News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by kypro on Friday January 22, 2021 @10:30PM (#25879342)
How is this not foreign political interference?

The UK media has been preaching to us about dangers of Russian election interference for years at this point, but simultaneously they seem completely unconcerned that a handful of wealthy Americans how the power to censor popular media outlets, entire political movements and political activists at a whim.

The SWP is massive. I don't know for sure, but I suspect they had millions of followers on Facebook. This isn't some fringe, extremist group by any sane interpretation of those terms.

It seems we're now quickly moving on from just censoring those with extremist political views to simply censoring anyone who who dares express a non-establishment political view online.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by boomboomsubban on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:16AM (#25879880)
>How is this not foreign political interference?

America doesn't "interfere" in elections, it gently persuades people to follow the true democratic path.

Truthfully, it is nothing more than American exceptionalism. Even as our nation spent years outraged over Russian interference, we continued both private and public interference in elections worldwide.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by DSingularity on Saturday January 23, 2021 @01:39AM (#25880206)
Gentle? Is that how we describe 10,000lb bombs over Baghdad?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by littlestymaar on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:22AM (#25880636)
Looks like you've missed the sarcasm.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by DSingularity on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:10AM (#25881439)
I’m just piling on.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by littlestymaar on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:32AM (#25881515)
Poe's law striking again.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by Ygg2 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:43AM (#25881312)
They aren't using nukes.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by boomboomsubban on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @11:43PM (#25924399)
I'd like to thank you for getting the song "Bombs Over Baghdad" stuck in my head again.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by blippage on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:28AM (#25880914)
I hear that their use of Full Metal Democracy helps avoid surgical complications. More importantly, it prevents their democracies from jamming during particularly intense diplomatic negotiations.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by adventured on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:55AM (#25880044)
> Even as our nation spent years outraged over Russian interference

Only a minority of the country was (supposedly) outraged about the mostly non-existent Russian interference.

Most of the US knew it was bullshit the entire time, the Russians had near zero impact on the prior election (amazing how they didn't somehow swing this latest election, given their apparent god-like powers, despite how close it was). Trump's vast popularity showed up again in this latest election, they couldn't even try to hide it behind fake Russian interference. It was nothing more than a politcal ruse, a frame to hold Trump in, which the media almost universally played along with (and simultaneously they won't tag Biden as being controlled by China despite Biden having far closer ties to China than Trump does to Russia). It's the exact same thing they did to Tulsi Gabbard when she dared to go against their agenda. We're all owned by the all-powerful, magical Russians if we go off the acceptable message.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by simonh on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:25AM (#25880392)
If I was American and there was clear proof that Russia had interfered in elections, I don’t care how ineffective it was. I’d want it investigated and stopped.

I’d also rain fire and fury on anyone who interfered with or obstructed those investigations. But that’s me. I suppose caring about free and fair elections in the US is now a partisan issue over there.

For a British conservative that grew up under Reagan/Thatcher it’s all desperately sad and disappointing.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by roenxi on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:06AM (#25880821)
> ... I don’t care how ineffective it was. I’d want it investigated and stopped.

The level of interference to the election was so trivial I doubt you can back that attitude up. At some level of ineffectiveness, having an investigation and stopping the activity is more costly than just ignoring it. Investigations take time, money and it turns out have collateral damage:

Looking at the charges out of the Mueller investigation, for example [0]:

- ~80% of those charged are beyond the reach of the US government and the charges aren't going to be tested. Weak evidence that whatever it was they were doing did anything given the Trump 2020 election counts were pretty similar to/improved on the 2016 counts.

- ~15% of those remaining hadn't done anything wrong until they were hit with process crimes in the investigation itself (counting those with only "false statements" charges + R. Stone).

- ~5% of charges I can't be bothered to read up on, but given that 95% of the charges are scrambling to find a problem I doubt the remainder are all that impressive.

I'm not deeply up to speed on the all 5 of those "false statement" charges - but the one against Flynn were probably politically motivated. They were interviewing him about a call where the investigators already had a transcript of the call. It is unclear why they were charging him for what could be a mismemory of routine diplomacy.

