“There is no direct evidence of her taking any money... She adamantly denies stealing. There is no CCTV evidence. There are no fingerprints or marked bank notes or anything of that kind. There is no evidence of her accumulating cash anywhere else or spending large sums of money or paying off debts, no evidence about her bank accounts at all. Nothing incriminating was found when her home was searched...Do you accept the prosecution case that there is ample evidence before you to establish that Horizon is a tried and tested system in use at thousands of post offices for several years, fundamentally robust and reliable?”
The jury pronounced Seema Misra guilty.
There are many more details in this very comprehensive report by Private Eye: https://www.private-eye.co.uk/special-reports/justice-lost-i...
On the one hand, you had the possibility of hundreds of sub-postmasters committing fraud in many different unrelated locations. There was zero evidence of them taking any money even after really deep scrutiny.
On the other hand, there was the possibility of software being buggy.
How could they happily conclude it was the first and not the second option is impossible to understand, and leaves me deeply worried about the UK legal system.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. In order to support the existence of such a distributed fraud scheme, they should have brought convincing evidence. There was zero. Furthermore, they happily ignored an option that is several orders of magnitude more likely. Namely, that badly built software fails and management was deliberately hiding this to save their face.
It is unfortunately fairly common. I have a friend who has been working for the USPS for over twenty years; way back when he got started, a co-worker was busted for pocketing cash from stamp sales. He was my roommate at the time, and was freaking out because she was trying to pin it on him, had to talk to the FBI, etc; the investigators figured out that she had been running the scam over 10+ years (something like $130k if I remember correctly (pocketing about 25 bucks a day, adds up!)). Retail scams just aren’t very unusual.
But you are correct in that evidence is, like, kind of important in a trial…
He said juries just aren't that great at the job. They're easily influenced by current events, susceptible to fallacies, etc. A lot more so than judges, according to my acquaintance (who was admittedly biased).
What about a panel of highly-trained rational-evidence evaluators? This would absolutely be superior to laypeople... Except for the corruption potential
It’s not great, sure, but people from the same circumstances judging a peer is as good as it gets.
Let's just say I have SERIOUS doubts that this system satisfies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
If it's too difficult to fake evidence, we could randomize say 1% of the cases where the convicted is exonerated and given immunity and asked to anonymously report their actual guilt to a system in the interest of supporting a better legal system... yeah, this too would be difficult... hmmm... there must be a way to do this
Is that not the case in Britain?
It's also one of the few instances where the _prosecution_ may appeal without violating double jeopardy protections.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judgment_notwithstanding_ver...
This is a fundamental breach of the prosecutor's duty to disclose any evidence that undermines the prosecution case or supports the defence case. This duty continues to exist after conviction so timing of knowledge is irrelevant.
The judgment is telling in that there are records in which Post Office officials made statements that minutes of meetings about faults in the Horizon system should not be taken so as to avoid having to disclose them in proceedings.
It is corporate failure on an unimaginable scale and three convicted individuals have died before having their convictions quashed.
Yesterday's judgment is long but very readable. I would anticipate further fallout and understand there may be a live police investigation on the basis that several individuals may have perverted the course of justice by either proceeding with prosecutions or omitting material evidence from testimony.
The OP asked, "doesn't there need to be evidence beyond just 'a computer said so'?".
You said the answer is that "the computer said so" and then the operator of the computer said "I agree with the computer".
In my mind, the question still remains. Isn't there any requirement to show where the money went, what account it went into, give dates and details about how they stole the money, etc?
Of course, hiding the known bugs in the software is a scandal and worth talking about, but it doesn't answer the original question I think.
So this is basically saying "the system is only as just as the integrity of the persons involved with the case when factoring in perverse incentives"
The Post Office might not be bankrupted, but I don't think this is going to go well for many of the people involved in the prosecution. The wheels of justice run slow but grind exceedingly fine etc.
You're conveniently overlooking the role that Fujitsu, the software contractor, played.
The issue is concentration of power at large organizations, relative to the rights of individuals in society.
It is problematic when any organization accumulates too much power and runs roughshod over an individual citizen, whether that organization is government or private enterprise.
With private companies, everyone else is often left holding the bag - esp e.g. with mining and drilling companies. But with private corruption companies too - the bankruptcy of the company typically involves all of those being owed money taking a hit if not losing their money completely.
You mention that as if it’s a bad thing? Wiping out bad investments is one of the major tenets of free market approaches. It’s the negative feedback loop for bad investments.
If something is unsustainable, it should go out of business and the investors should take a loss.
Example: imagine an oil company that can pump toxic fluids into the ground in order to cheaply extract lots of oil. Those toxic fluids render miles of ground as wasteland far into the future. The owners of the company should not be allowed to take the profits now, then allow the company to go bankrupt so they don't have to pay back and repair the damage they did.
The limited liability company should be eliminated as it encourages terrible behaviors.
