And on the topic, I can also promise you that they do in fact know about the concept of capacity factor and that the sun doesn't always shine and the wind doesn't always blow.
And on the topic of France, their reactors oveheat the river they use for cooling and have to shutdown. And just as you claim you can't soley consider the cost of a plant, you can't solely consider the smokestack emissions of a plant without consider the mining, enrichment, handling, and disposal of nuclear.
Germany has a large CO2 output because they have a large manufacturing industry, and for policy reasons technically decoupled from their investment in solar, they also maintain production capacity of a dirty type of coal as power source because they have it in abundance within their own borders, its a security interest.
If you think your armchair analysis has outsmarted the energy industry then go ahead and invest in fossil and nuclear i guess.
When the Swedish government shut down a nuclear reaction the political promise were a greener power grid that polluted less. What we instead got was a oil power plant in the southern part of Sweden that previous only operated as a backup in case of harsh cold winters. Now it is operating all year because it suddenly became commercial viable to do so.
For long I have advocated that the solution to this disconnect between what is being said and what actually happens is laws. No new fossil fueled power plants, and no extended capacity by fossil fueled power plants. One do not need to be pro-nuclear, nor pro-solar or pro-wind. All that is needed is an expanding energy demand, a aging nuclear power plants, and a law that forbid people to use the easy but environmentally damaging alternative. Smart people in the energy industry can figure out what is the cheapest alternative that does not warm up the planet, and politician can stop trying to sell an untruth.
They fought Clinton, Illinois’ nuclear plant for decades. The locals were uneasy because it’s on a recreational lake. The lobby for it dismissed the concerns of the uneducated rabble and built it anyway.
An amoeba that causes encephalitis grew in the heat from the cooling plant. Nobody was allowed to swim there anymore. There’s not a lot to do in the middle of the Plains States if you aren’t in a metropolitan area. Swimming and boating are two of your options.
Fusion, fission, geothermal all dump between one and two units of heat at the source for every two units they push down a power line (which is mostly turned into heat at the destination and a little along the way). In the big picture, all of them are bad pairings with global warming.
And hydro reservoirs boost methane emissions.
I can't find any references to cases of amebic encephalitis from that lake either, only a study stating that the amoeba was found in the lake both before and after the plant became operational. Their own website touts its swimming opportunities. Can you cite sources for any of your claims?
https://www2.illinois.gov/dnr/Parks/Activity/Pages/ClintonLa...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinton_Lake_(Illinois)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinton_Power_Station
https://www2.illinois.gov/dnr/Parks/About/Pages/ClintonLake....
I got it from regional news, at the time. If building a lake is how you bribe people into doing something they don't want to do, and then you take the lake away, then from their perspective you've lied.
There are other ways to build a cooling plant for a nuclear power station, btw. Lots of places make them do that now, because dumping the heat back into the environment instead of into the sky causes far more mundane problems than this. And occasionally weirder ones. And since the thesis was about heat pollution, not regional nuclear politics, I'll thank you not to nitpick.
No, it's not like Gell-Mann amnesia at all.
It really feels like you're pushing a particular narrative, facts be damned.
Apparently they started building this based on nuclear power plants as well in Russia (Woronesch, Nischni Nowgorod), but gave it up. That would've been a bit creepy, to have a pipe straight from the local reactor to your home...
Comparing tradeoffs is what we should be doing, but it's really frustrating when people just pretend that their favorite technology doesn't have the tradeoffs.
A lake somewhere being unswimmable is a small price to pay for a livable world.
And if lakes are or aren’t really local, rivers sure as hell are not.
Of course they know, but I don't care about what they know, I care about what they say and if it's true or not!
Are the headline figures fudged by neglecting storage or including subsidies? Or is the headline legitimate, and solar can actually stand on its own now?
It seems to me that if a group of people who were once so vehemently against nuclear for decades (few people were more vocal in opposition to it) finally realized that their fight against climate change simply isn't practical without nuclear, then why are some people still so against it?
You couldn't ask for a more powerful endorsement than the one from nuclear's (former) greatest critic.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertbryce/2020/08/23/after-48...
