News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Aunche on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:03PM (#25680520)
Currently, the richest 10% are responsible for half of all CO2 emissions [1], and you only need $93k be in the richest 10% [2], quite modest by HN standards. Historically, the only way countries have been able to lift themselves out of poverty is by burning fossil fuels for energy. While alternative energy is rapidly advancing, Nigeria isn't going to wait decades to build a solar plant when they can build several coal power plants right now.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/dec/02/worlds-r...

[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/11/07/how-much-money-you-need-to-b...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:17PM (#25680641)
So, the figures in that Oxfam report, when that Guardian article was published, was from 2007/2008. The report was written in 2015, but the data was already out of date. I mention that because from 2007 to 2019 (figures from 2020 aren't available yet), China's per capita emissions increased by 55% while those of the West have declined. China's per capita emissions have risen from 5.25 tCO2/capita in 2007 to 8.12t in 2019 while the UK's have dropped to now just 5.45tCO2.

On the other hand, your point about solar vs coal is wrong. It takes less time now to build a solar power plant than a coal power plant. Especially for developing countries that don't already have substantial port and/or rail infrastructure. And this applies somewhat to natural gas, too. It's diesel that they tend to run for this reason. Solar, and now solar + storage, can compete just fine with diesel (and solar + storage + diesel is a pretty resilient combination that also can be built out super fast, is very cheap to build and operate, and also happens to get you to like 80-90% carbonfree... so there's decent hope out there).

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Aunche on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:29PM (#25680747)
Thanks for the updated figures. It's worth noting that China does 28% of the world's manufacturing, much of which is exported to developed countries.

As far as solar goes, clearly coal is cheaper than solar in Nigeria because that's what they're mostly building now. Regulations and subsidies are what make solar cheaper than coal in the US.

Edit: To be clear, I'm completely in favor of coal being replaced by renewables. I'm just pointing this out to raise awareness of the economic realities that are incentivizing coal power in developing countries.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by toomuchtodo on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:40PM (#25680833)
This is absolutely not true. Solar and wind, unsubsizded, are the cheapest forms of energy currently. I highly recommend reviewing both links below to better understand the economics.

https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...

https://www.irena.org/newsroom/pressreleases/2020/Jun/Renewa...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ipodopt on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:05PM (#25681040)
Not after accounting for load balancing. Depending on the situation. Weather, load profiles, etc. Hence cheap energy storage being a big deal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_renewable_energy#Comp...

I remember my department had a few very large grants for solar and wind integration studies. There is always some x profitable level to integrate into some portion of the grid. Before you actually start to lose money. Used to be around 30% in most cases a decade ago. Imagine it is bit asymptotic without improvements to the cost of energy storage. I would guess 40% in most cases now.

Found this: https://www.iea.org/articles/will-system-integration-of-rene...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by toomuchtodo on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:32PM (#25681538)
Yes, I argue even when accounting for grid integration. It's a slam dunk anywhere where it's paired with natural gas due to fast throttling on open cycle and combined cycle turbines, and a little less so where coal is used. Nigeria, for example, is primarily natural gas for fossil electrical generation (~16% of their electrical generation capacity), so any kwh's you're generating with renewables is natural gas burned only when renewables can't meet load demand.

Check out South Australia on OpenNEM [1]. Paired with natural gas and transmission, they're at an exceptionally high amount of renewables penetration [2] and have a very low cost of power in Australia [3]. They're also using a large, recently expanded, Tesla utility scale battery for ancillary/frequency response services [4] (previously profitably performed by natural gas generators), which is causing financial pain for those mentioned gas operators (who are having trouble profiting now on either the power provided or frequency response services).

[1] https://opennem.org.au/energy/sa1/?range=7d&interval=30m

[2] https://www.afr.com/policy/energy-and-climate/coal-generatio...

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/dec/24/south...

[4] https://hornsdalepowerreserve.com.au/

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by caeril on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:48AM (#25685221)
There are some regions for which storage requirements are relatively small, and would be perfect for 100% solar rollout targets.

Phoenix and Las Vegas come to mind - places where incident solar flux and electricity demand (due to heavy air conditioner use) almost perfectly coincide (peaks are separated by only ~50 minutes)

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:21AM (#25697478)
Nigeria also fits that description. It's right on the equator, meaning there's very little seasonal variation in solar. This is in contrast to all of Europe, especially northern Europe like the UK and Germany.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Aunche on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:58PM (#25680980)
I'll admit solar and wind are more attractive than I had thought, which makes me somewhat more optimistic.

