The bigger factor is that per-worker productivity is amplified immensely by technology. Historically, businesses needed to scale their employee base nearly linearly with the number of customers. If you were in the business of building houses or growing produce, your economies of scale topped out early. If you want to serve more customers, you have to hire more people to do the work.
In the technology era, the marginal cost of additional customers is minuscule. Netflix has to pay marginally more for bandwidth and licensing fees with each additional customer, but the number of employees necessary to support a growing customer base is minuscule. Even physical goods can have automated production as they scale up, so physical workers are less and less necessary as scale grows.
For the jobs that remain, supply and demand still dominates the equation. Engineer salaries have been pushed upward because demand for engineering work exceeds supply. Factory worker salaries have been flat or gone down because demand for [domestic] manual labor is decreasing, meaning more people are willing to work for lower compensation just to take those jobs.
Try as they might, the financial people can’t simply break the laws of supply and demand. If they try to keep so much of the profits that their wages fall below other companies, employees will simply leave for higher paying jobs. If the company raises wages so much that they need to charge customers more, their customers will simply leave for lower cost competitors.
This behavior is more intuitive when you put yourself in the shoes of the decision makers. If you called a plumbing company to fix your drain and they quote you a price 2X that of the competitor but claim that it’s because they pay their plumbers more, are you going to gladly take it? Or would you just call any number of alternatives that will charge you market rate costs? (If you are among the few who would gladly pay more for the same service, ask yourself how the general population would behave)
Here's some data:
https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2020/01/09/trends-in-income-...
Something is driving down wealth at the low end while driving it up at the high end. It seems unlikely in the extreme that this a reflection of actual value produced by people at the high end relative to those at the low end. Much more likely is that this is a reflection of some kind of structural problem in the system that is being perpetuated by the people at the high end using the political power that being at the high end affords them. Whether those people are "bankers" or are better described by some other label is kind of irrelevant. It's the overall dynamic that matters.
Nothing is driving wealth down. Wealth is increasing for everyone, generally speaking. This observation is important because it recognizes that wealth is created, not allocated. This is not a zero-sum game.
You say it seems unlikely that actual value is increasing at the high end but I do not think this opinion holds up to scrutiny. I think it is very likely that value at the high end has increased by multiples -- white collar jobs have become vastly more productive with the introduction of technology. Correspondingly, low value work has not. In fact, many of our most common low value jobs (retail, driving) risk going the way of the switchboard operator. There was no conspiracy to devalue the work of the switchboard operator; rather, so called "high value" tech jobs made this type of lower value work entirely obsolete.
I think it is unsurprising that high end work is rising in relative value while low end work is falling. I don't see any basis for imagining political or economic conspiracies: What we see in terms of value is exactly what we ought to expect.
That depends a lot on how you count. See:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBLB50107
The average net worth of the bottom 50% over the last 30 years is about the same as it was 30 years ago.
Compare to:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBLT01026
and note that the net worth of the top 1% has been increasing more or less monotonically for the last 30 years, with only a very small dip in 2008-2012.
The bottom 50% take a much bigger share of the losses and a much smaller share of the gains. Over the last 30 years the bottom 50% has barely broken even.
For example, suppose you have a car that you paid $20K in cash for this year. That works out to about $10K 30 years ago (I think the Fed charts you showed are in inflation-adjusted dollars, though they don't say so). So as far as monetary vaue is concerned, you have the same net worth in your $20K car today as a person 30 years ago would have in a car that cost $10K then. (Or even a car that cost $20K then, if we aren't adjusting cost for inflation.)
Having owned cars over this entire time period, however, I can tell you that the wealth contained in that $20K car today is quite a bit greater than the wealth contained in a car that cost $10K 30 years ago. A $20K car today will be more reliable, get better gas mileage and give better average performance, have numerous safety features that didn't even exist 30 years ago, and have more bells and whistles in general. So in terms of wealth, I'm quite a bit more wealthy with $20K worth of car today than a person 30 years ago would be with the same inflation-adjusted monetary value of car.
And cars are actually a pretty poor example as compared with, say, computers or phones.
[1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-ans...
Also, even in the CPI, they don't do "hedonic adjustments", which is what you are describing, for all goods. For example, I mentioned cars and computers; the only adjustments made for those items are "cost based adjustments". And many items don't even get those.
Then there's the question of whether the methodology they are using for making "hedonic adjustments" where they are making them actually captures what it claims to capture, which is, to say the least, not something everyone agrees on.
I think this depends on where you get your health care and education, but I agree that in many cases quality vs. price is certainly not where it should be.
> Inflation-adjusted money is a pretty good proxy for wealth. What else is there?
Not trying to centrally plan an entire country's economy based on faulty proxies for something that cannot be reliably measured [1]. Central planning just makes it easier for the rich to siphon more wealth from everyone else while disguising it as "helping".
