News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by thayne on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:09PM (#26125832)
I am a casualty of this. I was originally intending to follow an academic career, until I discovered that my career would be dependent on my ability to secure grants. Something that if I was not bad at (which I think is unlikely), would at least be extremely stressful for me. It isn't the only reason I decided to to switch to being a software engineer, but it is a major reason.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dekhn on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:18PM (#26125921)
Me too; I had my first NIH R01 turned down without a score and left for industry (which has allowed me to do more scientific work than academia ever did). I only realized later that most PIs don't get their first NIH R01 approved until ~10 years older than I was at the time.

What's ridiculous is the amounts of these basic grants that beginning scientists are trying to get are tiny- basically 1 person-year salary.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ramraj07 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:28PM (#26128058)
So surprisingly, many of my friends got their first R01s approved in the last year or two. Some actually didn't even have a good publication record or pedigree or institutional position. One even got 3! But was told that the committees are being lenient with first time appplicants.

Somehow that feels worse? Like a heroin dealer giving the first shot at a discount?

Glad I got out. I'm still hell bent on finding a way to do research (garage lab? Startup?) But f*k academia and universities. No way in hell I'm going to tacitly condone their ways by being part of it whether I can be successful or not.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by crawfordcomeaux on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:28PM (#26129132)
I'm working to create a community model with a communal research lab. It's meant to meet my needs as a researcher while also removing pressures/norms from capitalism, colonialism, and imperialism. What do you want to research and what's in your way?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:39PM (#26129440)
I've heard this dream a few times, and have had it myself. Hazardous waste disposal and storage. This is the big kicker for any research project I might want to do.

Every other expenses after getting that set up is trivial (in comparison) for an individual researcher, though national lab style shared analytical equipment is nice. That can come later though...

It's really hard. It's much simpler to set up a machine shop or similar, but then it's just a new hackerspace that there are good models for already.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:51PM (#26134968)
>Hazardous waste disposal and storage.

Partner with a hazardous material testing lab, or another type of operation where they use lots of hazardous material similar to yours and end up turning a bit of it into waste themselves.

Not necessarily an environmental lab where they actually test waste, better an industrial lab that tests material.

Some better opportunities can even be with material or waste handlers who have no lab at all.

Hazardous material does not become hazardous waste if you can legitimately sell/ship it off the site as a worthwhile product instead. Otherwise if you need to truly discard excess (even prime chemical assets then become a liability) you need to not only usually pay, but bump your paperwork and liability up from merely dangerous goods to full waste documentation requirements.

Ideally, as a scientific consultant (giving free advice only) once you get on the toxic site where yours is a drop in the bucket by comparison, you will be able to identify recycling opportunities worth way more to them than the cost of properly disposing of your paltry amount by the established registered professionals, according to the specific arcane regulations in place which you value their expertise for. They will love you.

So you can get the best deal possible.

Don't just recycle the equipment, recycle the chemicals.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:38PM (#26137380)
> Hazardous material does not become hazardous waste if you can legitimately sell/ship it off the site as a worthwhile product instead. Otherwise if you need to truly discard excess (even prime chemical assets then become a liability) you need to not only usually pay, but bump your paperwork and liability up from merely dangerous goods to full waste documentation requirements.

This is what I meant. For a small organization I would expect a lot of small volume experimental products that are not exactly known in composition combined with perhaps some rinse acetone or other solvents.

Have you encountered an example where this works? I've done consulting for startups in exchange for a fume hood before, so I guess it's not that out there. It's much harder to imagine doing this for a big hazardous waste site, but maybe?

Thanks for the idea, I definitely won't be trying to do that but maybe there could be a symbiotic thing going on there. Probably a lot easier to do that with a university somehow? A national lab will be too stuck up to accept hazardous waste or advice, but maybe a university would hire you part time to work for them while letting you use the space for your own project.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:08AM (#26139638)
Yup, I'm moving toward "retiring" from my employer and doing without a lab for a bit as I decide to get back into more action than the employer can muster.

I'll be able to maintain a good relationship with them and if I do go back into private practice nearby they will be able to handle the few liters a month I would expect to generate single-handedly.

Which is a drop in the bucket of their few drums, which are a drop in the bucket of the EPA waste hauler's truckloads.

Unknowns-R-Us.

OTOH the only time I went without a lab I built, was 2013 and I was tempted to try and operate in some vacant small-university space in my late father's retirement location, but I did not have the resources to _branch out_ while I still had my main lab in mothballs.

Things were also very uncertain plus one of the surplus spaces had already been unfavorably occupied by a not-very-well liked commercial EPA testing lab that I think failed just a year or two earlier and left everyone involved with a bad impression.

Now after recovering a bit from natural disaster, I'm going to check out UH where they took over the old Schlumberger facility as part of their energy effort a number of years ago. It still seems not fully occupied but I'll find out for sure eventually. Before the internet I sure spent a lot of time in the UH library.

When it comes to an actual university operation though, about half the time when I check out a chem department's equipment it looks like they sure could use some help from someone with more than just a few years on the gear, and often so underequipped I could bring in & restore the surplus electonics to double their capabilities within a year not much differently than at a commercial lab. Also without a PhD there are actually some long-term employment or career positions already funded which could be conformed creatively to this effort. If I did this I would want to hit successive universities since I am very fast, but I am mainly retiring from employment more so than my present employer's facility which I expect to routinely continue to visit as long as I am in their areas, to our mutual advantage.

I started out as a teenage businessman anyway so I'm not worried about going forward with only a briefcase again.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:43PM (#26145718)
> When it comes to an actual university operation though, about half the time when I check out a chem department's equipment it looks like they sure could use some help from someone with more than just a few years on the gear, and often so underequipped I could bring in & restore the surplus electonics to double their capabilities within a year not much differently than at a commercial lab. Also without a PhD there are actually some long-term employment or career positions already funded which could be conformed creatively to this effort. If I did this I would want to hit successive universities since I am very fast, but I am mainly retiring from employment more so than my present employer's facility which I expect to routinely continue to visit as long as I am in their areas, to our mutual advantage.

This is basically my part time job now, I help maintain a university lab including things like repairing ancient equipment, training grad student TAs, helping the lecturers plan and run their experiments, and then just random grad students and professors drop in for advice and help. It's pretty fun.

What I don't do is take advantage of the fact that I have a chem lab attached for any personal work, I've never actually thought to ask. I have asked about setting up a catalyst test reactor lab to collaborate with the college of computing to see if we can build a testing lab for anyone creating new catalysts to analyze the results and invent new types. There were too many professors with a vested interest in doing that kind of project so they had no interest in supporting it.

