I believe that's a bit misleading because it includes Ford's lending arm. They borrow money and lend it out at higher rates. So lots of Ford debt is lent back out to consumers at profit.
I imagine that "120B in debt" means net debt, but I'm not sure.
[follow-up] yes, that's $120B net debt. They have a total $160B of debt, and ~$23B of that is from the automotive side of the business, not the financing side.
https://stockdividendscreener.com/auto-manufacturers/ford-to...
That works if the debt is for things like building factories or designing cars. But when's it's borrowed and then lent straight out it doesn't make sense.
They don't net out -- if you default, my asset will disappear without taking the liability with it. But it might be strange to say that I'm worth $300,000 based on my debt, when the whole concept of that debt is that it's theoretically guaranteed by, and related to, that asset. This combined situation does not suggest that I'm personally worth $300,000; I'm earning the difference in interest, and my debt to my creditor is based mostly off of your net worth, not my net worth.
The majority of their debt comes from financing the sales of their cars to fleets, dealers, or consumers. This earned them 1.7B last year.
Tesla's real advantage imo comes down to not having dealers eat into their margins.
The actual term was "less insane" which isn't really the same thing.
- Tesla is achieving vertical integration to a degree no other mainstream auto OEM has achieved. The only other example of vertical integration to the extreme that I can think of is Koeneigsegg, and they are _very_ niche. This only helps Tesla make cheaper cars faster while collecting more margin per car.
- Tesla's FSD marketing is highly contentious, but they are the only auto manufacturer that is building (designing) their own SoCs explicitly for this. I wouldn't be surprised if they are outspending other auto OEMs on autonomous driving R&D by several degrees of magnitude.
- Tesla still has a major, major lead in EV battery tech which will only be cemented if they can get 4680 into revenue production. They also own the largest and (arguably) most reliable charging network in the world, which is growing at a faster rate than Electrify America, the second biggest competitor.
I think that Tesla is overpriced long term in a world where 91% of American cars are EVs and 48% of them are self-driving, but I think they are correctly priced for _right now_
This is crucial. It’s also why Tesla vs automakers reminds me of Apple iPhone vs existing cell phones. Sure making an electric car is “not that hard,” but because the carmakers didn’t take Tesla seriously for 10+ years, they now have a lot of catching up to do.
Even the SPEAKERS inside of the Model 3 and Y are designed by Tesla (and manufactured by a vendor).
That's the big difference. It's also the reason why legacy manufacturers will struggle to effectively respond to Tesla. It takes a LOT of money and egos to upend generations of culture (and accept hundreds of millions in losses in the process)
In this particular case, is this really a good thing? Porsche's high end option for example is getting the speakers, amplifiers, tuned filters etc. from Burmester. Since Burmester specializes on this kind of thing, and the sound system (not the head unit and interface) are pretty much entirely distinct from the rest of the car, except that it has to be tuned to the environment it will exist in, that intuitively feels better conducive to focus areas and quality all around.
I think the German manufacturers just understand their customers vanity, sadly, where being seen to have the brand matters. The label is practically more important than the sound beyond a certain point.
But you may have a point anyway: The Bose system in the same car (a vastly more popular option because it is much, much cheaper) sounds worse than the cheap sound system in my old Ford.
https://www.suncoastparts.com/product/SKUBERTWEET.html https://www.suncoastparts.com/product/SKU680TWEET.html
Source: https://twitter.com/PaulMaric/status/1160777733825150976
Tesla has made a lot of claims - volumetric efficiency, worrying about air resistance, when Musk toured the Toyota factory there was talk of them moving at granny pace. After the worlds most dramatic production ramp they still have yet to reach the capacity at Freemont of their predecessors (GM/Toyota).
Vertical integration represents the biggest issues with Tesla, a lack of focus. During the ramp of their mass production car, they went and bought Musk's cousin's company for a product that didn't even actually get released until basically this year. I don't see how that is a competitive advantage.
That's because other OEM have worked hard NOT to be vertically integrated. There are benefits to splitting the value chain and letting each supplier concentrate on what they are best at, and get economies of scale from selling to multiple clients.
It seems to me that Tesla lack of focus is actually one of their biggest problem. You can't the best at making cars, batteries, solar panels, etc. all at the same time.
Does it have to be? I can imagine that going from 100 years[1] of internal combustion engines to an entirely different type of drive train is going to be jarring, to say the least. But neither are EV completely new at this point, nor is a car just its drive train.
Surely other comparable transitions have been successful? Any older computer corporation has more or less reinvented itself a few times. More topically, airplane manufactures must have gone from piston engines to vastly different jet engines at some point[2].