Well, con-men also know that they sell BS, and what exactly is in the snake oil that they sell, but they still push it...
Some nuclear reactor were shutdown to protect fish in the river in a summer during a heatwave because they had no cooling tower.
Nuclear reactor with cooling tower were fine. And current solar panels are less efficient when it's hot.
You dismiss CO2 per kWh because you say the whole lifecycle of the nuclear plant and it's fuel should be taken in account. Well it is already.
The way you word this it sounds like renewables == bad, when in reality Germany is burning a boat load of coal which is causing the extra emissions, while France’s emissions are offset because they have lots of Nuclear power.
Nuclear power takes 20-50 years to come online- it’s too late to rely on it and burn fossil fuels in the mean time. That ship sailed long ago.
That ship was sunk.
Germany had a lot of nuclear power, and decided shut it down. That is why Germany is producing so much CO₂.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_phase-out#German...
No, they really didn't. At its height it accounted for barely 20%. It was dwarfed by coal, lignite and natural gas. It was never anything like France that went all in with nuclear.
Since then, German consumption has exploded, yet the non-renewables have stayed about static while virtually all new demand is met with renewables.
Edit: „Deal with it“ might have been a snarky way to say it but on a serious note - nothing good comes from regretting missed opportunities forever. Get over them and make the best of the situation.
South Korea builds nuclear plants in less than 5 years on average.
https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/article/2027347/south-korea-s...
The point is that unfortunately renewables == good is not often true either despite the common perception. It all depends on how they integrate with the rest of the grid which is something rarely considered when I hear speeches about having more and more renewables in the future
Once you decided to stop nuclear and go wind/solar, what do you do when it's 8pm in winter and there is no wind? => You fire up your coal/gas plants
The answer could be "storage" but right now, as you can see from the stats, this option is not favored and I believe there are good reasons. As you can imagine, if storage was an easy solution today, Germany's emissions would be much smaller.
Hopefully it becomes a more viable solution in the near future but at the moment we're still far from it
And you seem to be attributing the CO2 emissions to the renewables, but that's in no way fair. Even if we had the solution to energy storage, you'd expect a country switching from coal to renewables to have high emissions even at the half-way point.
> So, no, large scale solar power is neither cheap nor clean.
It's more complex than headlines would lead you to believe. But that's ALWAYS the case. This conclusion is just as dumb as the headlines, if not even dumber.
You're right that storage and backup is a big factor, but it's a problem that's rapidly being solved.
Have you read articles with scenarios about % electricity stored compared to daily consumption for instance? Are we going to reach any significant number in the next decade?
From this IEA article [1] it is not clear that we're getting close to it fast enough
These are not the same !
The cost you're comparing (0.17€/kWh) includes transmission costs (Enedis + EDF), taxes (CSPE, ...) AND the energy cost (~0.06€/kwh, market rate).
You cannot compare costs between countries like that, because taxes are different and transmission costs too.
You must compare market rate costs (from eex for example).
It is however not that hard to do since the energy market basically operate already on this principle. Energy companies bid on supplying a specific demand in the future, and the bid that is lowest win. That bid also include if I understand it right the cost of transmission. The practical end result is that different companies win the bid depending on all the variations that makes energy production commercial viable. A solar plant that is not producing enough energy because of weather conditions is not going to put in a bid, and thus the fossil fueled power plant wins the bid and the outcome is pollution. The more times fossil fueled power plants win, the more economical incentives there are to build more fossil fueled power plants, and the more pollution we get in the air.
The only way to have a non-polluting power grid is to either outlaw fossil fueled plants from bidding, or make sure that there is always an pollution free alternative that has an economical reason to make a lower bid. Nuclear, renewables, batteries, solar, wind, carbon taxes or what have you, as long as fossil fueled power plants can manage to make the lowest bid we have a problem.
