News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by gizmo686 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @01:48AM (#26312561)
Adverse selection. If your differenciating feature is "you can say what you want without getting banned", your userbase is going to tend towards people who get banned on other platforms. In todays climate, that is mostly the far right.

Compounding this is PR and network effects. Once they become known as the place for the far right, then more far righters go there, and more distant people avoid it.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by 8fGTBjZxBcHq on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:12AM (#26313379)
> Tech's obsession with hating on Gab/Parler is based upon on the identity of the people in them

Correct. We hate nazis.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by krageon on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:44AM (#26314251)
You're putting words in their mouth and then arguing with those words. Seeing as you're responding to a single sentence, this is an impressive amount of extrapolation.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by croon on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:27AM (#26314135)
As another European, I completely disagree.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by smcl on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:49AM (#26314283)
You're suggesting that right-wing white males are an oppressed minority in the USA. It takes a serious amount of ignorance and mental gymnastics to sincerely believe this. I suspect you are trolling, but if you're not then I don't know what would convince you otherwise because the amount of information you'd have to discard or ignore to reach this conclusion is alarming.
[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by krageon on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:59AM (#26314823)
If you're just going to lie, you could at least pick something everyone isn't versed in. As opposed to implying the US has no oppressed minorities, which is by now so well and extensively documented to be the case nobody sane will take you seriously after reading you say it isn't.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by smcl on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:26AM (#26315031)
You got downvoted to oblivion then [Dead]-ed. Maybe some mini-brigading going here? Anyway FWIW I vouched for your comment.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by krageon on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:17AM (#26315528)
It happens on very few of my comments, usually when I'm a bit too forceful while pointing out something that can be construed as politically left-leaning. Thank you :)
[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by 4ggr0 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:39AM (#26313861)
> White vs Black..oh sorry i mean People of no Color vs People of Color

Congratulations, you played yourself.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:50AM (#26315874)
>Congratulations, you played yourself

Congratulation you did not understood the irony.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by 4ggr0 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:34PM (#26317856)
Judging by your plethora of flagged and greyed out comments, I think I'm not the only one with that problem.
[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by 4ggr0 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:21PM (#26322588)
Not from the US, but thanks for wishing me luck anyways.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by vkou on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:23AM (#26313770)
White vs Black was something that was ripping the United States apart since the arrival of the first slave on the continent, so I'd have a hard time crediting the KGB for it.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:31AM (#26314606)
Heating up the debate with no chance for consensus is/was one of the strategy's of the KGB to rip a democratic society apart.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by vkou on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:58PM (#26318167)
What could you possibly mean by 'no chance for consensus'?

Let me get this straight. One group of people has all the political power in an area. That group of people repressed another group. The second group wants to be treated like human beings.

To me, it seems that if you want to avoid conflict and strife, the first group should immediately give in to those demands. Those demands are just, and the status quo is indefensible, and the first group has the political power to solve the problem, and anyone obstructing the immediate implementation of those demands is the one causing strife.

Since they have a monopoly on power, the onus is on them to make the society they built just, not on the people they are repressing.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:12PM (#26319956)
>Since they have a monopoly on power

Who? The democrats or the republicans?

>The second group wants to be treated like human beings.

Who is that? The Citizens or the establishment? You have much deeper problems in your society, and it's not skin-color, that's just the game to distort you (yes and the police) from the real problems...trans vs woman, democrats vs republican, man vs woman, white vs black, vegans vs meat-eater those are some of the other ones. You always hit your nearest made up "enemy" not the one thirteen steps away. Keep the dump's entertained with problems so they don't see the bigger picture, and at one point they start to entertain themself with made up problems.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by vkou on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:18PM (#26320046)
> Who? The democrats or the republicans?

Segregationists, and their various flavors of racist allies of the 50s, 60s, 70s, and 80s. I don't really care which party they belong to. They had a monopoly on power, they built an unjust system, and I will firmly put all arising strife on their unwillingness to treat people of other races as human beings.

> Who is that? The Citizens or the establishment?

African Americans during the broad civil rights era. You are talking about the KGB, right? The KGB operated between 1954 to 1991, so I have to assume that whatever black versus white 'conflict' you are talking about is somewhere in that time period.

> You have much deeper problems in your society, and it's not skin-color, that's just the game to distort you (yes and the police) from the real problems

I assure you, when your society has no-n_____ water fountains, train cars, classrooms, and suburbs, your society's problems include skin color. They include it incredibly prominently.

Are you arguing about real issues that real people faced? Or are we going down some weird, theoretical rabbit hole? I have no patience for the latter.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:14PM (#26320856)
>They had a monopoly on power, they built an unjust system, and I will firmly put all arising strife on their unwillingness to treat people of other races as human beings.

Had? Have, is the right word or did that changed i the last 2 month? But yeah absolutely, human are humans and everyone has the same right and has to be treated the same way.

>African Americans during the broad civil rights era. You are talking about the KGB, right?

I was talking about that one of the KGB strategies was to heat already existing conflicts up to the point where no consensus is possible, that just works in democratic systems where consent is the ~only way to achieve something.

>I assure you, when your society has no-n_____ water fountains

Look that's the problem, i NEVER said that skin color or religion (especially muslims...remember the hate after 2001, but also jews) is not a problem in your country, again for me there is no race just humans. But ATM it's white vs black etc, that's the opposite what Martin Luther King said like "Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that", atm your countrymen create borders between community's which creates a downward spiral, and the profiteer is for sure not "we the people" but we the media and the party (the two same ones) which can profit out of it and in the meantime easily maintain the status quo (both the democrats and the republicans...they have the exact same goal, they just play different so you have the illusion of choice).

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:12AM (#26314459)
White vs Black was something that was ripping the United States apart since the arrival of the first slave on the continent

That isn't true, since the first black slaves were brought over by the ethnic group we now call Latinx.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:41PM (#26317941)
> the first black slaves were brought over by the ethnic group we now call Latinx.

No, they weren't. Latinx (or the equivalent combination of Latino/Latina) is not synonymous with Hispanic, and more to the point, even if it was, the slavers were (by modern American terms) racially White ethnic Hispanics, so it wouldn't change the White/Black racial dynamic.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @01:14PM (#26318389)
racially White ethnic Hispanics

That’s some pretty impressive mental gymnastics. It’s likely that the crews of those first Portuguese and Spanish slave ships included plenty of mixed Hispanic/North Africans too.