[1] BMW for example exists since 1916. [2] Apparently Boeing was originally founded in 1916, too.
Exactly this. The EV drivetrain is also simpler than an ICE because a transmission is not needed[1]. I think the hardest part about vehicle manufacturing, which is the issue Tesla seems to run into repeatedly, is dependable mass production.
The major auto conglomerates have a lot of experience with cranking out massive volumes of quality vehicles. I don't think that re-tooling their production lines is going to be a problem. The primary issue with switching to EVs, which Tesla should capitalize on, will continue to be energy storage. Sourcing large quantities of batteries is tricky. Tesla had the right idea to just vertically integrate cell production and likely has a lot to gain by being the premier battery producer for the industry.
As an aside, hopefully the switch to EVs will help fund research for the next breakthrough in battery tech.
[1]: Application-dependent but most 2-axle consumer electric vehicles should not need a transmission
Musk agrees substantially. He says prototypes are fun and easy and it's the mass production scaling that is the most hell.[0]
For certain companies, market capitalization is a good proxy for enterprise value, but as this poster is mentioning, that's not always the case for companies with debt.
enterprise_value = market_cap + debt - cash
Looking at the market caps of long-standing US car manufacturers is doubly problematic cause they have significant pension obligations. They're producing cars to build shareholder value and pay for retirements.
Comparing market capitalizations of companies that have completely different debt / pension obligations is misleading.
That's not an impossible outcome. I have no bets in this market, I'm strictly wait-and-see.
It's worth pointing out that Apple's valuation before it carved out that "Apple-sized share" was much, much lower.
Their net profit margin is barely 2%.[1]
I would not call it good by any stretch.
By contrast Apple has a 25% net margin[2]. That is what I call good.
[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/profit-...
[2] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AAPL/apple/profit-...
From a market valuation standpoint, this is also why Apple valuation is 44 times higher than Ford's.
[1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY21_Q2_Consolidated_Fin...
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-05/tesla-wil...
* Convincing the public to spend 50-70K on a car
* Convincing the public to buy an EV
* Convincing the public that Tesla can be trusted for long term repair costs/reliability
Right now Tesla is squarely in the luxury vehicle market, competing against Lexus/BMW/Mercedes, rather than against Mazda/Honda/Kia, and it's a new automaker, so we don't have good long term reliability or serviceability data, nor do we have good info on how long the batteries will last, or what costs someone buying a 10 year old model Y will face.
These questions will resolve themselves with time, but whether they will all resolve in Tesla's favor is another matter.
The Model 3 SR+ starts at $39k. For a while, the Model 3 SR was available by special order for only $35K [1] but it did not include autopilot (Autosteer+TACC) and other things.
For $39K it's actually a tremendous value. If you plan on keeping it for more than 5 years. It will actually beat a comparable Accord/Camry Hybrid in terms of TCO.
"Calculating insurance, maintenance, repairs, taxes, fees, financing, depreciation and cost of electricity, we get the true cost of ownership for the Tesla Model 3 which is $25,209."
2020 Tesla Model 3 SR Plus: $25,209
2020 Toyota Camry Hybrid : $36,571
As for reliability. There are already plenty of really high mileage Teslas out in the wild. Like this guy who put 800,000+ miles on his 2014 Model S: https://twitter.com/gem8mingen
Sources:
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_-_t29bciw
https://www.wheelsjoint.com/toyota-camry-vs-tesla-model-3-co...
https://cleantechnica.com/2019/04/25/tesla-model-3-vs-honda-...
https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/27/tesla-model-3-vs-toyota...
Rear drive standard range model 3 starts at 40K. There is simply no universe in which this is either affordable or a bargain. This is entry-level luxury car pricing. If you are buying an out of warranty used Tesla for 20K, say 5 years old, then your TCO is going to be far higher than if you buy a 5 year old out of warranty Camry or Toyota. It is also foolish to include temporary government subsidies when determining the long term viability of a company. Those will all go away shortly at which point your TCO will also go up, and used car buyers do not benefit from these subsidies.
And the Camry is the more expensive sedan, with the cheaper Corolla outselling it regularly.
That's kindof the point. If you want Toyota style volumes, be prepared to have Toyota-style reliability, repair costs, parts eco-system, independent mechanics, and selling prices.
The weighted average retail price for new Toyota cars sold is 34K, and 2/3 of cars purchased each year are used cars. The weighted average selling prices of Teslas is ~60K, nearly double the price of Toyotas. And remember that Toyota is a premium brand due to their legendary reliability. Let me know the lifetime service costs of a Tesla and then we can compare that to the Toyota. Include battery replacement costs in that figure and get back me to me with a real TCO.
