News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by ben0x539 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:53PM (#26450367)
Is price a good metric for whether bitcoin is dead or not? It seems trivial to imagine a thing that is very expensive but still has ~no value as a currency.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by PKop on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:21PM (#26450630)
It's not a currency, it is an asset, like gold.

How many transactions per second does gold do? How many stores accept gold for purchases?

Yet it certainly has value and isn't going away as a reserve asset is it?

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Waterluvian on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:30PM (#26450718)
"It's not a currency, it's an asset" is accurate. And it seems to be making people rich.

But it was meant to be a currency and failed at that.

Now it's just an asset with no practical use (unlike gold) and a pretty hefty cost for it to persist.

Like Gamestop, I think Bitcoin will eventually be worth nothing. Until then, a lot wealth will change hands, but none is being generated.

A meta comment: I don't recall seeing more emotionally zealous defenders of a topic on HN than Bitcoin boosters.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by tekdemon on Sunday March 14, 2021 @12:55AM (#26453130)
I think you need to remember that at the end of the day Bitcoin is software running on the hardware of the internet, so assuming that it stays static in it's capabilities doesn't really make good sense. I mean when we used 14.4kbps modems for dialup to access AOL or Prodigy the sort of bandwidth we had then wasn't very good, but assuming that this would always be the state of the internet would have been made you very wrong. It's the sort of prediction Paul Krugman made when he proclaimed that the internet would be no more important than fax machines.

Bitcoin will have changes made to it's core software that will allow significant scaling improvements-some of that foundation is being laid this year via taproot and we're really talking about a foundational piece that will take years for the benefits to be fully realized with additional future improvements. But there's little reason to believe that the current state of Bitcoin where it's an asset that can't function as a currency will be a permanent one.

At the moment people already have easy to use currencies they can use on their smartphones, so Bitcoin being an easy to use digital currency adds nothing to their lives. What Bitcoin does provide is simply the fact that it's not a fiat currency. This may not seem valuable to people who've grown up in a nation with relatively stable currency value and a sophisticated economic system. But just look at the value of currencies in numerous nations around the world over the last 2 years. Whether you look at Russia, Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, Venezuela, Lebanon (street value), Nigeria, Zimbabwe, etc. what you see are nations where the currency has dropped in value by double digits per year. So if you live in the US or Canada or a EU nation you may not feel the sort of urgency to find a solution to this problem, but people elsewhere aren't as lucky. You also have to remember that people in these countries can't just buy reputable US securities via a smartphone app like people in most advanced nations can. Their choices for storing their wealth come down to literally their native currency that's tanking in value, blackmarket US dollars, precious metals, and Bitcoin.

I honestly think if you think outside of your own life experiences and look at the experience elsewhere in the world then the actual true value of Bitcoin becomes much more apparent. Then the energy use stops looking so plainly wasteful and in fact you might start wondering whether the fact that video game consoles like the Xbox actually use significantly more power than Bitcoin (and significantly less renewables) makes Bill Gates a bit of a hypocrite when he attacks Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by xiphias2 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @06:20PM (#26451118)
It takes time for assets to start functioning as currencies. Bitcoin needs about 10 more years to get adopted by enough people to function as a currency.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Waterluvian on Saturday March 13, 2021 @06:30PM (#26451203)
Interesting concept I haven't heard of before.

Where might I find anything talking about this more? Why 10 years? Is it time or just adoption? How many people?

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by xiphias2 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @07:58PM (#26451730)
Read the Bitcoin Standard book, or Nick Szabo's Shelling Out blog entry to see how new money is usually adopted. Bitcoin has about 200%/year growth rate, right now at about 100M users (1% adoption, maybe somewhat less). In 10 years it has a good chance to be adopted by billions of people (there's no guarantee though of course).
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Hamuko on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:29PM (#26450706)
>It's not a currency, it is an asset, like gold.

Is this why the infamous whitepaper is called "Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System" and has zero mentions of the word "asset"?

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by pharmakom on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:25PM (#26450675)
Bitcoin was supposed to be a currency. That was the original vision. So far it hasn’t done very well. Maybe lightning network will fix it? It’s not dead yet, but it also never really got started.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by latchkey on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:35PM (#26450763)
The word 'currency' only appears once in the white paper.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Hamuko on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:37PM (#26450777)
Which is more than the word "asset".
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by PKop on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:28PM (#26450696)
This is your bias projecting onto it what you thought it should be. It is not Bitcoin's fault you were mistaken and it certainly does not equate to failure.

It is easy to see in hindsight that a blockchain is and was always going to be inefficient as a transaction mechanism, moreover a finite "money" also can never compete with "easy" fiat money in expandable supply for commerce.