By the way North Africans raided as far as the south coast of England in order to capture slaves of their own.

it wouldn't change the White/Black racial dynamic

The word you are looking for is “narrative”.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by KDJohnBrown on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:01AM (#26315361)
This is simultaneously a fair point (the Portugeuse were the first slavers) and a miscategorization (puritans/white european invaders were quite racist and violent from the moment they landed on Plymouth rock and began stealing from / killing Natives).
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:03AM (#26315391)
puritans/white european invaders were quite racist and violent from the moment they landed on Plymouth rock and began stealing from / killing Natives

I guess I can't keep up with the shifting terminology, are natives considered blacks now then? Isn't that supposed to be BIPOCS?

Actually if we are talking about slaves, then native Americans had been enslaving each other for centuries before Whites or Latinx arrived.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:50PM (#26320488)
This pro-slavery attitude was huge from you people.

Black people enslaved other blacks in Africa, Latinx shipped them to America where the natives were also enslaving each other. White people put an end to all 3 of these activities, everywhere. This is historical fact.

PS I am Welsh.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by KDJohnBrown on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:49AM (#26344738)
Welsh, british, scottish, all the same. All three groups were slavers, both of Africans and of the Irish, not to mention countless other Asian cultures.

You rewrite history, white wsshing it to make yourselves out to be the great white saviors despite having participated for many centuries.

“Hey the Africans sold their enemies to us so it must be Ok.”

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:48AM (#26315841)
>native Americans had been enslaving each other for centuries before Whites or Latinx arrived.

So had the peoples in africa:

>>Very few Americans know that slavery was common throughout the world as well as in Africa, says Sandra E. Greene, History.

https://research.cornell.edu/news-features/curious-history-s...

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:21PM (#26320089)
>What’s your address bro, I need a slave.

No one said something about justification, but since you need a slave you obliviously did not evolve...let me guess your from the US right?

BTW: I'm not your "bro" little wanna be slaveholder.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by KDJohnBrown on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:52AM (#26344774)
You are clewrly juwtifying slavery. Wvery single white supremacist uses this rhetoric:

Native Americans enslaved each other so they needed white Europeans to civilize them.

Africans enslaved each other and sold them to us so it was OK to make avaracian fortunes doing the same.

You enslaved Africans so it is only fair play for them to invade your nation, rape your women and enslave your populace.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:27AM (#26316247)
So had the peoples in africa:

Oh dear, we have strayed from the narrative and now the Californians are here

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:28PM (#26317793)
Yes they vote everything down if it's not Pink Pony compatible...and yet my OS is from Berkeley ;)
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by abernard1 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:15AM (#26313394)
> Correct. We hate nazis.

If you believe there are 10s of millions of Nazis in America, you have issues.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:38AM (#26313856)
That was not claimed anywhere. Your logical fallacy is: straw man.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by abernard1 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:29AM (#26315641)
There are 10s of millions of people on Gab and Parler. Are they all the baddies?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Rapzid on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:36AM (#26315117)
There are 10s of millions of Ordinary Men.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by orf on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:12AM (#26313706)
Serious question: how many people would you estimate identify as Nazis, or hold highly anti-semitic/racist + authoritarian views in America?

Hundreds of thousands? A million?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by thu2111 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:35AM (#26314634)
Probably only a few thousand white supremacists in the entire USA:

https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/16/you-are-still-crying-w...

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by 8fGTBjZxBcHq on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @01:55PM (#26318925)
Yes and one of them wrote that article.

I know people are going to mad about this because tech boys loooove him but google it he's a eugenics supporter and endorses far-right race philosophers.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by argvargc on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:39AM (#26313864)
On Gab daily. Never seen a single Nazi. Seen some unorthodox/thought-provoking views for sure, but that's part of why I visit and one of the same reasons I visit HN.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by likeafox on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @11:38AM (#26317134)
Andrew Anglin, operator of The Daily Stormer is famously one of the biggest 'influencers' to move to the original Gab platform, and he remains fairly active there. Gab's front page has been tuned over time to be less egregious, but I have been poking around the site for a long time and remember when even in logged out view the home page would be a lot of altright / TDS type of posts filled with general /pol/ tier takes.

And though the main feed / explore page is not quite as openly tilted toward that audience today, the 'groups' features not one but three QAnon groups, which appear to be some of the largest on the site.

In short - if you've been looking at Gab's content since their inception, it be hard not to see activity from some prominent altright/stormer users, and there remains a large quantity of both weird political extremism and general cultism promoted at the top level of the site.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dublin on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:07PM (#26322441)
So what? If you happen to see an obnoxious Nazi posting, simply mute them and move on with your life.

Personally, I usually don't even do that, because it's useful to occasionally comment on their posts (which are a tiny, tiny fraction of Gab's content) to point out to them that Nazi totalitarian tyranny is in no way preferable to socialist/Communist totalitarian tyranny.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by jki275 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:01AM (#26314841)
This.

I wonder if anyone here has ever even seen either site, because the vast majority of the comments here are simply regurgitating national media talking points about the sites - and those talking points bear zero relationship to reality.

America used to be about the free exchange of ideas.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dublin on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:00PM (#26322364)
There are a handful of Nazis on Gab, as I'm sure there are a handful of Nazis on HN. One of the nicest things about Gab is its Mute feature, which allows you to easily to never see the really obnoxious idiots again.

As for myself, I hate all totalitarians - Nazis are no worse than Communists, but they are no better, either. (Arguably, as horrible and inexcusable as the Nazis were, by the numbers they are in the flyweight class for genocide in the 20th century compared to their Communist counterparts...)

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by wokwokwok on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:16AM (#26313398)
What point are you making?

Those are the “far right” (or “far left” depending on your views) in those contexts.

The point remains: extreme views will gravitate to these platforms.

That is “far right”.

If you don’t prefer that title call it “extremist views”; it’s irrelevant what you label it; the point remains entirely valid.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by oooooooooooow on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:11AM (#26313702)
This reasoning directly leads to "twitter is the authority on what constitutes an extreme view"
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by djfobbz on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:16AM (#26314946)
Ok, give this some thought for minute: you’re a normal person going about your business everyday and sure, you have your personal views. Let’s say you strongly believe in having your own network infrastructure vs going to the cloud. It’s better for your business than cloud XYZ, which will eat into your profits too quickly. Now, imagine having a rational discussion about this topic on HN and it makes you feel good that you’re able to project your thoughts in a positive manner. However, the next day you find out that you’re banned. All of the sudden, your views are being titled “extremist” as if you’re against the society if you’re not hosting your app in the cloud.