It was very disappointing to see, I'd have been happy to run a test facility for all the professors to work with as a shared experimental facility but they all wanted to be the one to get the papers first. The minor consideration to me of being able to do some of my own research projects with the setup and a salary is all I'd have wanted out of it, I love mentoring students and would have loved to provide deep expertise to students working on such projects...

Could have made three departments able to produce high quality research in a field that no one here seems to actually be good at (i.e. traditional heterogeneous catalysts) with ChemE, MatSci, and CompSci all benefiting from the ability to generate large reliable datasets of how new catalytic materials behave in traditional chemical reactors. So cheap to set up too... just such a shame that I cannot do such a project at the place I work despite having been the director of chemical process development and specifically catalyst development at previous jobs. Ostensibly because professors are already doing it in their labs, but like, why would you not take advantage of expertise like mine to make these projects work?

So bizarre but I just don't have the stamina to push them on it, I probably literally just have to switch job titles for them to even notice that I am in fact a world class expert on catalysts and chemical processing. Instead I'm repairing oscilloscopes which is super fun but I sure miss doing actual research that matters.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ramraj07 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:14AM (#26130117)
That's great! Honestly I'm still navigating more pressing existential crises (like which country and then city to set roots in, if I even have a choice) but after that the plan is to embrace fields that are amenable for cheap amateur experimentation. In that regards, I have some connectomics projects with c. Elegans in mind, followed by evolution with basic cell lines. Depending on answers to aforementioned crises I was planning to be near some big univs so I can mooch off of their inventory control auctions and core facilities as need be and go from there! However if there's actually communities of similar minded people that'll only be great since it'll expand the no. Of topics I can dabble in (which is precisely what you can never ever do in academia contrary to whatever crap they peddle to get you into the system).
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by crawfordcomeaux on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @12:49PM (#26156610)
Here's what I want: a lab to experiment with these findings (https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-018-0078-7)in a 3D colonies from the perspective of encoding various structures from human culture (particularly the community housing the lab) and seeing how the microbes address different perturbations. And then remodeling the community's culture based on whatever findings are uncovered to test the relationship between human and microbial cultures. Or remodel the cultural blueprint within some communal space to see how it works with the outside world. Or...I don't know. There are so many ways to play with culture in this way.

We're tackling the question of where to live, too. I find it useful to identify my values & then to use that to filter my options. Choosing based on availability of resources tends to lead to all kinds of blindspots in my experience. We're also trying to figure out how the community model can work without moving and what the process looks like for building it out where anyone is. The approach I'm going for right now is to identify the exact spaces and ways of relating to them I want, creating an absurdly long organization name with all those words in the name, and a mission of "evolve the name" or something similar, short, and simple.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:16PM (#26135236)
I find the surplus equipment from universities is not usually sent to _asset recovery_ (auctioned off) until it is older and more worn out compared to industrial operations.

So I always wanted (always did) have my lab in a heavy industrial area.

For biotech the US area of New Jersey and Connecticut has a high concentration of pharma giants and their many satellite contractors.

One business model has been to become enough of a contractor yourself to pay the bills, then research all you want and own it all yourself.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacquesm on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:32AM (#26130400)
I love this idea. A 'lab space' instead of a maker space. If someone is going to do this in NL then I'd be happy to help fund it.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:01PM (#26134495)
Are you near Rotterdam?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacquesm on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:20AM (#26140376)
Hilversum
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by kayhi on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:06PM (#26129285)
For most it is the start up costs.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by the_only_law on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:08PM (#26129296)
Yeah I tend to browse eBay and other resellers looking for old engineering / scientific equipment and even for obsolete stuff it often still resells pretty high.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ramraj07 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:16AM (#26130130)
The way I think about it, people own boats, and this still can be cheaper than that hobby!
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:37AM (#26130414)
I guess not if they live in them?

https://www.instructables.com/How-to-Get-a-Free-Yacht/

I love this one.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by rleigh on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:53AM (#26131234)
I stuck it out in academia for (if I total it up completely), 15 years, before getting out and into industry. My experience matches yours--there's just so much interesting scientific work out there, and while some might argue that it's constrained due to the business priorities, the same applies to working in an academic group with specific priorities. Just like choosing a research group in academia, choose a company with priorities and interests which align with yours.

On the face of it, it's also a less risky choice. In academia, you're always fighting over scraps of funding, and you're always just one grant application away from a career failure. Just one rejected publication or failed experiment can end you if it causes you to fail to get more funding. While I wasn't a PI, I was made redundant after our group lost some of its funding, and I put some of that down to a paper rejected on utterly ridiculous grounds by a competitor lab. Petty academic politics. In industry, it seems that companies are much better at managing and mitigating risk. Projects are initiated with the expectation that they will have a high chance of failure, but that useful knowledge will be gained. Project managers will give projects a certain amount of runway and then make a go/no-go decision for continuation at defined points. You might run several projects in parallel and know that some will work out and some won't. Being on a "failed" project isn't a career-limiting move in that situation--you'll try your best doing some very cutting-edge stuff and your efforts will still be valued. Rather than being fired, you'll move onto another project and continue doing interesting stuff. It's much less stressful even though I likely work harder! And if the company stops being interesting, there are plenty of others to go to.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:58PM (#26126228)
Biomedical engineer with a 2.977GPA. Lots of extra curriculars, volunteered in labs, 160 credit hours of mostly STEM classes, lots of grad-level courses, relevant work experience, but GPA was 0.023 too low to pass the automated filters and I didn't get into any of the grad programs I applied for.

I ended up doing fine in software development though. Also, the Wright Brothers didn't need a research lab to invent flight. Biology-focused hacker spaces are on the rise so there are still ways to do research.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fma on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:27PM (#26128837)
There's many issues in our science system, but it may be a blessing that you got rejected.

I'm a senior software engineer. My wife has a PhD in biochemistry from a top university. When she graduated she could not get a job anywhere. We both agreed she should choose a different path and she started a business in a totally unrelated field.

Meanwhile someone like me...I'm literally turning away interviews. I have no doubt she'd be able to be success in the IT industry amongst the many roles offered if she had chosen the path. And many of her peers have self studied, dropped their grad programs and get hired by the likes of Facebook, Microsoft.

Pragmatically, the smartest one would never get into fields with limited jobs and pay. I'd rather pick a field so I can feed my family, than to save the world.

The US will get leapfrogged in R&D as the brain drain goes towards generating ad revenue (For the record I do not work for a company that relies on generating ads)

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by throwaway_gerts on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:48AM (#26130454)
> Meanwhile someone like me...I'm literally turning away interviews.

How do you manage that? I've been a software developer for over 20 years now, and every time I lose my job it's a SLOG to find another one, with anywhere from a few months to a year in between. I can't even remember the last time a recruiter contacted me (perhaps 5-6 times in my entire career).