That said, I think this analysis misses two important factors when it comes to impoverished countries. Otherwise, you would see more solar there. Developing countries have much lower standards when it comes to building a new power plant, so don't need to pay for sulfur scrubbers. The other factor is that unskilled labor much cheaper there. Solar and wind require much higher-skill labor as there is much more maintenance that needs to be done.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by avmich on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:02PM (#25681014)
> Solar and wind require much higher-skill labor as there is much more maintenance that needs to be done.

Are you sure that the steam turbine (high RPM, balancing, thermal stress to blades, steam conditioning) is easier to maintain than a electric generator or an array of photovoltaics with control circuits?

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by throwaway201103 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:52PM (#25681645)
Coal/steam power generation is old, old tech. China will be happy to build a coal plant in Nigeria and train up the operators.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:25AM (#25697518)
Modern steam turbine plants are not that old, and they require a lot more maintenance. Plus, Nigeria produces hardly any coal, so you'll have to either import coal (requires import terminal and rail plus reliance on foreign coal) or mine more coal (open coal mine infrastructure, rail). Solar just produces electricity and doesn't need a bunch of infrastructure.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by rstuart4133 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:14AM (#25698831)
More attractive might be understating it:

https://www.abc.net.au/news/12990532

> The owners of Australia's newest coal-fired power station have written down the value of the asset to zero, wiping out a $1.2 billion investment in the face of an onslaught of renewable energy. ... The decision was booked in Sumitomo's September accounts, in which the company acknowledged the facility was worthless despite being barely 10 years old.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by nradov on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:59PM (#25680986)
That's only true if you don't count the storage cost necessary to maintain a highly reliable base load supply.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by avmich on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:04PM (#25681038)
Requirements for high reliability can be lower in places where electricity itself isn't a given. In other words, if you don't have money for full range of functions, you'd be glad to have at least some.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ethn on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:36AM (#25686414)
This is not true, the figures you and others have provided account for an additional theoretical externality cost on our well being for coal. The nominal price of coal energy in the US is more than half of the cost of solar per kWh (3.2 vs 6.8 cents on average)[1].

It’s even cheaper in third-world countries (and China) due to the cost of labor.

[1] https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/the-real-costs-of-u-s-ene...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:29AM (#25697556)
Your source is from 2011. Coal has gotten more expensive and solar much cheaper. In fact, building new, unsubsidized solar power plants is cheaper than operating an existing (and paid for) coal power plant: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2020/10/23/its-cheaper-to-build-.... 2.9-3.8 cents per kWh for unsubsidized solar in the US.

Nigeria is closer to the equator and has lower labor costs for installation, so their solar costs will be even cheaper.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ethn on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:15PM (#25702874)
The Lazard study includes carbon pricing which is exactly what I said: “[All studies] provided account for an additional theoretical externality cost on our well being for coal”.

Like every industry in the last decade, coal generators have also become more efficient.

I’d be shocked (heh) if solar power becomes more efficient given the Shockley-Quessier limit of PV cells which have a maximum efficiency in the best theoretical case with an infinite stacking of panels of 30%. Large synchronous machines on the other hand, in practice, can have a 95% efficiency.

Here’s a study without the “carbon pricing”: https://energy.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/MITEI-WP-2...

Again coal is much cheaper.

I’m sympathetic to your agenda but it’s deceitful and unfair to presume agreement given the unique circumstances theses results affect conclusions. A place like Nigeria has to worry about what’s happening to their people in the next month rather than in the next 50 years, thus they’ll have different trade offs to make.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by pstrateman on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:53AM (#25682589)
That's really only true if you have perfectly elastic demand.

As soon as you need to store energy wind and solar become much more expensive.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:31AM (#25697568)
Not really. A few hours of storage are now included in a lot of new solar projects, and it adds very little to the cost. Solar+4hours of storage has a LCOE of just 3.3 cents per kWh. https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2019-09-10/ladwp-v...
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:13PM (#25681094)
"Coal is cheaper than solar in Nigeria because that's what they're mostly building now"

Firtly, thats a circular argument:"clearly bloodletting works because everyone is using it"

Secondary, the argument is meanongless without a timespan - for example a hydroelectric dam is the chepest source of electricity ever, but is very expensive upfront: no private investor wants to fund that because their returns will take decades. Channel tonnel is profitable now, but initial investort got wrecked, etc.