Would you say that this kind of a pushback on your views, which to me don’t seem extreme, have any significance in actually making you an extremist?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by abernard1 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:17AM (#26313412)
The point is there's nothing inherently "far right" about the technology or the platform.

Protection of offensive speech is a bedrock classical liberal view.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by wokwokwok on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:09AM (#26313690)
> The point is there’s nothing inherently “far right”...

The point being made is that the application of censorship on some platforms results in a uneven distribution of users with such views in platforms that don’t due to self selection.

If the entire population has an X% rate of folk with extreme views, and 0% are allowed on platforms A, B, C... but platform D allows it.

The regardless of the overall distribution of users you cannot deny that the rate of folk with extreme views on D will be more than the 0% on A, B, and C.

Like, it’s not a matter of opinion; that’s just a fact.

So it’s fair to say Gab has higher proportion of users with extreme views simply by allowing them; that is, it is inherently controversial to even allow controversial discourse on your platform.

I don’t care if you don’t like that; that’s irrelevant. It’s simply not correct to assert that the platform is not to blame; when different platforms enforce different rules you get different content on different platforms.

It’s the same for porn, under age users, pictures of dogs ffs.

If you allow it, you’ll get it... and if you do when no one else does, you’ll get attention for being the “only Platform with [whatever]”.

The argument to here is about if the content is good or not; whether Gab is “far right” or “far left” is just arbitrary bs labels that distracts from the actual discussion of the content itself.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by pron on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:41AM (#26313530)
> Protection of offensive speech is a bedrock classical liberal view.

So is the protection of personal freedom, and yet no one claims we shouldn't put people in jail. Protection of speech is not an absolute principle of liberalism; just one principle that is weighed against others. Plus, in this case, most of the speech banned by Twitter is protected and can't land you in jail. It is also not at all a principle of liberalism that any publisher must publish any speech. Quite the opposite, the reputation of institutions like newspapers and universities are entirely predicated on their freedom to filter out and not disseminate certain things. The liberal view is that institutions should be able to build their reputation by choosing which speech they want to disseminate and amplify.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by orf on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:26AM (#26313452)
> Tech's obsession with hating on Gab/Parler is based upon on the identity of the people in them, not on whether offensive or not-sanctioned speech should be allowed in general.

Because it’s often one and the same: the “identity” of the people on them are the ones spreading hate speech and disinformation. You don’t need to sugar coat it as “not-sanctioned speech”, nobody is banning anyone for saying “hey I support Donald trump!’ They are banning people for saying “trans people will burn in hell” and “the Jewish cabal that run the world are eating babies and that’s why Biden stole the election and the democrats will be executed on TV by trump”.

Unfortunately this kind of speech comes from mostly one side of the political spectrum. Yes, I’m sure you can cherry pick random left-leaning Twitter users saying dumb things, but it’s not quite on the same level as you can find on ParlerWatch[1] for example.

Gabs founder: https://i.redd.it/u8mbqmrh41k61.png

1. https://old.reddit.com/r/ParlerWatch/top/?sort=top&t=month

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by SaintGhurka on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @11:55AM (#26317340)
>nobody is banning anyone for saying “hey I support Donald trump!’

They most certainly are. That exact phrase will literally get you banned on some forums. [0][1]

If you want to radicalize people, a good way to start is to marginalize them.

[0]https://www.ravelry.com/content/no-trump

[1]https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/new-ban-do-not-post-...

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by orf on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:11PM (#26317563)
Two irrelevant niche forums banning you does not make an argument.

Go to /r/conservative and say “I support Biden” and you will be banned within a minute. Does that mean liberals are being brutally silenced by oppressive moderators and therefore we have no choice but to helplessly become radicalised by racists?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:33AM (#26313484)
That is exactly the point. People that define their identity by feeling superior because of their race, religion or their sexuality are not the kind of people that are known for their differentiated, non problematic comments.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by soundnote on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:09AM (#26314438)
People have suggested re-education camps or other "deprogramming" for Trump voters, including elected Democratic representatives.

And yeah, it is often one and the same. Don't remember who it was, but someone said that the problem with free speech is that you'll spend most of your time defending scoundrels.

As far as hate speech goes, people literally lecture that people who happen to be born like me are "born into not being human", say the lives of people like me don't matter. We are told we should not speak and yet that our silence is violence. Trainings for "diversity" across a wide range of institutions have started segregating along racial lines, and the list goes on. During the Grievance Studies hoax, for example, one of their papers was sent back because it was too sympathetic and not sociopathic enough. Said paper advocated making white students sit on the floor and putting them in chains as a learning experience.

Yet open racism is fine, because the target ethnic group and sexual orientation are acceptable to the activist class.

Likewise, people who get kicked out for "transphobia" will often not be people who hate transpeople in any proper sense, but have policy disagreements where there are no win-win solutions. Yet anything but being completely on board with the activist class's 100% no limits pro-trans policy agenda is "phobia". The claim holds up as well as wet paper.

How about gender affirming treatment for kids who cannot physically know what sexuality properly is because they haven't been through puberty? Someone's a bit off their gender role? Tomboy, nah, they're a boy, time to stuff them full of hormones. Concerns that this just might be insane are again, labeled hate.

Said cultists insist on mantras of trans(wo-)men are (wo-)men in an explicit denial of biology that the best of our medicine can't alter: We just craft a facade that eases dysphoria to care for our fellow human beings. As Buck Angel put it: "I use testosterone to masculinize myself so I feel more like me." He's routinely called a transphobe.

This is basically the biology equivalent of flat eartherism or young earth creationism, but not subscribing to the creed is stamped hate speech. The mantra wouldn't even be necessary if its claim was actually true. It's even worse than flat eartherism, since a human can't at a glance confirm that the Earth is indeed round, but TWAW/TMAM asks us to baldly deny the input of our eyes in everyday life.

Hate and disinformation do not at all come "mostly from one side of the political spectrum" - science denial in the "party of science" is alive and well.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:14AM (#26314473)
but someone said that the problem with free speech is that you'll spend most of your time defending scoundrels.

That was Chomsky.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by SamoyedFurFluff on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:27AM (#26315041)
This post is a lot of FUD with no citations.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by djfobbz on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:19AM (#26315542)
1. Katie Couric on the need to "deprogram" Trump Voters https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2021/jan/19/katie-couri...