Whatever people (mistakenly) thought it was going to be, it is so far succeeding wildly at (long term, with great volatility) store of value asset.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Judgmentality on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:32PM (#26450733)
I think you're projecting your own bias. It seems pretty obvious to me bitcoin was meant to be a currency based on the original whitepaper.

https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by ncallaway on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:40PM (#26450793)
> This is your bias projecting onto it what you thought it should be.

"Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System"

"A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution"

Sounds a lot like the original project was intended to be an electronic version of cash, which would make it an electronic currency.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by latchkey on Saturday March 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#26451304)
... make it an electronic commodity.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by pharmakom on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:44AM (#26453697)
Umm no. I read the white paper and followed bitcointalk etc religiously in the early days. Satoshi even committed code towards building a marketplace

It is very successful as a speculative financial instrument, I’ll give you that!

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Hamuko on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:32PM (#26450726)
>It is not Bitcoin's fault you were mistaken and it certainly does not equate to failure.

I guess Satoshi was mistaken as well.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by capsulecorp on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:47PM (#26450862)
Really? Because Satoshi's whitepaper is literally titled “Bitcoin: a Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System", not "Bitcoin a 'store of value'". It seems to me the real answer is Bitcoin was sequestered by Blockstream and purposely sabotaged in order to promote their offchain solutions. BCH had to hard fork away to maintain the original intention of the project. Thus BCH can be transferred quickly and for mere fractions of the fees in BTC. So bitcoin is a currency, but that currency is now BCH. Whereas BTC exists to serve Blockstream and its for-profit offchain solution, which conveniently solve the limits they fought to impose.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by splintercell on Saturday March 13, 2021 @09:48PM (#26452354)
Technically speaking a layer 2 based payment system would also do the job.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by capsulecorp on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:19AM (#26453614)
Technically speaking, that still wouldn't be Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by splintercell on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:54AM (#26467488)
Bitcoin's main purpose was to create an unattackable (by govt or private entities) decentralized consensus. It was best perceived to have been created by the a currency on it. This currency can still be used on layer 2 for smaller transactions.

If you and your buddy opened a tab between each other to have bitcoin settlement at the end of the day, that wouldn't be saying "But you aren't using bitcoin".

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by capsulecorp on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @04:45AM (#26474304)
I believe you are mistaken, the purpose of Bitcoin was very clear from the whitepaper title. It was to create "a Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System". Bitcoin Cash is the real, continued implementation of bitcoin, as it was designed in its whitepaper. BTC is simply an attempt (rather good one at that) by bad actors, to purposely hamper the protocol and then sell offchain solutions to solve those issues they introduced.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by splintercell on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @01:39PM (#26480152)
Imagine if for some reason the word "bitcoin" turns out to be problematic (maybe it means "Shit/fart/poop" in Spanish and Chinese, which means most people in these countries wouldn't wanna use it, so the bitcoin people decide to rename the project to "Cryptocoin", are you going to say that clearly this violates the fundamental principles of bitcoin because Satoshi called it "bitcoin"?

Because based on what I read on Satoshi's communication, he would take 2 mins to change the name to something else (look how easily he applied the block size limit when the need arrived).

Similarly, there are essential attributes to what bitcoin is, and there are accidental attributes to it. Clearly the name of bitcoin is not necessary for it to be bitcoin.

What about the 'cash system' part? Clearly you and I disagree on this. I believe that cash part doesn't mean that the basic token must be trasnferable on layer 1.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by danShumway on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:25AM (#26490871)
Changing the name or updating implementation details is not the same thing as completely abandoning the technology.

You're talking about building a completely separate payment system that has nothing to do with Bitcoin, that suffers from all of the original privacy and centralization problems as regular cash, but just because the funds get converted to Bitcoin after some purchases we're still going to pretend it's using the same technology and that it still aligns with Satoshi's original goals?

If we're doing that, then I'm declaring that my credit card is a Bitcoin system, because I can buy Bitcoin from Coinbase using a credit card. I'm declaring that Visa is already just a layer 1 payment system on top of a Bitcoin backend.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by capsulecorp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:49AM (#26492003)
As another commenter mentioned to you: "Changing the name or updating implementation details is not the same thing as completely abandoning the technology.". I agree with them, your comparison doesn't make much sense in this context.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by stale2002 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:23PM (#26450644)
That is a great example, actually.

Because gold as a store of value, in and of itself, is a net negative on the world.

The world doesn't benefit with a bunch of gold locked up in a vault.

Goods and services are useful because people use them or transact them. Not because they are sitting there doing nothing.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Judgmentality on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:26PM (#26450681)
Gold actually has intrinsic value though.

https://geology.com/minerals/gold/uses-of-gold.shtml

> Of all the minerals mined from the Earth, none is more useful than gold. Its usefulness is derived from a diversity of special properties. Gold conducts electricity, does not tarnish, is very easy to work, can be drawn into wire, can be hammered into thin sheets, alloys with many other metals, can be melted and cast into highly detailed shapes, has a wonderful color and a brilliant luster.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by stale2002 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @08:35PM (#26451956)
Gold has value if it is being used.

