yet they have average device working lifetimes and post-sale vendor support periods much longer than the very best you'll find among their competitors.
You can also see this from the way they retain their second hand value for years longer than competing devices with much higher repairability scores. People buying these devices second hand know perfectly well they have practical longer working lifetimes than their competition, and they're willing to pay for that.
That will get incentives in the right place.
I think most people just want to ban the worst anti-repair actions, like trying to disable the device in the event of repair attempts or preventing the use of otherwise compatible 3rd-party hardware with key signatures or proprietary authentication mechanisms.
It is a very neoliberal view to think free markets are the only source of innovation and government is just standing in the way.
Governments create lots of different incentives to foster innovation. Patents themselves are a government regulation meant to encourage innovation. Ironically companies have corrupt government to such a degree that patents today is often a hindrance to innovation. However well designed patent laws are likely better than no patent laws at all.
If a new part is smaller than an old part, the new part probably uses less materials. Less heavy metals in the solder and component body etc, less weight for shipping which burns all kinds of fuels, etc etc.
Saying "thinness" is kind of stupid, because making the full outside shape of something too tiny to even use, is the stupidest way to use a decrease in the size of all the parts inside.
The gains could just as well be taken advantage of by filling the same space with other stuff like more battery or even empty air.
Taking the idea to an unlikely extreme just to illustrate: A phone that was the exact same size as my current one, and performed the same jobs no better or worse than my cirrent one, but which was mostly a hollow shell just to give my hand something to hold and screen to see, and all the eletronics were in a little glass thumbnail would be perfectly great on several fronts.
Reduced component size has made an infinity of things either more efficient, or made them possible at all instead of impossible. There is no such thing as "small enough already". That's identical to saying "efficient enough already".
Many of us here would have been called in to upgrade a family members SATA hard drive, which was black magic to them, but trivial for us. Same applies to soldered on RAM. DRM issues aside, its a trivial job to upgrade for someone who knows what they are doing. As long as the software doesnt refuse to recognize it.
And it makes much more sense for governments to legislate around theoretical concepts like DRM, rather than trying to be a technical standards body detailing how you should structure electronics. They are bound to always be behind on technical matters.
If you want corporations to have free reign on being able to innovate, there has to be some counter-incentive to force them to find innovative solutions around lengthning the life of of the product and its ability to be repaired and recycled.
As it stands today, bad press is the only incentive and its effect is easily mitigated by marketing and lobbying.
It needs to hurt. Innovation is born out of a need to improve. Making manufacturers responsible for their decisions is a way to balance their incentives.
Totally agree. But they should be publicly labeled as extreme polluters whose devices aren't repairable and who design devices that way intentionally.
They should be free to do it, and then free to be denounced for it.
>The government doesn't need to be involved in this respect.
The environmental aspect of unrepairable devices should probably be regulated like any other industry who makes the decisions to pollute because they want to.
2) You could incorporate total material usage + average power consumption
I haven't heard anyone actually push for this. I've just heard people ask for access to information and the ability to buy parts.
I ask this as somebody who would love to have the schematics of all my devices. I would love to know why this actually isn’t a big deal.
2. Screw trade secrets anyway. They should get zero consideration in any matter of law or public policy.
Anyone capable of recreating an electronic device from schematics can easily reverse engineer such device from the board. They are not secret. Reverse engineering them is a little time consuming, but it's not hard. Circuit board design follows established conventions. I can fix boards without schematics.
Especially when there’s possibly thousands or more ‘official’ repair people, whatever information they have is not a trade secret.
Furthermore, any other company could pretty easily reverse engineer or at least approximate the schematics (the kind we’re talking about here) making it not a trade secret.
A motherboard with soldered on components like RAM or CPU are still more likely to fail because of a bad capacitor or some liquid damage on the traces.
You may have interpreted the statement the latter way. If interpreted as I suggested, surely it's fairly uncontroversial? Capacitors are quite notorious for failing.