2. MSNBC Nicolle Wallace suggests Drone Strikes on US soil to combat Trump cult aka inciters https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aU5hw9H7htc

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by SamoyedFurFluff on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:26AM (#26316230)
So one is from a leftist journal condemning their own (thanks for the context! I’m glad the leftists are policing themselves from violence it seems!) and the other is a clip? What about the multiple paragraphs about trans people?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by abernard1 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:32AM (#26313475)
> nobody is banning anyone for saying “hey I support Donald trump!’

If that person says they don't believe the results of the election they are. If that person says that they don't believe the vaccines or lockdowns don't work, they are.

Twitter, Facebook, and tech in general have lost this card to play. They've been banning people for things that have nothing to do with racism and everything to do with them being not-Democrat.

In a world where 95+% of tech companies are Democrats in the U.S., it's easy to believe all the head-nodding and congratulations that your views are the only morally correct ones. It's also easy to deliberately avoid any sense of nuance or context because that would require overcoming cognitive dissonance that half the country isn't a bunch of racists.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by orf on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:37AM (#26313506)
> require overcoming cognitive dissonance that half the country isn't a bunch of racists

The Republican Party: not racist, just #1 with racists. I think that’s the problem.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by croon on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:32AM (#26314171)
> If that person says they don't believe the results of the election they are. If that person says that they don't believe the vaccines or lockdowns don't work, they are.

So spreading misinformation then?

You just proved GPs point.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:47AM (#26314268)
The political spectrum of tech is pretty centrist. Leaning fiscal-conservative, even.

It's the right wing of American politics that has swung so far to the right of where it used to be that it's made tech look Democratic in contrast. If tech employees are supporting Democrats, it's because the alternative has come to look insane.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by bitdizzy on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:58AM (#26316635)
> He's routinely called a transphobe.

Because he routinely harasses other trans people and has a coterie of cis people chomping at the bit to bully trans kids he retweets and mocks. He's not called that for the quote you chose. I think similarly the rest of your points are warped and exaggerated to fit your view that you are under siege by "open lunatics" because you're tired of certain people you find undesirable having a collective voice all of a sudden.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:20AM (#26313427)
I dont care about their idendity. I do care about their offensive/hate speech though.

Saying racist sh*, and wanting to restrict the rights of minoritys is waaaay different then protesting against an opressive regime.

It is a shame, that the far right were and are able to use the ccp-protestors for their meanly targets.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:31AM (#26313472)
>I do care about their offensive/hate speech though.

The far right is a minority, and you are actually the one who try to restrict them with the label "offensive/hate"..is that correct?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by jpgvm on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:34AM (#26313496)
There is a difference between choosing to be part of a minority/fringe hate group and being born a different race.

There is a good reason why "political" views aren't a protected class in most modern countries.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:52AM (#26313588)
>There is a difference between choosing to be part of a minority/fringe hate group and being born a different race.

But who is the instance who gives a group the label "hate" you? And why do you have to be a different race to be a fringe hate group?

>There is a good reason why "political" views aren't a protected class in most modern countries.

I fact they are, hence the term "political prisoner" which is equal to "no modern country" just have a look at spain atm.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:39AM (#26313518)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

You are right, exactly that is my point!

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by wwww4all on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:22AM (#26312721)
It’s mostly normal people freely associating with other normal people, without fascist establishment elite government control, like Twitter, Facebook, elite media, and most other social media.

Did you ever wonder why you are calling others far right or far left? Why are you referring to other American citizens with those terms? Who is pushing those terms that divide the vast majority of normal Americans? Who stands to gain?

The fascist establishment elite are getting richer by the second, while the lower classes are calling each other insulting names and fighting amongst themselves.

There’s an old movie called They Live. When you watch it now, you can call it time shifted documentary.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by fattire on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:29AM (#26312768)
For those unaware, the premise of They Live is that the elites and one-percenters are actually inter-dimensionally traveling space aliens.

It's a great movie, but a metaphor not a "time-shifted documentary", unless I missed the latest Qdrop.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by meepmorp on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:29AM (#26313132)
Take a deep breath.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by bawolff on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:30AM (#26312771)
Wait, you object to describing "american citizens" with political labels and then in the very next paragraph use a political label on a specific group of american citizens.

Interesting position.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by phroobster on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:17AM (#26312689)
Alternative viewpoint: platforms without censorship tend to be right wing because that is what succeeds in a free marketplace of ideas. Left wing ideas require censorship to thrive.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by zpeti on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:46AM (#26312875)
Mainstream ideas require censorship to survive. In the 60-70s it was the left that was obsessed with free speech because their views were less mainstream, something many people on the side of censorship seem to ignore.

As glen greenwald says, censorship eventually is always about those in power staying in power. Unless you are in power it’s sad to see so much pro censorship these days.

Read up on Ira Glasser at the ACLU or watch the documentary. Why did he as a Jew defend neo nazis?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:41AM (#26313874)
Counterpoint: Parler and Gab have plenty of censorship, so those don't fit your 'platforms without censorship' description.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:22AM (#26312719)
How many left wing dictators have there been?
[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by zokula on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:15AM (#26313396)
I bet you think North Korea is a Democratic Republic as well?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:11AM (#26313699)
You really should learn more about the NS, it was socialistic, but just for the nation, if your interested, that book is a great analysis of hitler:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Meaning_of_Hitler_(book)

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Mauricebranagh on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:49AM (#26314279)
Alex Kershaw's Bio of Hitler especially the first vol covers this.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by brigandish on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:15AM (#26313728)
Normally, people use "socialism" synonymously (intentionally or unknowningly) with _international_ socialism. There are plenty of other kinds, and _national_ socialism is one of them.

Obviously, if you're going to name your faction with a preceding adjective like national/international then:

a) it's important to you

b) you're probably not going to get along with the other faction that is named in direct opposition to yours

Which pretty much explains how these two groups of socialists hate each other and why the Nazi's 25 point plan [0] reads 50% nationalist and 50% socialist.

It's not a misnomer, unlike the DPRK.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Program#The...

Edit: formatting

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by feralimal on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:15AM (#26314064)
Democrats are democratic in the US, of course.

Oh, I see. Names don't matter if they are inconvenient....

Nazis (a literal shortening of Nationalsozialismus) - no they weren't the left.. 'cos Hitler, and Hitler bad.

Freedom is speech, but not 'hate speech'. (Who defines 'hate speech'?) What is hate speech except for a reason to stop people speaking. These are ideological positions couched as morality. And everyone needs moral busybodies who know it all, to tell them what to do, right?

