News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by mensetmanusman on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:18PM (#26742601)
“ “Scary though if it isn’t a deepfake,” Shamook added. “This could be the start of people being able to discredit real evidence by simply saying ‘deepfake.'” “

This.

I have been in a jury, and I wouldn’t be surprised if image based evidence won’t always be discounted by defense attorneys. It probably is already starting for the high paid ones (e.g. the notion itself will protect the rich.)

It brings up an interesting future where you can’t trust any witness testimony (because people do misremember) or any video, image, or audio evidence due to this technology.

The only societal workaround will be to implant cryptographic keys inside of bodies and monitor all interactions on some blockchain /s?

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by nickysielicki on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:01PM (#26743080)
The phrasing of this rubs me the wrong way -- I get the feeling that you're more afraid of guilty people being presumed innocent than you are of innocent people being framed by deepfakes.

Our justice system worked for a very long time in an environment where cell phones didn't exist, where cities weren't covered end-to-end in CCTV cameras, and our courts were able to do a decent job of protecting the innocent and putting away the bad guys. Distrust of video evidence only makes us revert back 30 years to when we weren't so monitored. It's something that we can survive. On the other hand, if we don't see an outright rejection of deepfakes in our courts, we're going to see it used as a political weapon. We can survive the former, but not the latter.

Unfortunately, I don't see it working out that way. Once courts and police get their hands on a new technology and it becomes sufficiently ingrained, it doesn't matter how little sense it makes. Drug dogs are bullshit, but they're still everywhere. [1] DNA evidence can be synthesized and planted, but it's the gold standard in terms of courtroom evidence. [2]

Given all of this, I don't have a lot of faith in our justice system getting deepfakes right, and that worries me a lot more than guilty people being presumed innocent.

[1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/02/05/supreme-c...

[2]: Good reason to avoid giving your DNA to 23andMe or to the state. Unfortunately, both my parents did 23andMe, so I'm screwed regardless. https://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/18/science/18dna.html

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Klinky on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:22PM (#26743288)
The track record of the justice system has been extremely mixed for many, and downright awful for minorities. DNA testing has been absolutely crucial in the last 30 - 40 years for undoing some of the damage the justice system caused before DNA testing was adequately available. There is no comfort found in regressing backwards to where forensic science becomes easily dismissible, and we're reliant on who can buy the most prestigious expert witness to testify for them.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Rule35 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:48PM (#26744771)
Courts and police have still done vastly more for minorities than against them.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by lupire on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:11PM (#26744918)
That's not really comforting to the minority people whose lives were ruined by them.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Rule35 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:57PM (#26745241)
> That's not really comforting to the minority people whose lives were ruined by them.

Actually, it probably is somewhat. I hate paying money but that my taxes go to useful things makes it bearable. I hate sucking up to a guy in a uniform but that he also arrests murderers makes it less infuriating.

But moreover, that's not the issue brought up originally, which was net damage to a group. The implication was that the justice system harmed minorities and as a group that's simply not true.

Also, the language used is trying to borrow outrage. Harmed minorities? No, harmed the poor. Many of whom were minorities. But there are rich racial minorities too.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Klinky on Thursday April 08, 2021 @08:36PM (#26745502)
You are trying to dilute the impact the racist history of US has had on minorities via the justice system. Justice and policing policies disproportionately target minorities. Sure the poor are affected by lack of proper representation, but minority populations also happen to be disproportionately affected by poverty. Stop and frisk, racial profiling, less lenient prosecutory discretion, mandatory minimum sentencing, and the War on Drugs all disproportionately impact minority groups compared to Caucasians[1]. If you just think we need to solve the poverty problem, a significant part of that problem is rooted in systemic racism too.

Per the Innocence Project, 70% of the cases they have exonerated have been of a minority group, and often these cases involved underlying racial prejudice to railroad an innocent person into a long-term prison sentence or death.[2]

>As of November 2019, 367 people previously convicted of serious crimes in the United States had been exonerated by DNA testing since 1989, 21 of whom had been sentenced to death.[9] Almost all (99%) of the wrongful convictions were males,[19] with minority groups constituting approximately 70% (61% African American and 8% Latino).

1.https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/un-report-on-...

2.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocence_Project#Overturned_c...

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by ghufran_syed on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:20PM (#26746356)
So the largest discrepancy from proportions in the US population is the overwhelming skew in favor of males (99%) - are they “minorities” too?

If the problem is racism, in a country where sexism against women is said to be a major problem, why would there be a 99:1 preponderance of men? Are the racists also biased in favor of women and against men?