For example, if we take your observation about quality vs. price for health care and education as true, and compare it to my observation about cars and computers, the general pattern is that the areas where quality vs. price is worst are the areas that are the most centrally planned, and the areas where quality vs. price is best are the areas that are least centrally planned.
([1] - The reason wealth cannot be reliably measured is that it's subjective; the value of a good or service depends on who has it and what use they can make of it. This is the only reason wealth can be increased by specialization and trade in the firt place.)
I apologize because I don't mean to only present disagreements but I don't think this is true, either.
I think that like-for-like health care has largely fallen in cost. The catch with health care is that we've developed better (and much more expensive) methods. Spending has increased dramatically. My grandparents grew up on a farm and when they broke a bone they set it at home. They saw a doctor on very rare occasions and when they did, treatment was limited. Their health care spending was very small, but so was the scope of their treatment. When my grandparents got cancer, they died. There were not nearly so many expensive options available for end of life ailments.
It's possible to live with the same kind of spartan health care today, but almost no one would because we are fantastically more wealthy than past generations.
Willingness to buy more is exactly what we would expect to see if wealth has risen over time, as I am arguing. The status quo rises dramatically as overall wealth increases.
Education is tricky as it's largely a fashion product at this point. Knowledge itself is often freely available in ways impossible to imagine decades ago. It's the prestige and pedigree that cost money. Fashionable limited-quantity things get wildly expensive as wealth increases.
No, I don't think that it does. The bottom 50% generally do not have savings and investments - they invest their wealth in tangibles: Housing, food, belongings.
It is not meaningful to look at investments or savings as a measure of wealth when most people near the bottom do not and have never had those things. It's necessary to look at what does signify wealth in this class: Consumption and physical belongings.
For example, when we look at the average square footage of a home for the bottom 50% we see dramatic increases over the last century -- because wealth in the bottom 50% has had a dramatic increase.
Income is not the dominant factor in whether or not someone lives paycheck to paycheck. People live this way with startlingly high incomes.
The real difficulty is in deciding who "gets credit" for producing a given thing. Is the person driving the tractor really more productive, or is the tractor itself responsible for producing most of the value (return on capital)? Maybe the bank that provided the loan for the tractor is creating value? Without any of those components, the food wouldn't be grown, so there's not an obvious way to divide it into the sum of individual contributions.
Exactly. The situation we currently have is that the people who are getting the most "credit" as you put it are by and large the same small group of people who make the rules for who gets the credit. "Bankers" is a convenient popular label for those people even though most of them don't actually work at banks.
Has been there been any detailed breakdown of how much more effective the median CEO in 2020 is over the median executive in 1970? I am certain they are doing things better, have more data, etc but what scale are we really looking at here?
Because, just thinking out loud here, the bulk of the workforce in the United States is more educated and has more hard skills than their predecessors did in 1970s. Firms demanded technology skills, for which they provided little or no training, and their workforce was able to acquire the necessary skills.. and yet the "upside" was nothing more than possibly being able to keep their job.
Effectiveness isn't the measure, exactly, it's how replaceable the CEO is, and the same is true of any employee. If everyone is more educated (and education may be nothing to do with what's required, incidentally), then people are still just as replaceable.
I have no good answers, as I definitely think there are pros and cons to modern executive teams, but it starts with replaceability.
The key takeaway is that that boards set the compensation based on the average compensation CEOs at peer companies, but performance isn't equally distributed. Essentially, the highest performing CEOs pull up the mean, and so the average and below average CEO compensation goes up.
[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/ceo-pay-and-performance-dont-ma...
You can't do a Tesla without PayPal exit level of money, you can't do a PayPal without zip2 exit money and you can't make a zip2 without a real estate agent footing the initial bills
It's financial levers all the way down
In that case even if all CEOs are equivalent getting hired is a lottery ticket
For example, you may not get the following explanation much, even though it requires no conspiracies and explains the outcomes: income is disproportionate because risk and capital are more important to a business' success than any particular individual's labour, and so they are correspondingly rewarded more as well.
> Although the economy is a complex system and it's dangerous to try to over-simplify, my personal opinion is that there are two main and intertwined causes:
1) the cost to participate in the US court system.
2) the abuse of copyright, patent, trademark, and contract[1] law to divorce workers from their experience and treat employee knowledge as company property.
The time and money involved in both pursuing and defending court cases favors larger entities with armies of lawyers and large war chests. Intellectual "property" cases take especially vast amounts of resources because of the fuzziness involved. Meanwhile, treating workers as fungible producers of ideas that can be bought and sold both reduces the bargaining power of individual workers while empowering companies that can amass large portfolios of patents, etc. to use in litigation.