“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” - CS Lewis

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by tor11 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:45AM (#26314262)
> Democrats are democratic in the US, of course.

of course.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:49AM (#26312896)
That's a very obtuse and dishonest take of the the Nazi party and socialism.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/02/05/right-need...

Besides, party names have never been a good indicator of political standing. Only policy is. You can look at the Liberals in Australia as an example of a conservative party.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by feralimal on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:52AM (#26312924)
No it's not. They built roads, made the people's wagon (volkswagen), etc.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by sofixa on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:09AM (#26313366)
That's got to be the lowest bar for "socialism" i've ever seen. So, is Eisenhower socialist as well? The US Interstate highway is much bigger than the Autobahn, so it surely counts?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:58AM (#26312952)
Who are the great right wing leaders then who did not build roads or create any infrastructure during their tenure?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by feralimal on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:50AM (#26312908)
Stalin and Mao were communists.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by goatinaboat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:30AM (#26313814)
Stalin and Mao were communists.

Marx used the terms socialist and communist interchangeably in his writings. So that is a distinction without a difference.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:59AM (#26312960)
This only works if you put cold war blinders on and equate the word communism to being left wing. Their policy and actions were decidedly not left wing.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by xupybd on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:34AM (#26313155)
The problem is left and right are not a single dimension. Liberal left wing policies can often overlap with libertarian right wing policies. This is because the align on the freedom dimension. There are other examples but I don't think you can argue that Mao and Stalin are not left wing. They both push the idea that the state can and should supply the needs of the people. This is a very left wing view on both the financial and social dimension.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:20PM (#26317705)
I agree that there's overlap in certain areas.

However it also depends are you simply looking at the economic beliefs of left/right wing idealogies or also social rights? It also depends on which era of left vs right is being considered, since the traits of the spectrum have changed over the decades.

Perhaps the issue is many consider only the economic models as the indicator, whereas many others consider the entirety of policy with regards to equality and rights.

If we're only looking at economic policy, then sure, Mao and Stalin are left wing.

If you look at it socially, then I'd argue they were not because they violently impugned on the freedoms of people to install totalitarianism.

Maybe one could argue they're far left, or alt left in todays vernacular however. But even that would be eschewing much of the social aspects of leftism. Mostly because their aspects of "equality" only applied to the people they deemed equal. Which was unequal to start with.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by xupybd on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @01:25PM (#26318543)
Well that is what I was trying to illustrate. There is an authoritarian right ( e.g. Hitler ) and an authoritarian left ( e.g Stalin ).

It sucks if you're on the left or right and are more on the pro freedom end when someone drags up the authoritarian cohort of your respective side.

I'm right of centre ( pro private industry ) but anti fascism. I'm pro private industry because I don't like a concentration of power. So a mix of small government with the power to provide basic services and break up monopolies seems the best way to keep everything free. So slightly left wing social policies such as free medical care aren't my first choice but much better than giving the government more surveillance powers. So I think I'm further away from fascism than I am from socialism. Yet as I'm right of centre people throw Hitler is on your side at me.

[dead]
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:22AM (#26313090)
It's a bit rich to claim you're neither right nor left, when you're constantly repeating right wing talking points. Maybe you don't prescribe to a label, but all your arguments thus far all hinge on labels and not policy.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by fenderbluesjr on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:16AM (#26313730)
He didn't state any of his own political views so you can't place him. You should consider whether those talking points actually have some legitimacy rather than using them to identify which group he's in. This is actually part of the problem he refers to.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:59AM (#26316652)
So you're l saying he raised specific points but that they aren't reflective of his political beliefs but are somehow reflective of mine because I don't agree with them?

That's certainly a level of mental gymnastics to paint things favorably for your political beliefs.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by feralimal on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:26AM (#26313114)
Ok - here's my criticism of the 'right'. They talk about less government, but never do anything about it! Never. They will say whatever it is that sounds good to conservatives, but do the opposite.

Left and right are all on board with the same system. And this is increasing a fascist system, run by corporations.

But whatever the case - if people purport to have a constitution that allows for free speech - but that a lot of people do not have meaningful ability to exercise it, well its not surprising that places like Gab spring up. And that all those de-platformed views make their way there. People need to be able to have their say.

It used to be that it was a left position to say 'I don't like what you say, but I'll fight for your right to say it'. Those days are long gone - de-platform the hate speaker!

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:51AM (#26316545)
You have a flawed understanding of free speech.

It only protects against retribution by the government. It doesn't extend to society accepting any and all speech was acceptable.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by nix23 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:06AM (#26313675)
Absolutely correct!
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Mauricebranagh on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:47AM (#26314272)
Not really if you read Kershaw's two vol bio early on the NAZI party did have some "socialist policies" but Hitler changed the policy and threw those out in the late 20's.

Its also one of the reasons that the SA was purged.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by scrose on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:03AM (#26313331)
The Nazis were socialist only in name. I highly suggest reading at least the first book in Richard J. Evans’s trilogy on ‘The third Reich’ if you want your eyes opened to unbiased historical facts. Referring to names to determine the leaning of a political party or even community groups is never a good idea. Look at their policies and what their people are saying.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:17AM (#26313411)
Absolutely, look into it. Mixed with their tyrannical racial nationalism, you will also find many socialist ideas; here are some examples from the 25 point plan, their early party platform:

> We demand that the State shall above all undertake to ensure that every citizen shall have the possibility of living decently and earning a livelihood.

> We demand... that all unearned income, and all income that does not arise from work, be abolished.

> We demand the nationalization of all trusts.

> We demand profit-sharing in large industries.

> We demand a generous increase in old-age pensions.

> We demand the creation and maintenance of a sound middle-class; the immediate communalization of large stores which will be rented cheaply to small tradespeople

> We demand...the abolition of ground rents, and the prohibition of all speculation in land.

> We demand that specially talented children of poor parents, whatever their station or occupation, be educated at the expense of the State.

> The State has the duty to help raise the standard of national health

https://www.historyplace.com/worldwar2/riseofhitler/25points...

Edit: I'm not surprised that these inconvenient facts are being downvoted. Why acknowledge facts when you can attempt to suppress them instead? Why read history in the very words of the people of the time, when you can rewrite it instead?