By my reckoning, at least 75% of the charges in the Muller investigation that could actually be prosecuted were crimes that wouldn't have existed except for the Muller investigation! That is a big cost for what turned out to be nothing much. Even if you want to use some sort of irrational strategy as a deterrent the cost is higher than the benefit.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_charges_brought_in_th...

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by simonh on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:27AM (#25880909)
How on earth are you going to find out how effective interference was, or the extent of it, if you don't investigate it?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by roenxi on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:04AM (#25881130)
The same question could be put after every election on a variety of integrity-related issues - and indeed, probably is. The exercise of asking and answering is pretty much strictly political, no matter how much fire and fury the bystanders are raining down.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by sebws on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:10PM (#25888320)
That 15% of charges wouldn't have occurred if they hadn't lied to the investigation. To blame an investigation for people's crimes is bizarre.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by pjc50 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @01:23AM (#25880144)
People went to jail over it. At least until they were pardoned by the president.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by cm2187 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:59AM (#25881104)
For tax fraud and falling into perjury traps. Not for colluding with Russia.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by Taniwha on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:01AM (#25881641)
no one "falls into a perjury trap" - what one does is commit perjury - lie under oath, there's no trap there, all you have to do is tell the truth when you should and you don't get indicted .... in the US you even have the option of pleading the 5th
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by koolba on Saturday January 23, 2021 @08:29AM (#25882048)
If you’re John Brennan you can even lie, under oath, on camera, directly to Congress. The trick is to be deeply connected with the political establishment.

For a reverse example, look at the treatment of Michael Flynn. They weren’t looking into a crime, they were look for one.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by concordDance on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:50AM (#25882593)
IIRC the details of that perjury make it fairly clear that it's the kind of perjury a reasonable normal person could end up doing incidentally. But I last read up on it a couple of years ago so check it out yourself.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by phs318u on Saturday January 23, 2021 @01:54AM (#25880271)
> mostly non-existent Russian interference

This is not true. The Republican-led, bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee found, over the course of their 3.5 year investigation, that there was in fact Russian interference. You can find the actual report (all 5 volumes) here [0]. Alternatively, a TL;DR summary can be found here [1].

> amazing how they didn't somehow swing this latest election

Let's for a moment, assume that the Russians were indeed behind the interference campaign. Having experienced many Democrat and Republican administrations, they would know that neither side of politics has historically been favourably predisposed to firstly Soviet and later Russian geopolitical ambitions. So, why would you bother getting a particular party in power, if both parties present have always been on a unified ticket against you? Answer - you wouldn't. It was never about getting a particular party in power, rather it was about weakening your enemy's unity. In this case, Vladimir Putin can absolutely pat himself on the back, and more than any other world leader in recent decades, truly declare, mission accomplished (if it was indeed a mission). For all Biden's talk of unifying the nation, there is no way that the all of the millions of Qanonistas left scratching their heads over the absence of "The Storm", are going to go back to quietly accepting a two-sided status-quo. The chaos monkey in chief has successfully taken the raw material of a discontented working class, and using tried and true methods [2], shaped a potent political weapon, who importantly now realise they have power. There are now millions of chaos monkeys at loose within the Republic. If that's not a win for enemies of the US, I don't know what is. Do we know for sure whether this was part of a Russian long-term psyops play? I doubt we'll ever know. It's my view that the vast majority of those at the top of the power pyramid in place over the last four years, are almost certainly not Russian operatives or plants or had anything to do with Russia. What they were (and are) is hungry for power. Seeing an opportunity to implement their wet dream neo-neo-con agendas by riding the dragon, they went all-in weakening people's trust in institutions, science, evidence, truth. They were, as Putin might smilingly say, useful idiots. This is my view. I don't believe I'm alone in holding this opinion. But at the end of the day, it's speculation - another conspiracy theory. It's entirely possible that this was a coincidental but very happy set of circumstances for Putin. Either way, it's an outcome that reflects the fact a significant number of people close to the levers of power, played themselves into a position that suited them, and also conveniently suited someone else.

[0] https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/press/senate-intel-relea...

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-russia-senate-f...