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Klinky on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:58PM (#26746532)
This sounds like apples v. oranges.

Are males a minority group? No, technically not, since sex split is about 50/50. Is the high preponderance of men ending up in prison concerning? Yes. Frankly our high incarceration rates for non-violent crimes is extremely concerning. Does this somehow invalidate the problems brought up around female equality? Absolutely not. I also believe there is probably additional negative bias towards African-American males because of racist tropes.

Also the 99% figure was from the Innocence Project, Google brings up Federal Bureau of Prisons stat suggesting active incarceration is closer to 93% male, 7% female. Still concerning.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Rule35 on Friday April 09, 2021 @12:09AM (#26746608)
> You are trying to dilute the impact the racist history of US has had on minorities via the justice system.

Hasn't anyone told you that you learn more with questions than assertions?

No. I'm saying that the language used is throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Regardless of all the stuff you mentioned, which is true, the system is still a benefit.

You should not go out of your way to further weaken trust in the system that has benefitted those minorities you mention more than it has hurt them. Especially as you are presumably not those groups, you should be careful not to wreck what they have. (You may not be aware, but white 'progressives' often speak for people of color. Their messages sound like ones of support initially, but because these people are often merely social signaling the rhetoric can often prove harmful to people who have to live with it.)

> [...] all disproportionately impact minority groups compared to Caucasians

Some minorities, yes. Others, no. Deeply troubling to the white v black narrative is that Nigerian immigrants often do very well in the USA, even when Americans don't know if they're american-descendants-of-slavery or not.

But yes, ADoS do have it rough. If you want to support someone though, vague "minorities" is not how you do it.

> Per the Innocence Project, 70% of the cases

You can't use that stat in that way, presumably they picked the most egregious cases which would be the poorest, etc.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Klinky on Friday April 09, 2021 @12:33AM (#26746753)
I think you're saying minorities are better off with a justice system than without. Maybe everyone is technically better off with a justice system, than with something like vigilante justice, but the US has always had some level of justice system even during slavery. Was it really to their benefit at that time? Can we say things have improved, yes, very slowly, but systemic racism still exists.

>You can't use that stat in that way, presumably they picked the most egregious cases which would be the poorest, etc.

No, you cannot just ignore ingrained racism within the judicial system from day one as simply being a class issue. You can read more from the National Registry of Exonerations about racial bias in exonerated cases[1].

1. http://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Documents/Race_...

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by rossdavidh on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:12PM (#26743189)
I don't think the history regarding how courts (and juries) handled eyewitness testimony, is all that different from how they handle DNA evidence. It's regarded as far more reliable than it is.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Daho0n on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:20PM (#26743886)
>Drug dogs are bullshit, but they're still everywhere. [1]

Just because some abuse them and have no proper training doesn't mean they are fake. You clearly have never seen a police dog work. They are able to find dead people, drugs, etc. that is at the bottom of the sea or follow the path the target took while inside a car. What is BS is the "police" and justice system in the US.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by samatman on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:00PM (#26744369)
This is a misunderstanding of why "drug dogs are bullshit".

Yes, dogs are capable of sniffing out people, animals, and substances. This has been made use of for centuries.

Dogs are also capable of "hitting" on the trunk of a car, just because they guess that their master wants to look inside it. Plenty of evidence that this happens all the time.

Which undermines the right protecting against unreasonable search and seizure. All you have to do is be the wrong color, or driving in a "suspicious" way (which means whatever police want it to mean), and they can bring a K9 by, the dog will dutifully point at the trunk, and the cops get their search.