Total price: 30.43 ct/kWh*
Supplier’s cost (23%)
Grid charges (24%)
Renewable energy surcharge (21%)
Sales (value-added) tax (16 %)
Electricity tax (7 %)
Concession levy (5%)
Offshore liability levy (1.3%)
https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/what-german-house...It's also strange to talk about energy cleanliness in the context of nuclear energy yet only bring in C02 when the environmental factors with nuclear extend much beyond C02
Nuclear certainly has a place in baseload generation but new greenfield development is rare and costs skyrocket upon decommissioning. On the other hand Germany is well positioned to take advantage of cost declines in battery storage to solve the intermittency problem. It’s not clear what France does when all of their reactors age out.
Within 10 years, Germany will already have to replace a good half of their renewable capacity so I doubt that assessment will change. That's the next issue which is not often taken into account, those renewables have a very low lifespan.
You also need to factor in that Germany is exporting more power than it imports within a year, primarily to Austria and Switzerland but also a bit to France.
If we do end up building a few thousand large reactors, we will want to switch to waste recycling.
The whole 'no idea what to do with it' is what the antinuclear movement chose to say after stonewalling the permanent disposal work in the USA for years. Very cynical in my opinion especially if you consider existing waste to be imminently hazardous to the biosphere.
I have to challenge you on this statement. Certainly the 1940s Hanford reactor designs were for weapons production, and yes dual use (weapons & commercial power) was briefly considered in the early 1950s, but as early as 1953 it was rejected as an option by the US government, who had enough weapons material production coming from Hanford and projections from Savannah River that there was no justification for more.
Further, the Atomic Energy Commission actually worried that if nuclear power plants became very popular, they didn't want to be stuck with a fixed price contract requirement to buy any excess plutonium.
The Power Demonstration Reactor Program of 1958-1965 was run to find the best reactor for making economical power. It was very open and public. By 1965, light water reactors were offered at cost parity with coal plants and the fleets of today were kicked off.
So, brief mention of dual use was ended in the early 1950s, whereas the designs of today were commercialized in the 1960s.
https://www.hanford.gov/page.cfm/NReactor
But as you say it was not the norm in the US.
(For the record I am very pro-nuclear, but it feels disingenuous to mention solar requires storage but totally ignore nuclear disposal)
And the BN-800 reactor that’s online and in commercial service.
Also, SuperPhénix.
I guess those costs are for future generations and not our problem. (Kind of like CO2)
Most home solar panels have a 10 year warranty so you want to make sure your payback period is less than 10 years.
I believe we should be doing a better job of calculating how much it costs to dispose of those panels once they are no longer working.
Could you please provide a concrete example of a problem of security or maintenance on such facility and with such scenario, what makes you think that it is more likely to happen than any other threats with similar impact our societies face?
They need to be security because they can be stolen and the waste within can be used as a weapon.
When I think about the future and its risks I never think about nuclear waste. I think primarily about global warming and all its consequences: massive migrations, droughts, fires etc.
To me these are way more important because
1) the likelihood is MUCH higher 2) the impact is MUCH higher
"And so we are basically guaranteed to ruin the area where waste is stored at some point in the future"
That logic makes a lot of cheap things cost an effectively infinite amount, like shopping centre security.
A waste storage facility doesn't need armed guards if it isn't being used any more than a shopping centre would. If the facility isn't being used then it can be sealed with a big plug of concrete or something else that has a cost that is small vs. infinity.
Plus there is a decent chance that the dangerous stuff will be a valuable fuel source in 100 years.
As far as I'm aware we are not currently sealing dry casks in concrete and forgetting about them. They need to be maintained and managed.
Then the facilities are probably still in use.
If the waste were sealed underground by a 100m long concrete plug in any access tunnel there isn't going to be a lot of call for guards.
(I guess what you're saying is that rates are effectively zero, and they are, and then the cost is infinite indeed...)
As long as fossil fuels are used however the risk of runaway climate change is a much bigger issue than nuclear waste. The risk of runaway nuclear waste is unlikely.
For the record, the whole of France’s nuclear fuel waste since the 50’s is a 15mx15mx15m cube.
Also, that 40 years numbers is a financial one, not a technical or design one. Some reactors based on the same designs have been validated for 60 years in the US.
That’s the problem with spent fuel: you either toss it, but it’s still recyclable and burnable again or you recycle it, and you’re inevitably left with some bomb grade material that flies in the face of all international agreements of non-proliferation.