[2] https://www.azquotes.com/author/5626-Joseph_Goebbels

[2 Note]: This is not a glib Nazi reference. I believe that many of these quotes represent political axioms, and that those that understand them and are willing to implement them, can, and historically have, achieved great power.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by einpoklum on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:52PM (#25922468)
> The Republican-led, bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee found, over the course of their 3.5 year investigation, that there was in fact Russian interference.

1. It "found", i.e. asserted, that there had been - but no evidence of interference in the elections, nor even covert influence on public opinion, by the Russian government was presented.

2. Of course Russia had some influence the elections: Through RT America, which has significant viewership. This is actually much more influential than the sophomoric Jesus-vs-Satan or Buff-Bernie Facebook memes which much of the investigation focused on.

> You can find the actual report (all 5 volumes) here [0].

I scoured the Muller report, when it came out, looking for the evidence of ussian interference

> Let's for a moment, assume that the Russians were indeed behind the interference campaign

You're already assuming there had been an interference campaign. But there wasn't one.

Also, the term "The Russians" conflates Russian people with the Russian government. This use of plural nouns is nearly always underhanded: "The Americans", "The Jews", "The blacks" - they all must have done something nefarious, they're up to no good, they're a danger to "us" etc.

> it was about weakening your enemy's unity... tried and true methods... enemies of the US... Russian long-term psyops

Ah, back to the cold war.

This kind of rhetoric also emphasizes how the Russia interference conspiracy theory is at the end of the day an internal political tool, to discredit criticism of the political establishment as it veers farther away from public sentiment.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by aquadrop on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:26PM (#25886259)
Yeah, intelligence service of both(and more) countries probably do that kinda of stuff on a regular basis, that's why they exist, but I don't think that had hardly any effect. "Russians, Russians", "Trump is a puppet of Putin" etc was a convenient scapegoat for losing the election. But problem of democrats was not Russians, but the fact that half of the country was ok with voting for Trump. And split was there long before and just growing with time, but Americans are doing great job splitting up themselves. Like with anti-sanders higher up demparty struggle. Both sides are now so politicized they are ready to bend reality and view everything through hate to the opponent.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by jhardy54 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:36AM (#25880447)
Thanks for engaging these folks with well-written comments. They may downvote you for speaking the truth and linking to evidence, but hopefully it will plant a seed.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by cm2187 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:58AM (#25881097)
What I find remarkable is that all the claims of russian/chinese/iranian interferences in US elections suddenly stopped when it became clear Biden won, and we switched to “it’s a perfect election”. It seems that Trump’s warning of not interfering into US elections have worked and the said countries complied. And we were told only weeks before voting day of evidences of those interferences, so I assume they also complied retroactively.

The brave new world of “post-truth”.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by samastur on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:49AM (#25881341)
Claims that the last US election was fair were stated well before it was clear Biden won.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by tim333 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:38AM (#25881791)
>the Russians had near zero impact on the prior election

I'm not American or that bothered by Trump but he only won the swing states by less than 1% and I'd guess it's quite likely the Russian email hacking the the like could have swung it.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:46AM (#25881325)
The SWP is not massive. It's never been massive. Current paid-up membership is maybe four figures.

It's considered eccentric, comically cliched, ineffectual, and frankly irrelevant by virtually everyone on the British left.

It's the very definition of fringe.

Which is why banning the SWP sets a very bad example. Especially when there are far more dangerous organisations on the British far right which Facebook seems happy to host.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by chiefalchemist on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:11AM (#25881679)
So then it would seem, this is a great "beta test" for FB & Co. That is, pick a fringe meaningless group - but one with enough name recognition - and ban them to grease the skids of societal expectations. The group is small and fringe so few will feel the relevance which makes it a fitting target for FB and its ilk to normalize banning.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by notahacker on Saturday January 23, 2021 @11:07AM (#25883232)
Facebook has banned, unbanned and rebanned UK registered minor political parties before. (Britain First, a far right party that was only marginally less hopeless at winning votes than the SWP but very effective at getting Facebook likes back when it still had a page) The world didn't begin in January.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by egwor on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:35AM (#25881778)
Another view is that they're banning it to show that banning organisations according to some policy isn't effective and therefore they shouldn't be policing it 'because, how could they?'.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by ianai on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:22AM (#25881715)
Or it’s the smallish act that reveals FBs true pro-far right bias.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by washadjeffmad on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:52AM (#25881848)
FB skews conservative in content because that's who uses and invests in it, not who staffs it (primarily coastal, urban elites).

