News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by julienchastang on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:29PM (#26296268)
Fun fact: This is not the first time a space program has flown on another planet. The Soviets launched weather balloons on Venus during the Venera missions [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vega_program#Balloon

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by ChuckMcM on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:31PM (#26297727)
And given the density of Venus' atmosphere, here is a fun thought experiment.

It may be possible to make 'titanium' balloons for longer term operation. The would work by creating the balloon envelope on earth, have a sealing mechanism that you activated in orbit so they had vacuum inside. And then drop them into the atmosphere.

Same idea a glass floats on fishing nets[1] except with titanium (so they can withstand the compression forces given they have a vacuum inside). It might be useful/necessary to put some additional structure inside the envelope for strength but like eggs, the sphere is a pretty good shape for distributing compressive force.

Anyway, put a number of them on tethers attached to the instrument payload and drop it off into the atmosphere once you've gone trans-sonic with parachutes or retro rockets. The platform will then fall to the point where the lifting force of the floats is equal to the weight of the platform.

Ideally the titanium would be impervious to the atmospherics's corrosive effects.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_float

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by zhoujianfu on Monday March 01, 2021 @01:14AM (#26300179)
Does anybody have any thoughts on how feasible it would be to make a metal “vacuum sphere” that floated in earth’s atmosphere?

That’d be pretty cool!

How huge would it have to be? Would it have to be made of titanium? Aluminum? Stainless steel?

How good are those materials at withstanding a vacuum (or partial vacuum) if the diameter was say... 50m?

I feel like at some size it must work, as the volume of air displaced goes up with r^3 and the surface area of metal only goes up with r^2.

If people here can do the math, maybe I could build one in time for next burning man...!

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by ChuckMcM on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:36AM (#26300474)
The challenge is that Earth's air isn't dense enough. That said, the math is "easy" density is volume/mass, vacuum adds no mass, so it is just material mass / volume.

A 20cm diameter diamond sphere that was .5mm thick would have a mass of about 41g, a 20cm diameter sphere of air at sea level and "room" temperature is about 50g. So you would get 9g of "lifting force" from such a balloon (assuming I did all the calculations correctly). And experience about 2,900lbs of compression force.

Any air in the sphere would add weight.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by bananasbandanas on Monday March 01, 2021 @05:17AM (#26301304)
If you're interested in some fiction with this concept: In Neal Stephenson's 'Diamond Age' humans have mastered assembly of individual atoms in basically arbitrary ways. They use it (among other things) to create flying airships with an envelope made of diamond with a vacuum inside. Found it to be a fun read in general.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by gibspaulding on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:47AM (#26303217)
I've really enjoyed several of Stephenson's books, but 'Diamond Age' was one I couldn't get into. I need to give it another shot.

On the subject of Sci-Fi, there's also a vacuum airship featured in one of Edgar Rice Burroughs' Tarzan novels - 'Tarzan at the Earth's Core'. It is of course much less scientific than Stephenson's version though.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by rtkwe on Monday March 01, 2021 @10:27AM (#26303608)
He really likes to drop readers in with minimal explanation into a world, he's gotten much better at it over time but Diamond Age is both one of his earlier works and one of his most esoteric worlds with the odd neo-Victorians etc.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by rtkwe on Monday March 01, 2021 @10:22AM (#26303562)
That's always a fun blast from the tech hype past where nanotechnology was going to be pure magic with tiny machines capable of doing anything. That was an exciting possible future while it lasted, nanotechnology is doing neat stuff but it's nowhere close to the wild promises.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by mojomark on Monday March 01, 2021 @11:20PM (#26311875)
I too always thought the field of clatreonics (1) would be further along by now.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claytronics

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by rtkwe on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @08:56AM (#26315324)
Yeah we're starting to do that but the individual pieces are pretty large and I think we're much more level headed about how small they can be shrunk now.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dredmorbius on Monday March 01, 2021 @08:12AM (#26302408)
The concept is known as a "vacuum airship". TL;DR: Materials aren't strong enough past very trivial volumes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_airship

This is a plot element in Neal Stephenson's The Diamond Age, as well as several other fictional appearances (Edgar Rice Burroughs, Azhar Abidi, Peter Watts, and Iain M. Banks all use the trope).

