News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by chrisseaton on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:33PM (#26926170)
The law presumes that computer systems operate correctly unless there is evidence to the contrary.

This is a reasonably common thing - for example the law also assumes letters are delivered after being posted unless there is evidence to the contrary.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by crazygringo on Saturday April 24, 2021 @02:06PM (#26926977)
But that's still circumstantial evidence.

If the computer says money amounts don't match, that still doesn't say who stole it.

It could have been the person directly responsible for it -- or it could have been a third party attempting to steal from them, or someone hacking the system, etc.

You still need to go beyond reasonable doubt -- establish motive, establish corroborating evidence, etc.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 24, 2021 @02:47PM (#26927326)
One pretty obvious piece of evidence for faulty software would have been if there were significantly more such accusations after the introduction of this software than before. I wonder if anyone asked for these statistics.
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by youngbullind on Saturday April 24, 2021 @03:46PM (#26927750)
They could always say the software was shining a light on a problem that was going unnoticed before.
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 24, 2021 @04:26PM (#26928024)
That wouldn't be very credible though. They would have had to explain why stock keeping and accounting was so much less accurate before. They would also have to explain why their staff was supposedly far more delinquent than staff at comparable shops.

Of course they can claim anything they want, but it could have weakened their argument considerably. As a defense lawyer I would have asked for those numbers to raise some doubts, not because it's incontrovertible proof.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by chrisseaton on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:29AM (#26931207)
> They would have had to explain why stock keeping and accounting was so much less accurate before. They would also have to explain why their staff was supposedly far more delinquent than staff at comparable shops.

Clearly they did not have to do these things.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by fauigerzigerk on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:58AM (#26931337)
I don't know, because I don't know if anyone even asked the question.
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by lewispollard on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:25AM (#26932929)
They did ask those questions, and it was their defense in court in many cases. Unfortunately, due to a few factors - lack of funds for competent defense lawyers (many of the accused had to represent themselves against the huge teams of Post Office prosecutors), insular court process that involved only internal Post Office investigators and prosecutors, false information given by the Post Office to the accused that they were "the only ones having this problem", "say you're guilty of false accounting and we'll drop the more serious theft charge", and finally, the union representing the accused sided with the Post Office and offered no help at all (and, bizarrely, the Post Office was and I believe still is the major funding source for that union... I'll leave you to do the speculation...)

In addition, the Horizon system only offered the accused the "client-side" data, so to speak - they could see what they had inputted and what the system had printed out. They couldn't see any kind of internal transaction data, or what happened to the data once it was inputted. Post Office repeatedly obstructed attempts of the accused, their lawyers, and even the third-party auditor they hired to examine the system for faults to retrieve that data - likely because they knew that handing over that data would immediately show the flaws in the system.

The whole thing just stinks of corruption, to be honest.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by fauigerzigerk on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:32AM (#26932998)
Thanks for the info. It's truly shocking what has happened in this case - on so many levels.
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by natch on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:59PM (#26926396)
To riff off that, it’s also a very common (not universal, nobody is saying that) thing to presume that the justice system works correctly, at least in some countries. But this is aspirational at best.

We need better frameworks for incorporating doubt into our thinking about such things... whether it’s the reliability of computers, or of the justice system, producing what we expect.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by FpUser on Saturday April 24, 2021 @01:05PM (#26926454)
>"This is a reasonably common thing - for example the law also assumes letters are delivered after being posted unless there is evidence to the contrary."

They did not invent registered mail for nothing. It is exactly for the reason that mail does not get delivered. I am sick of counting how many times I've received somebody else's mail. And I got $8,000 worth of integrated circuits from Digikey marked as delivered but missing. By sheer accident found that it's been delivered to the house of one of my neighbors.

I even once chased the postman and asked him why are you dropping somebody else's mail in my box? All I could get from him was: "it is ok"

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by DanBC on Saturday April 24, 2021 @01:13PM (#26926529)
But in for legal cases in England and Wales you only need proof of posting, you do not need proof of delivery.

Using proof of delivery can cause problems. People are allowed to decline to accept those letters, and if they do that there's now a paper trail proving they didn't get your letter. That doesn't happen if you just use proof of posting.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by FpUser on Saturday April 24, 2021 @03:22PM (#26927571)
>"But in for legal cases in England and Wales you only need proof of posting, you do not need proof of delivery"

Then it is sorry state of affairs. People could get punished for no fault of their own.

Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by mitchdoogle on Saturday April 24, 2021 @01:49PM (#26926838)
I don't see the problem in what you describe. Seems like a problem only for people who find the truth inconvenient
Re:Convicted Post Office workers have names cleared by chrisseaton on Saturday April 24, 2021 @01:44PM (#26926788)
> They did not invent registered mail for nothing.

You need proof of posting, not proof of delivery. If you can prove posting, it’s up to them to disprove delivery.