There have been numerous stories about FB employees lifting their noses at the platform's contents and users only to be reminded by Zuck that those are their users, and they serve them no matter who they are.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by icebraining on Saturday January 23, 2021 @08:44AM (#25882151)
The Facebook PAC also funds politicians like Andy Biggs, Michael Burgess, Mike Kelly, Tom Emmer and many others, so it's not just about the user base.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by cm2187 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:48AM (#25881036)
Ha ha. Time to regurgitate all the “private suppression of information isn’t censorship”, “facebook is a private company free of kicking anyone out of their platform”, “facebook shouldn’t be compelled to carry speech it dislikes”, etc.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:21AM (#25882392)
I mean... yes? I can't speak for others but my opinion on the matter remains unchanged despite who the target is. I may disagree that it was a good move, but it is, in my opinion, Facebook's right to ban anyone it wants.

It'd be like if dang decided he'd had enough of me bitching about package management, bad UIs, and software bloat and banned me. I wouldn't like it, but I also don't believe I am entitled to force HN to host my rants.

I believe the right way to handle this, if you are upset about how Facebook does things, is to stop using Facebook and tell other people why you don't use Facebook.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by ganafagol on Saturday January 23, 2021 @08:38AM (#25882097)
And that's why it was wrong to kick off Trump, just as it's now wrong to kick off the SWP.

A slippery slope was started and now the genie is out of the bottle and can't be contained anymore.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by whatever1 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:13AM (#25880353)
Australian Rupert Murdoch says hi from his American Fox empire.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by collyw on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:23AM (#25882835)
That is a valid point, but then every one of my friends in Europe posting anti-Trump stuff, encouraging Americans to vote for Biden could be considered election interference as well, no?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by friedman23 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:00AM (#25879810)
wait, we don't like corporate censorship now?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by lenkite on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:17AM (#25879883)
Me-thinks that their automated procedure for banning right-wing actors removed large swathes of left-wing actors too. Not surprising really. After all, the SWP describes itself as "revolutionary" and that has got a bad name in recent days.

Looks like they will need to make special "permit-list" for the language of left wing parties.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by spartanatreyu on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:36AM (#25880444)
Why would you think they would make a permit list for political pages?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by lenkite on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:07AM (#25880577)
I thought that was obvious ? To avoid their automated process making the mistake of banning them again.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by beowulfey on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:47AM (#25881567)
If they were banned for something they said, it was most likely because it breached FBs terms of service.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by Marinus on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:42AM (#25880711)
Why should onky left wing parties get special protection?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by radiator on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:06AM (#25880825)
GP did not say they should, they just mentioned the fact that they do.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by waheoo on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:47AM (#25880006)
Uh trump was kicked off Twitter a week ago.

The bans of non fringe, left leaning libertarian liberals have been getting kicked off Twitter for months labeled alt right for having such scary ideas like they should be allowed to use the words they choose.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by ssakamoto on Friday January 22, 2021 @10:59PM (#25879506)
Facebook is a private company and can do whatever they want.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by roenxi on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:44PM (#25879726)
That statement is neither true, wise nor a rebuttal.

(1) They have to obey a whole bunch of laws. Including laws on political interference.

(2) If there is a corporate exception to foreign interference, foreigners will found corporations to interfere. If founding an LLC lets someone interfere without hinderance then the world would soon be contending with the NSA, LLC and GRU Pty. Ltd. and Guoanbu Inc.

(3) Any US billionaire, Zuckerberg included, is a potential presidential candidate. They are all politically connected. Facebook will also cooperate with US intelligence which has a long proud history of overthrowing or suppressing various leftist movements.

