I think practically everyone, including myself agrees with that. And I pointed that out in my original posts. Power doesn't occur in a vacuum and the Nazi's capitalized on peoples (mostly unfounded) fears and anger to grow their base. My original point was that the Nazi's themselves were not socialists. Referencing a name they came up with and their published propaganda was not a convincing argument to say otherwise.
Their brand of Nazism survives to this day:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strasserism
So I don't think it's accurate to say "the Nazi's themselves were not socialists", as if none of them were.
I never said that.
> I don't think it's accurate to say "the Nazi's themselves were not socialists", as if none of them were.
I never claimed that none of them were.
Making it sound as if I and others are talking in absolutes and manufacturing talking points around that is a waste of everyones time.
I joined this discussion because you said "The Nazis were socialist only in name."
Only.
That sounds fairly absolute to me.
I'm going to give this thread a break since it seems as though you're simply looking for arguments where none exist.
But if you don't consider it an important claim, then let's move on. I'm satisfied that I've shown a fair amount of evidence that it's untrue.
Despite that, the Nazis did gain support from many socialists, and ultimately, like so many other governments that rose to power with socialist promises, failed to live up to those promises.
But I don't think Hitler himself was a socialist, and I agree that Hitler was using the socialists just as he used everyone else who supported him. I just think people should acknowledge the role that socialists played in helping him rise to power.