A hypothetical asset that lasts forever has infinite ROI but if it takes you 200 years to make your money back noone will invest.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by xupybd on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:24PM (#25681155)
Nigeria may not have the funds to bank roll renewables even if they are cheaper in the long run. Cash flow often matters a lot more than people realise.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:45AM (#25682551)
Coal is worse in that regard because of potential for delays and the binary nature of operating a coal power plant. You either have built the whole thing and it's making some money or you haven't and it's a money pit.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by seg_lol on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:46AM (#25685202)
Solar also doesn't have to be centralized like a Coal plant. Not only can solar start delivering power on day 1, it can be incrementally added closer to the point of use, also saving on distribution costs.

If someone said a coal plant is being built in Nigeria, my first thought that this is being forced on them by creditors that probably already own a bunch of coal.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by avmich on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:57PM (#25680969)
> As far as solar goes, clearly coal is cheaper than solar in Nigeria because that's what they're mostly building now.

If we want to find out what's cheaper in order to decide what it is more reasonable to build, we can't rely on the fact that something is actually being built as an argument. It's the other way around - first we decide what's better, then do it, otherwise whatever we do would be right since we're doing that.

Or - in this case - if you assume that those calculations were made and it was found that the coal is cheaper - and that's why they're building coal plants - then there is a question of discrepancy (coal is more expensive lately than solar according to <sources>), which needs to be addressed, otherwise it might be assumed that a mistake was made.

> Regulations and subsidies are what make solar cheaper than coal in the US.

Doesn't coal industry also receive subsidies, and aren't those subsides comparable or bigger than subsidies for solar? I'm not sure; are you?

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by qwantim1 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:03PM (#25681017)
> otherwise whatever we do would be right since we're doing that.

I didn’t follow the logic there. Are you saying everything everyone does is right?

I dig that, but it’s a strange thing to see in an argument.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by avmich on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:07PM (#25681048)
That's what I'm questioning.

We can't assume a proposition is correct if we're trying to figure out if it's correct or not.

The post I'm replying to was in effect "coal is cheaper since they're building coal plants". I disagree, and show why the logic is "illogical".

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by vbtemp on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:13PM (#25681426)
> It's worth noting that China does 28% of the world's manufacturing, much of which is exported to developed countries.

You don't have to go to bat for china, you know. Does the fact that they have so much manufacturing make their emissions ok? If those manufacturing emissions we're instead from the US, would you make the same note?

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by convolvatron on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:42AM (#25684626)
the point being that an importing country should be held at least partially responsible for the emissions of the manufacturing country. if the importing country made the widgets themselves, their emissions would increase. if the importing country didn't buy the widgets at all then the manufacturing country wouldn't produce them and not emit as much CO2
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by vbtemp on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:50AM (#25685845)
> the point being that an importing country should be held at least partially responsible for the emissions of the manufacturing country.

Ok, so Saudi Arabia is responsible for America's emissions. Russia is responsible for Europe's emissions. America is responsible for China's emissions.

But let's just keep playing word games to deflect responsibility from China and make sure it's all America's fault.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by gibbonsrcool on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:42PM (#25680847)
> Regulations and subsidies are what make solar cheaper than coal in the US.

Please stop parroting this. Coal is cheaper than solar in the same way that a house with no down payment is free. The environmental debt from coal's CO2 emissions will far exceed costs of solar.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:50PM (#25680920)
This is on point - pollution is the loanshark in everyone's blindspot. To 'save' a dollar on renewables is to codemn your kids to pay a thousand
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by avmich on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:59PM (#25680987)
The point is that even without pollution costs - and without subsidies either way - it might be more expensive to build coal plant than an equivalent solar plant. Operation costs are clearly higher in case of coal. Pollution is the cherry on top, or possibly the proverbial elephant in the room.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by disown on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:41PM (#25681584)
> Coal is cheaper than solar in the same way that a house with no down payment is free.

Except that rich europeans got the "house with no down payment" for centuries, but now expect poor africans to put down a down payment? That's going to be a hard sell to poor africans desperate to get out of poverty.

