News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by crawfordcomeaux on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:28PM (#26129132)
I'm working to create a community model with a communal research lab. It's meant to meet my needs as a researcher while also removing pressures/norms from capitalism, colonialism, and imperialism. What do you want to research and what's in your way?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:39PM (#26129440)
I've heard this dream a few times, and have had it myself. Hazardous waste disposal and storage. This is the big kicker for any research project I might want to do.

Every other expenses after getting that set up is trivial (in comparison) for an individual researcher, though national lab style shared analytical equipment is nice. That can come later though...

It's really hard. It's much simpler to set up a machine shop or similar, but then it's just a new hackerspace that there are good models for already.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:51PM (#26134968)
>Hazardous waste disposal and storage.

Partner with a hazardous material testing lab, or another type of operation where they use lots of hazardous material similar to yours and end up turning a bit of it into waste themselves.

Not necessarily an environmental lab where they actually test waste, better an industrial lab that tests material.

Some better opportunities can even be with material or waste handlers who have no lab at all.

Hazardous material does not become hazardous waste if you can legitimately sell/ship it off the site as a worthwhile product instead. Otherwise if you need to truly discard excess (even prime chemical assets then become a liability) you need to not only usually pay, but bump your paperwork and liability up from merely dangerous goods to full waste documentation requirements.

Ideally, as a scientific consultant (giving free advice only) once you get on the toxic site where yours is a drop in the bucket by comparison, you will be able to identify recycling opportunities worth way more to them than the cost of properly disposing of your paltry amount by the established registered professionals, according to the specific arcane regulations in place which you value their expertise for. They will love you.

So you can get the best deal possible.

Don't just recycle the equipment, recycle the chemicals.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @06:38PM (#26137380)
> Hazardous material does not become hazardous waste if you can legitimately sell/ship it off the site as a worthwhile product instead. Otherwise if you need to truly discard excess (even prime chemical assets then become a liability) you need to not only usually pay, but bump your paperwork and liability up from merely dangerous goods to full waste documentation requirements.

This is what I meant. For a small organization I would expect a lot of small volume experimental products that are not exactly known in composition combined with perhaps some rinse acetone or other solvents.

Have you encountered an example where this works? I've done consulting for startups in exchange for a fume hood before, so I guess it's not that out there. It's much harder to imagine doing this for a big hazardous waste site, but maybe?

Thanks for the idea, I definitely won't be trying to do that but maybe there could be a symbiotic thing going on there. Probably a lot easier to do that with a university somehow? A national lab will be too stuck up to accept hazardous waste or advice, but maybe a university would hire you part time to work for them while letting you use the space for your own project.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:08AM (#26139638)
Yup, I'm moving toward "retiring" from my employer and doing without a lab for a bit as I decide to get back into more action than the employer can muster.

I'll be able to maintain a good relationship with them and if I do go back into private practice nearby they will be able to handle the few liters a month I would expect to generate single-handedly.

Which is a drop in the bucket of their few drums, which are a drop in the bucket of the EPA waste hauler's truckloads.

Unknowns-R-Us.

OTOH the only time I went without a lab I built, was 2013 and I was tempted to try and operate in some vacant small-university space in my late father's retirement location, but I did not have the resources to _branch out_ while I still had my main lab in mothballs.

Things were also very uncertain plus one of the surplus spaces had already been unfavorably occupied by a not-very-well liked commercial EPA testing lab that I think failed just a year or two earlier and left everyone involved with a bad impression.

Now after recovering a bit from natural disaster, I'm going to check out UH where they took over the old Schlumberger facility as part of their energy effort a number of years ago. It still seems not fully occupied but I'll find out for sure eventually. Before the internet I sure spent a lot of time in the UH library.

When it comes to an actual university operation though, about half the time when I check out a chem department's equipment it looks like they sure could use some help from someone with more than just a few years on the gear, and often so underequipped I could bring in & restore the surplus electonics to double their capabilities within a year not much differently than at a commercial lab. Also without a PhD there are actually some long-term employment or career positions already funded which could be conformed creatively to this effort. If I did this I would want to hit successive universities since I am very fast, but I am mainly retiring from employment more so than my present employer's facility which I expect to routinely continue to visit as long as I am in their areas, to our mutual advantage.

I started out as a teenage businessman anyway so I'm not worried about going forward with only a briefcase again.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:43PM (#26145718)
> When it comes to an actual university operation though, about half the time when I check out a chem department's equipment it looks like they sure could use some help from someone with more than just a few years on the gear, and often so underequipped I could bring in & restore the surplus electonics to double their capabilities within a year not much differently than at a commercial lab. Also without a PhD there are actually some long-term employment or career positions already funded which could be conformed creatively to this effort. If I did this I would want to hit successive universities since I am very fast, but I am mainly retiring from employment more so than my present employer's facility which I expect to routinely continue to visit as long as I am in their areas, to our mutual advantage.

