News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by garyclarke27 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:14PM (#26835756)
About time Humans eradicated mosquitoes - they are by far the number 1 animal, that kills humans and are responsible for untold misery and suffering to humans, livestock and wildlife. Of course their predators may decline somewhat but that’s a price worth paying. Humans have decimated so many ecosystems - eg in Great Britain were no large beneficial predators remain - that this change pails in comparison.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by kewrkewm53 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:06PM (#26836474)
Most mosquitoes are harmless, so getting rid of all of them would be incredibly stupid. Getting rid of only species which carry malaria is another matter entirely.

Also, the fact humans have destroyed a lot of biodiversity already is no excuse to do so in the future.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by flower-giraffe on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:00PM (#26837140)
This story is about Aedes aegypti - it certainly does spread dengue fever, chikungunya, Zika fever, Mayaro and yellow fever.

I’m not super comfortable with the unknown risks related to GM insects but having seen the impact of dengue first hand I hope this proves successful at limiting the insect population in urban areas.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by aeternum on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:23PM (#26836664)
Mosquitos can transmit diseases that can negatively affect other animals. Perhaps we would have more biodiversity without mosquitoes.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by kodah on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:33PM (#26836793)
Can this not also easily be stated as, "mosquitos keep populations in check?"
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by filoleg on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:55PM (#26837088)
I mean, so do wars and pandemics, and yet we are not quite thinking of those as good things.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by kodah on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:21PM (#26837353)
Wars are not biological, unless you subscribe to some very meta-thought on population control.

Pandemics could be argued to be a biological control on population, but I think mosquitos would be of more naturally-recurring consequence that make it a "normal" form of population control.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by BugsJustFindMe on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:44PM (#26837565)
It sounds like you're engaging in an appeal to nature fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by kodah on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:52PM (#26837649)
Nope. I am not saying "because it is natural it is good". I am saying that mosquitos, and their negative side effects, play some role in the ecosystem and eradicating them entirely sounds suspiciously like fucking with the firmware too much.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by filoleg on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:52PM (#26838960)
>I am saying that mosquitos, and their negative side effects, play some role in the ecosystem and eradicating them entirely sounds suspiciously like fucking with the firmware too much.

Would you say the same about diseases and pandemics?

There are plenty of things humans do that sound suspiciously like "fucking with the firmware too much", but I don't think many would argue that eradicating polio or fighting cancer or HIV are bad things. And even the "side effects" excuse would apply here too, because letting those people pass on their genes to their offspring potentially interrupts the "natural ecosystem" and introduces weak links into the gene pool.

But there are plenty of good reasons for why this line of thought would not gather much sympathy or consideration these days.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by kodah on Friday April 16, 2021 @07:14PM (#26840056)
> Would you say the same about diseases and pandemics?

For sure. Anything that we chip away in population control will end up having effects elsewhere in the ecosystem. I don't understand how that's a controversial statement. That doesn't mean we shouldn't but it also doesn't mean eradicating things like mosquitos is a good idea either. The same arguments have been given time and again when talking about genetically modified species of insects and animals; the variables of change are too high to predict how it will affect the world around us.

Imagine if all animals and all humans only died of old age from the dawn of time until now. Would Earth be able to sustain itself? I think not. Maybe biology has changed since I've taken it, but these things are considered pieces that are a larger part of homeostasis for ecosystems.

The last part of your statement is just generally confusing.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by _Microft on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:35PM (#26836821)
With all due respect but the role of the "number 1 animal, that [...] is responsible for untold misery and suffering to humans, livestock and wildlife" clearly falls to humans.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by zestyping on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:29PM (#26837418)
Mosquito-borne diseases have killed far more humans than all wars in history. I don't have an estimate for how many other creatures they have killed, nor how much suffering they have caused, but on the whole I suspect mosquitoes are still the winner by a wide margin.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by vlan0 on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:06PM (#26837821)
The comment you're replying to is comparing the suffering humans cause to animals vs mosquitos and their diseases.

It's pretty hard for it not to be us when you look at livestock numbers. We slaughter 10s of billions of animals _yearly_ in the name of food.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by Koliakis on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:44PM (#26836934)
Look, we simply can't accept any competition.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by IncRnd on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:31PM (#26836768)
This targets a particular mosquito in the Keys. There are over 80 types of mosquitoes in Florida, so this isn't expected to eradicate mosquitoes.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by laurent92 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:46PM (#26836960)
The problem with GMO Mosquitoes is, it’s auto-scaling. We want to code one behavior and let it grow by itself better than autochtone species.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by _rpd on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:19PM (#26836626)
My understanding is that it is quite difficult for a disease to be spread by mosquitoes. There's an aspect of co-evolution that limits significant spread to particular species. Of thousands of species of mosquito, there are just a handful that cause the vast majority of suffering.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito-borne_disease

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by exabrial on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:35PM (#26836820)
Ooof.