> The environmental debt from coal's CO2 emissions will far exceed costs of solar.

Expecting poor africans to give a shit is going to be a real hard sell. Especially when the climate problem is almost exclusively a rich european creation and poor africans had nothing to do with it.

Caring about climate is an enterprise of the privileged few. Unless we are willing to subsidize billions of poor africans and others around the world to the tune of trillions of dollars, I think africans and everyone else are going to go with the lowest hanging fruit. It's 2021 and hundreds of millions of africans live with electricity today. Think about that. It's insane. Considering the centuries of suffering they endured, if they have to burn down the planet to get some semblance of good life, then so be it. Let europe live in mud huts for a few centuries.

https://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/600-million-africans-go-with...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by rocknor on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:22AM (#25684958)
Unfortunately in 2021, lifting people out of poverty still always implies increased carbon emissions (historically that's how rich countries got to where they are). After the death of colonialism, poor countries also naturally want to have the same luxuries rich countries already enjoy. But now we realize that with our current scientific advancements these luxurious lifestyles are not sustainable for such a large global population.

What you said is 100% right, just the tone was a bit harsh. Since this site mostly has people from rich countries who refuse to learn history and accept any blame, you will be downvoted.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by tomp on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:02AM (#25682311)
> Let europe live in mud huts for a few centuries.

This kind of vindictive rhetoric is probably something we should try to avoid in times like these. Even if you’re just “trying to make a point”.

Really our only chance of solving the climate is doubling down on high tech. Turning Europe back centuries would be clearly counterproductive.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:48AM (#25682561)
>Let europe live in mud huts for a few centuries.

I can just buy an AC and pay for electric heating. I'm not so sure that every African can do that.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by chelical on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:23PM (#25688983)
To be fair, solar mix places more stress on the electrical grid and likely requires more expertise to maintain in countries struggling with brain drain. That said it's still preferable to building more coal plants.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by disown on Friday January 08, 2021 @12:04AM (#25681695)
> China's per capita emissions increased by 55% while those of the West have declined.

Well that's because china was late to industrialization ( by 150 years ) has come from a low emission base. And even if ignore the fact that a significant chunk of china's emissions are dedicated solely to manufacturing goods/junk for the west, if we completely stopped all emissions, it would still take china many decades of emissions to catch up to the emission's put out by the west the past 200 years or so.

> China's per capita emissions have risen from 5.25 tCO2/capita in 2007 to 8.12t in 2019 while the UK's have dropped to now just 5.45tCO2.

That's deceptive since much of UK's emissions was export to china via manufacturing. It's like your roommate "cleaning" his room by dump his trash in your room.

Just by something as basic as "standard of living", it's a certainty that the west, and especially the UK, accounts for far more emissions on a per capita basis. It's impossible that on a per capita basis, a brit has lower emission footprint that a chinese person, indian, african, etc.

Certainly, we aren't any better here in the US. I remember watching a documentary that said that if everyone on earth lived like us, it would take like 5 additional earth's resources.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by tonyedgecombe on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:41AM (#25682823)
>That's deceptive since much of UK's emissions was export to china via manufacturing.

Total UK emissions including imported emissions have been falling since 2007.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/nationalaccounts/uksectoracco...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by dflock on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:23PM (#25680700)
> Nigeria isn't going to wait decades to build a solar plant when they can build several coal power plants right now.

Solar is cheaper & quicker to build & run than coal plants. And it can be built incrementally and start generating power and profits very quickly, compared to traditional power plants, which are large construction projects that don't generate power or profit until after they're completed.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by tuatoru on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:03AM (#25682316)
Nigeria prefers coal because it involves lots of heavy construction, which means lots of kickbacks for the political elite.

Acemoglu and Robinson's concept of "extractive elites" is useful here.[1]

1. http://whynationsfail.com/blog/2012/5/1/who-are-the-extracti...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Solocomplex on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:23AM (#25682101)
Maybe in California, where everyone here seems to be from.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by jansan on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:50AM (#25682253)
Source tell me that the weather in Nigeria is not completely unsuitable for solar energy, either.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by konjin on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:23PM (#25681151)
And without grid scale storage, which doesn't exist, solar at noon is about as useful as coal in the middle of Australia. Renewable only is a pipe dream and is distracting from the fact that we need to build nuclear plants if we want to have a planet by the end of the century.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by kolinko on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:34AM (#25682787)
With solar+hydrogen you have a higher stability than nuclear. When solar process fall by additional 50%, this setup will be even cheaper than coal.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by konjin on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:21AM (#25684409)
So on the one hand we have a technology that works, on the other we have a pipe dream.