For Tesla, there are real question marks about out of warranty cost of ownership and battery replacement costs for purchasing used Teslas. For example, I've never paid more than 13K for a car, always have it serviced at independent mechanics I have a relationship with, and I have always kept my car for at least 7 years, with relatively cheap maintenace cost -- the biggest repair ticket item I ever needed to pay was a clutch replacement. So I am not willing to eat 5-7K in depreciation+maintenance per annum that Tesla buyers will pay. I've only ever suffered at most 1.5K per annum in depreciation+maintenance over the life of cars I've purchased. So don't talk to me about the great deal of paying 40K for a tesla that will lose 20K in depreciation over 5 years. I don't care how much cheaper electricity is than fuel, there is no universe in which this is a cost effective form of car ownership for the majority of the public (2/3 of car sales are used car sales).
I buy reliable used cars that are 5-7 years old that are easy to service. So do other cost-conscious purchasers. For this demographic, there are too many question marks for me to dip into the EV market now, but wait 10-20 years for more reliability data to come out and to see if a cost-competitive third party aftermarket springs up for Teslas that has replacement parts and service costs comparable to what you can get with a good local mechanic working on Toyotas or Hondas, as well as battery replacement costs that are less than the price of the car when the battery dies -- unless the plan is to sell disposable cars, at which point the value proposition is even worse for cost-sensitive purchasers, and Tesla will have a hard time competing if their intention is to sell disposable cars for a higher price than cars that can be maintained for 30 years.
Even if you round up $39K to 40K. It's still a far cry from your initial $50k assumption. $10K is not even close to being a rounding error and makes it seem like you're reaching.
You also made quite a bit of other assumptions here. You should actually fact check some of your claims. You can do the math yourself. Numbers don't lie.
If you can somehow show that the articles and data is wrong. I genuinely would love to see how. Because I put a high value on facts/data vs opinion and that will be news to me.
Tesla 3's ASP was ~60K in 2018 https://cleantechnica.com/2018/08/23/tesla-model-3-average-s...
That was the latest data I could find and I decided to give them a break. You will find in analysts calls a number of 50K is a common estimate.
> Numbers don't lie.
Agreed
> Agreed
So... Do you have that calculation handy where a Camry/Accord cost less to own after 5 years? I would love to see it, so we can compare notes.
(The other posted also talked about ASP of Toyotas, so his comparison was fair btw.)
I've been joking to my wife for years now that we should get a Tesla eventually. Over that time, I've seen her going from "what's up with these EVs anyway?", through "that's a really expensive car", to "sure, but if anything breaks, IIRC the closest shop that can repair it is in Norway".
Both of these have been happening for years now. You can even look up parts/diagrams and order directly from Tesla if you provide your VIN here: http://epc.tesla.com/
Maybe these are not obvious to non-owners. But it's silly to assume things where you have incomplete/false information.
You can talk to actual owners here: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/. I lurked around and asked questions to owners for years there. When I was researching if owning a Tesla is even viable. I own 2 now and never looked back.
Also on your reply above. There are already 10 year old Model S's out there.
My old neighbor just sold his Toyota 4Runner and got a 2012 Model S with 75K miles for $25K that still runs like new. He has it for almost two years now with ZERO maintenance/issues and spends $15-20 a month on electricity.
Apple worked hard to make an iPhone a different product segment to a smart phone the App Store, iMessage and an ecosystem of Apple-compatible services and products. As a result of you want to buy an iPhone you need to pay the premium Apple is asking.
Tesla have the supercharger network and brand name recognition. Neither of them would allow them to completely own the EV market.
All other car companies are primarily debt financed rather than equity financed. Ford's market cap is $45B, but because it has $120B in debt which means it is worth $120B to it's bondholders and $45B to stockholders for a total enterprise value of $160B.
So Tesla isn't worth as much as all of the companies put together, it's worth about as much as 2 or 3 of the big ones. Which is still a lot.
But all the other car companies are facing an existential threat. Climate change and the EV transition are going to be tough. That has to be depressing their valuations some.
Tesla also has a really good profit margin. If they can keep that up, it goes a long way to justifying their prices. Pretty big if, that one -- the general assumption is that it will go down as they go downmarket to chase volume. Vertical integration might let them keep it up, though. Think of it like Apple -- 20% market share but >80% of the profit.
What I'm saying is that if Toyota or Volkswagen had no debt, a Tesla level profit margin and no overhanging challenge like the transition to EV, they'd have a market cap similar to Tesla's.
That still doesn't justify Tesla's market cap, but it makes it seem less insane.