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by fenderbluesjr on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:32AM (#26314164)
It's hard to argue against this, that really is the 25 point program of the Nazis. However, I think it is generally understood that Hitler's entrance into the National Socialists marked a deviation from Socialist ideas. My understanding was that there were literally two factions, one which took the socialist aspects seriously and one which had no interest in socialist principles. The socialist faction had people like Gregor Strasser as figureheads and they got routed out as part of the night of the long knives.

Much of the Big Business that invested in the Nazi party were tentative at first because of socialist name and were convinced by Hitler et al that it was in name only..

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:54AM (#26314319)
> I think it is generally understood that Hitler's entrance into the National Socialists marked a deviation from Socialist ideas.

No, the 25 point plan was announced by Hitler in 1920, including all of those socialist ideas.

And the night of the long knives was in 1934. For over 14 years, socialists like Strasser were an important part of the Nazi party, working side by side with Hitler.

Then Hitler consolidated power and eliminated all rivals - not only socialists like Strasser, but people with many ideologies. His primary target was not the socialists, but his most dangerous rival, Ernst Roehm, the leader of the brownshirts.

Even after that purge, the socialist programs continued, such as Volksgemeinschaft (people's community), Deutsche Arbeitsfront (the German Labor Front), and Nationalsozialistische Volkswohlfahrt (National Socialist People's Welfare).

> The NSV [National Socialist People's Welfare] was the second largest Nazi group organization by 1935, second only to the German Labour Front. It had 4.7 million members and 520,000 volunteer workers.

> The Nazi social welfare provisions included old age insurance, rent supplements, unemployment and disability benefits, old-age homes and interest-free loans for married couples, along with healthcare insurance, which was not decreed mandatory until 1941

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_People%27s_...

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by fenderbluesjr on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:16AM (#26314490)
> No, the 25 point plan was announced by Hitler in 1920, including all of those socialist ideas.

I'm not contesting that.

Here's what the book I'm reading has to say about the 25 points:

> A good many paragraphs of the party program were obviously merely a demagogic appeal to the mood of the lower classes at a time when they were in bad straits and were sympathetic to radical and even socialist slogans. Point 11, for example, demanded abolition of incomes unearned by work; Point 12, the nationalization of trusts; Point 13, the sharing with the state of profits from large industry; Point 14, the abolishing of land rents and speculation in land. Point 18 demanded the death penalty for traitors, usurers and profiteers, and Point 16, calling for the maintenance of “a sound middle class,” insisted on the communalization of department stores and their lease at cheap rates to small traders. These demands had been put in at the insistence of Drexler and Feder, who apparently really believed in the “socialism” of National Socialism. They were the ideas which Hitler was to find embarrassing when the big industrialists and landlords began to pour money into the party coffers, and of course nothing was ever done about them.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:31AM (#26314608)
> They were the ideas which Hitler was to find embarrassing when the big industrialists and landlords began to pour money into the party coffers, and of course nothing was ever done about them.

I think that's fair, but I would characterize it this way:

The Nazis started out "socialist" in the traditional sense of collective ownership, and ended up "socialist" in the modern sense (popularized by Bernie Sanders) of a strong social safety net.

(That safety net being restricted, of course, to those the Nazis deemed worthy.)

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by UncleMeat on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:46AM (#26314717)
Yeah and the really really bad part that we all remember the nazis for took place after hitler rose to power and all the socialists in the party were murdered.

When people say “the nazis were socialist” they are trying to draw a line from the modern left to genocide. But this is just not a functioning argument.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @03:48AM (#26326097)
I'm not trying to draw a line from the modern left to genocide. But I don't agree with refusing to acknowledge historical facts for fear someone might draw that line.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:39AM (#26314209)
> Mixed with their tyrannical racial nationalism, you will also find many socialist ideas

Yeah, that's true of their early platforms, but even on paper (and much more in practice) socialist elements were progressively deemphasized as Hitler consolidated power within the party.

> Why read history in the very words of the people of the time,

You should definitely read their words, but you should read all of them as they change over time, and track the objective external facts of who held more power as they changed, and also check words against actions. Because just because something was at one point the words tied to a faction doesn't mean:

(1) that it represented that factions immutable view for all time across changes in internal power dynamics, or even

(2) that it was ever anything more than cynical, opportunistic manipulating propaganda.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:31AM (#26314601)
You are missing very important points here:

1. national-socialism seams to have equality as a target. But this equality accounts only for a small group of superior people. In case of Hitler that was the aryan, german race.

2. Those points and the reality are two completetly different things

In fact Nazi-Germany was not socialist but capitalist. Rich people and companies became richer. The only people that were expropriated were jews, political enemies and minoritys. The jews were working as slaves until death to provide wealth for a capitalist upper class. Siemens for example increased their turnover by a factor of 5. Single persons became incredible rich. At the same time, the normal citizens of germany had to live under the worst circumstances because of the war. (You would not believe what my grandma experienced...)

The core idea of national-socialism is inhumane. Who ever was not productive like disabled people, or people with mental illnesses(which includes homosexuals etc.) got killed. The Nazis propagated the rule of the strongest and racism. They propagated social darwinism.

That stands completly against everything the left parties in Germany , even socialism, stands for. The main target is equality and equal oppurtunities for everyone. The main target is a humane society. One of the main points of our left wing, is to fight any form of facism to prevent anything similiar to Hitler from happening ever again.

The right wing partys are the Heirs of the Nazis. They want to exclude minorities and restrict their rights. They propagate racism.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:00AM (#26314828)
I'm certainly not defending the Nazis here. I'm cherry picking because someone claimed there were no cherries (socialists) in that bowl of grapes (nationalists) and cherries. So I'm pointing out the socialists.

The role of the left in the rise of the worst governments of the twentieth century should be remembered, so that nothing like Hitler ever happens again.

Many horrible governments start with promises of equality and a humane society (not the Nazis, who promised revenge, but certainly the communists), because that much concentrated power is a catastrophe waiting to happen. A government big enough to give equality is also powerful enough to impose tyranny, as we saw far too many times in the 20th century.

Even the Nazis only rose to power because of the horrible mistreatment imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. Germans saw themselves as the oppressed people.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:48AM (#26315834)
I am not sure If you got my point. I never said that your are defending the Nazis. But you were and still are refering to Hitler as a part of the political left. Something he definetly wasn't.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:02AM (#26315994)
I'm not referring to Hitler personally as part of the left, I'm talking about the support he received from so many socialists on the left.

