I don't think anyone can solve that. You can't disallow moderation in a space, otherwise you just have people screaming at you all the time. If there is freedom of expression, you can't then also force people to platform things they find abhorrent. The freedom to express surely also includes the freedom not to express.
I don't think there are easy answers, and "people should have to have the firehose of the internet sprayed at them unfiltered" seems like a bad take to me.
The spread of propaganda to undermine the democratic process is chilling.
It's unpopular to say this, but both sides see it this way.
We can observe reality to determine who is telling the truth, rather than blindly repeating lies alongside truths.
The right in the US have created an alternative reality to live in, but it clashes with actual reality if you spend even a little time comparing what they say to what has actually happened in the world.
So, in the perfect world, you have all these nodes with different levels and types of moderation and people can communicate across them, but pick the level and type of moderation they want by what instance they use, right?
The reality is, no one has a good idea how to moderate something at that scale, even with the resources that come from have a walled garden. You don't even get that, and you want better moderation to draw people away? No one is doing it.
Then, on the other end, you want someone to believe in free speech enough to host the completely unfiltered one, and not baulk at some point when abhorrent shit is on their server? You just end up with a nazi server run by nazis, because those are the only people who actually want that.
It's "solved" only in theory, in practice, there is no practical draw for real-world users.
Until we can find a way to make a Mastodon better than Facebook, it'll be impossible to gain a critical mass for people to take it seriously.
This might come from marketing the benefits of decentralization, maybe finding a way to have a universal "login" page that can direct users to particular nodes, etc.
Protocols instead of platforms:
https://medium.com/holochain/holochain-reinventing-applicati...
People don't want everyone to have a complete platform to them to say anything they want. So somewhere someone has to be doing some deciding of who gets a platform. Protocols can't magically solve that problem.
I think there is something to giving people options on what moderation they want distinct from having to limit who they can communicate to, but all of the current attempts at that don't do a good enough job, they all offer technical solutions, but no real solutions.
What you really need is for one of these protocols to get a particular instance that does an amazing job of "no nazis, no one telling you to die or that you shouldn't have human rights", while giving you the room to move and remain on the protocol if the instance you are on starts to limit you or you start to disagree with the moderation.
Of course, this begs the question of who is going to be doing that moderation and why. That's the hard part, not the decentralised platform.
Applications built using Holochain are literally using a novel pattern that hasn’t existed before. If you know of a project that uses the same agent-centric ontology, please let me know, because I’ve looked far. As to why the lack of diversity of protocols in existing platforms (or non-usage of new protocols), I think the reason many platforms/protocols aren’t adopted is because the commons has been plundered: trade secrets block progress and have led to the creation of the web as walled gardens. Great for capitalists and advertisers, but crap for individuals.
> People don't want everyone to have a complete platform to them to say anything they want. So somewhere someone has to be doing some deciding of who gets a platform. Protocols can't magically solve that problem.
Who is 'people'? Who do you speak for? Could you share any sources that back up your claim?
From your (seemingly) quick dismissal, I’m curious to know if you read up on the actual tech? I’d be curious if you have any critique on the underlying tech?
I agree that any community needs moderation but that doesn’t mean we should have a faceless company doing it. It can be done by making cooperative block-lists/blacklists, and sharing those among participants. We don’t need the middlemen at all, in fact they are unaccountable, and are dangerous by themselves since their only focus is to exploit users and extract a profit for shareholders.
As I said though, I’m curious about any critique about Holochain tech (the software pattern). Personally I think it’s inevitable that we will move in that direction imo: the direction of an agent-centric web, a space of direct protocol negotiation and renegotiation.
I’d like to make you aware that Holochain also paves the way for new types of value accounting systems. If you are curious, check out the work of Lynn Foster, Bob Haugen, Pospi and others on hREA / http://valueflo.ws. They are in the later stages of developing a fully featured, fully distributed, Resources Events Agents (REA) accounting system built using Holochain - creating one of the world’s first Network Resource Planning software [1] that uses an official ISO standard.
It's some really groundbreaking stuff here, that's got me super excited and hopeful.
[1] https://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Network_Resource_Planning
> Who is 'people'? Who do you speak for? Could you share any sources that back up your claim?
The fact that we don't allow people to scream whatever they want in your face as you walk around the supermarket.
You don't seem to be able to see the forest for the trees and are trying to lawyer me on this. How do I know people don't want literally everyone to have a direct line to them? I'm a human being, and it is obvious as hell.