Facebook is absolutely a source of foreign political interference.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by Marinus on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:45AM (#25880723)
Weird how that statement was 'true' when it was Trump&pals getting kicked of, but now that radical leftists get kicked of, it's not true anymore.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by JustinVx on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:05AM (#25880814)
I think it’s mostly liberals that have been spreading this statement. If you take a look at for instance Glenn Greenwald’s latest tweets or statements from the ACLU you’ll be hearing something very different.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by NumberCruncher on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:39PM (#25879711)
Sounds good, until the next bail out comes and private companies and their investors has to be saved.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by petre on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:38AM (#25880457)
Facebook is not critical infrastructure like banks. Instead of bailing them out they can be simply let to go bankrupt.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by cudgy on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:51AM (#25880023)
So true, but next bailout? The bailout is continuous so long as the Fed keeps rates near zero, delaying the inevitable adjustments to asset prices and allowing large hedge funds with access to these extremely low rates to gobble up even more with little worry about the downside. Current Stock market is a primary example of this.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SV_BubbleTime on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:25PM (#25879636)
That’s been said mockingly and seriously so many times in the last few weeks; it’s literally impossible to tell which this is. Bravo on ambiguity.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by Strongylodon on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:43AM (#25881809)
> and can do whatever they want.

That's not quite correct - they need to follow the laws of the state they are headquartered in.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by herostratus101 on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:27PM (#25879650)
Sure, they can. Should they? And should they be allowed to looking forward, or are they now an active threat to democracy? By the way, I say this speaking as a conservative who opposes basically everything the Socialist Workers Party stands for, but who is more threatened by autocratic tech censorship than by opposing ideas.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SllX on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:47PM (#25879741)
There isn’t a shortage of means to socialize and communicate digitally. Facebook rises and falls on its own merits and if your speech depends on Facebook, that’s a personal problem, and reflects your own personal choices.

20 years ago Facebook didn’t exist. Now we have Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat, Tumblr, WordPress (both the service and the software), YouTube, SoundCloud, the Fediverse, Twitch, Slack, Discord, iMessage groups, whatever the 3 Google messengers of the day are, XMPP clients and servers, IRC (which is admittedly more than 20 years old), countless dating sites, Reddit, and countless other “social networks”. When the bars re-open, we’ll have those too, and that is an ancient institution.

And for what it’s worth, there’s also the comments section of NRO and The Dispatch. Oh, and the forum we’re talking on.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by bostonsre on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:12AM (#25879859)
Sure, there isn't a shortage of digital communication, but they are responsible for a large proportion of that communication and they hold the power of tilting democracies by choice of those in charge of the company or by seemingly random bearucratic decisions made by their employees. They are a medium of information distribution. If certain phone companies decide to not put through calls years ago in an effort to sway democracies, would that have been acceptable? They are a for profit business ruled by one individual that has extraordinary power. As a society, are we really supposed to just let them do whatever they want just because there are less popular alternatives?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SllX on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:07AM (#25880330)
There was an argument to be made to treat phone companies like common carriers, I’m not entirely sure that was the best way to handle them, but it happened, and it was a good argument nonetheless, or at least well argued.

Social media isn’t like that at all. Social media proliferates and in different forms and it does so internationally with popular and unpopular opinions easily spreading like wildfire. I have no problem with the Facebooks and the Twitters of the world running their servers with the carte blanche of the private property owners that they are because what you and others perceive as a lack of options and alternatives looks more to me like there’s not a lot of options today compared to how many there will be 20 years from now.

Go look back at the history of the web, here’s an incomplete and not comprehensive list of sites and internet services which have existed, do exist, ceased to exist, got gobbled up by bigger fish and spawned smaller networks of their own and probably in some small way contributed to the political conscience of most Americans alive today and definitely not concerning ourselves with all of the countless web forums, Usenet groups, and mailing lists: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_social_networking_serv...