It's not like my technical skills are lacking. I've worked professionally with most popular languages and technologies, have dozens of popular open source projects under my belt, many of which you're probably even using at work in some fashion. I've even been called a "miracle worker" a few times for the projects I've saved from ruin, or terrible processes I've optimized.

I'm friendly with everyone, not badmouthing, staying out of politics, treating everyone professionally and expecting the same.

But then whenever there are layoffs or there's an opportunity to push someone out, I'm in the first wave to go (they never say why). I've even been fired for "not stepping up enough." And then I spend another few months slinging resumes all over, spending my days doing coding challenges in the hopes of getting an interview. Then another year of employment and the cycle starts all over again. I have to constantly prove myself again and again, as if I were fresh out of college or something.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by stocknoob on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:12AM (#26130530)
This may be difficult to hear, but something is wrong if you have been working for 20 years and old colleagues aren't occasionally checking in to see if you'd like a different gig at their current company. The people who called you a miracle worker, they don't keep in touch? They don't want you to join their current project?

You may want to ask someone who you are on good terms with what's going on.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by throwaway_gerts on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:26AM (#26130852)
I've never had an old colleague contact me. Is that a thing?

Forgive me, but I'm not even sure what I should be asking these people... "Why haven't you contacted me" sounds too abrasive...

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fma on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:34PM (#26134822)
Original commenter here. People don't reach out to me. I reach out to people. I make sure I keep the relationship open. People are way too busy with their lives to maintain connections. Imagine how happy you would be if someone you used to work with reached out to see how you're doing. I'd be very happy. That's why I try to do it...because I know on the other end my former colleague would be happy.

I work at a huge company and have been on many teams and projects. Every few days, weeks - I'd ping people just to see what's up and strike a conversation. I don't do it annoyingly...there's a fine balance. You also need to be able to tell who is social and who is not. If you can read that someone has a social personality I'll talk to them more, be friend them...talk to things besides work. There are those who only like to talk about work, and that's fine. Then we just talk about work. I go out of my way to help them out with any problems at work or outside of work.

For example someone is a first time home buyer...so I gave advice (I've bought 2 homes in my young career). Another, a manager...his son is in med school, I gave advice (my roommates in grad school were in med school). Another had problems with implementing PGP...so I stayed late one night to help her out.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by cornel_io on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:34AM (#26131482)
Yes, that's a thing if you have good relationships with coworkers who have hiring power in later jobs. Since I switched to being a founder I've firmly disabused most previous coworkers of the notion that I'd ever come to work with them, but I used to regularly hear from them, and now I routinely reach out to the people that I liked working with.

If you're not experiencing this, you really can't ask anyone else anything, but you can ask yourself what's wrong. It might just be that you haven't made friends with people who have hiring influence; that said, most people can at least refer folks. More likely is that you aren't getting personally close enough with people at work, so they are not thinking of you. Spend more time interacting on a human level with non-engineers, who are way more often to be influential re: hiring at future jobs.

It's also possible that you're not considered a solid worker, or you don't get along with people, but in my experience that's a lot less common than merely not making friends with people who are likely to have jobs to offer in the future. Learning to find and befriet those people is a key career skill.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by stocknoob on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:03AM (#26131001)
Maybe 10% of my coworkers transitioned from work acquaintance ("Hi Jim") into good work acquaintance ("hey man, grab lunch?") into friend ("hey man, want to grab dinner/beers later?") into good friend ("hey man, want to go on an out-of-country trip?").

If nobody is making the jump into good work acquaintance, where you enjoy hanging out casually without needing an explicit work reason, something is amiss. I don't try to form connections, it just happens similar to how you make friends in class. Work is class. If nobody talks to you after the project is over something isn't right.

You can't ask people who aren't close directly why they aren't close, but maybe family members / non-work friends. "Is there something about me that makes it difficult to make connections?" It's quite hard to get explicit feedback on this type of thing.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by throwaway_gerts on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:20AM (#26131058)
> You can't ask people who aren't close directly why they aren't close, but maybe family members / non-work friends.

Yes! I've done exactly this, and the result is always the same: They can't believe that I'm having problems in this area. "I can't understand how ANYONE could dislike you!" is what my dad said.

Fuck... now this is making me sad.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by stocknoob on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:32AM (#26131119)
Ah, don't get sad -- you seem aware enough to recognize the problem. Just a few thoughts:

* These connections are easier when you're in your 20s, single, have time to kill. The company culture may encourage/discourage this too.

* If you're a developer, you may be among a less-extroverted cohort, and have to make efforts to reach out vs. being reached-out-to.

* These are the hard-to-teach-explicitly items, but is every interaction with coworkers purely about the project? Hobbies, shared interests, movies they've seen, games they play, trips they've done/are going to do, etc.? With a (non-work) shared interest it's hard not to have casual conversations that build a work repoire over time.

* There are intangible social signals about willingness to connect (person is overly polite/formal/rigid, facial expressions/body language, warmth of tone and language, etc.). Basically when you sit down next to someone on an airplane, you can tell if they want to chat without having to ask them. Being actively disliked is rarely the issue. You don't dislike the cashier at the grocery store, but the relationship is purely transactional, we can be friendly but let's just get this over with. For some reason, your coworkers may see things this way.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by junon on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:59AM (#26131633)
This is insulting and just flat out unrealistic. If you've had this experience, great, but what you're describing is very far from the norm.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by stocknoob on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:50PM (#26134395)
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/new-survey-reveals-85-all-job...

Working somewhere for decades and not being in touch with a single colleague is not normal. Imagine hearing "I didn't keep in touch with a single person from my 16 years of primary + university education after school ended."

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by junon on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:02PM (#26145234)
I don't keep in touch with anyone I went to school with, no. I also don't keep in touch with many past colleagues beyond a yearly checkup, if at all.

Sorry, but your assumption about how the world works / should work isn't applicable to everyone. Some people don't have the capacity to do so.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by stocknoob on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:12PM (#26156895)
Some people can't see color either, and unfortunately their life is more difficult because of it. But seeing color is the expected outcome for most, and the world is built with that assumption in mind.

If you aren't making connections you are unfortunately at a severe disadvantage. To the extent you're self-aware to realize this, you may be able to correct it. Otherwise, like anything else, you learn to adapt.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by junon on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @08:21AM (#26165980)
What a ludicrous comparison. Contrasting a physical disability vs. a conscious choice not to engage with colleagues from companies past is a sign of a failing argument.

Your tone also comes off as incredibly patronizing, as though you know my life better than I do.

Rest assured, not keeping in touch with old contacts has not caused me to miss any opportunities that I would be otherwise interested in.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fma on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:25PM (#26134733)
Lots of replies and I'd mostly agree.