It's no different from the "I smelled pot" routine: there aren't any penalties to the police for doing an "I smelled pot" search and not finding cannabis, and there are no consequences for a K9 'hitting' on a trunk which turns out to have nothing more interesting than a gym bag.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Daho0n on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:24PM (#26745004)
That is a very convoluted way of stating that police dog handlers in the US are as bad as the rest of the US police. It is not that "drug dogs are BS" but that "US police have a huge problem and it includes their use of drug dogs".
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by not1ofU on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:24AM (#26750953)
I love dogs, I also used to love weed. I had planned a trip to a far away country for the New year. I left my country of origin on a short flyover to meet with friends and catch main flight to destination. I was absolutly smashed from smoking 2 joints before getting on the plane (outside the main door of the airport). When I arrived I walked through bagage area, with no baggage to collect as it was going straight to the final destination. I spied a dog, and made a beeline to say hello. I had fun playing with the dog and just as I was walking away I could feel this burning feeling that someone was giving me the evil eye. I turned around and followed the dogs lead to the owner, who was a fair way away, and dressed in a high-vis jacket. I continued on without thinking about it, until i started to think about it. Lets just say the next couple of hours waiting for my friends was not so pleasant. (I wasnt carrying anything, but still).
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by rStar on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:05PM (#26744403)
drug dogs usefulness to law enforcement, almost exclusively, are as machines to manufacture probable cause on command. As this is how they’re used, “bullshit” is far too kind a descriptor.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Daho0n on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:19PM (#26744962)
In the US perhaps.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Enginerrrd on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:06PM (#26744419)
Just because one drug dog might actually work doesn't mean that, on average, they and their handlers are performing to standard sufficient for probable cause.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Daho0n on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:27PM (#26745032)
I'm aware that there are huge problems with police training and integrity in the US but that isn't a problem with drug dogs. That is a problem with the training and integrity of their handlers.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by drdeadringer on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:27PM (#26744596)
I remember an episode of the Olde Time Radio show "The Shadow" where Lamont and Margo attend a trial as audience members. This is in the 1930s // 1940s for context.

The prosecution projected a film with audio [cutting edge technology at the time] demonstrating the crimes in question [bribery and related charges].

Lamont ['The Shadow'] was able to hear the audio and read lips at the same time and figure out that what was heard was not was what said. "Believe half of what you see, and nothing you hear" was his takeaway.

As the story goes, that's what happened. The film shown at court was dubbed for audio by a hired guy who did great vocal impersonations. The accused was innocent.

Short story long: deep fakes aren't a new idea. 100 years and counting. Same trick, different tools.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by paxys on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:27PM (#26742701)
IMO it's a step in the right direction. Photos and videos should at minimum be signed/cryptographically verifiable if they are used as key testimony in court. We have had the tools to easily and convincingly fake photos for decades now. I can bet there are people behind bars today because someone got creative with photoshop.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:45PM (#26742903)
> Photos and videos should at minimum be signed/cryptographically verifiable if they are used as key testimony in court.

This kind of "verification" doesn't work. You're trying to have the device authenticate the image. That implies a root of trust that goes through the device manufacturer, which state actors will immediately compromise, making the signatures untrustworthy regardless. Then people will find vulnerabilities in the devices themselves, or convincing ways to have the device take a picture of a doctored photograph instead of a picture of the world, extending the ability to forge signatures to the general public.

The resources needed to forge a signature aren't going to be much different than the resources needed to create a deepfake to begin with. The creator gets to choose which device to use and can choose based on which device they find a vulnerability in. So it's more likely to be a liability than a benefit because it lends false credence to the authenticity of fakes.

For it to work you would need all devices to be secure against all attackers. It's not realistic.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by jjk166 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:20PM (#26743268)
Chain of custody is standard for evidence already. It might not be 100% infallible, but it certainly works better than nothing.

Yes, if a state actor wants to create evidence to frame you, and they didn't care about cost or returns, they could do so. But they could always do so. The fact is most of us are never going to get framed by a nation state.

The notion that you're either secure against all possible attacks or nothing is absurd.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:36PM (#26743450)
Chain of custody implies you have some impartial authority who was actually there at the time to authenticate the recording. But then you would already have an impartial eyewitness. That doesn't work the other 99% of the time when the two parties to the case each tell a different story and one of them is offering evidence they have in their possession. The chain of custody then contains someone partial to the case and untrustworthy.

> Yes, if a state actor wants to create evidence to frame you, and they didn't care about cost or returns, they could do so. But they could always do so. The fact is most of us are never going to get framed by a nation state.

This is a major problem for elections. Nation states absolutely will doctor video of adversarial political candidates and for other propaganda purposes.

> The notion that you're either secure against all possible attacks or nothing is absurd.

But that's how signatures work. You're trusting every device in the world to sign the output of its camera. If the attacker can compromise any device, they can produce signed forgeries.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by jjk166 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:12PM (#26743812)
You're describing a situation where the recording ought not to be admissible anyways. If you can't trust where evidence came from, it's not evidence.

Again, nation states have always been able to doctor video of adversarial political candidates. Lookup pictures where the KGB made someone disappear.