There are no materials known with sufficient strength to withstand compressive and buckling forces. Not even diamond.

Lightweight stiff structures (honeycomb, something resembling aerogel, perhaps) are other options, but seem unlikely as well.

Gas-filled airships or balloons benefit from the fact that low-density gasses (by either chemical composition or temperature in the case of hot-air balloons) exert a countervailing pressure to balance atmospheric pressure, but with a lower mass, hence providing buoyancy. The internal pressure actually provides some (or much) of the structural rigidity of most airship variants. Any vacuum airship would have to make up for this factor, again, increasing strength (and material mass) requirements.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by MayeulC on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:07AM (#26302858)
I am following https://www.o-boot.com/en/ with interest. They claim to have solved the buckling issues by using a roman arch-like structure.

The idea sounds relatively sound to me. One could construct a sphere out of aerogel cones, and the external pressure would reinforce it. Not sure how practical it would be to build such a thing, though.

At some point, since volume grows slower than volume, I expect you can make the envelope relatively thick without sacrificing density. That's also the idea behind Cloud nine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_Nine_%28tensegrity_spher...

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dredmorbius on Monday March 01, 2021 @10:05PM (#26311442)
s/since volume grows slower than volume/since surface area grows slower than volume/

Square-cube law. Mass scales with surface area, lift scales with volume. Large balloons (conventional, not vacuum) are simpler and more efficient than small ones.

As to materials, a tremendous problem with areogels are that they're exceedingly friable. Any friction, flexing, or stress will crumble the gell to a powder. I suspect this is why the gel hasn't taken off as it had been projected to. I did some very-early 1990s work in the space and aerogels were a noted emerging technology thought to have applications in, e.g., mobile home, pre-fab housing, and RV designs. For the most part, fibre-based insulation or expanded-foam (polystyrene) insulation remains the standard, largely because road and other vibration don't reduce your insulation to a few inches of fine dust at the bottom of wall cavities.

Material properties are complex, and represent interesting trade-offs between afforded capabilities and imposed constraints.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by neurostimulant on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:24AM (#26303003)
It's not feasible in earth's atmosphere, but seem to be feasible in mars: https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2017_Phase_...
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by bagels on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:27AM (#26300444)
Vacuum would be pretty difficult. The strength requirements literally outweigh the buoyancy.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tryauuum on Monday March 01, 2021 @01:29AM (#26300227)
reminded me of a mythbusters episode where they created a lead balloon
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by xadhominemx on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:22PM (#26299063)
Venus’s atmosphere is 100x denser than earth’s, so you could just seal the metal balloons at sea level pressure and it wouldn’t really make a difference. Or you could seal them in a vacuum on earth. Not sure why you would need to feel them in space.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by simcop2387 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:36PM (#26299137)
Weight and volume. The air has weight so it'll cost more to launch. The volume would also make them more difficult to launch. Assembling or unfolding in space near earth would allow you to make them larger and inspect them before they leave for venus.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by minitoar on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:46PM (#26299203)
I could see reusing an empty fuel tank or something as a cute way of doing this.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by ChuckMcM on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:16AM (#26300401)
Oh I like that idea! Tricky to get it through the deceleration phase into the atmosphere but it would have a lot of volume. You would want some way to detach the engines (less mass) after you slowed down while still sealing the tanks.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by thaumasiotes on Monday March 01, 2021 @12:59AM (#26300120)
> Assembling or unfolding in space near earth would allow you to make them larger and inspect them before they leave for venus.

Don't we want them to be rigid spheres?

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tempestn on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:53AM (#26300545)
Yes, but you could still construct it in orbit. Imagine building four quadrants, spooning them together for launch, then fusing ("cold welding") them into a sphere in space.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by thaumasiotes on Monday March 01, 2021 @03:22AM (#26300657)
It is surely better to construct them here, where we have all our tools, and if really necessary pump them out here. There just isn't an advantage to doing it in space. You end up paying more to create a lower-quality sphere.