You are just completely missing the point of my post.
Maybe. I feel like you’re completely missing the point of my post too.
Holochain’s novelty lies in its use of DHT’s to create, store and retrieve data. Like Git source chains, it then uses cryptography to guarantee data integrity in this distributed application context. You’re basically agreeing in advance on which functions to use. Instead of using proprietary functions that are kept secret behind a firewall or limited through an API, Holochain allows you to create and use apps that directly enforce and verify open rules in a 100% distributed peer to peer way. To the best of my knowledge this sort of system hasn’t been seen or invented before.
Thy have great descriptions on their website:
[from https://holo.host/faq/]
“Holochain maintains data integrity without the need for global consensus. It uses an agent-centric approach, combining ideas from BitTorrent and Git, along with cryptographic signatures, peer validation, and gossip.
An overview:
- hApps have validation rules.
- Agents have their own local, tamper-resistant hash-chains recording their actions, built upon hApp rules.
- Each hash-chain entry is cryptographically signed (multi-party actions, like transactions, are mutually countersigned).
- Data is shared to random peers who validate it.
- Validators gossip to share good data, warn against bad data, and blacklist bad actors.“
Their code is free software, available on Github here: https://github.com/holochain
If that were true, we'd never have had the Fairness Doctrine, and the debate over Net Neutrality would have been over before it began.
Compelled speech or forced speech is not free speech.
A similar rule, the equal-time rule, still exists. Arguments that it violates the First Amendment have never worked in court.
The equal time rule has so many exceptions that it might as well not exist. Also, to my knowledge, it has not been extensively reviewed by the Supreme Court on constitutionality grounds, probably because of those exceptions that mean there's never really a case to fight over. The one case I could find wasn't fighting the rule itself, but rather it's interpretation.
It's really hard to argue that websites are a limited public resource.
In this particular case, I would quickly argue "Hell no, storming the US Capital is illegal for good cause, and I will never condone such acts of violence." But I would allow the discussion. We have to allow the discussion. Because if you draw a line here, then you will be censored when you argue for things like marijuana legalisation and gay marraige while they are still illegal as McCarthyites will censor you based on inciting people to break the law.
This is why 'incitement' has such a high bar.
I could be wrong. Maybe "praise and support for /storming/" is incitement to violence. I'm glad I'm not a judge that has to make that call. So long as the line isn't drawn on the wrong side of the points I argued above.
There's probably not a clear line in every instance. Whether you think "praise and support" crosses the line, it would be pretty hard to claim it made things better, and pretty easy to see how those words, from the most powerful person in the country, might make a person more likely to continue doing whatever it is they're doing.
I strongly agree with this. I just don’t agree that you’re entitled to use other people’s publishing resources to do it.
(Hypothetically) If I can praise and support them, the majority of what they advocate being conceptually illegal if implemented, then yes... the First Amendment seems clear that anything shy of advocating and/or planning imminent action is permissible.
Of course, Facebook as a private company is under no obligation to follow Constitutional limits on permissible vs non-permissible speech. But should they be?
Absolutely not, the first amendment only applies to the government for a reason.
Perhaps there should be a government-run equivalent that is subject to the first amendment.
Though honestly, I think that would work out horribly. The number of people you can reach by shouting in a town square isn't very high, that's why the government can allow any kind of crank to do it. If you can reach millions...bad things would happen.
I'm not an American, and I still don't know if there was cheating or not, and actually I don't understand whether there is enough data on it to decide, though usually the bigger problem is when a president stays in the president seat forever.
Absolutely. Many people want to talk in the public (or at least town) square, which trends strongly towards a few providers (where everybody is), which establishes de facto global free speech limits via those provider's policies.
And "moving to another service" isn't a feasible redress.
Do we want to live in a world where conservatives only read ConservaPedia, and liberals read LibPedia? Or one where they're exposed to each other's ideas and share some facts?
>> the first amendment only applies to the government for a reason. [...] The number of people you can reach by shouting in a town square isn't very high, that's why the government can allow any kind of crank to do it. If you can reach millions...bad things would happen.
I'll assume that's the reason you were referring to? If so, we disagree on the intent of the First Amendment.
I don't think it's about audience reach, so much as relative power: government has historically had controls not available to private companies.
Yet in modern times, Facebook / Twitter / Youtube have as much or more control over their platforms, which are as bigger or bigger than the largest First Amendment-covered venue.