Without out projects to revive old phones, which have to struggle to reverse engineer qualcomm modems, we would have so much more stuff in landfill. I use 10 yr old phones and they are just as fast as back then and get the job done.
The only reason to upgrade is to push their "addictive" app store as that is the major way of making money
Just leaving everything to the market isn’t tenable. Markets have all sorts of flaws. It is one of the reasons why we have so many environmental problems. In this case it is appropriate for governments to devise regulations to remedy obvious problems.
It's not that complicated or costly to enforce.
Two points.
- What is your evidence that it is not complicated or costly ? Remember that lost profits because of repairs is a perfectly valid cost to be considered here. - Someone builds a device, it is their device and they are selling it to you with full advertisement that certain parts can not be repaired. How moral is it to impose additional restriction on such an entity through government coercion ? Seems immoral thing to me. Today it is about repair, tomorrow it will be something else.
I agree that people should do their due diligence when purchasing their tech products, but I am strongly against a company doing something solely for the purpose of impeding repairability.
Yes. How much cost do you think a large company incurs to make few documents publicly available.
Note that it is not just a document you share, you are putting your entire company's reputation into that doc, every cut corner and opening yourself to potential lawsuites as well.
Let's say company A asks manufacturer F to make 100,000,000 units of a product. One element of this product costs $10. An enterprising person suggests that if 1% of the material submitted to the mfg line was counterfeit, but could be made to pass "inspection" they could make at least $10,000,000. They could resell the "genuine parts" on the grey market at a 50% markdown, but only pay 1% of the cost for the counterfeits. The product would ship. Company A would ultimately be left to deal with the 1% (but not trivial number) of unhappy customers and perhaps a class action lawsuit due to "not meeting specs".
In the post I am responding to, there is no requirement by anyone to validate that a part is within spec. Current contract manufacturing for a lot of products does not involve the originating company being able to independently validate the product before it is shipped to the end user. All validation needs to occur during manufacturing, on-site at the manufacturer. If you aren't validating what goes into manufacturing, how can you make any promises as to what comes out?
If company A decides to implement serialization of parts to combat manufacturing "problems". Those advocating "right to repair" are going to be upset because they are now 100% collateral damage. There are other aspects of this, where chip vendors attempt to lock-in customers with the promise of using "custom part numbers" (HP has a fabulous history for this, extending back to the 1980's) or for "custom" programming during fabrication. Many, many. many parts now contain programmable elements and silicon vendors have capitalized on this to gain a business advantage and lock in.
In a world of fraud, especially in the "repair" market, how can and do you establish trust when purchasing parts?
Let's also look at something entirely different. The "Blue Pill" is a development board, originally based on an ST microelectronics STM32 part. If you wanted to purchase a "Blue Pill" board, you will now >90% of the time (based on price) receive a counterfeit product - the microcontroller will not be an STM32 part and it will not exactly meet the specifications (especially in low power situations). Who is to blame? Who pays for this fraud? Should this be "fixed"? How? By who?
Pivoting again. This news "report" is a product, delivered to customers. Are journalists prepared to document the thought processes that went into their product. Will they commit to documenting any changes to the product, including why the changes were made and for what reasons? This is what many of these articles are implicitly asking of hardware manufacturers!
I am generally in favor of being able to repair, but it isn't as simple as toilet roll unroll forward or backwards? (a deliberately chosen metaphor as the majority of the worlds population does not use).
2) Irrelevant: Companies can and do defraud each other already; that has nothing per se to do with right-to-repair.
3) General observation: If one finds oneself needing to write a Breivik-manifesto-length screed in defense and explanation of some viewpoint, that may be a sign that the viewpoint needs rethinking.
I am, however, against the idea of companies being forced to design products around being easily repairable. If a company wants to make a super thin device with basically no easy way to take it apart, that's their prerogative. If a company wants to solder on components to the device like RAM or the storage or the cpu or gpu, that's their prerogative. There are tradeoffs to both approaches to designing the products and you'll find in many markets you will absolutely find many options on the market to suit your own needs or wants. The government doesn't need to be involved in this respect.