It has no value, sitting in a vault.

Go ahead and talk about all the use cases of gold, and how it can be used in electronics or whatever.

But, regardless of that, all the vaults filled with gold, are a net negative on the world.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by PKop on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:33PM (#26450740)
Your point would make sense if the world was going to try to shoe-horn finite assets into the role of currency transactions, but again, this is a mistaken assumption. There is historical support for the idea of "two monies", soft/weak money, credit, fiat etc that is very good for commerce and day to day transactions, and as unit of account.

And hard money for long term savings, and best for settling trade between foreign regimes. There's a reason central banks all hold gold as a primary reserve asset.

Give this a read [0] it discusses in detail the idea that there isn't one type (hard or soft) money that best serves both competing use cases of currency and store of value, but that two different monies work best.

[0] http://fofoa.blogspot.com/2011/05/return-to-honest-money.htm...

(Ctrl + F "two monies" for specific section; whole article is good read though)

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by stale2002 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @08:41PM (#26452001)
> and best for settling trade between foreign regimes. There's a reason central banks all hold gold as a primary reserve asset.

> both competing use cases of currency and store of value

An action can be both rational for an individual to take, and still be a net negative to the world.

I am argueing that the gold in a vault use case, which sometimes people call "store of value" is a net negative upon the world, while still possibly being individually rational.

That is my point. I agree that gold serves the use case of a store of value, and could be rational for an individual to take.

And I am saying that this is still a net negative, that causes more harm than good, because you have a bunch of resources doing nothing.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by louloulou on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:32PM (#26450734)
The reason money exists is to transfer value that has ALREADY been created in the economy.

Gold is good for transferring value across time.

Fiat is good for transferring value across space.

Bitcoin is good for transferring value across space & time.

Therefore Bitcoin is better money.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by bhupy on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:08PM (#26450509)
> It seems trivial to imagine a thing that is very expensive but still has ~no value as a currency.

What are some examples?

Keep in mind that Bitcoin doesn't have to ever be a "currency" for it to remain relevant, as a "thing".

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by adflux on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:15PM (#26450568)
Considering that it was touted as the future digital CURRENCY until up to about 2 years ago, it has failed horribly in that regard. Its no longer being used on darknet either, that place has been taken by monero.

Bitcoin failed as a currency. Bad UX, high fees, high volatility. All things you dont want for a currency.

Now for a store of value, thats something else. If everyone "believes" it to be worth something, thats what it'll be.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by bhupy on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:17PM (#26450589)
We agree. Bitcoin doesn't ever have to be a currency, but that doesn't mean that it will ever be "dead".
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by londons_explore on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:24PM (#26450657)
It isn't impossible for it to form a currency sometime in the future...

Something like lightning popping up that actually worked could turn it into a currency overnight.

Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by andrepd on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:24PM (#26450662)
Lightning network will improve transactions substantially.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by ben0x539 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:58AM (#26454311)
idk, expensive cars?
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by tokai on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:57PM (#26450406)
Yeah seems ridiculous. When skimming through the earliest articles they mostly seems to be about Bitcoin as a currency. Btc turning in to a speculative asset underscore their point if anything.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by PKop on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:25PM (#26450673)
Hal Finney has early quotes speculating that BTC would best serve as a reserve asset like gold, predicting that transactions would be inefficient at scale.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by Mc_Big_G on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:10PM (#26450528)
If you're willing to accept that Bitcoin is not viable as a currency, you can then embrace that it's a better store of value than fiat currencies because the monetary policy is static and it is scarce. Bitcoin is digital gold, not a currency.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by danielmarkbruce on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:25PM (#26450665)
There is some implication that the only alternatives are fiat currencies. Anyone in finance will tell you: "do not to hold a lot of cash as an asset or store of value". Buying real assets is the general advice.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead – Tracking all notable Bitcoin skeptics s... by wizzwizz4 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:27PM (#26450690)
Bitcoin is a deflationary currency with high barriers-to-transact (rendering it nearly useless as a currency), backed by consensus trust in two assumptions:

• Enough people are burning enough electricity using enough computer processors that no one entity has control over enough computer power to become the majority burner of processing power.

• That's the only way to violate the axioms of blockchain transactions.

Assuming these two points, Bitcoin is a reasonably good “financial asset”, albeit one that's rendered GPUs almost impossible to buy and is rapidly becoming a major contributor to the anthropocentric climate change that's rendering our planet a harder place to not-die.