And what weighs more - the air that got trapped in the sphere when we made it, or the machine we sent up to space to assemble a sphere there?

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by withjive on Monday March 01, 2021 @05:58AM (#26301533)
Seems quite short sighted to assume space manufacturing processes would not improve - or we would not want to improve them.

Cold weld it in space, it's not that difficult with some engineering.

Space X?

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by thaumasiotes on Monday March 01, 2021 @06:41AM (#26301797)
The assumption is that no matter how much space manufacturing processes improve, ordinary manufacturing processes will improve more than that.

This is pretty well guaranteed.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tempestn on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:30PM (#26307128)
It's not just the weight that's an issue, but also the volume.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by endymi0n on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:40PM (#26296359)
This is so cool, I didn‘t know about these yet and I‘d call myself a space buff...

Speaking of flight and picking the nits here — looks like Wikipedia also isn‘t completely correct here:

> It is planned to make the first powered flight on any planet beyond Earth

...arguably the first _powered_ flights were done by the sky cranes of Opportunity and Perseverance

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by alpaca128 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:59PM (#26296493)
> ...arguably the first _powered_ flights were done by the sky cranes of Opportunity and Perseverance

Not the Apollo 11 lunar module? In contrast to the sky cranes it actually lifted off again.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by m4rtink on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:47PM (#26296917)
On the Moon the first controlled powered flights were likely the Surveyor and Luna probes - they had braking and landing thrusters controlled by onboard avionics.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dal on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:09PM (#26296580)
The moon is not a planet.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by rriepe on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:25PM (#26297205)
I'd argue Mars is still the most impressive. Rockets in no atmosphere is easy. Floating on Venus is easy because it has more atmo than any other rocky planet.

Figuring out something that works well in Mars' thin (but still there) atmosphere, especially a helicopter, is really impressive. The celestial body classification is just a cherry on top.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by spullara on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:32PM (#26298491)
Highly recommend looking at the specs of the helicopter. It masses just 1.4kg. Each blade is 35g!
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by xwdv on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:13PM (#26298752)
Basically a DJI Phantom 4.

Edit: Phantom 4 is 1.3 kg and blades are 45g

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dntrkv on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:23PM (#26299379)
Except Ingenuity's blades are 4 feet long.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dotancohen on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:38PM (#26297320)
By many definitions the Earth-Moon system is a dual planetary system. The moon has more that 1% the mass of the Earth, which is by far the largest primary-secondary "not a planet" system in the solar system. Only not-a-planet Pluto and Charon exceed it.

Also, Isaac Asimov considered the system a dual-planet system as the Moon's path around the sun is at no point convex nor retrograde.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by jojobas on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:10PM (#26298732)
Earth-Moon centre of mass is inside Earth, so, it's obvious that the Moon is orbiting the Earth, not both orbiting something else.

1% is an arbitrary threshold and solar orbit is dependent on external circumstances rather than the Earth-Moon system itself.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by dotancohen on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:08AM (#26300367)

  > Earth-Moon centre of mass is inside Earth, so, it's
  > obvious that the Moon is orbiting the Earth, not both
  > orbiting something else.
I used to agree with that school of thought, until I came up with a small thought experiment. Consider two bodies that are right on the planet-moon / dual-planet definition threshold. Intuitively, increasing the orbital distance between them would push them in the direction of which definition: planet-moon or dual-planet?

I'd tend to say that separating them further would tend more towards planet-moon. Yet doing so moves the system's center of mass outside the larger body, so would actually push the system into the dual-planet definition by that criterion.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by shawnz on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:21AM (#26302980)
The barycentre being inside of one of the things in the system is also an arbitrary threshold, isn't it?

The barycentre of the Sun and Jupiter isn't inside of the Sun.. so does that mean Jupiter doesn't orbit the Sun?