Hitler himself was, I think, a megalomaniac who wanted nothing but his own power, and a delusional madman intent on killing almost everyone. He doesn't belong on the left-right spectrum, because he was motivated by nothing other than his own madness.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by scrose on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:26AM (#26315612)
I can’t downvote. I’m also being downvoted and definitely don’t think people’s goals are to ‘rewrite history’ here. But also the list you mentioned is just that. A list. Behind every bullet point there’s a grimmer meaning, if a meaning at all outside of gaining more support from the socialist groups who had more political sway at the time. No sane person would place Nazi ‘state education’ in the same class as a modern day public school for example. I personally think it’s just a bit odd that you’re using a propagandist list by the Nazis on its own as proof that they were socialists. The Nazi playbook is so much deeper than that. The books I recommended earlier quite literally only scratch the surface around the tricks the Nazi's played to consolidate power by all means necessary.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:16AM (#26316122)
I would argue that there was a grimmer meaning behind similar promises from every socialist leader, except those where there was no meaning at all other than cynical pursuit of power (like Stalin).

Despite that, the Nazis did gain support from many socialists, and ultimately, like so many other governments that rose to power with socialist promises, failed to live up to those promises.

But I don't think Hitler himself was a socialist, and I agree that Hitler was using the socialists just as he used everyone else who supported him. I just think people should acknowledge the role that socialists played in helping him rise to power.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by scrose on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @12:46PM (#26318003)
> I just think people should acknowledge the role that socialists played in helping him rise to power.

I think practically everyone, including myself agrees with that. And I pointed that out in my original posts. Power doesn't occur in a vacuum and the Nazi's capitalized on peoples (mostly unfounded) fears and anger to grow their base. My original point was that the Nazi's themselves were not socialists. Referencing a name they came up with and their published propaganda was not a convincing argument to say otherwise.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:16PM (#26320016)
Hitler wasn't the only Nazi. Some socialists, like Gregor Strasser, weren't merely supporters, they were full members and even leaders of the Nazi party.

Their brand of Nazism survives to this day:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strasserism

So I don't think it's accurate to say "the Nazi's themselves were not socialists", as if none of them were.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by scrose on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @09:28AM (#26328693)
> Hitler wasn't the only Nazi.

I never said that.

> I don't think it's accurate to say "the Nazi's themselves were not socialists", as if none of them were.

I never claimed that none of them were.

Making it sound as if I and others are talking in absolutes and manufacturing talking points around that is a waste of everyones time.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:53AM (#26331049)
> Making it sound as if I and others are talking in absolutes and manufacturing talking points around that is a waste of everyones time.

I joined this discussion because you said "The Nazis were socialist only in name."

Only.

That sounds fairly absolute to me.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by scrose on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @01:12PM (#26332269)
Do you not see the irony in the fact that you had to grab a tiny snippet of a response several posts prior to 'prove' your counterpoint to a criticism made towards you in regards to practically every response you've had in this thread thus far?

I'm going to give this thread a break since it seems as though you're simply looking for arguments where none exist.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @01:41PM (#26332609)
That was your first statement in this discussion, and I consider it the central claim I'm arguing against.

But if you don't consider it an important claim, then let's move on. I'm satisfied that I've shown a fair amount of evidence that it's untrue.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by _-david-_ on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @11:25AM (#26316995)
Stalin and Pol Pot are good examples.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @11:58AM (#26317395)
Again, this only applies if we blindly use the cold war association that communism is a left wing ideal, without actually looking at the policy of the people.

The reality is that communism as a movement spans a wide political range, and both Stalin and Pol Pot had diverged significantly from any form of leftist Marxism in their hunt for power.

Even stalinist supporters decry Pol Pot https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~furrg/pol/khmerrouge.html

Looking at simple party names is a red herring at best. It's best to look at the policy choices of the dictators in question.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by throwaway3699 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:52AM (#26312922)
Hundreds. Stalin. Hitler. Mao. The list of genocides is longer than my arm.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:57AM (#26312944)
This is a very interesting world view you have where Hitler is left wing. I think that alone scuppers any substance to your argument.

Stalin and Mao would only be left wing if you prescribe to the thought that communism by nature must only be left wing. I assume your train of thought on Hitler is similar because you're likely equating the socialist word in the Nazi party to left wing socialism.

At best this is dishonest and ignoring actual policy.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by soundnote on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:38AM (#26314659)
Isn't the flipside of that coin that leftism is more or less just plain good and ceases to be leftism the moment it deviates from what we think of as good, ie. basically a No True Scotsman?

One reason the Marxist kind of thought pattern is dangerous is because of something like that. The ideas in and of themselves can sound good and appealing - who wants poor people to live in squalor and so on? But if we look at what natural and sexual selection ingrains in biological life - it is by necessity kin-preferring, competitive and in non-eusocial social creatures, status seeking, for example. Things that prefer non-kin and don't compete just die out.

In that light, a sound philosophy would understand that those things can't be eradicated by human will, take the impulses and hone something constructive out of them. But Marxist thought is rationalist in the sense that it thinks doctrine and reason can mold human nature to whatever shape, and then achieve their utopistic ends. That, of course, cannot happen because we're built from competitive, kin-preferring, status-seeking genes, not utopistic ones. Marxism is incompatible with biological life, and to get biological life to comply for any length of time, it must be forced constantly, or the utopian society degrade into tyranny, which has thus far happened every single time these things have been tried. But it's never done properly, so we should try again.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:54AM (#26316590)
I'm hardly invoking any sort of no true Scotsman fallacy.

I'm asking for people to delve into the so called left wing policy of the people they're claiming are left wing dictators.

So far people have only been listing people by their party names. Which would mean that North Korea is a bastion of democracy. I'm asking for substance to back up their assertions.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:54AM (#26313599)
As a german, I can definitly tell you that Hitler was not left wing. There is no overlap in the political views at all. (Something I can not say about germany's far right.)
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Hitton on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:03AM (#26314002)
In that case, as a German expert here, can you correct leereeves' comment, please? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26313411
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Draken93 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:33AM (#26314617)
There you go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26314601

I have to add that "no overlap at all", may not be correct, as those points were shared by different political spectrums in the history. The point is: The core idea, is completly different.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by golergka on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:22AM (#26313088)
Vast majority of them, especially if you compare by the body count.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:26AM (#26313111)
Can you list them and their body counts + Policies that caused those deaths?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by leereeves on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:51AM (#26313262)
Fortunately someone has already done so. It's far from a complete list, but it's enough to prove the point:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_killings_under_Communist_...