Classmates.com: 1995

GameFAQs: 1995

Newgrounds: 1995

ICQ: 1996

AIM: 1997

CaringBridge: 1997

Slashdot: 1997

Penny Arcade: 1998

Yahoo Messenger: 1998

BlackPlanet: 1999

Blogger: 1999

Fark: 1999

Kiwibox: 1999

LiveJournal: 1999

Metafilter: 1999

Neopets: 1999

Something Awful: 1999

Xanga: 1999

CrossFit: 2000

DeviantArt: 2000

Radio UserLand: 2000

Wikipedia: 2001

YTMND: 2001

Yahoo Groups: 2001

last.fm: 2002

Meetup: 2002

4chan: 2003

Gaia Online: 2003

LinkedIn: 2003

MEETin: 2003

MySpace: 2003

Second Life: 2003

Steam: 2003

WordPress: 2003

Digg: 2004

Facebook: 2004

Flickr: 2004

hi5: 2004

IMVU: 2004

PatientsLikeMe: 2004

RoosterTeeth Forums: 2004

TV Tropes: 2004

World of Warcraft: 2004

Yelp: 2004

Vimeo: 2004

Dailymotion: 2005

Google Talk: 2005

LibraryThing: 2005

Ning: 2005

Reddit: 2005

YouTube: 2005

CafeMom: 2006

Flixster: 2006

Goodreads: 2006

iLike: 2006

ReverbNation: 2006

Twitter: 2006

Chess.com: 2007

Italki: 2007

SoundCloud: 2007

Tumblr: 2007

Hacker News: 2007

Justin.tv: 2007

Academia.edu: 2008

GovLoop: 2008

identi.ca: 2008

Nextdoor: 2008

Formspring: 2009

Foursquare: 2009

Grindr: 2009

Pinterest: 2009

Quora: 2009

WhatsApp: 2009

Friendica: 2010

Instagram: 2010

Untappd: 2010

Duolingo: 2011

Fishbrain: 2011

I Had Cancer: 2011

Letterboxd: 2011

Twitch: 2011

Whisper: 2012

Google Hangouts: 2013

Slack: 2013

Vine: 2013

Voat: 2014

Yo: 2014

Discord: 2015

Periscope: 2015

Gab: 2016

Houseparty: 2016

Mastodon: 2016

Peach: 2016

micro.blog: 2017

Parler: 2018

So let’s break this down.

> Sure, there isn't a shortage of digital communication, but they are responsible for a large proportion of that communication and they hold the power of tilting democracies by choice of those in charge of the company or by seemingly random bearucratic decisions made by their employees.

No. We are responsible for our own communications and when we don’t trust the messenger, we encode our messages or we use a different messenger. We are also the ones responsible for the upkeep of our own democracy and the upkeep of the institutions which maintain it because it’s ours and our responsibility. Corporations, as it turns out, as organizations which represent the aggregate interests of their owners and employees, are also actors in aggregate within the framework of our democracy, much like name a group of three or more people.

How ten thousand people voted in one place or fifty-thousand voted in another isn’t Facebook’s responsibility, or Twitter’s, or Reddit’s, or Slack’s. It’s the responsibility of every single person who cast their own vote, which should be all of the people who cast votes in every election.

> They are a medium of information distribution.

They are a handful out of the millions of ways that exist to distribute information.

> They are a for profit business ruled by one individual that has extraordinary power. As a society, are we really supposed to just let them do whatever they want just because there are less popular alternatives?

They are dust. If our free speech depended on the whims of one Mark Zuckerberg and one Jack Dorsey, then we didn’t have free speech to begin with. Facebook and Twitter are critters of the last 20 years, there have been others, and there will be more like them, but also entirely unlike them.

The way people talk about social media companies today they make it sound like we need some sort of Social Media Public Commission to control the moderation policies and enforce the publication of government speech. We don’t, because we have what we need: competition and the many many technologies that enable it and a free flow of cash and labor and capital.

It’s disgusting to me how freely conspiracy theorists, socialists, PRC apologists and neo-Nazis can easily congregate and talk themselves up into a furor about seizing the means of killing the Jews before Bill Gates takes over the world and prevents Chairman Winnie the Pooh from leading us into glorious revolution, but that’s the mark of a free society that they can find a way and will always find a way. So is being able to tell the President and anyone else to get off your lawn and/or servers.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by bostonsre on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:35PM (#25922790)
> the list Just because there are hundreds of extremely less popular social media platforms does not erase the fact that they have most of the users. Decisions they make about filtering content impact a large majority of our population.