I sure know which one I want to bet the future of the planet on.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Hypx on Friday January 08, 2021 @05:41PM (#25691476)
Neither one's really a pipe dream anymore. Solar+wind+hydrogen is at the point where it can replace all fossil fuels.

This doesn't mean you can't have nuclear, but it's no longer necessarily.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by adrianN on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:23AM (#25683013)
You can do 50% renewables without any storage. The world is pretty far away from that.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by konjin on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:22AM (#25684412)
Germany, Australia and California say otherwise.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by adrianN on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:55AM (#25684723)
I don't understand what you want to say. Germany is relatively close to 50% renewable electricity without a lot of grid scale storage.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by chelical on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:14PM (#25688826)
Germany is hovering around 41% renewable electricity, but its primary energy supply is still 78% fossil fuels.

https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/renewables/germanys-energie...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by adrianN on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:13AM (#25697874)
41% is "fairly close" to 50%.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by kumarvvr on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:19PM (#25680658)
>Historically, the only way countries have been able to lift themselves out of poverty is by burning fossil fuels for energy

This is an interesting point, but I don't get the cause and effect scenario here.

What bothers me is the ideological trap that fossil fuels are the only resources that can be exploited to bring people out of poverty.

Are we so lacking in innovation that we cannot come up with sustainable development models?

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ip26 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:27PM (#25680730)
They are not the only such resources. But they have been the cheapest, which means they have been the fastest track out of poverty.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:52PM (#25680935)
We have the cheapest credit in human history, yet we can't fund renewable projects with positive ROI.

Meanwhile people are 'investing' in bitcoin, and pumping meme stocks.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:08AM (#25682660)
Christine Lagarde (head of ECB) also got a lot of flak for announcing that the european central bank will keep reducing it's exposure to CO2 intensive companies.

At this point the amount of self harm in the population is so great that there is nothing to be done. Is this the curse of right wing populism? Why do disenfranchised people love voting for people that don't care about them? Trump didn't win the election but he still had lots of support even though he was only looking out for himself (and others like him) during his presidency.

Green investments are such an incredibly easy way to implement jobs programs yet people hate on them because they believe not subsidizing anything is more important than solving real problems like domestic underemployment. Yes, when I talk about green investments I am not even considering how you are doing something for the planet, I'm just talking about the economic impact of building up a domestic industry. For all intents and purposes you could also have spent money on maintaining roads or building lots of houses for all I care but when you listen to someone like Trump he would spend it on useless crap like coal. There are very little employment opportunities (if you ignore the work needed to undo the CO2 emissions) in a dying industry. But hey, it's got high visibility and is an emotional topic so lets shoot renewables down in favor of it even though you had more to benefit from the "green scam" (hyperbole) than coal.

China is doing an extreme amount of jobs programs. All those ghost cities are there to employ construction workers first, sell capital to wealthy individuals and eventually be populated by immigrants. They also loan money to developing countries and build infrastructure for them.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ip26 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:13PM (#25708948)
Yeah, I don't know why investment isn't available, especially if the ROI is good. Wish I did.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by javajosh on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:00PM (#25681000)
>Are we so lacking in innovation that we cannot come up with sustainable development models?

Well, yes. We Americans are fat, lazy and comfortable. 70 years of being on top will do that to you. But we are still voracious, even in old age, and will happily burn resources on our vanity, greed, and, perhaps worst of all, mere convenience. We are not willing to inconvenience ourselves to address global threats. (And that alone is enough to disqualify us from any kind of global leadership role.)

(In fact I believe it was a twin existential threat that led them to loose their minds. Global climate change requires of Democracy what I call a "voluntary contraction". This is impossible to accept by the many people in this culture who feel entitled to earn/consume even more than their parents, and their grandparents, because it's been that way for 80 years. Sustainability changes this; it means accepting that you'll have less material wealth than your parents. The other threat is more personal: politically correct thought policing from the left, complete with mob enforcement through cancel culture. Together these threats might be powerful enough to cause a delusion in which one is saved from reality by a reality TV star.)

