Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly
by jojobas on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:10PM
(#26298732)
Earth-Moon centre of mass is inside Earth, so, it's obvious that the Moon is orbiting the Earth, not both orbiting something else.
1% is an arbitrary threshold and solar orbit is dependent on external circumstances rather than the Earth-Moon system itself.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly
by dotancohen on Monday March 01, 2021 @02:08AM
(#26300367)
> Earth-Moon centre of mass is inside Earth, so, it's
> obvious that the Moon is orbiting the Earth, not both
> orbiting something else.
I used to agree with that school of thought, until I came up with a small thought experiment. Consider two bodies that are right on the planet-moon / dual-planet definition threshold. Intuitively, increasing the orbital distance between them would push them in the direction of which definition: planet-moon or dual-planet?I'd tend to say that separating them further would tend more towards planet-moon. Yet doing so moves the system's center of mass outside the larger body, so would actually push the system into the dual-planet definition by that criterion.
Re:The Mars Helicopter Is Online and Getting Ready to Fly
by shawnz on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:21AM
(#26302980)
The barycentre being inside of one of the things in the system is also an arbitrary threshold, isn't it?
The barycentre of the Sun and Jupiter isn't inside of the Sun.. so does that mean Jupiter doesn't orbit the Sun?
Also, Isaac Asimov considered the system a dual-planet system as the Moon's path around the sun is at no point convex nor retrograde.