> They are dust.

How is having 223 million users in the United States in 2020 equate to facebook being dust? They have a strangle hold on the market and a large portion of the United States uses facebook as their primary news source.

> If our free speech depended on the whims of one Mark Zuckerberg and one Jack Dorsey, then we didn’t have free speech to begin with.

I either don't understand what you mean by this or it sounds incorrect to me. People use facebook as a means of communication and as a means of receiving news. Why does that fact have any bearing over whether or not we had free speech before they came along? And are you saying that just because we didn't have free speech before means its ok that free speech is entirely free now?

> Facebook and Twitter are critters of the last 20 years, there have been others, and there will be more like them, but also entirely unlike them.

Does it really matter what the state of social media companies was before or in the future in this conversation? They are infringing on speech now. Their goals are not aligned with the United States, they are aligned with making money.

> The way people talk about social media companies today they make it sound like we need some sort of Social Media Public Commission to control the moderation policies and enforce the publication of government speech. We don’t, because we have what we need: competition and the many many technologies that enable it and a free flow of cash and labor and capital.

Are you seriously saying that fair competition is currently happening in the social media market? Facebook is currently being sued for being a monopoly. They have unfairly crushed numerous companies and will continue to do so.

Is your conclusion that everything is fine and that companies should do whatever they can to make money no matter the impact it has on people or our democracy?

Facebook dominates the social media market right now. They are making decisions on speech of a large proportion of our country. They themselves have attempted to setup commissions to better define how to moderate content fairly, but to this point they have failed. Why would laws detailing how they should moderate content be a bad thing? There are already laws around horrible content that should not be served, could it really hurt to extend it and make free speech content moderation a public policy decision of our democracy?

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SllX on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @03:15PM (#25933332)
Look forward, and look back.

Facebook and Twitter are a blip in history. Their relevance today pales in comparison to their historic and future relevance. All 233M, scratch that, all billion or two billion or however many of those users have other things to do with their time besides Facebook all day. Facebook in that case is a part of their lives, it is not a replacement for their lives nor what ultimately determines their lives and choices, meaning it does not absolve anyone of personal responsibility for the choices they make.

So yes, they are dust, as dusty as the lot of us together. Reactionary policies and laws would do more to cement their place and continued presence in society than letting new generations grow up and make determinations about which social networks they value and develop antibodies to the shrillness of mass to mass communication. There is value in Facebook, so new users continue to make accounts and make use of the service much as people continue to buy smartphones and PCs and automobiles, but the value looks different to every person.

If Facebook and Twitter were the only two socialization methods available to society, I might be more concerned. They’re simply not, and most people have multiple means of socialization and multiple social networks.

EDIT: Forgot one bit in particular I wanted to address.

> Their goals are not aligned with the United States, they are aligned with making money.

That is correct. We’re not just one big unified hunky dory family all marching towards the same ends and the same future. We’re a bunch of people, with our own interests, and mostly unconcerned with the government and the State until we need to be. Facebook is concerned with making money, I’m concerned with my own affairs, and you are also concerned with your own affairs. That’s life, and if we see each other on the street, let’s get along.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by bostonsre on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @06:51PM (#25935862)
> Facebook and Twitter are a blip in history. Their relevance today pales in comparison to their historic and future relevance. All 233M, scratch that, all billion or two billion or however many of those users have other things to do with their time besides Facebook all day. Facebook in that case is a part of their lives, it is not a replacement for their lives nor what ultimately determines their lives and choices, meaning it does not absolve anyone of personal responsibility for the choices they make.

Why does the past or future matter? Their decisions can impact our democracy now. The fact is, they own the market now and they can impact our democracy now.

Are you in favor of a completely "free" market? You really believe that competition alone will ensure consumers have the final say? What about standard oil? Did that go well? Monopolies and oligopolies strangle out competition and harm the consumer. That is why laws were put in place to prevent those types of things from happening. That is why facebook is being sued by the FTC right now. Their business practices are unfair to competition and are not in the best interest of our society.