So while Facebook or Google can't send the FBI to your door, they can effectively disappear your idea / product from their ecosystems, and there are very few checks on that power, particularly when ranking algorithms are allowed to be shielded from public scrutiny.
Maybe that's the problem?
Some speeches are omens to terrible actions and they are usually supported by symbols.
I've seen the pictures of the Confederate Flag waving in the halls of the Senate, It was pretty disturbing to me.
If I am not wrong that never happened before, not even during the Civil war.
IMO if the flag entered the Capitol Building in 1860 it would have been normal, but today it has become the symbol of the resistance to the racial integration and the support to the segregation, hence it should be banned and people speaking openly about any "racial supremacy" should face consequences.
outside the contexts of "art or science, research or teaching" (quoting the The German Strafgesetzbuch (Criminal Code) in section § 86a) it is simply unacceptable.
After all it is written in the US Constitution that
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.
Absolutely. Which is why the US Supreme Court has continually debated and weighed First Amendment tension against public safety.
To my knowledge, the Confederate battle flag has never flown in the US Capitol. Not in July, 1864, when the Confederate Army stared at it across 6 miles and lightly defended lines [0]. Not after 1939 when it was hoisted in film by Gone with the Wind with sanitized nostalgia for an antebellum past [1]. And certainly not in the 50s and 60s when it was appropriated by the reborn Ku Klux Klan to represent their racist beliefs [2].
But it has been present at all three instances of armed insurrection against the US government -- Civil War, first US terrorist organization, and modern, militant Trump supporters.
And ultimately, it's those people's actions, not their ideas or symbols, that are dangerous.
As Justice Louis D. Brandeis wrote in Whitney v. California [3], by way of Jefferson's views [4]:
"[Those who won our independence] believed that freedom to think as you will and to speak as you think are means indispensable to the discovery and spread of political truth; that without free speech and assembly discussion would be futile; that with them, discussion affords ordinarily adequate protection against the dissemination of noxious doctrine; that the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people; that public discussion is a political duty; and that this should be a fundamental principle of the American government.
They recognized the risks to which all human institutions are subject. But they knew that order cannot be secured merely through fear of punishment for its infraction; that it is hazardous to discourage thought, hope and imagination; that fear breeds repression; that repression breeds hate; that hate menaces stable government; that the path of safety lies in the opportunity to discuss freely supposed grievances and proposed remedies; and that the fitting remedy for evil counsels is good ones."
To consign evil to the shadows is no victory, for there are always shadows.
[0] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/when-washington-dc-ca...
[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qSEVyzKmlyU
[2] https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/the-confederat...
[3] https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/274/357
[4] https://jeffersonpapers.princeton.edu/selected-documents/eli...
What about if we were talking about allowing the widespread social propagation of those siding with and advocating for al qaeda on 9/12?
A rhetorically extreme comparison in terms of levels of violence BUT to me this is equally as <u>symbolic</u> of an attack on our Democracy and country. Even worse because it was from our own citizens attempting to actively stop Democratic process with weapons.
There are zillions of unencumbered ways to have unmoderated discourse on the tubes. The entitlement of having it on the most amplifying platforms is something that people couldn’t dream of a decade ago.
And its not permanent. The same people can discuss this at length at some future time. Just not during a riot.
Lets not pontificate about fine points of personal rights, while the nation's Capitol is under attack?
You're free to say whatever unpopular thing you want, just not everywhere. Given how these events have played out, I suspect many of the tech giants will take similar actions.
This seems to be limited to a place where it's clear protests aren't peaceful and people are calling on / acting undemocratically and are pretty open about it.
Facilitating folks who wish to take undemocratic steps would seem to bring us closer to far more serious restrictions, imposed by those same folks as far as how a democracy is or isn't allowed to operate.
You are not
Facebook is private property.
Let's pretend there was a massive Harvey Weinstein-like sexual harassment scandal at Facebook Inc. And Facebook responded by removing any posts mentioning the scandal or blocking the account of any journalists that reported on it.
Would you shrug your shoulders and say "private property". If not, then I think you have to admit that Facebook has some obligations to not abuse its moderation powers. If not in the formal legal sense, at least in a cultural and moral sense.
I think the grandparent was indicating that this is mostly a debate between the positions "Facebook should be broadly permissive of legal speech" and "Facebook should shape the discussion in ways that benefit the public good". The argument that Facebook has a moral right to do whatever the hell they like is mostly just a cudgel of an argument, though, to be picked up when it suits whichever of the two "real" arguments you support.