Yes, if an attacker can compromise any device they can produce a signed forgery. But that's a really big if. There are a lot of potential attackers who can't compromise any and all devices, and signatures protect against them.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by moftz on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:51PM (#26743612)
I guess the weakpoint in all of these techniques to prove a photo was taken by a certain device, at a certain time, in a certain place is for someone wearing a very good disguise to publicly commit crimes in your name. Any witnesses or photo evidence is going to point to you. A full movie costume makeup kit probably costs less than what it takes to hack Apple for someone's iPhone private key.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by chrisco255 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:00PM (#26743069)
> The resources needed to forge a signature aren't going to be much different than the resources needed to create a deepfake to begin with.

How? If you have a public/private key pair and then do some kind of multisig process wherein the manufacturer can sign the photo, the OS can sign the photo, and then a user supplied signature could also sign the photo. You're not going to be able to fake 3 cryptographic signatures without 3 private keys. It would be extremely difficult to fake all of that. It would take a concerted, concentrated effort and would be extremely rare in practice. It would certainly improve the situation.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:02PM (#26743087)
Once you compromise the device it doesn't matter how many keys there are because they all have to be on the device.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Rule35 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @08:51PM (#26745608)
You'd make the camera reach out to a signing server for the user's signature. You'd even sign the whole photo, not a hash supplied by the camera, to give you (via the server) a chance to verify the image was correct.

Or, you'd adapt a hardware wallet to do the same. Either way, there'd be two devices from two manufacturers, communicating over a transparent protocol.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by titzer on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#26743557)
As a user, why does my private key need to be on the device? Especially, because I wouldn't want it there, because devices get stolen.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:49PM (#26743587)
It has to be where the camera is. Otherwise the device holding your private key would need some way to authenticate photos from the device with the camera, which was the original problem.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by chrisco255 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:57PM (#26743673)
First off, you'd have to steal the actual device. Then you'd have to break the device encryption itself to then extract a an encrypted version of a private key. (the private key itself can be encrypted with a password not stored on the device) You pair the 3 sigs plus a blockchain to track timestamps and photo hash signatures and maybe pair that with a different blockchain app to report lost or stolen devices...and you've got yourself as secure of a system as you can conceive in the age of deep fakes.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by xyzzy123 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:17PM (#26743861)
One threat is that a malicious actor uses a compromised device to fake a "legitimate" verified image.

This image can now be injected into the news cycle and be taken seriously.

Keeping a secret on the camera is more or less the "jailbreak problem", aka being able to make a dvd player or console that only does the things that the manufacturer wants.

I will be pretty sad if this problem is actually "solved" effectively because it portends a future where manufacturers can completely curtail user freedom. But...

If the key on the device is compromised by reverse engineering or because the manufacturer is compromised then the whole root of trust is gone.

Attackers can choose the weakest brand of camera.

You now have some doubt about any image that has been "verified" because it could have come from a compromised camera secret.

All the rest of the stuff, the blockchain, etc depends on the root of trust in the camera.

You also now have debates around camera country of origin because there is no near future world where governments can't lean on local manufacturers. Finally, doubt can be thrown on images retro-actively if we later learn that a camera we thought was secure, has vulnerabilities.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by chrisco255 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:35PM (#26745084)
This isn't a "freedom" issue. And no, even if the private key on the device is hacked, you wouldn't be able to hack all the cameras (assuming the device manufacturer would embed a different key for each unit ID), you would still have to hack the OS and the User and the Phone's encryption. So the surface area of a hack would be small. You cannot fake all those signatures, you'd have to literally hack all that encryption.

All of this would be optional, of course. People can always edit out metadata. But it would lend credence and authority to a photograph or video. Which would carry more weight in a court of law, for example, where this stuff really matters.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by xyzzy123 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @08:14PM (#26745359)
This is an interesting conversation because we both seem convinced we're "obviously right". I am clearly having trouble understanding your point of view. I apologise in advance if I'm mis-understanding your argument. Perhaps "First off, you'd have to steal the actual device" from upthread is the clue.

I think the disconnect might be that you are working from a threat model where someone else is trying to tamper with an image from your camera. I agree you could make that arbitrarily difficult. But I am primarily concerned with the threat where someone is tampering with their own camera to fake evidence. This possibility makes it harder for you to prove that your own image is legitimate.

Your reasoning implies that one or two hacked cameras are not a problem. To my way of thinking, the possibility that "at least 1 hacked camera exists" or "any camera could possibly be hacked" are enough to throw doubt on any "verified" images that someone tries to present in a high stakes context such as national security or the courtroom. We're back to debating provenance.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by chrisco255 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:16PM (#26746331)
I don't know. I don't want to live in a world where someone can literally murder someone on camera and get away with it on a technicality. Witness testimony is already used in court and is quite unverifiable and subject to all sorts of psychological phenomenon where people sometimes believe they saw something entirely different than what actually happened. I think cryptographic signatures couldn't guarantee validity 100%, but they could improve the situation in a world of deep fakes on demand.

