> unlike a traditional union, which demands that an employer come to the bargaining table to agree on a contract, the Alphabet Workers Union is a so-called minority union that represents a fraction of the company’s more than 260,000 full-time employees and contractors. Workers said it was primarily an effort to give structure and longevity to activism at Google, rather than to negotiate for a contract.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/04/technology/google-employe...
In societies that are not America, unions are traditionally left of center but most definitely still more or less in the center.
It seems that political discussions relating to the US don't have the appropriate vocabulary to discuss political opinions that are positioned to the left of the corporate wing of the Democratic party.
liberalism is not a far left ideology, it is actually pretty centrist. "Hyper-liberal" is more synonymous to libertarian than it is to what these google activists are.
America has a stunted perception of political ideology. This is pretty apparent when you observe far right pundits and politicians refer to democrats as "far left" when the majority are actually right of center and would be considered conservative in most european countries or even by the democratic party of 20 years ago.
I mean you can guess which 230 people are more likely to lose their job, then they had been before (if the union fails).
(I don't mean Google will target them, but that if Google considers letting them go for whatever other reason it's now more likely that they will let them go.)
imagine using tools explicitly created to facilitate communication and organization between employees but suddenly its abuse when used for organize something other than a potluck
That's like the guy hanging up memos from the top floor in the company lunch room one day deciding to slip in a political message, printed on official company stationary to disguise it as an official memo.
It's not about using general-purpose internal communication tools to remind co-workers of their rights, it's abuse of a privileged position involving the power to broadcast official messages.
Whether someone thinks it's justified by the cause is a separate argument.
0: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/12/engineer-says-go...
1: https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/cpt20...
I can guarantee you that there are AWU members who have tried to push back against product decisions by Google that you aren't a fan of, and been unsuccessful in doing so. Perhaps with more political force, they'll be better able to keep bad product decisions in check ;)
They thought it would be a home run given all of the nonsense that goes on there. As it turns out, selling people on the idea of unionizing is much harder than it sounds. People weren’t even necessarily afraid of the company, they just didn’t want to be in a union.
They, too, gathered a small number of people at first, but the effort fizzled out when the initial enthusiasm didn’t spread beyond those few idealistic people.
In a company the size of Google, it wouldn’t be hard to find 230 people who would claim to be unionizing, but it doesn’t mean much when you’re talking about a tiny fraction of employees.
> Google workers announce plans to unionize
I agree that the number involved is quite small at the moment, but given how hostile Google has been to any unisation effort, the fact the 230 people have organised anyway, and now put their jobs on the line, is quite a big thing.
I suspect that there are many at Google that would happily join a union, just look at how high the attendance of Google's walk outs have been. This announcement clearly indicates that union organisers believe they have enough support to come out of the woodwork, and start some serious campaigning.
You're assuming a lot here. The Google Walkout had a huge attendance because it had zero teeth and zero commitment. People took their lunch break outside to say "I don't like sexual harassment". Then they went back to their desks and back to work. Google refused all but one of their demands, fired or drove out all of the organizers, and went on with it's day.
Essentially, very few people who walked out would put their cushy Google job on the line for what they believe in. The organizers did, they're gone. A handful of other people since then have also put their jobs on the line for their principals, they've also now been fired. Every time Google has fired organizers, it has made it much harder for the remaining workers to organize, both because the people who would organize are gone, and those left have a cautionary tale of what happens if they do.
Everyone at Google today is someone who had a chance to stand up for what's right in a manner that risks their employment, and has chosen not to do so.
That being said, I'm not contesting the validity of the movement - it's certainly possible that thousands of Googlers will sign on in support now that the movement is public, and more power to them!
It just seems like the reporting on this should be making it more clear where this effort stands and just how much needs to happen before it's legally viable. Arguably, more honest reporting in that regard would help make clear to potential allies that their support is needed, and this is not a sure thing.
The people who are organization the union and signing petitions, but not hacking employer systems or calling their coworkers "Nazis" are still employed and organizing but also less visible to the public.
Much like cyclists facing cars have to learn that it's better to be alive than claim the right of way and be dead, activists need to be smart about taking calculated risks. (And if people are calculating that getting fired is good for their political cause or future career at a like-minded organization, then good for them!)
I'm hopeful that you're right, but I also suspect that a lot of engineers will look at the fees and decide "hey, 1% of my total compensation is actually a hefty amount." The walkouts were free.
This smells like "1% is the smallest positive number" fallacy on behalf of the owners.
(But that 1% is perhaps/likely only salary not equity.)
Blue collar unions need money to pay bills during a strike, but Googlers don't need that.
A big question to ask is whether Googlers need to pay for union or if they should donate to politicians who would regulate Google.
Well, think about it this way. 1% of 200k people making >$50k is the same amount.
There are 775k members of the IBEW, for reference, which charges 2% of base wages in additional to fixed overheads. The SAG charges dues of 1.575% on the first $500k. Writer's Guild charges 1.5% with no cap. So 1% is actually low.
> (But that 1% is perhaps/likely only salary not equity.)
The article stated "compensation", which I suppose could go either way, but I lean toward "total compensation" in my reading. But either way, I'm sure the majority of Google employees do make over $100k in base salary (between those in the Bay Area, New York, Seattle, Boston, London, and more).
> A big question to ask is whether Googlers need to pay for union or if they should donate to politicians who would regulate Google.
How many of those regulations would impact the profitability of Google (e.g. through antitrust enforcement) versus encourage better working conditions?
Huge difference between signing on and voting in a secret ballot - esp. in the context of in a company.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/20/technology/Google-union-c...
So this lowers the pool by quite a bit.
Also I believe in the USA has structural issues where each location has a union and not a whole company un ion
These minority unions do not have collective bargaining rights unless the employer agrees.
I’ve worked at places where certain departments were unionized (for example hospitality) but others were not. Far below any such 30% threshold for total employment. Also unions form at individual worksites all the time, so I sincerely doubt there’s any company-wide membership requirements.
Edit: I'm correct. There's this concept of a bargaining unit, so it would only have to be workers doing a certain type of work in a certain place, generally, though it can be just those doing a certain type of work:
https://www.workplacefairness.org/labor-unions#4
A company like google could end up with hundreds of unions.
This is something else.
Legally (I think, just learning about this now), to form a union, a majority of workers must show their willingness to form a union. Alternatively, to choose an existing union to join, an election with 30% of the workers support is required.[1]
So with that said, am I reading this right? Does this group of 230 people need to find at least ~40,000 more people for this to be a valid effort to form/join a legal union?
[0]https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/02/google-employee-growth-2001-...
[1]https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/how-to-form-a...