I work for a big company... It's not a FAANG, but it's recognizable world wide. Even though it's not a tech company, I believe the name recognition gives some credibility to recruiters.

I'm lucky to have worked at a previous company that had a lot of well connected software engineers and management. It was a mid size company so I was 2 levels from the CTO. They are my connections on LinkedIn so I think that adds credibility.

I'm a java developer. Despite the hmm...'hate' for Java on HN, if you go to dice.com and put in various languages...Java is very high ranking. Having years of experience in a technology with a lot of jobs help.

Some alluded to keeping in touch with old coworkers. I'd have to strongly agree to that. Strongly. I have your back, you have my back. Right? I hate interviewing. HATE. I've been fortunate in the last several years to have had 4 former colleagues ask if I want to join their team/company. I seriously considered each one, but declined for various reason.

At one point, my company was having layoffs. I knew I should have a backup plan in case my name was on the list. But I hate interviewing...all it took was a phone call to an old colleague of mine (he's now a director) and I was given an open job offer. I enjoy where I currently work {enough} that I'll stay for a while longer.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacksonkmarley on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:30AM (#26130870)
Seems weird to never be contacted by recruiters, are you not using linkedin during your job searches? After my last round of linkedin application spamming I get a steady stream of emails about opportunities even after I stopped looking.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by throwaway_gerts on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:37AM (#26130890)
Yes, when I'm looking for work I turn on the looking-for-work thing on linkedin. I'll get 1 maybe 2 generic pings over the next few months for "fullstack dev" (which I'm not - I do server-side or low level software), but that's about it.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacksonkmarley on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:58AM (#26130972)
I don't want to dunk on you with really obvious suggestions like "you have a bad resume, fix it" type comments, maybe you've already had it looked over, and you're in a non-optimal location or something. Maybe ask a few specific questions on reddit somewhere like r/cscareerquestions.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by throwaway_gerts on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:16AM (#26131050)
I've been wracking my brain for years over this, and I'm still not any closer to understanding what the problem is.

I've had my resume looked at and tweaked over and over. I never send a cover letter without having someone else proofread and offer suggestions. I've lived and worked in many tech-hub places, including San Francisco for 6 years.

I just don't know... I think it's got to be socially related, but I have a hard time examining that aspect because I'm autistic. But I always make a concerted effort not to offend people, to make sure everyone gets their say and can contribute. People even say I'm a really nice guy, so then I'm left wondering what exactly "it" is that's tanking me...

It always happens the same way:

- I get a job and everyone is super friendly. Some inevitable technical hiccups getting set up for the first month, but no big deal.

- Everything goes swimmingly for the next 6 months to a year. People seem happy with me, performance reviews are fine, 1-on-1 with the boss is fine. I even make a point of asking if they're unhappy with anything about me, and they say "no, everything's fine".

Then one day things go bad (or maybe they've been bad and I didn't see). People start being rude to me, start shutting me out of conversations, start being extra harsh or petty in code reviews etc. In some cases they start name-calling. No higher-ups step in so I try to avoid the people doing this and not antagonize them.

Eventually my boss brings me in for the "it's not working out" talk. They can never give me a solid reason why, and often they resort to roundabout firing methods because it's technically illegal otherwise. There's never a warning, never a list of things to improve upon. I spend most of my days at a company wondering when I'll get "the call". The worst one happened on Dec 23rd.

So yeah... Probably nothing that anyone on HN could help with, because the feedback mechanism I'm subjected to is so vague. But it's frustrating nonetheless, and even today I have constant stress spikes whenever my boss asks to talk to me for a minute about something, wondering if this is it.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by loup-vaillant on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:07AM (#26131321)
> I think it's got to be socially related, but I have a hard time examining that aspect because I'm autistic.

There you have it. It's brutally unfair, but autism, if strong enough to be perceivable, sounds like the most likely cause: you're different, and people don't like you because of it.

Even worse, I believe that people on the autism spectrum don't even perceive they're different. I personally have no idea whether I'm on that spectrum, or how far. Still: my own Mom once stated the "obvious": that I must notice that I'm not like others. I had to tell her that I don't. At 35.

So. People perceive you're different. It's obvious enough that they expect you to perceive that difference, even though you may not. So when you fail to conform to the obscure (to you) group norm, they end up rejecting you. Perhaps even rationalising that you're doing it on purpose (remember, the difference is obvious to them). Then you're out of the group.

---

There may be other factors as well. Folks tend to be kinder, more forgiving, of pretty people, so if you can improve that in any way, try to do so (one habit at a time though, take it easy). The easiest thing to go for, I think, is clothing: try having someone you trust chose your clothes for you. Pay explicit attention to the dress code at your workplace, emulate it a little (but don't buy the exact same clothes either!). Also consider light makeup if you're a woman (and maybe get counsel about that too).

Much harder is taking good care of your health. If you're fat, unfit, or otherwise unhealthy, try to work on that. Sleeping well, eating well, and exercising properly is surprisingly hard when you're not used to it, but it's a must.

---

Edit: also consider telling your colleagues about your autism. I expect it's not easy, and it may not even be a good idea, but there's a chance that people knew why you are the way you are, they'd tolerate it better.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacksonkmarley on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:20AM (#26131387)
(edit: oops sorry I didn't properly parse the bit about being autistic on first read. I won't delete my suggestions in case they are useful in some way)

Well the coworker stuff is a separate issue because recruiters don't usually know you, probably you need to address the two issues separately.

As for improving your interactions with coworkers, I'll just throw a few ideas because who knows, maybe the answer will come from a random source like me:

- read 'How to win friends and influence people', maybe some stuff by Mark Manson.

- Try to learn from your successful relationships what you're good at/comfortable with

- Actively choose the environment you aim work in to fit your social strengths e.g. team size, people types. ( This one depends a bit on solving the jobsearch issues first )

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by robbomacrae on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:36AM (#26131877)
Asking for feedback directly will never work. Instead, try asking a friend (or use a fake account) to ask for a reference about yourself. You can then be as targetted as you like.. "have you considered referring throwaway_gerts before? If yes/no why?" Or "were there any issues working with throwaway_gerts?"
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by phobosanomaly on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:44PM (#26127702)
It's unfortunate to see people disadvantaged by pursuing a truly difficult major.

A 2.97 in bioengineering could represent someone who simply took more challenging courses, and got lower grades because the courses were truly difficult.

A straight bio major might have a 3.8, but never had to work through a year-long Pchem sequence, instead padding with softer, more grade-inflated courses.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fma on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:21PM (#26129657)
The GPA is an interesting system when you sit down to think about it. I came into college with almost 30 general education credit hours. I received the International Baccalaureate diploma in high school. I only needed 1 more gen ed course to fulfill my requirements.