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tempestn on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:55AM (#26300553)
Technically the moon is a dwarf planet, as it has sufficient gravity to form itself into a spheroid shape, but it has not cleared its orbit.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by Daho0n on Monday March 01, 2021 @08:28AM (#26302541)
It's Pluto all over again!
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by trailbits on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:13PM (#26299636)
It's a fun exercise to work out the Gravitational Force between the Moon and the Earth and between the Moon and our Sun. It will surprise many that the Sun exerts more force on the Moon than the Earth does. So the Earth inflicts a strong perturbation on the motion of the Moon but it's not the dominant gravitational force on the Moon.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by m4rtink on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:48PM (#26296928)
On Mars the Viking probes used rockets for controlled landing, so that likely also counts. Pathfinder just had one shot braking rockets.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by svachalek on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:49PM (#26296416)
It seems that rocket propulsion does not count as “powered flight”
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday March 01, 2021 @08:46AM (#26302688)
Powered? definitely.

But Flight? A rocket has no fixed or rotating wing providing lift, so maybe not.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tus89 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:50PM (#26296940)
If we understand "flight" as being the use of a wing to generate lift in an atmosphere, then I think we can safely say this is the first time we have flown on another planet. I assume this little helicopter actually has rotary wings rather than fans.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by rhino369 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:04PM (#26297045)
The common understanding of flight definitely doesn't include lighter than air (well atmosphere in this case) vehicles.

The first flight was in 1903, not 300 BC China when they used sky lanterns.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by monkeydreams on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:17PM (#26297632)
> The first flight was in 1903

The first powered flight was in 1903, with the criteria that it was not gravity assisted, that it was sustained and that it was controlled. No one is claiming that it was the first flight ever.

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by sangnoir on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:58PM (#26297901)
Lighter than air is flight - one cannot say dirigibles and hot air balloons are not flying machines.The distinction is made between lighter than air and heavier than air - for which the first was success was by the Wright brothers.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by contravariant on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:04PM (#26297044)
If we're splitting hairs then the lack of control seems like a better criterion to distinguish the two. If you ask me there's no reason a zeppelin would be inherently less 'flighty' than a helicopter.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tus89 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:18PM (#26297156)
I think they are more "floaty" that "flighty" :P
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by johnwalkr on Monday March 01, 2021 @05:15AM (#26301294)
In the space industry, “flight” is used for all types of vehicles so I’d also argue to use that very broad definition rather than terrestrial terminology.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by contravariant on Monday March 01, 2021 @06:31AM (#26301725)
And even on Earth the term "flight" doesn't really care about the method, you've got 'balloon flights' for instance.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by jeremyjh on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:39PM (#26299482)
The term used in the article was “powered flight”. This distinction is relevant in the history of aviation on earth as well, and usually that term is used.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by taf2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:20PM (#26296678)
For sure the soviets did some neat science work but I think a motorized helicopters flying on Mars is pretty darn cool too compared to a ballon floating in a dense atmosphere it even feels like an advancement
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tachyonbeam on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:33PM (#26296793)
They're both cool because they're both technological firsts. The weather balloon on Venus was in 1985, a whole 35 years ago!

https://www.nytimes.com/1985/06/12/us/soviet-drops-weather-b...

Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by macintux on Monday March 01, 2021 @12:53AM (#26300097)
Absolutely. The Soviets did some incredibly impressive work with Venus.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by causality0 on Monday March 01, 2021 @07:21AM (#26302055)
It's actually not even the first time a powered aircraft has flown on Mars. Both Curiosity's and Perseverance's descent stages were powered aircraft that, after releasing the rovers, flew up and away from them in a controlled manner through the air.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by TedShiller on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:39PM (#26296856)
A balloon is barely an aircraft
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by tachyonbeam on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:52PM (#26296960)
A solar drone that takes hours to charge and flies only a minute at a time is barely an aircraft too. Don't get me wrong, it's a very cool tech demo and I can't wait to see the video, but IMO if your goal is to take pressure/composition measurements in the atmosphere at a variety of altitudes, a weather balloon is the right tool for the job.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly by buzzerbetrayed on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:37AM (#26300479)
Nobody is arguing that it isn't the "right tool for the job". Just that a balloon isn't an aircraft. While a drone that flies for a minute at a time clearly is.