One refutation of this "private property argument is instrumental" position is the one the grandparent mentioned: That the people making the argument would "support" Facebook taking down speech that they deem "just". If the private property argument only holds for taking down unpalatable speech, it's not a position that's held honestly.
Making the argument even when it's not compelling (that is, even when there are other hypothetical cases in which it doesn't sway you) isn't necessarily hypocritical.
Do you object to Facebook censoring child pornography?
How nakedly egregious does the crime have to be before you're ok with Facebook censoring or removing it?
It doesn't sound like you consider solicitation to commit a crime of violence to be a serious enough offense. So I guess promoting, instigating or encouraging treason, sedition or subversive activities is acceptable to you.
There is also a difference between disliking a company covering up its own bad acts and a company preventing a 3rd party from using its resources for a thing that walks up to the edge (and in many people's opinion crosses over) into inciting other illegal acts.
Sounds like a win-win to me.
Since it should be obvious not to use Facebook if you dont agree with their service’s tendencies.
We conceded our communication to private ISPs, to private, device manufacturers, to private websites.
When people feel they cannot be heard, something is going to give.
The left has been in this position forever. But somehow we’re supposed to sympathize when a bunch of yokels storm into a parliamentary procedure and start shooting it up?
> The internet is nearly entirely private and controls the vast majority of communication.
Yes it's private, that doesn't mean they can't own it, they can setup their own private servers and be free of restriction.
Facebook needs to make all posts non-public to become private property. Then they can moderate.
Every time that this topic comes up, where the discussion is about the right and wrong of censorship, about finding a moral balance for safety and justice and expression, trolls like these jump in and give the "well it's not illegal so suck it" argument. It's tiresome, it's in bad faith, and it incites an emotional response from the reader.
At least as a reader of comments that's what I'd rather read: a well thought out rebuttal, than to never see the exchange due to moderation. Eternal September and all, it's fresh for someone.
Secondly, your tone suggests you'd think I have an inconsistent worldview if I believe moderators should perform any moderation action at all? You'll have to explain how that makes sense to you, because moderators providing escalating warnings to users that post insubstantive and volatile comments is something that's been with me for a long time and I'm rather fond of the practice.
> This is about ethical duty. Facebook is trying not to shirk this ethical duty. The top-level comment believes they are misapplying and overreaching in their effort to do this. Both my comment and the one it replies to largely do not touch even this discussion, their shtick is property rights and mine is substantive discourse. If you think I made a point about censoring unpopular content, you replied to the wrong comment.
As to this, fair enough. I had wrongly assumed this comment to be implicitly taking the other side of the GP comment, simply calling for its removal instead of refuting it (you’d be surprised how much things like this happen)
1. Tiresome; it gets made every thread, rebutted every thread, and no progress is made in the discussion. It's time to stop saying the same thing over and over.
2. In bad faith; it does not respond meaningfully to the discussion. Something being legal does not make it ethically optimal.
3. Inciteful; these comments are lightning rods for emotional arguments in the replies. If a comment always causes low-quality discussion, then it's a low-quality comment.
You're free to disagree with my points. I suppose I started the character shitflinging by calling the author a troll, but I really think anybody that's been reading HN for long enough (a decade, in that user's case) can do better if they intend to.
At a certain point, someone has to call it out as it really is - not what they say it is.
What are they against? I don't know a bunch of people who are part of this mob, but I'll make a guess. They are against a political establishment that has ignored them and their concerns.
Bernie appeals to the same kind of people, but the mainstream Democratic Party does not.
Of course in this particular situation FB are siding with the existing laws of a well-established Deomcracy, though in a nearby future they could easily side with the laws of a Dictator in some other country, or even just side with whoever happens to be in charge of some country right now otherwise they'll be shut down in said country.
It seems pretty risky to allow a private company that controls as much "global voice" as FB does to censor people with no oversight.
Surely this will end badly.
Removing non violent posts that contain: “Calls for protests — even peaceful ones — if they violate the curfew in DC” or “Praise and support of the storming of the US Capitol” feels like such an overreach. It makes me sick.
Unpopular speech is the most important, perhaps the only speech that needs to be defended. As Rosa Luxembourg said: those who do not move do not notice their chains. Any discourse that isn’t allowed to happen in popular mediums don’t disappear, it happen underground, and it’s a lot harder to detect.
I get removing calls to violence, but I don’t want these tech overlords making these judgment calls.