It would require a larger degree of premeditation and effort to convincingly pull off a deep fake in that world.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by krageon on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:48AM (#26748540)
> a technicality

It's not a technicality if the video can't be distinguished from perfect nonsense. Just as you don't let someone with a documented history of hallucinations testify on their own.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by nharada on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:07PM (#26743137)
> The resources needed to forge a signature aren't going to be much different than the resources needed to create a deepfake to begin with

I imagine deepfakes will become way easier in the near future because there are legitimate commercial reasons to make them easy and accessible (for example digital art assets). I don't see the same happening for cracking devices, which is more a standard security cat and mouse game between hackers and device manufacturers.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:10PM (#26743169)
All you're saying is that creating deepfakes would get easier, not that cracking devices would get harder. And it's already not hard enough to be a significant barrier.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Asraelite on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:10PM (#26743161)
One possibility would be for all recording devices to immediately upload checksums of their recorded footage to multiple trusted online authorities upon recording.

If someone presents altered footage, you can show that the checksum of the original was uploaded earlier.

This of course only covers certain cases. If the deepfake is crafted from scratch or from a camera that doesn't upload its checksums, and the incentive for the creation of the deepfake arises before the supposed time the deepfake takes place, then this method won't be of use.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:41PM (#26743506)
Opt out and it's an invasion of privacy, opt in and nobody does and it isn't applicable to 99% of authentic footage.

And subject to attack. Don't want to be recorded? Jam wireless so they can't have anyone sign their videos, then claim they're fake.

Also doesn't work for state actors. A country can compromise three separate signing authorities.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Asraelite on Friday April 09, 2021 @03:29AM (#26747625)
I don't quite understand how it would be an invasion of privacy. All that's needed is a checksum paired with a timestamp, you don't even need to identify yourself. There is no way anyone could extract any meaningful information out of that without the footage.

And you can just upload it to ten different authorities in ten different jurisdictions, or even a hundred if you're paranoid. States are powerful but they're not _that_ powerful. It's the same principle that makes Tor work.

I agree jamming wireless could be an issue, but only for prosecution. In the case of proving innocence it's a moot point because this checksum system only covers after-the-fact fabrication anyway.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by krageon on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:52AM (#26748551)
> you don't even need to identify yourself.

They'd also have logged the IP, which combined with a time will probably significantly narrow down the individual in question if you can also access telco records. Especially if inadvertently more information is also documented (such as a user agent).

> It's the same principle that makes Tor work.

Tor doesn't work for this kind of problem, unless you are significantly more technically savvy (and even then...) then the average smartphone user.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Asraelite on Friday April 09, 2021 @06:05AM (#26748619)
I think you missed the point regarding Tor. I mean that for Tor to be compromised, a state actor would need to compromise on the order of dozens to hundreds of nodes simultaneously. The fact that Tor works shows that they are unable to do this, and so they would also be unable to simultaneously compromise dozens of checksum authorities. Nothing to do with using Tor for uploading checksums, I was just using it as an example.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by tshaddox on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:24PM (#26743926)
You’ve explained why it wouldn’t work flawlessly, but that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t work better than the current state of affairs. Video evidence is already useful in the legal system despite “video evidence” obviously not being a flawless system. A state actor or even a competent video effects studio with a modest budget could already create a convincing fake video!
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by astrange on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:46PM (#26742919)
There are pretty good ways to detect photo editing, using things like measuring levels of JPEG artifacts across the image. Or if you save pictures raw I’ve never seen anyone try to fake a camera raw file.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by NortySpock on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:08PM (#26743152)
Couldn't you just "rebalance" the JPEG artifacts as a final pass? Or some sort of slight blur that re-jumbles the least significant bits of every pixel?
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by therealx on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:58PM (#26743679)
Yes, this is standard in the forgery business - dust and speckle filter, drop the res, ensure the light is balanced, and maybe blur if you can get away with it.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by astrange on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:31PM (#26744627)
These general techniques are weak against specific detection models that understand how the original image should’ve been generated. Another example is camera noise modeling since the injected noise won’t be consistent with how a phone camera etc actually behaves, or an ML model for image depth might see that it's at the wrong distance somehow.