> That is correct. We’re not just one big unified hunky dory family all marching towards the same ends and the same future. We’re a bunch of people, with our own interests, and mostly unconcerned with the government and the State until we need to be. Facebook is concerned with making money, I’m concerned with my own affairs, and you are also concerned with your own affairs. That’s life, and if we see each other on the street, let’s get along.

So are you saying we just let facebook do whatever they want until they are replaced by competition? What if that impacts our society negatively for a year? A decade? 100 years? At what point do we step in and enact laws to protect our society from negative consequences?

The point of the government is to be a steward of our society and to ensure it is fair, healthy and prosperous. Laws are put in place to do just that. The content moderation practices of facebook can impact our society. It seems logical to me that the government should enact laws to do the same in this case as it would in other activities detrimental to society (e.g. murder, drunk driving, etc).

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SllX on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:53PM (#25937941)
> The point of the government is to be a steward of our society and to ensure it is fair, healthy and prosperous

This is your understanding of government, and it is a paternalistic understanding of government. I do not share this view and that is a source of contention between us.

> Why does the past or future matter? Their decisions can impact our democracy now. The fact is, they own the market now and they can impact our democracy now.

They own some of the servers people spend some of their time and do some of their communication on. Everything from Netflix to POTS is their competition, and Facebook does not have a monopoly on community.

> So are you saying we just let facebook do whatever they want until they are replaced by competition? What if that impacts our society negatively for a year? A decade? 100 years? At what point do we step in and enact laws to protect our society from negative consequences?

At what point do we charge people with the responsibility of managing their own time and making their own choices independent of where they choose to spend it and how they choose to socialize and communicate? Our democracy is the countless choices people make every day, at the ballot box, in the courts, and how we live with our communities. Facebook is an option.

Whatever relative power Facebook holds today, has held in the past and will hold in the future is a consequence of the choices of billions of individuals, but power has its own economy that competes against power for varying outcomes. Power, no matter how concentrated, does not exist in a vacuum.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by mnd999 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:52AM (#25881355)
> socialists

You keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it means.

Not just you either.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by SllX on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:20AM (#25882384)
It does, I don’t often, and I don’t use it as a synonym for non-socialist parties and ideologies.

Try again mate.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by throwaway45349 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @12:00AM (#25879813)
I mean, that's fine, but I take issue with one party having this massive megaphone to the world, with the other side having theirs completely snuffed.

Either ban them all, or ban none of them.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by EliRivers on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:57AM (#25881091)
Are they not a public company? Sure are publicly traded.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by golemiprague on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:34PM (#25879686)
They can do whatever they are allowed by law, nobody argue about the legality but rather about the existing legislation. It seems like we need to change our laws if we don't want SV companies, which we don't vote for, to control our lives and govern what we can or can't do.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by pasquinelli on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:18PM (#25879601)
that can change. what's the cost and the benefit of doing so?
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by jariel on Saturday January 23, 2021 @01:37AM (#25880188)
Because it's not an attempt to interfere in politics and they are assuredly not being banned due to their political views.

Facebook bans groups and people all the time, it does not imply that it's political.

It seems FB has no given their reasoning for the ban, which is rather odd given the significance, I suggest we'll either hear from them forthcoming with evidence of 'violence' or they'll walk back their mistake. My hunch was that this was a mistake ...

And the bit about 'no explanation' is a bit outrageous, I mean, how blatantly unfair is that.

Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by freeone3000 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:52AM (#25880511)
The bit about "no explanation" is completely fair. That's how bans on Facebook work -- nobody gets an explanation, so it's inherently fair.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by hanspeter on Sunday January 24, 2021 @05:49AM (#25890982)
Actually Facebook always gives an explanation by referring to a particular breach of terms. It may not feel sufficient or fair to the banned, but you do get a reason for why you are banned.
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by xupybd on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:33AM (#25880674)
It's political interference if it was intentional or not. It's not the intent but the outcome that's the problem here..
Re:Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain by jariel on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:06PM (#25885573)
That's irrelevant if the group is breaking the rules.

If they are causing violence (though I doubt this) then they are going to get banned and that's that.

It's very well within reason.