This is basically my part time job now, I help maintain a university lab including things like repairing ancient equipment, training grad student TAs, helping the lecturers plan and run their experiments, and then just random grad students and professors drop in for advice and help. It's pretty fun.

What I don't do is take advantage of the fact that I have a chem lab attached for any personal work, I've never actually thought to ask. I have asked about setting up a catalyst test reactor lab to collaborate with the college of computing to see if we can build a testing lab for anyone creating new catalysts to analyze the results and invent new types. There were too many professors with a vested interest in doing that kind of project so they had no interest in supporting it.

It was very disappointing to see, I'd have been happy to run a test facility for all the professors to work with as a shared experimental facility but they all wanted to be the one to get the papers first. The minor consideration to me of being able to do some of my own research projects with the setup and a salary is all I'd have wanted out of it, I love mentoring students and would have loved to provide deep expertise to students working on such projects...

Could have made three departments able to produce high quality research in a field that no one here seems to actually be good at (i.e. traditional heterogeneous catalysts) with ChemE, MatSci, and CompSci all benefiting from the ability to generate large reliable datasets of how new catalytic materials behave in traditional chemical reactors. So cheap to set up too... just such a shame that I cannot do such a project at the place I work despite having been the director of chemical process development and specifically catalyst development at previous jobs. Ostensibly because professors are already doing it in their labs, but like, why would you not take advantage of expertise like mine to make these projects work?

So bizarre but I just don't have the stamina to push them on it, I probably literally just have to switch job titles for them to even notice that I am in fact a world class expert on catalysts and chemical processing. Instead I'm repairing oscilloscopes which is super fun but I sure miss doing actual research that matters.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ramraj07 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:14AM (#26130117)
That's great! Honestly I'm still navigating more pressing existential crises (like which country and then city to set roots in, if I even have a choice) but after that the plan is to embrace fields that are amenable for cheap amateur experimentation. In that regards, I have some connectomics projects with c. Elegans in mind, followed by evolution with basic cell lines. Depending on answers to aforementioned crises I was planning to be near some big univs so I can mooch off of their inventory control auctions and core facilities as need be and go from there! However if there's actually communities of similar minded people that'll only be great since it'll expand the no. Of topics I can dabble in (which is precisely what you can never ever do in academia contrary to whatever crap they peddle to get you into the system).
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by crawfordcomeaux on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @12:49PM (#26156610)
Here's what I want: a lab to experiment with these findings (https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-018-0078-7)in a 3D colonies from the perspective of encoding various structures from human culture (particularly the community housing the lab) and seeing how the microbes address different perturbations. And then remodeling the community's culture based on whatever findings are uncovered to test the relationship between human and microbial cultures. Or remodel the cultural blueprint within some communal space to see how it works with the outside world. Or...I don't know. There are so many ways to play with culture in this way.

We're tackling the question of where to live, too. I find it useful to identify my values & then to use that to filter my options. Choosing based on availability of resources tends to lead to all kinds of blindspots in my experience. We're also trying to figure out how the community model can work without moving and what the process looks like for building it out where anyone is. The approach I'm going for right now is to identify the exact spaces and ways of relating to them I want, creating an absurdly long organization name with all those words in the name, and a mission of "evolve the name" or something similar, short, and simple.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:16PM (#26135236)
I find the surplus equipment from universities is not usually sent to _asset recovery_ (auctioned off) until it is older and more worn out compared to industrial operations.

So I always wanted (always did) have my lab in a heavy industrial area.

For biotech the US area of New Jersey and Connecticut has a high concentration of pharma giants and their many satellite contractors.

One business model has been to become enough of a contractor yourself to pay the bills, then research all you want and own it all yourself.

Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacquesm on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:32AM (#26130400)
I love this idea. A 'lab space' instead of a maker space. If someone is going to do this in NL then I'd be happy to help fund it.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by fuzzfactor on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:01PM (#26134495)
Are you near Rotterdam?
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by jacquesm on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:20AM (#26140376)
Hilversum
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by kayhi on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:06PM (#26129285)
For most it is the start up costs.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by the_only_law on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:08PM (#26129296)
Yeah I tend to browse eBay and other resellers looking for old engineering / scientific equipment and even for obsolete stuff it often still resells pretty high.
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by ramraj07 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:16AM (#26130130)
The way I think about it, people own boats, and this still can be cheaper than that hobby!
Re:Our brutal science system almost cost us a pioneer of mRN... by neltnerb on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:37AM (#26130414)
I guess not if they live in them?

https://www.instructables.com/How-to-Get-a-Free-Yacht/

I love this one.