You ignored what I wrote. Wiping out investors is making externalities born by the company.
My statement has nothing to do with externalities. It’s about investors being on the hook a good thing.
The grandparent implied that poor investors lose their money on one hand and complain about externalities going to public on the other, which makes no sense. Holding companies, and subsequently shareholders, accountable for all of the company liabilities is the capitalist way.
However the post office is a public good, so just letting it disappear is something that needs to be prefaced by an actual public discussion to do so.
Not really. Budgeted government programs can’t continue to exist without money. They are default dying without top-ups.
Former PwC Auditor here , the court accepts evidence from independent IT Auditing company who are qualified to perform an audit on the system and asses the reliability of the system or from the vendor himself who provide proofs that the system he sells is reliable ( testing , certifications etc..)
If you're developer you'll probably agree with me that this approach is of course a "non-sense" because no software was ever created "bug-free" or can be really defined as "reliable".
Yet , that's how the court works : "The vendor says the software has no bugs , thus the court is rejecting the objection of buggy software. The court found you guilty"
I'm sadden by this news because it depicts how much the mixture of "bad software" and "corporate/enterprise software" are tied together and how much it can impact people on their daily life with irreversible impact.
It seems that this was the conflict of interest that made Fujitsu's testimony unreliable. They couldn't admit fault without risking the contract. And I'm not sure that relationship was addressed in court for a jury to note.
And, do you hate Lotus Notes?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Clark
I agree the issue is a legal system bug.
The poor woman suffered the loss of her two sons, had to go through a Kafka-esque ordeal of trying to prove her innocence, only to spend three years in prison, all the time being reviled by the press, prison officers and prisoners for being a child-killer. Her second appeal seems to only have been successful because the family discovered that the prosecution had actually withheld exculpatory evidence showing that the second death was actually due to a bacterial infection (the first appeal acknowledged the statistical evidence was flawed but still upheld the conviction). She effectively received a death sentence as she died four years later from psychological issues that were a direct result of her ordeal.
If such a tragic miscarriage of justice could happen to a reasonably well-off, professional working woman (solicitor), it could happen to anyone!
https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/hamilton-others-v-post-of...
There's possibly something on Bailii. (A small volunteer run project, but the website is tricky to use.) Searching for [post office horizon] reveals a few cases.
Here's one useful transcript and discussion: https://journals.sas.ac.uk/deeslr/article/view/2217
A wider question is why no one asked why so many people with the same job were being charged and convicted/pleading guilty. Fraud is a rare crime and rarely prosecuted. So many Cases in one profession is fishy all by itself.
Indeed. You would hope at some point someone would ask why so many have "stolen" money, but yet the actual money has never been located in any account, almost as if the money just disappeared, or never existed in the first place. Hmmm.
Absolutely not the case. If one cannot afford a solicitor one will be appointed.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing
I only discovered this 2y ago when I was arrested. My solicitor in the police station explained he was free but only on that day. I'd have to pay in advance if the police choose to prosecute (they didn't, I was released without charge).
A lot of people don't realise how expensive it is to be innocent in the UK sadly.
This book is a chilling insight into the state of criminal justice: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Secret-Barrister-Stories-Law-Broken...
What makes you think that?
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing
So maybe the UK should spend less time writing horror stories about other "undemocratic" countries and concentrate on their own sorry state of human rights.
What had happen should be impossible in a "democratic western country that respects human rights". Last time I checked they count themselves as one.
I wear it as a badge of honor ;)
From what has been reported in the media, the Post Office and the contractor knew that the software had issues but chose to cover it up and to go after innocent individuals instead. In some instances people were also made to sign settlements preventing them from criticising the software.
This is why this is such a big scandal in the UK. The software was buggy but people lied and sent innocent people to jail to cover it up.
This is a reasonably common thing - for example the law also assumes letters are delivered after being posted unless there is evidence to the contrary.
If the computer says money amounts don't match, that still doesn't say who stole it.
It could have been the person directly responsible for it -- or it could have been a third party attempting to steal from them, or someone hacking the system, etc.
You still need to go beyond reasonable doubt -- establish motive, establish corroborating evidence, etc.
Of course they can claim anything they want, but it could have weakened their argument considerably. As a defense lawyer I would have asked for those numbers to raise some doubts, not because it's incontrovertible proof.
Clearly they did not have to do these things.
In addition, the Horizon system only offered the accused the "client-side" data, so to speak - they could see what they had inputted and what the system had printed out. They couldn't see any kind of internal transaction data, or what happened to the data once it was inputted. Post Office repeatedly obstructed attempts of the accused, their lawyers, and even the third-party auditor they hired to examine the system for faults to retrieve that data - likely because they knew that handing over that data would immediately show the flaws in the system.
The whole thing just stinks of corruption, to be honest.