Believe it or not, the balance of nature depends on them. What would dragon flies eat? What would endangered birds that eat dragonflies eat?

Some animal populations are _only_ constrained by their food supply and disease vectors in the environment. For instance, local deer populations, where human's have eradicated their predators, quickly spiral out of control unless hunting permits can be issued in number to keep the populations in check.

Eradication isn't a good goal, but perhaps rebalancing is and removing those that spread deadly cross-species diseases.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by tmountain on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:40PM (#26836892)
I believe this argument has been mostly refuted in the scientific community. Here's an excerpt from a Forbes article on the topic:

What are the risks of eradicating mosquitoes?

As you noticed, there are no keystone species in mosquitoes. No ecosystem depends on any mosquito to the point that it would collapse if they were to disappear. An exception may be the Arctic, but the species there are non-vectors and thus can be left alone.

https://tinyurl.com/5bmksuf4

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by asymmetric on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:08PM (#26837227)
FYI, this is an “article” copy-pasted from Quora.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by tmountain on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:18PM (#26838606)
Didn't know that, but there's far more out there on the topic if you go looking for the info. Bill Gates had some commentary on the topic regarding the ecological impacts not being what people believe them to be (under the umbrella of public health in Africa).
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by mullingitover on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:55PM (#26837085)
> Believe it or not, the balance of nature depends on them. What would dragon flies eat? What would endangered birds that eat dragonflies eat?

Aedes aegypti are an invasive species in most of the world. It's a pure win to eradicate them, they have zero benefits to the ecosystem.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by exabrial on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:56PM (#26839487)
that's quite fascinating actually
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by rirze on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:55AM (#26841667)
I agree with your statement's intent, but it not quite right to compare the eradication of higher level creatures in the food chain to ones that are quite lower. The eradication of insects and bugs can potentially be more disruptive than removing an apex predator species.

As others have stated however, mosquitoes have been studied to not have a significant impact if they were to go extinct.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by RamRodification on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:18PM (#26835806)
> somewhat

Can you back these numbers up?

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by jjk166 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:59PM (#26836380)
There are 3000 species of mosquito. Only a few dozen transmit diseases to humans, and of those just 3 are the primary spreaders. No predator feeds exclusively on the disease spreading species.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by noxer on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:57PM (#26837712)
The real question is which one will replace the 3 if we remove them?
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by galago on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:16PM (#26836584)
(That we know of.)
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by m0llusk on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:27PM (#26838693)
Last I checked the animal most deadly to humans was the white tailed deer which have an unfortunate habit of leaping in front of speeding vehicles and then freezing there until struck.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by ericbarrett on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:33PM (#26838768)
Mosquito-borne diseases are estimated to have killed 50 billion humans throughout history: https://www.amazon.com/Mosquito-Human-History-Deadliest-Pred...
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by m0llusk on Saturday April 17, 2021 @08:31AM (#26843762)
I was talking about yearly numbers in North America. Sorry I made you angry, but honestly I think I was contributing positively to the conversation such that the downvote--yes, I am commenting about the downvote--was unwarranted.

Good luck with your pet issue I guess.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by ericbarrett on Sunday April 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#26854408)
Sorry friend, I wasn't angry and wasn't the one who downvoted you, I'm just very passionate about mosquitos...!
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by soperj on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:30PM (#26835957)
Mosquitoes are a major pollinator.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by gus_massa on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:53PM (#26836289)
Note that this is not like DDT that will kill all the mosquitoes (and everything that looks like a mosquito, and many more animals).

This is only against Aedes aegypti that is responsible for most of the transmissions and is not a native specie of Florida.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by Turing_Machine on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:54PM (#26837062)
Right. Aedes aegypti is native to Africa (as one might guess from the name), and is essentially an invasive species elsewhere in the world.

If anything, wiping them out should push the local ecosystem back toward its normal state, as the native species of mosquito (of which there are many) would face less competition from the invasive Aedes aegypti.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by jjk166 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:50PM (#26836248)
There are thousands of mosquito species and only a few dozen spread diseases to humans, of which only 3 make up the vast majority. Eradicating the disease carriers would have minimal effects on the ecosystems.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by awb on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:04PM (#26836446)
> Eradicating the disease carriers would have minimal effects on the ecosystems.

I'm not going to ask you to prove a negative, but it sure sounds like it's going against all the advice I've heard about ecology.

Namely that ecosystems are far more complex than we understand and that even small changes can compound into larger changes. Basically: don't play God.

If this is safe and it does work, then it might be helpful to have some new messaging about when and where we can start actively designing ecosystems.

"Don't mess with mother nature" is easy to understand. So, how would you create a new maxim that preserve that general rules but also accommodates eliminating undesirable subspecies?

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by joe-collins on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:45PM (#26836950)
> Basically: don't play God.