Scaling the image down seems like one of the best tricks if you can get away with it. Another cheap one would be shifting the image 4 pixels over to break up the DCT artifact grid.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by krageon on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:54AM (#26748561)
> the injected noise won’t be consistent

With a good forgery it will be. Even then, the fact that it's noise means that you won't ever be sure about this.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Ma8ee on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:08PM (#26743148)
Why would it be harder or different to fake a raw file?
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by astrange on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:50PM (#26743602)
I didn’t say it would be hard, just that I haven’t seen one. But they contain a lot of information that can’t be displayed on a computer monitor and so it would be a lot of work to check all of it.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by floren on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:35PM (#26744042)
As a fan of film photography, I smile at a future in which a roll of developed negatives is valuable evidence because it's a lot harder to fake.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by thebean11 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:59PM (#26743065)
If I'm an end consumer taking pictures and videos for fun / posterity what's the incentive for me to have them cryptographically signed? Why would I ever need to prove they're real?

Are you saying that by law devices should cryptographically sign pictures?

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by ben0x539 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:43PM (#26742880)
Hm, I'm out of the loop here, who would sign the photos? The camera app?
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by cabalamat on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:36PM (#26743460)
Maybe something like Third Eyes ( https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/05/08/raikoth-corruption-pri... ) could do the job.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by foepys on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:46PM (#26742926)
Who does the verification? Who does guard the keys? Who is responsible when keys go missing and "prove" false information?

Just saying "we need to sign photos" isn't enough and simply naïve.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by woah on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:58PM (#26743056)
It's always so odd when people assume that there were no functioning legal systems during the tens of thousands of years of human history before photography was invented
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by buran77 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:47PM (#26743565)
The question is how effective that justice system was, not whether it existed or not. It's the same with medicine, it existed for quite some time but the effectiveness increased drastically and you wouldn't want to roll back all that progress.

The reality is that for most of those tens of thousands of years justice systems were mostly a sham where the focal point wasn't actually determining innocence but rather the appearance of justice and pleasing (some) people.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by xmprt on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:03PM (#26743102)
People lived before the Internet existed but it would be a huge setback if we lost it. Similarly, advancements in technology have allowed for our justice systems to be a lot better and it would be a real shame if we lost that because of deepfakes. I'm not saying it will go that far, but it's totally normal to be wary of it.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by tshaddox on Thursday April 08, 2021 @05:15PM (#26743850)
Or now, for the vast majority of cases where direct photographic evidence would be useful but does not exist.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:11PM (#26743177)
>It brings up an interesting future where you can’t trust any witness testimony (because people do misremember) or any video, image, or audio evidence due to this technology.

That future sounds a lot like the past where we couldn't trust testimony and audiovisual evidence was practically nonexistent.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by throwaway17_17 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:53PM (#26742991)
The other aspect of discounting image evidence in this way would be to produce multiple conflicting versions and then argue a jury can never be sure which is real (where deepfake quality is comparable to the law enforcement original). This would have a hurdle for admission in a criminal case, but I would be able to very easily argue an acquittal if it was presented to the jury.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by interestica on Thursday April 08, 2021 @07:57PM (#26745242)
I think you just created a new field/job.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by jmcqk6 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:22PM (#26742650)
I don't think this is new at all. The specifics might be new, but the problem is quite old, and has been with us for thousands of years.

I think the danger is in trying to come up with an abstract, general solution for it. I don't think one exists.

I think the only thing we can do is deal with things on a case by case basis in these situations.

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by pvarangot on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:23PM (#26742660)
I thought that juries are instructed to decided when it's "beyond any reasonable doubt"? So if the defense wants to discredit video evidence they have to make a case that that's a reasonable doubt, probably have experts review the video and provide at least a sketch up of the motive behind spending resources on forging evidence like that. Also I understand that in most cases that go to trial there's more than just video evidence.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Ma8ee on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:10PM (#26743163)
It would surprise me if there aren’t cases where the only evidence is security camera footage.
Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by fxtentacle on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:50PM (#26743598)
There already are services who claim to be able to verify the authenticity of images. And so far, I managed to fool all of them with good CGI videos injected through MIPI into an Android system.

I remember that TruePic was especially awful, because their app fell for me just taking a photo of a printed out image. Plus their website overflows with Blockchain and Crypto buzzwords

Re:A “deepfake” is at the center of a harassment case, but w... by Yajirobe on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:52PM (#26743627)
> There already are services who claim to be able to verify the authenticity of images. And so far, I managed to fool all of them with good CGI videos injected through MIPI into an Android system.

Not to mention adversarial attacks will probably always exist, so there will always be a way to fool these systems.