We need better frameworks for incorporating doubt into our thinking about such things... whether it’s the reliability of computers, or of the justice system, producing what we expect.
They did not invent registered mail for nothing. It is exactly for the reason that mail does not get delivered. I am sick of counting how many times I've received somebody else's mail. And I got $8,000 worth of integrated circuits from Digikey marked as delivered but missing. By sheer accident found that it's been delivered to the house of one of my neighbors.
I even once chased the postman and asked him why are you dropping somebody else's mail in my box? All I could get from him was: "it is ok"
Using proof of delivery can cause problems. People are allowed to decline to accept those letters, and if they do that there's now a paper trail proving they didn't get your letter. That doesn't happen if you just use proof of posting.
Then it is sorry state of affairs. People could get punished for no fault of their own.
You need proof of posting, not proof of delivery. If you can prove posting, it’s up to them to disprove delivery.
It is an absolutely crazy situation where the onus is on the person disputing the computer evidence to show that something is wrong. Even in the middle ages they had a system in place where both parties would have reliable evidence to deal with non reputation in financial transactions. They used a split wooden tally sticks [2], yet now because it is on a computer, and computers are supposedly rarely wrong the courts will allow an organisation to produce something from essentially their own 1 sided ledger and it is up to the other side to prove it wrong. The sub postmasters had no evidence, no ledgers or paper receipts of their own, they were expected to rely entirely on this system to be correct, when it wasn't the entire justice system was rigged against them with the only possibility of winning was to prove that a multi million £ IT system was not working correctly. This would have been hard enough anyway, but the company who built it and the one using it were both willing to lie to cover up its failings.
I am wondering too if they maybe had "experts" testify , and those experts were just clueless.
> Since when does a court accept the uncorroborated report of software, without any other corroborating evidence, and sentence someone?
Since before software has had bugs. Law is the human-governance form of software. It's just as shitty as software is, for the same exact reason.
If a police officer tells the jury that they are 100% sure the person they saw with the knife was the defendant, the defence understands how and to what extent they might be able to persuade the jury that the officer is mistaken about this, or how else to undermine this testimony, and they won't accept it if the officer seems to suggest that, since they're sure this was the person with the knife therefore that person stabbed the victim. There are lots of reasons why, even if the jury is convinced their client is lying and had a knife, that doesn't necessarily mean they stabbed the victim.
In contrast when an "IT expert" tells the jury that 100% the only way this database entry would appear is if the defendant stole money, the defence legal team may be unsure how to persuade a jury (since they aren't IT experts) that this might not be so, and they may end up allowing this to go unchallenged even though I would know to ask lots of questions about access, logging, test strategies, and so on.
Or if a medical doctor tells the jury that the only way this baby gets so many broken bones is that her parents were deliberately shaking her because she was crying, and so they're guilty of murder, the lawyer isn't a medic, and neither is the jury. So who is there to tell them that er, actually there can be other causes and the prosecution needs something else?
Light Blue Touchpaper covered some cases where it seems likely what happened is that crap implementations of EMV ("Chip and PIN") were defrauded by crooks who understood where the flaws were and how to exploit them, but the banks went after their customers, telling juries that the machine is infallible and if it says they used a PIN, that must be true, even though the researchers show various ways it might not in fact be true. Further, bank employees will cheerfully tell a jury that there's no way for other employees to discover a customer PIN, even though meanwhile the bank is firing employees it knows did just that. We ultimately cannot entirely insulate the justice system against people who lie under oath. We can only punish them when they get caught.
So, to the extent anything should be done here, you'd want to start with say, not rewarding the people at Post Office Ltd and in the Horizon team who lied about this and tried so hard to prevent justice being done. Two guesses whether the present government chose to do that...
Then they're a crap defense.
They find an expert witness -- an IT witness in this case -- for their side to explain how the software might make errors, how no software is perfect, etc. Having opposing expert witnesses, one for prosecution and one for defense, is standard.
Lawyers don't need to be domain experts in every, or even most, cases they take on. They do need to find experts though.
> Defence accounting and IT experts were instructed. Detailed disclosure requests were made in respect of Horizon and its underlying data … On the other side of the scales, statements from Fujitsu employees attested to Horizon's reliability. Ultimately, the issue of Horizon's unreliability was not pursued at trial – possibly because the defence experts had struggled to understand the Horizon system.
https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Hamilton...
Courts are supposed to be a level of protection.
If they can't show motivation, point to actual dates and quantities of money stolen, a bank account or purchase it showed up in, all the usual standards of evidence to make an actual criminal case...
...how does this progress from an accusation to beyond reasonable doubt?
Software is buggy. Since when does a court accept the uncorroborated report of software, without any other corroborating evidence, and sentence someone?
This boggles my mind, and seems to go against fundamental legal principles.
Is this going to result in some sort of legal reform? The root cause here isn't a software bug, it's a legal system bug.