So imagine me, a 18 year old jumping immediately into fairly difficult courses my freshman year...adapting to college. Whilst my peers are taking English 101 and inflating their GPA. I did not receive internships offers my early years in college and I feel this had a big part of it.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by Al-Khwarizmi on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:08AM (#26131024)
Not for you obviously, but in case someone else that is still in the situation of applying for grad school is reading this.

Have you checked outside the US?

In the EU there are plenty of universities that offer grad programs without the crazy access requirements of US universities. Tuition is free or at a token price in many countries. And it's reasonably easy to get a paid PhD studentship where you get paid a real salary, not slave wages (probably this is not that easy to get when you're straight out of your Master's with a mediocre GPA, but once you have shown ability to do research successfully and have a couple of papers under your belt, it shouldn't be hard in most places).

Sure, EU universities don't give you the clout of Ivy League, but many do perfectly fine research, you may even learn more as the 3rd PhD student of a professor than as the 27th PhD student of a superstar professor that talks to you five minutes once a month, and can advance your career path just fine.

I'm talking about the EU because it's where I am and can talk more or less confidently about, but this is probably true of many other countries and regions outside the US.

It's crazy to see how many people don't even consider this. I remember an Iranian researcher I was going to hire for a PhD position, she ended up going to the US because you know, it's the US... she faced the Trump ban and the PhD student tax hikes (here she would have a salary allowing her a middle-class lifestyle and without all those threats), and to this day she has significantly fewer papers than the person who had the second best CV and interview and I hired instead. Seriously, there is life outside the US!

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alwahi on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:48AM (#26131209)
Which institutes would you recommend for Engineering research?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by Al-Khwarizmi on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:59AM (#26131271)
I think your question is too general. For example, there may be institutions that have e.g. a great civil engineering lab while being mediocre at electrical engineering. And the same can be true of subfields of each engineering discipline (for example, I'm in CS, and it's common to see institutions that have a powerful group in one specific area of CS - say computer vision, robotics, NLP, theoretical CS - and aren't anything special in others).

I think you should look at what specific research you want to do and then check what labs are publishing interesting papers on that specific thing.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by DukeBaset on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:51AM (#26131982)
Perhaps I should have been more clear, I am a PhD dropout in Mech Eng with lots of CS and finance/econ exposure as I dropped out to join a bank. I want to do something cross disciplinary and vague ideas of systems science especially since I read Saltzer Kaashoek(sorry for butchering the spellings) Principles of Computer System design and sort of using a systems design approach to manufacturing processes and such. Like a lot of ideas of CS are from Engineering Management like JIT etc and how the design of networks is an evolution of earlier metaphors of telegraph and telephone systems.

To keep it short, how do I even find what I want to look for? Any tactics that you would want to suggest?

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ineedasername on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:40AM (#26130428)
This is not a judgment on you. It sounds like you really challenged yourself, and may have done well in such a program.

This is just an explanation of how admissions offices work: Bio programs of any flavor at most halfway decent schools are so over-subscribed that there are far more people who exceed the minimum requirements than there are spots for them. Admissions offices have very limited resources to review enormous #'s of applications. 3.0 is a pretty good low-pass filter that eliminates a lot of those applications while still retaining applications from students who, from a probability standpoint, are most likely to succeed in the programs. Extra curriculars & volunteer work at labs show that you're willing to work hard, but not the quality of that work, so those become distinguishing factors only for students that already jumped the GPA hurdle. Academic success from someone with < 3.0 GPA would represent an outlier, and there are no good ways identify who those outliers are, and finding them isn't important when there are plenty of qualified applicants who are easier to identify.

There's probably lots of students in your boat who would have contributed well to the body of scientific knowledge. But for every one of them-- and I have literally seen these students-- there are dozens upon dozens that are let into more lenient programs, unable to do the work & burdened with $100k+ in debt & nothing to show for it.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dmitryminkovsky on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:01PM (#26126266)
> Biology-focused hacker spaces are on the rise so there are still ways to do research.

I am very interested in this concept. Are you thinking of any in particular? I really wish people invested in public spaces people could go do science, particularly chemistry.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:17PM (#26126406)
I joined one called "BioCurious"[1] in the SF Bay area to work on a project making a fluorescence microscope. The project was advertised on Meetup.com which is how I found it, and there were other similar projects that met up weekly. If you paid a membership fee though you got 24/hr access so I met a person there outside of academia who was using the lab's resources to continue the neuroscience research he had done for his PhD.

In the bay area I also know of CounterCulture [2] which I've only heard high praise of but I've never visited. I've since moved to Baltimore and found some places I wanted to check out but unfortunately because of Covid I've been stuck at home.

[1] https://biocurious.org/ [2] https://www.counterculturelabs.org/

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by gww on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:27PM (#26126511)
If you haven't seen it Lior Pachter at CalTech has been sharing open source / 3d printable designs for lab equipment [1].

[1] https://twitter.com/lpachter/status/1354955229532360707

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dmitryminkovsky on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:48PM (#26129780)
Thank you!
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dmitryminkovsky on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:45PM (#26129766)
Thanks for sharing. I'm in Baltimore, too. Please post these places if you have a chance. Would love to check them out when possible. Searching the web, I have found https://bugssonline.org/.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:44PM (#26157905)
Hey, sorry for taking so long to respond to this.

When I moved here I made a list of hacker spaces that were both general and biology-focused. I thought I had found more that were focused on bio but unfortunately I think you're right, for biosciences it's only Baltimore Underground Science Space.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by acomjean on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:55PM (#26127794)
In Cambridge MA there is Bos Lab: (microbiology).

https://www.boslab.org/

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dmitryminkovsky on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:13AM (#26132134)
Thank you!
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by dehrmann on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:59AM (#26130484)
I had a 2.97 cumulative GPA. I never did this, but someone told be to put 3.0, and if anyone ever challenges me on it, say "significant figures."
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by gruez on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:53PM (#26129233)
>Also, the Wright Brothers didn't need a research lab to invent flight.

That's only because all the low hanging fruits were still not picked, right? Many discoveries during that time and in the centuries before were done by individuals rather than institutions.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by icelancer on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:49PM (#26129501)
>> That's only because all the low hanging fruits were still not picked, right?

There's plenty of low hanging fruit as the industry grows wide.

While any given industry is subject to the asymptotic curve of progress, innovations in human biology have been incredibly slow due to bureaucracy and IRB slowdowns + grant model.