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:15AM (#25682693)
> Sustainability changes this; it means accepting that you'll have less material wealth than your parents

There is actually more wealth to be gained for the average person because green investments can be an effective domestic jobs program. Central bank money is merely increasing the relative value of wealthy people's assets. So it's a net loss for the working class. If wealth inequality grows by 2x they owe the rich twice as much. If that money could be channeled in a way that pays the income of workers and actually gets spent it would mean that economic growth will come back and incomes will grow over time instead of stagnating.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by tomjakubowski on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:13PM (#25680608)
According to the Oxfam report linked by that Gyardian article[1], the global top 1% (~ millionaires) produce 15% of emissions, "more than twice the poorest 50% (c.3.1 billion people), or more than the entire cumulative emissions of citizens in the EU."

[1]: https://oxfamilibrary.openrepository.com/bitstream/handle/10...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:17PM (#25680646)
Old data. They used 2007/2008 data.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by tuatoru on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:05AM (#25682332)
Inequality has worsened since then, thanks to the GFC and incompetent responses to it.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by magnio on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:21PM (#25681476)
Is it? The report claims this is in 2015.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by Robotbeat on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:20AM (#25697467)
Got to look at the actual original Oxfam report from 2015 which said it used the latest data available which was 2007/2008.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by shakna on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:27PM (#25680732)
> While alternative energy is rapidly advancing, Nigeria isn't going to wait decades to build a solar plant when they can build several coal power plants right now.

It is _faster_ and _cheaper_ for Nigeria to build a solar plant right now. [0] We've crossed over that line.

[0] https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a34372005/solar-che...

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by melling on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:30PM (#25680752)
Let me restate that for you.

The richest 760 million people are responsible for half of all CO2 emissions.

I am imagine that includes the cars, big homes, the electricity, and all the products that we buy from China.

I’m not sure what you want us to do with that information. There’s nothing actionable in that observation.

We should’ve stopped using coal two decades ago. I’m sure we can spend all night talking about this, but it’s all been said before.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by fulafel on Friday January 08, 2021 @12:08PM (#25686857)
It's actionable. Maybe it takes a lot of rehashing to get through, but still. Lots of these people voluntarily give up cars, big houses etc already, and more are partial to making carbon caps / policies that result in carbon neutrality.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by dehrmann on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:23PM (#25681490)
> all the products that we buy from China

Not sure why you're calling this out. Container shipping is very efficient.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by adrianN on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:42PM (#25681593)
Making the stuff in the containers is usually not very efficient.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by melling on Friday January 08, 2021 @04:21AM (#25683007)
They burn a lot of coal to make the stuff we buy.

We have to look at the entire supply chain if we want to reduce our emissions.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:55PM (#25680953)
emissions are being produced by people wealthy enough to invest in renewables / offset / etc.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by melling on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:04PM (#25681030)
I’m not sure where we stand on solar panels on everyone’s homes. Doesn’t seem to be replacing power plants, which is what we need.

Making sure my manufacturered imports are carbon neutral will be difficult. All the other indirect emissions will also be hard to account for.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by dheera on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:23PM (#25680696)
That is, unless we put actual scientists in political power who understand that helping fund solar in Nigeria and elsewhere will be a net positive for your own economy by simple aversion of several economic disasters due to climate change.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by carlmr on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:03AM (#25682317)
>helping fund solar in Nigeria and elsewhere will be a net positive for your own economy

The issue here is probably that there are so many people on earth you'd have to invest in so many places that you'd be a poor country before getting any returns.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:19AM (#25682712)
Well, in theory that would be the case. In practice as long as you invest printed central bank money carefully you can actually make a nice return. However I don't see why any country would have an obligation to invest into foreign infrastructure. It would be more politically acceptable to solve domestic problems first.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by javajosh on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:13PM (#25681098)
I wonder if they've done that analysis and found that it wouldn't actually be worth it. My concern is that those threat models might not be great at factoring in the cost of the end times.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by asdff on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:16AM (#25682061)
>Historically, the only way countries have been able to lift themselves out of poverty is by burning fossil fuels for energy

I think this is only because historically, the only realistic way to produce energy for a lot of nations was by burning fossil fuels. No poor nation 70 years ago would be able to construct a nuclear plant or build a massive dam. Now, we have renewable sources available for a much lower upfront cost than what was available historically.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by lenkite on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:38PM (#25694863)
Please go by sovereign nation. China is the world's largest contributing country to CO2 emissions—a trend that has steadily risen over the years—now producing 10.06 billion metric tons of CO2 (and increasing). US is half of that and falling further. India is at #3 with half of US emissions.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by eloff on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:13PM (#25681428)
New coal plants are not economical compared to solar in any sunny location, Nigeria definitely included. It's cheaper in many places to build new solar compared to operating existing coal plants - that's how bad it's got for coal.