(Un)fortunately, we already are God. We already mess with Mother Nature. Our continued existence has impacts so complex that those impacts cannot be modulated solely in degree, because changing degree causes a cascade of effects that makes it a change in type.

It is unpredictable, not because it is natural, not because it is sacred or some other special case, but because of the number of parts. And in spite of that lack of clarity, we are inescapably responsible for making choices that will steer the ecosystem. As Sartre wrote,

> In one sense choice is possible, but what is not possible is not to choose. I can always choose, but I must know that if I do not choose, that is still a choice.

There is no surety that non-intervention will lead to outcomes that are better by any measure, whether that measure is long-term stability, convenience for humans, or nearly any other you might choose. Left alone, nature can only select the traits that made the last generation breed the most. None of that is proof against the future. For every species alive today, many others are dead, exactly because nature was not messed with. Nature does not share humanity's moral attachment to conservationism.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by hackeraccount on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:20PM (#26836631)
"Don't mess with markets" is easy to understand. That said people are perfectly willing to mess with them in ways both large and small. Sometimes they have a guiding maxim and sometimes they just say it's a self-evident action that will outweigh any downside.

I suspect the truth is that in both cases it comes down to who is going to benefit - with it more likely to happen if the "who" is either a large number or a small number with a lot of influence and the "benefit" is something that's immediately apparent to the winners and not immediately apparent to the people who lose in the intervention.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by germinalphrase on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:10PM (#26836536)
“How would you create a new maxim that preserves that general rule but also accommodates eliminating undesirable subspecies?”

“We are as gods and might as well get good at it,” Stewart Brand.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by diebeforei485 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:57PM (#26837105)
We introduced invasive species like tumbleweeds (unknowlingly) that have messed with mother nature.

We have also introduced some species that haven't really created problems.

We have also created new habitats (cities) where some species are quite problematic. If we could get rid of cockroaches and bed-bugs, life would certainly become better.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by jjk166 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:15PM (#26836579)
It's not like we're snapping our fingers and making an irreversible change to the whole planet. We can and have been testing this process in isolated cases and if anything unexpected happens we can stop the process and reintroduce the species, but we actually do have a pretty good understanding of ecosystems.

Mother nature does not have your best interests at heart, and decisions that affect the lives of millions should not be made based off short maxims.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by awb on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:18PM (#26837331)
> We can and have been testing this process in isolated cases

Anytime you jump from the lab to the real world it's going to be different. And each ecosystem in the country and state will be slightly different.

> if anything unexpected happens we can stop the process and reintroduce the species

Has this been done before with insects though? This sounds a lot harder than reintroducing wolves at Yellowstone that are small enough in number that they can be monitored.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by coding123 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:22PM (#26836653)
Famous last words.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by BitwiseFool on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:39PM (#26836086)
We can always re-introduce them if it becomes a problem.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by throwaway823882 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:26PM (#26836695)
I'm sure the rest of the ecosystem will just wait around for a few decades while we begin to repopulate them...
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by BitwiseFool on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:38PM (#26836864)
I'm not sure it would be so bad. Mosquitoes breed prodigiously and I'm sure they'd be back in no time.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by williamtwild on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:24PM (#26835880)
What about the impact of this food source on other animals? You are not concerned about that at all?
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by FredPret on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:31PM (#26835974)
I read somewhere that all the lethal-mosquito-eaters already also eat the non-lethal kinds, as well as other insects
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by BitwiseFool on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:57PM (#26836346)
Even the "Mosquito Fish" doesn't exclusively eat mosquito larvae and tends to prefer other food sources. I don't know of any species that exclusively prey on Mosquitoes.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by throwaway823882 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:22PM (#26836647)
I don't think it is possible to "accidentally" decline the number of predators without it rippling into a potential ecological collapse.
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by IncRnd on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:33PM (#26836799)
Just introduce European Rabbits. What could go wrong? /s
Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by laurent92 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:51PM (#26837025)
For those who don’t know, it’s a story worth telling: Rabbits on my grandma’s fields (France) have red eyes. All because of Australia ;)

Rabbits were introduced to Australia to get rid of other pests.

Then myxomatosis was engineered circa 1950 to get rid of rabbits. It killed 95% of them in 5 years. The 5% reproduced and now all rabbits in Australia have myxomatosis.

The researcher wanted to get rid of rabbits in his garden in UK. He brought myxomatosis back and 95% UK rabbits were killed in 2 years. The 5% regrew and all UK rabbits are myxo-resistant.

It spread to France. But I guess, by now, you know the story ;) Hence the story of the red-eyed rabbits.

Re:First GMO Mosquitoes to Be Released in the Florida Keys by IncRnd on Friday April 16, 2021 @10:43PM (#26841203)
Indeed! Thank you.

I was quite surprised that people here chose to downvote my comment, apparently not knowing what it referenced.