Human-powered flight wasn't considered a really good idea at the time of the Wright Brothers either, and many people died in the decades following it. It's only in hindsight these ideas seem obvious.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by deepnotderp on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:49AM (#26130017)
“Everything has already been invented” -1921 and 2021, some things don’t change ;)
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by GlennS on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:56PM (#26129534)
So I'm no in the US so not familiar with your GPA system, but couldn't you just take one more class which you knew you'd do well at to push that over the line?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:34PM (#26129714)
Yup, and I did consider it. But another semester of college just to boost my GPA would've been expensive. I don't have regrets how things turned out, but point is my story is common
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by im3w1l on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:09AM (#26129867)
Sounds like you weren't that motivated in the first place. Could have been a blessing in disguise to meet at hurdle sooner rather than later.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#26134406)
Hah, I'm still motivated but I was also pretty aware of the other comments being made here about higher education at the time (excessively political, funding sparse, job search difficulties for bio fields). I was lucky enough to get a scholarship for 4 years of undergrad and graduated with low debt. The extra semester would have doubled my debt with no guarantee I'd be better off after.

I know things I could've done or could do now if I wanted to go back, but I think I'm more interested at the moment in how to make the research I want to do more accessible.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by Larrikin on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:38AM (#26129983)
Not having financial means to waste more time in college has no bearing on the person's motivation.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ginger_beer_m on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:56PM (#26128266)
Could you share what are these bio hacker spaces, for example?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by slumdev on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:27PM (#26127095)
> GPA was 0.023 too low to pass the automated filters

Your application was most likely reviewed by real people, not just automated filters. People with GPAs below 3 do get into competitive grad programs (and med school). An upward trend is the key.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by lumost on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:49PM (#26127296)
I'm sure this happens to some people with the right combination of luck, perseverance, and recommendations. It's probably far more likely at your current institution as you already have relationships with professors who sit on the admissions committee. Particularly if you are already productive in a lab and the principal researcher goes to bat for you.

That doesn't change the OPs point that this is an uphill battle. If they didn't have the above, or they could only get into the right program then it still leaves them with better alternatives elsewhere. Harvard almost certainly filters all candidates with a GPA less than 3.0. Unfortunately academic grades have a poor correlation with future career or research performance.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by huijzer on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:33PM (#26127153)
Maybe indeed. Maybe not. It‘s probably more nuanced and random than that.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by idrios on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:25PM (#26134156)
Ah.. I don't think this comment deserved to be downvoted. I did actually have one place reach out -- a lab at U of Toronto. But they asked if I was international and when I said yes (USA) they apologized and said they didn't have funding to sponsor an international student. But yeah, all the other schools were faceless rejections
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:25PM (#26126484)
The grant system completely compromises most faculty'$ ability to do anything with their decades of training besides sell themselves. Especially young faculty during their most productive years. The only way to turn this around is to change the way we give credit for scientific achievements, and stop rewarding "I wrote the grant" With authorships. (Im ex faculty)
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by timr on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:36PM (#26127646)
> The grant system completely compromises most faculty'$ ability to do anything with their decades of training besides sell themselves.

I agree that the academic world is broken, but this narrative that success -- in any field -- isn't dependent on your ability to sell yourself is problematic.

I left academia behind because I saw that it was a brutal, improbable grind, sure, but mainly because I could see that the same skills needed for success as a professor had a much higher expected value elsewhere. In academia or otherwise, disproportionate success comes to those who combine ability with self-promotion. The people who put their heads down and focus on obscure problems will always be at the mercy of the winds.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by josephg on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:49PM (#26127738)
> but this narrative that success -- in any field -- isn't dependent on your ability to sell yourself is problematic.

Some people make fantastic researchers and are terrible at selling themselves and their work. It seems like a bad deal for everyone if these people are blocked from making contributions to science.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by etrautmann on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:57PM (#26127803)
Yes - the idea that everyone in science must be a fantastic Jack or Jill of all trades is absurd. There is no room for oddballs that are missing any of 20 subtle skills, including many social ones that should have little to do with research skill. Incentivizing teams to succeed instead of individuals is essential for reforming our current broken system.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by usrusr on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:19PM (#26128417)
The question is what would be the alternative to grant applications. A grant lottery?Tenure lottery? Stop funding entirely and just include "dear God, make our science advance" in your evening prayer? Nobody considers the grant treadmill an achievement to be proud of, but arguments against the claim that it's the least bad solution have to go beyond just "it's not good".
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:41PM (#26128551)
How about actually measuring them by the citation count on their papers (note this is already a minor factor in tenure decisions, after monies brought in :P )
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by cycomanic on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:44AM (#26130674)
The thing is, you're trying to create a metric that measures an essentially unmeasureable quantity and to predict future outcomes on this.

Moreover you're trying to do this for generally very smart people, so obviously they adapt their behaviour to those metrics (they game the system is a less favourable way of saying this). So the only thing you have achieved that the academics change their work to maximize those metrics. We have seen this with grants as well, to be successful you essentially have to write lots of grant (a period without grants can be career ending), so academics spend up to 50% of their time on grant writing and reviewing. At this point I'm not convinced a lottery would not be a better way of distributing money (and I say that as someone who has been fairly successful at getting grants)

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jltsiren on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:46AM (#26130011)
Citations are cheap, and they are being gamed all the time. It's like search engine optimization, but on a smaller scale.

Grants are one of the least bad means of evaluating a researcher, because the decisions are not made lightly. Getting funded usually implies that experts have spent a nontrivial amount of time judging the merits of the applicant and their ideas and found them particularly worthy.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:14AM (#26130113)
Having gotten grants including the NSF career award. I respectfully disagree lol.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by mcguire on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:46PM (#26129486)
Has a bit of a problem for them as don't have many papers yet.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by timr on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:30PM (#26135973)
> Some people make fantastic researchers and are terrible at selling themselves and their work. It seems like a bad deal for everyone if these people are blocked from making contributions to science.

Sure...lots of people make fantastic technical workers, and are terrible at selling themselves and their work. I'm not denying their existence. I'm saying that academia is an organization made up of humans, and as such, has the same bias toward self-promotion and social skills as any other field. At the end of the day, people make the decision of who get to be professors, get grants, and so on. Success in an academic discipline, for most people, is about being known, liked and respected amongst the small circle of colleagues who dominate that discipline.

The mythology I am combatting here is that academia was ever this magical unicorn land where introverts and brilliant weirdos can prosper. It happens more often than some fields, I guess, but mostly the same social dynamics apply. It's kind of the same wishful thinking you see from brilliant engineers who can't work on a team -- they invariably stop progressing, and wonder why they don't get promoted up the technical ladder. They can still contribute in the area of their greatest skill, but they're limited in the long run by their social abilities.

