This is crucial. It’s also why Tesla vs automakers reminds me of Apple iPhone vs existing cell phones. Sure making an electric car is “not that hard,” but because the carmakers didn’t take Tesla seriously for 10+ years, they now have a lot of catching up to do.
Even the SPEAKERS inside of the Model 3 and Y are designed by Tesla (and manufactured by a vendor).
That's the big difference. It's also the reason why legacy manufacturers will struggle to effectively respond to Tesla. It takes a LOT of money and egos to upend generations of culture (and accept hundreds of millions in losses in the process)
In this particular case, is this really a good thing? Porsche's high end option for example is getting the speakers, amplifiers, tuned filters etc. from Burmester. Since Burmester specializes on this kind of thing, and the sound system (not the head unit and interface) are pretty much entirely distinct from the rest of the car, except that it has to be tuned to the environment it will exist in, that intuitively feels better conducive to focus areas and quality all around.
I think the German manufacturers just understand their customers vanity, sadly, where being seen to have the brand matters. The label is practically more important than the sound beyond a certain point.
But you may have a point anyway: The Bose system in the same car (a vastly more popular option because it is much, much cheaper) sounds worse than the cheap sound system in my old Ford.
https://www.suncoastparts.com/product/SKUBERTWEET.html https://www.suncoastparts.com/product/SKU680TWEET.html
Source: https://twitter.com/PaulMaric/status/1160777733825150976
Tesla has made a lot of claims - volumetric efficiency, worrying about air resistance, when Musk toured the Toyota factory there was talk of them moving at granny pace. After the worlds most dramatic production ramp they still have yet to reach the capacity at Freemont of their predecessors (GM/Toyota).
Vertical integration represents the biggest issues with Tesla, a lack of focus. During the ramp of their mass production car, they went and bought Musk's cousin's company for a product that didn't even actually get released until basically this year. I don't see how that is a competitive advantage.
That's because other OEM have worked hard NOT to be vertically integrated. There are benefits to splitting the value chain and letting each supplier concentrate on what they are best at, and get economies of scale from selling to multiple clients.
It seems to me that Tesla lack of focus is actually one of their biggest problem. You can't the best at making cars, batteries, solar panels, etc. all at the same time.
- Tesla is achieving vertical integration to a degree no other mainstream auto OEM has achieved. The only other example of vertical integration to the extreme that I can think of is Koeneigsegg, and they are _very_ niche. This only helps Tesla make cheaper cars faster while collecting more margin per car.
- Tesla's FSD marketing is highly contentious, but they are the only auto manufacturer that is building (designing) their own SoCs explicitly for this. I wouldn't be surprised if they are outspending other auto OEMs on autonomous driving R&D by several degrees of magnitude.
- Tesla still has a major, major lead in EV battery tech which will only be cemented if they can get 4680 into revenue production. They also own the largest and (arguably) most reliable charging network in the world, which is growing at a faster rate than Electrify America, the second biggest competitor.
I think that Tesla is overpriced long term in a world where 91% of American cars are EVs and 48% of them are self-driving, but I think they are correctly priced for _right now_