Coal is on the way out and nothing can stop that now.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by LatteLazy on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:27AM (#25683587)
Are the richest 10% responsible for half because each percentile generates 5% or because the 1% generates 49% and the other 9% basically generate nothing?
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by bamboozled on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:17AM (#25682703)
They will all die from it, so it's not going to matter what they do.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by blhack on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:15PM (#25680626)
Does this mean the answer to global warming is to keep people in poverty?
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by toomuchtodo on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:22PM (#25680693)
It means we give away solar, wind, and energy storage to the poor, and build all of the above as fast as manufacturing allows. You make it economically untenable to burn fossil fuels.

Global PV production capacity is ~170GW per year, current fossil generation capacity in Africa is about 135GW. Not outlandish to get that replaced in short order while accounting for growth. Want it done faster? Build more PV manufacturing capacity. The product is glass and silicon with a hint of rare earths. PV panels are almost 100% recyclable.

Overbuilt renewables should be used to sequester atmospheric carbon instead of curtailing (throwing excess renewables away when unneeded). It’s going to take an incredible amount of energy to stick all of that burned carbon from the last 100 years back into the ground.

TLDR “You must construct additional pylons.”

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by SulfurHexaFluri on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:23PM (#25680703)
Thats not possible because we have the same capacity to produce product so there will always be a top % who use most of those resources. I think the real take away is that most gains can be made by fixing the processes of rich countries.

Countries like Australia have massive amounts of underutilized renewable energy that are not being used to their fullest extent combined with an American like obsession with cars.

We should be focusing on areas where easy wins can be made rather than looking at countries with the highest level of emissions which is a pointless statistic when they all have different population counts.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by 8note on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:53PM (#25680944)
Isn't that definition premature optimization?

A ton of quick wins that amount to minimal real changes to total emissions isn't going to stop the earth from heating too fast

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by SulfurHexaFluri on Thursday January 07, 2021 @10:01PM (#25681008)
These aren't minimal changes. Most of our greenhouse gas emissions come from energy production. We have solutions to this but they are not being deployed widely due to political bikeshedding, corruption and blame passing.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by imtringued on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:22AM (#25682732)
Also we are going to shift a lot of chemical energy based industries to purely electric. Transport will require green electricity and reduce it's dependence on burning things.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by option on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:21PM (#25680681)
no, the answer is to use nuclear - a scalable technology which we have spent decades developing and operating. France gets 75% of its electricity from nuclear.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by anohito11235 on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:33PM (#25680781)
People are too frighten of a nuclear meltdown like in Chernobyl or East coast Japan. Sure, we have been productively making nuclear plant to be safer but it takes time to convince the population, i guess.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:45PM (#25680885)
Is that even the issue any more? Most people probably don't remember Chernobyl, and forgot about Japan the instant it left the news.

I think the real resistance, is the drug of indignation. Folks are manufacturing it all the time, latching onto anything they can find to get spun up about. With negligible attention to facts. Its the one constant in our brave new world.

Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by option on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:51PM (#25680923)
I actually grew up near Chernobyl and both my parents still work there. Pretty much anyone who knows even a little about nuclear energy and does not have a political position is very much pro-nuclear.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by djrobstep on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:31PM (#25680763)
The fair solution is surely that the rich should consume less, not the poor.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by fogihujy on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:47AM (#25682240)
Yeah, sure. But how do we convince them?
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by djrobstep on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:32AM (#25682770)
Redistributive taxation would be a good start.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by vtail on Thursday January 07, 2021 @09:22PM (#25680688)
And/or to have fewer people overall.
Re:CO2 already emitted will warm Earth beyond climate target... by iridium_core on Friday January 08, 2021 @10:20AM (#25685515)
And what % of economic, scientific, and cultural output is that 10% responsible for?