Of course they can claim anything they want, but it could have weakened their argument considerably. As a defense lawyer I would have asked for those numbers to raise some doubts, not because it's incontrovertible proof.
Clearly they did not have to do these things.
In addition, the Horizon system only offered the accused the "client-side" data, so to speak - they could see what they had inputted and what the system had printed out. They couldn't see any kind of internal transaction data, or what happened to the data once it was inputted. Post Office repeatedly obstructed attempts of the accused, their lawyers, and even the third-party auditor they hired to examine the system for faults to retrieve that data - likely because they knew that handing over that data would immediately show the flaws in the system.
The whole thing just stinks of corruption, to be honest.
If the computer says money amounts don't match, that still doesn't say who stole it.
It could have been the person directly responsible for it -- or it could have been a third party attempting to steal from them, or someone hacking the system, etc.
You still need to go beyond reasonable doubt -- establish motive, establish corroborating evidence, etc.