Anyhow, CIGEO build still needs to start and how many years of future capacity does it allow for?
Many reactors were designed to run 40-50 years and they’ve been lengthened to procrastinate costly dismantling and maintain production without new builds (which are, at this point, highly uneconomical)
Not for long sadly :( Government policy is to reduce this to 50% by 2035.
If solar power were the cheapest energy source, it would be unilaterally adopted until it's no longer the cheapest option--it's trivial to hook up to the grid, private individuals do it today. Unless of course there is a global conspiracy with the entire energy utility, semiconductor, and financial industry; private individuals; and municipalities to avoid profit seeking behavior.
Profit seeking behavior from the fossil fuel industry is to resist change at all costs. Profit seeking behavior from our politicians here in Australia is to not upset the fossil fuel industry as they are a large source of donations.
However, what most don't know is that the big money (in terms of EBITDA) in the fossil fuel industry is in downstream services, plastics and other carbon products derived from oil. This accounts for around 80.1% of Exxon's Revenue[1] and even more in profit. The goal for Exxon is to reduce reliance of energy from oil to reduce the cost of crude oil and maintain the sticky margins of plastics.
It's for this reason that Exxon has always been in the forefront in carbon economies and taxes [2].
Energy is instead one of the worst businesses to be in, a low-margin commodity, with ever-decreasing margins.
[1] https://www.fool.com/investing/2020/04/16/how-exxonmobil-str... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/09/exxon-mobil-pledges-1-millio...
Solar will only ever be a part of the picture, not the whole thing.
In a recent 400 MW solar farm installed in Texas, I looked at the cost of land in that area, vs. the cost of the solar field. Land was about 1% of the cost. Land is cheap. We have lots of land. We have so much land, we use it for low value things like farming. And land that isn't suitable for farming is even cheaper than that.
So what if you can find one ideal area in North America with enough sunlight to theoretically power the whole world, it's not the point. Can you find a large enough spot of space with consistent enough sunlight in, say, Maine, to power even a single city there?
To counter the calculations of the IEA (who are a world more informed than cbmuser, I'm fairly sure), this guy conflates the entire historic mix of two very different countries, one with a long history of coal, natural gas and lignite (those decreasing as renewables enter the mix).
Can you point me to a grid that runs mainly on solar and wind that’s les than 150gCO2eq/kWh?
France is around 50-60.
Because journalists are not engineers: https://www.epsilontheory.com/gell-mann-amnesia/
“He holds a PhD in biochemistry from Bristol University and previously studied chemistry at Oxford University.”
From the Carbon Brief “about” page. (Click his byline on the linked article and you’ll see he works for Carbon Brief.) https://www.carbonbrief.org/about-us
So he’s a scientist.
Given that you disagree strongly with a well credentialed chemist, are you sure the profession of journalism or the credentials of its practitioners are the issue here?
Also, it’s interesting you linked an article that leans heavily on the authority of Michael Crichton, himself a noted climate change denialist — and a former physician.
It would seem to me poor information and sloppy work crosses many fields. I think anyone who has, say, used very much software in their life would probably agree.
Yes, not an engineer.
Nuclear is the only way fwd, sooner we come to realization better it will be for us.
Solar and wind do lot of eco damage due to low density output.
Yea I don't understand these non-sense which doesn't includes whole system costs.
As cool as PV is, there is a big difference between always-on, modular power source and one that has a variable and intermittent production.
It would be like saying one doesn't need heating in the winter since heat is cheap in the summer.
You cannot compare the cost of an electricity generation system solely based on the cost of the plant technology itself, you always have to take the whole system costs into account.
Solar panels might be cheap, but they are unable to provide a reliable electricity source without backup or storage systems which is what drives the actual costs.
France has 70% nuclear and their kWh costs around 17 Euro cents and causes greenhouse gas emissions of 50 grams of CO2 on average.
Germany has 50% renewables with the kWh at over 31 Euro cents and 400 grams of CO2 on average.
The French energy sector is responsible for 50 million tons of CO2 each year while Germany’s energy sector causes over 350 million tons of CO2 each year.
So, no, large scale solar power is neither cheap nor clean.