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:56AM (#26316614)
Where exactly is the list by numbers across the board? Unless you believe only community regimes kill.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by effry-much on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:30AM (#26312770)
Plenty? Have you ever heard about the XX century? Bolsheviks? Fidel Castro?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @11:02AM (#26316682)
I'm not saying there are none. I'm raising the point that there's been quite a lot more right wing dictatorships than left wing through history.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by bawolff on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:33AM (#26312793)
Wow. This comment section is a mess. Did y'all miss the other countries in the world that seem to be left wing without censorship. Or just history in general. Typically it tends to be a bit cyclic cycling between "left" ideas being popular at certain times and places, and right wing ideas being popular at certain times and places.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by lwansbrough on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @02:28AM (#26312758)
Conservativism largely fails over time in the free marketplace of ideas as evidence by human progress and societal change. Conservativism is fundamentally about suppressing change in favour of familiarity and established norms, which could certainly be seen as censorship. An obvious example of this is the conservative/Puritan influence in American culture, which has lead to excessive censorship of sexual content and cursing in American media.

Censorship is a product of political extremism though, it has no basis in one political ideology, only in how aggressively it is applied to society.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by exporectomy on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:04AM (#26312990)
Counterexample - Islamic culture is conservative and thriving in the world (20% of all humans are Muslim), with roughly the same beliefs and culture as it's had for the past 1000 years.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by sofixa on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:06AM (#26313351)
I'm not sure thriving is the correct term. When it comes to HDI, human rights record, freedom of press/expression/etc. i can't think of a single Muslim-majority country ( which isn't the same as Islamic, and i chose the former because they fare better by definition on various freedoms)

On the HDI, the first majority Muslim country is the UAE, at 31, and that's probably highly skewed by its limited population, extreme natural wealth, and slavery. And considering it's involved in a human rights catastrophe in Yemen, it fails any human rights record-based index directly.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Development_Index

On the contrary, I'd say that Islam is stuck in the past, which doesn't help Muslim nations thrive and develop, and those that do, do it based on "luck" ( natural resources).

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by andybak on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:34AM (#26313157)
> with roughly the same beliefs and culture as it's had for the past 1000 years.

I'm not sure this demonstrates a deep understanding of the shifting patterns within Islamic culture.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by PicassoCTs on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @07:30AM (#26314597)
Who cares? Gradual changes in a philosophy of a culture that has become the great game-board of all adjunct powers, over and over again, is not relevant. At some point all that remains, is the fact, that getting pushed around on the school-yard of the world, is a bad idea. Nobody cares for the history of getting pushed around. Just for the now full of mud, blood and laughter.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by brigandish on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:21AM (#26313757)
It'd be hard to make a monolith out of the beliefs, practices and behaviour of over a billion people even if you could boil some of it down into one book (and you can't even do that as even the Sunni majority uses at least 7).
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:26AM (#26313112)
> Conservativism largely fails over time in the free marketplace of ideas as evidence by human progress and societal change.

This is obviously just selection bias. Everything that changes is a loss for "conservatism"; ignore everything that stays the same, which is the majority of everything.

Here are some "conservative" (i.e. longstanding existing) policies: Due process, separation of powers, warrant requirements, freedom of speech. They are currently under attack. But the attackers are the ones on the wrong side of history -- even if they succeed, they lose, because then the monsters these policies were established to vanquish return and the polices get reinstated once the current generation has had a taste of what happens without them. But that route is a lot harder and bloodier than learning from history.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:28AM (#26313127)
All the "conservative" policies you listed are currently being championed for by the left however.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @03:32AM (#26313147)
Who is responsible for cancel culture? Tech censorship? "Believe All Women"? Who is calling for a new War on Terror targeting the domestic population?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by notahacker on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @05:06AM (#26313671)
> Who is responsible for cancel culture?

This depends on is being cancelled. It's not the left that cancelled Kapaernick or the artists formerly known as the Dixie Chicks or howled with rage that the Supreme Court - with the exception of three conservative justices - ruled their longstanding practice of cancelling gay people unconstitutional.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:28AM (#26330610)
"Whatabout Kaepernick" is not a denial that the left is doing this, or even that they're not the primary offenders.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by notahacker on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#26333829)
No, but the juxtaposition of "footballers' antiracist gestures must be silenced" with "We must intervene to prevent Big Tech from declining to broadcast racism" in the rhetoric of prominent mainstream US conservatives is a pretty good indication that the longstanding tradition they are actually defending isn't "free speech"...
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 04, 2021 @12:00AM (#26338824)
That only works if your frame for literally everything is racism.

Kaepernick kneeling during the pledge of allegiance can only parse as an antiracist gesture if the thing being disrespected (flag/country) is presumed to be intrinsically racist, i.e. it's accusing the whole country of racism. There are a lot of non-racist patriots who would take offense to that. The answer still shouldn't be censorship, but calling any opposition racism is accepting the very premise that the people opposed to the gesture are opposing it over.

Moreover, the implication that everyone who has been canceled was a racist is contrary to evidence unless you're making some heavy tribalist assumptions about anything vaguely conservative automatically implying racism.

And you're still not addressing the original point, which was that the left going around canceling people over speech is inconsistent with freedom of speech. Nothing anyone on the right does can make that untrue.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by dagmx on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @10:25AM (#26316220)
Cancel culture is just a right wing word to deflect from accountability
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:50PM (#26338750)
"Censorship is just another word for accountability," says person claiming not to be in favor of censorship.
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by tor11 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:35AM (#26314185)
> Who is responsible for cancel culture?

Libertarians making money.

Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by pineaux on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @04:26AM (#26313451)
Show me a case of "cancel culture" and I will show you a case where the "cancelled" person benefitted in popularity on the right wing side. The people that really do get cancelled, you don't hear from them. The examples you know of are all people who benefitted hugely from the "cancelling". Unless you count the #metoo people. But you probably believe all these men are innocent. I don't really get how due process and opposition to trial by media is usually not important with right wing people when someone is suspected of robbery, but when someone is suspected of sexual misconduct it is suddenly a problem. This feels like the protection of elites (because elites will never be part of a robbery, but can be hurt by a metoo-scandal). And I am seriously curious who is calling for a new war in terror. Tell me, who is doing this?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by Hitton on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @06:53AM (#26314305)
Ok, I'll bite. First three examples of cancel culture I can think of: dongle gate, rosetta mission guy, and more recent J. K. Rowling. How exactly they benefited?
Re:Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked by runsWphotons on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:19AM (#26314980)
CNN anchors and John Brennan.