It's really common to see brilliant people with no interpersonal skills wash out in grad school. It's almost a cliché. The ones who do make it, rarely advance to a professorship -- they'll get stuck at postdoc or staff scientist or something like that, because some professor is more than willing to keep them around, hidden in the lab, for their exceptional technical skill.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by UncleMeat on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:34PM (#26128499)
Yes, but how do you identify these people? The whole grant process is trying to find these people and give them money.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:40PM (#26128542)
If we weren't paying every mafioso at harvard 200k/yr in summer salary, we could fund a good number of them at subsistence wage. (note: there are also many decent people at harvard...)
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:35PM (#26128514)
It's true one must advocate for one's self. It's not true that we should choose structures that require more self promotion than productivity. Academia used to be rife with corners where obscure problem solvers could live a decent life. The pressure for grant monies and summer salaries have done away with those corners and it shouldn't be so.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by mcguire on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:16PM (#26129630)
On one hand, I've heard E. Allen Emerson (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._Allen_Emerson) complain that he was hoping with tenure he'd be able to just go off and work on whatever interested him.

On the other...there is no other hand.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by lumost on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:43PM (#26127235)
I wonder how much of the rise of modern "pop-sci" as a genre in writing, film, and tv is due to the current academic incentives. If you're so good at selling yourself and field why not take the pitch directly to a paying audience rather than grant committees?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by SCUSKU on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:39PM (#26127679)
While at first I balked at this idea, I suppose what you're proposing is crowdsourcing academic research funding. Naturally, the first thing that comes to mind is how accountability can be managed. One of the major pitfalls of the crowdfunding model seems to be that the fundraisers can make like bandits with the money, with seemingly little recourse, or incentive for the crowd.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by lumost on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:16PM (#26127960)
I don't think that I was proposing crowdfunding for science, but rather that the incentives in modern academia would give rise to modern popular science figures as those most able to secure funding. It's likely not the healthiest situation for actual discovery.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:10PM (#26135789)
There's still this:

https://experiment.com

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by laretluval on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:04PM (#26127413)
> stop rewarding "I wrote the grant" With authorships.

How could this work? If you have more grant money you have more resources to write papers.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:29PM (#26127601)
Many faculty getting the most funding are never involved in writing the papers attributed to them. (Source: years spent at the top five universities and my own faculty experience)

Would work simply: fund students directly. If faculty contribute training or ideas students can grant authorship. Faculty/postdocs still peer review papers.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by rsfern on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:16PM (#26128399)
I really like this idea of funding students directly, I feel like it’s pretty well aligned with e.g. the NSF’s mission wrt workforce development, and it reduces the power imbalance for students who find themselves in a toxic group environment

I guess there’s still a need for bigger grants because some labs cost more than others to run, but those grants could cover the cost of equipment and materials without having to directly cover student salaries.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @07:37PM (#26128522)
Yeah. I think simply making faculty apply for infrastructure and only funding students and no faculty time is the right way to go. Unfortunately this is the opposite of the way that the NSF is being propelled (since panels are dominated by 'eminent scientists' ~= well connected old lazy scientists)
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by JadeNB on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:32PM (#26129150)
> If faculty contribute training or ideas students can grant authorship.

I don't know a particularly good way to get around this issue and still reward faculty for collaboration with students, but, in this situation, faculty are just going to pressure students to 'recognise' their (the faculty's) contributions with an authorship—say, by threatening to withhold a recommendation letter.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by alpineidyll3 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:11PM (#26129600)
That threat is always there, these changes would only put more power into student's hands.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by Al-Khwarizmi on Sunday February 14, 2021 @05:35AM (#26131144)
> The only way to turn this around is to change the way we give credit for scientific achievements, and stop rewarding "I wrote the grant" With authorships. (Im ex faculty)

I totally agree with your diagnosis of the problem, but I don't see how your proposed solution would solve anything.

First of all, grants are needed to do any meaningful research and advance one's careers in most fields, authorship or no authorship. So the incentive to spend a disproportionate amount of time selling oneself would still be there.

Second, as you yourself imply, the reasons why young faculty don't take a more active role in research are (mostly) not voluntary, it's because they are forced into the grant treadmill. I don't see why they deserve punishment (in the form of fewer authorships) on top of that. They're already overworked getting the grants and you want them to spend more hours in the lab to get authorships in addition?

Third, how do you even police authorships? Especially when a person has a position of power due to having the funding with which other people in the lab are hired. There are already guidelines from scientific societies that in theory don't allow people who just obtained the funding to claim authorship, but people do it anyway. Even if someone complained, they can claim that they actually contributed (e.g. by going through the paper, checking and polishing for correctness) and it's very hard to disprove.

I think the solution has to be to the tune of (1) funding purely based on past CV, not projects (spare us all the effort of convincing reviewers that what we're going to do is the bee's knees, and drawing fictional Gantt charts when in research it's practically impossible to predict anything. If we have produced relevant results in the past, we will probably keep producing them); (2) flatter funding (reward better CVs with better funding, but keep decent enough funding for everyone to keep feedback loops at bay and not throw people that got unlucky with experiments under the bus); and (3) individual funding for everyone instead of a large chunk of funding that goes to the head of the lab.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by gww on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:10PM (#26126353)
It's a hard and frustrating career. I work on an academic lab but the chances of me having an independent research program are very low. However, everyone who wants something from you -- especially your PI -- will string you along in the hope you will stick to your low paying job. I am trying to find a better job in industry but the jobs I see posted tend to be for data science (I am not a strong stats person) or too junior for my experiences.Finding the right fit is very hard when my contact network is limited to clinicians and academics that tend to have anti-industry sentiments.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by mlinhares on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:22PM (#26128793)
It might be better for you to take the hit now and land a junior job and progress from that than continue to wait for the perfect job to arrive.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by joe_the_user on Sunday February 14, 2021 @12:38AM (#26129984)
A job being "too junior" for someone often means they can't get it even if they want it - the organization is looking for someone with little experience who is presumably young and can rise through the ranks.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:51AM (#26130466)
And willing to do it as a postdoc making too little to pay rent without more housemates than there are bedrooms in the house. Everyone needs a first job I guess, to learn how much more they're worth than they got paid in their first job?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by gww on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:27AM (#26132207)
I have already done the post-doc part. It was so painful that I really don't want to do a second one. There's that glass ceiling in academia when it comes to respect and salary they is very hard to break through without being promoted to a full PI and given your own lab.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:49AM (#26130457)
Postdoc pay is ridiculous, I had a job I was really interested in but the second they said it was a postdoc all I could hear was "this will not pay the rent". I don't get it. Urban universities are just so preferred that they can pay the same amount or less than a university in a lower rent town. It only makes sense if you're getting a giant reputational or career boost, or have personal reasons.

I dunno. I'm about where you are I guess. Stuff is either too junior or the stuff I want to do is just enough outside my field that it's hard to figure out who to talk to. It's depressing, even moreso now where you have to really work at it to "run into people".

The best I've ever figured out is to take the thing I'm really good at, and find places that happen to need that but also do the thing I want to learn. It doesn't work great. I guess I suggest conferences but I wouldn't go to one during COVID... I'm bad at this I guess though.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by gww on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:28AM (#26132218)
I have the same problem. COVID has made it much harder. I finally have some decent publications and was hoping to go to some of the bigger Cancer Genomics conferences this year to try to build a network but it's not the same when it's a virtual meeting.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:01PM (#26127847)
I wouldn't call myself a casualty, but I was definitely considering being a professor and definitely decided not to after seeing how ridiculously hard my adviser had to work despite her being famous and well funded.

It just didn't seem like a job that one could do for decades without ruining their health. I'm amazed by the people who do manage to do it, but I'm confident that my decision was the right one.

Instead, someone else will be the person to study how to use ML to develop new catalyst types, and I'm sad that all the thought and effort I've put into figuring it out will probably just never be of use to anyone. I'm not a good enough programmer for Google, so basically what other option would I have other than academia or a national lab? The problem isn't going to be solved in five years, but the rewards... maybe not mRNA vaccine level but reducing energy and resource waste with more efficient conversion technologies across the entirety of modern civilization seems worthwhile.

I don't even mind writing grants that much and have gotten lots of them for industry research. And I absolutely love mentoring. But I just know from what I saw that I have no desire to try to handle that much entirely unnecessary extra stress, even though it means that I do mostly straightforward electrical engineering despite having invented entirely new catalyst design technologies being used in industrial facilities.

Would I love to still be working in chemicals and energy more directly? Absolutely! Am I willing to do it for a third the salary with 80 hour work weeks having to scramble desperately to network in order to gain enough mindshare to get people to even listen to my proposals? I wish I had that kind of stamina.

Which is to say, ultimately, that I have no interest in academic politics. I want to solve these problems, and no longer have the energy to pursue another startup.

Maybe in another five years when there are more companies finally doing it I can just get a job there. Sadly I can guess that they will instead just get ML researchers and assume teaching them catalyst science will be easier than teaching me ML tools because ML didn't exist when I was in grad school as much of a thing yet so by sheer misfortune of timing I didn't learn it until my 30s.

It's just sad to me that I see no realistic way to get involved even though it's my honest life passion to fix this problem and it's such a stupid struggle to get support. It would have been really nice to feel supported in doing such work inside of academia.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by rsfern on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:15PM (#26128747)
If you’re looking to get back into the materials research industry doing applied ML, now is a great time — no need to wait five years. In my experience there’s a lot of demand for people conversant in both fields, a lot of interest in adopting this kind of work, and a growing set of interesting opportunities.

I work in this field at a national lab, but in my experience there are a lot of industry players trying to figure out how to grow in this area

Edit: take a look at what the technical societies are doing. MRS and TMS have been rolling out educational programming targeted towards industry members. I’m not in the catalyst field really, but I’m sure ACS and AICHE have similar programming, and following that thread is probably a good way to figure out who’s interested

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:41PM (#26128902)
Assuming you are working at PNNL I agree they have a great program. One of the few places I've collaborated with that understood the upsides involved.

I do see more and more educational opportunities and attempts to be forward looking with this. They just always seem super undercooked like setting up an institute to encourage collaborating (but good luck working there at an early stage unless you're already a professor somewhere). Or more often only really open to current PhD students or postdocs if you're not already a professor.

I'll figure it out eventually, I just wish it didn't feel like I have to bootstrap the whole thing to get anything to happen.

I'm just sad that now that it might finally be possible for anyone to lead such an effort I don't have the stamina to do it.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by twic on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:19PM (#26125934)
Same. With a side of seeing senior scientists whose work was mediocre but who were well-connected surviving, while seeing senior scientists whose work was good failing to renew their grants.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by yurlungur on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:05PM (#26129276)
Grant writing was also one of the aspects that most discouraged me from pursuing an academic career as well. I witnessed first hand the stress it induced in even the most capable professors and the level of result oriented thinking it mandated throughout the scientific process. Being a professor is a bit like being a lead contractor for NIH and NSF. If you want the resources (money) you need to chase where the fad is at. Failing that you will have to do a lot of teaching just to sustain yourself, and will cause your grad students to have a bad time throughout their career in your lab.

With all that said...the amount of academic freedom even within this flawed system is still greater than most other places I know of. Perhaps if you are a distinguished researcher working on your own terms and funded by one of the big tech companies things are better.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jseliger on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:30PM (#26126544)
I have met other casualties of this, and meeting them when I was teaching undergrads inspired me to write https://jakeseliger.com/2012/04/17/how-to-think-about-scienc...
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by benibela on Saturday February 13, 2021 @06:09PM (#26127903)
I have been writing a grant proposal for months

I am also supposed to have finished it months ago, but I really have no idea what I should write there. The current grant from my PI expires in two weeks, and then I have no funding

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by tomcam on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:51PM (#26128949)
I have absolutely nothing to contribute, other than to say I’m sorry you’re in that position I’m pulling for you. My very best to you.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by kaitai on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:48PM (#26126737)
Yep, I finally landed my first grant as a co-PI two months after I left academia for corporate data sci. Amusingly, or whatever, of the three grants I had up for review as a co-PI or contributor, two finally got funded -- but I was gone.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by api on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:13PM (#26128741)
I too considered the academic route and had some very interesting, concrete, and I think useful ideas of what to study. I was discouraged from it by existing Ph.D's who warned me about how absolutely brutal the system is and how hard it is to do anything.

I'd say we've bureaucratized science to death.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by cosmodisk on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:49AM (#26130930)
I would love to do something meaningful, be it research or similar activity but I can't imagine constantly working knowing that the carpet can be pulled from underneath my feet any minute or that I constantly need to do political ballet at some university to make my living. It looks that there are thousands upon thousands in similar situations.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by rtkaratekid on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:47PM (#26128935)
I had this shift as well. I met a prof who did some really cool research I was interested in but ultimately lost funding. His lab and basically his entire career went down the drain.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by avereveard on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:06PM (#26126927)
it's worse than that, especially at the beginning it is not your ability to receive grants that matters, but the ability to sycophant for the person that control the grant flows.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by de6u99er on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:38PM (#26126081)
I got hired after helping an external consultant at my student job. I solved a task I was given one week time, within 2h by writing a simple scriot doing all the work. I only had to fix some few edge cases manually.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by amelius on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:55PM (#26127346)
I wonder when academia will be a thing of the past. These days, sadly, most research is performed in companies anyway.