Not sure about reforms for the court system, but patent and copyright reform, combined with restrictions on unfair employment contracts, would go a long way to improving the situation.
[1] NDAs, NCAs, etc.
Most humans have an aversion to death and destruction: we get attached to people, institutions, ideas, employers, basically things that we can count on existing. Economics doesn't care though. If a new way of doing things is more efficient than the old, the market will select for the new way, regardless of the human suffering it causes. And since most humans are averse to causing suffering, they won't be willing to capitalize on this opportunity, which leaves large opportunities available to those who say "To hell with institutions, there's a more efficient way and I'm going to bring it to the masses." They (and the SWEs, SREs, UX, data scientists, etc. who help them) then reap large windfalls as they cannibalize large portions of the economy and throw the now-useless workers out of work.
This model explains nearly everything about the past decade. The downside is that it suggests that "revolution" - rather than being an angry but illogical reaction of a few disgruntled workers - is actually an inevitable consequence of the destruction of the old society. Political systems are embedded in the economic realities that birthed them; change economic reality and the economically rational outcome is for those political systems to fall. The same thing happened as industrialization destroyed feudal empires and ushered in the era of nationalism.
There are numerous financial products and services available to only the wealthy that reduce tax burden and increase wealth and income that are inaccessible to anyone else, create little value, and are predicated on the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few.
Just a random example, if you can afford to buy a home in cash, you shouldn't because the mortgage terms the banks will offer you are too good to pass up - you'll come out ahead just by taking on low interest debt and accounting for the rise in the home's value plus the more lucrative investments you can make with the cash.
In other words, the people who get the most help are the ones who need it the least. That is the travesty of contemporary finance.
When the critique of the financial system is made its not in place of supply and demand for labor but the fact it creates very little besides disparity. The god of liquidity should not be worshipped so much.
There is also additional pressure at the low end: Being poor is expensive, especially in a society with low solidarity.
Besides debt being a potential burden, there are many things that you don't have access to. You can't buy in bulk, you can't buy quality gear, a season ticket, a home, You simply cannot invest, even if that made sense in the long term for you, your community, society etc.
It depends on the class of workers. I'd agree with you w/r/t most wage earners being paid in transparent manner. But I think the GP comment was referring to technology workers (given the context of HN.) In the case of tech workers, many are paid in very complex ways.
If you have illiquid stock options in a private company, and especially if you have taken a below-market salary as many startup employees have, your compensation is about as complex as a CDO. Just like a CDO there are multiple tiers above you that need to be paid out before you ever get paid.
Unlike a CDO, where you can actually pull up the details on the tiers above you (tranches), at startups as employees, you dont get to see the cap table, so the whole maze is invisible too!
Worse, unlike a CDO where you can sell at any time, here you have to exercise and hold stock for some far-away liquidity event that usually doesnt happen. So you have an invisible maze, and then a pot of gold at the end, perhaps. Or not.
I think this is part of the startup mythos. At the three startups I've worked at (~10 people), none of us had to sacrifice competitive salaries for stock options. The options were on top to incentivize staying at the company longer.
I wonder how common it actually is for people to take significant paycuts in 2020 for a startup opportunity (founders aside)
I don’t know where you’re from, but in SF amongst my circles, senior engineer market rate is about 300-500k but most startups will only pay 150-225k salary so that’s a huge pay cut. However, the base salaries are same, but you can pay your rent, mortgage, or student loans with the public company RSUs.
That’s why it’s bullshit when employees get told they get common shares while investors get preferred because employees take salary and therefore less risk. If you’re walking away from 200k per year of public stock that you could instantly sell on the public market and buy real estate with, you are in fact taking a huge risk and a pay cut. Trying to pretend like you’re not and that the startup is paying a “competitive salary” is a sleight of hand used in 2020 to fool naive engineers.
1. Level up your career / role flexibility. 2. Big companies suck (but [big] startups can suck too). 3. Burning idea you want to get done / tech is interesting. 4. Lottery tickets (options).
The big difference is that the publicly traded companies can pay RSUs worth money NOW.
Given that so many of the hot startups are in the Bay, I'd say only fresh college grads are looking at remotely similar comp between the two. Everyone else is playing the options lottery.
Does this map to reality? Are you saying that if you were at Google making 250K in TC the Startups were paying you 250K Base salary + stock options? That seems ludicrous.
I think it's still super common in general, although perhaps not in the bay area.
There are no competitively paid senior+ swes that keep their comp going to a startup. Full stop.
Illiquid equity makes a significant difference too. We’re talking total realizable dollars earned in a year.
It’s worth noting that I’m not saying this is fundamentally broken - that’s just the design of the system.
I've never heard it adequately explained why employees should accept this state of affairs. Not only is the cap table invisible, but the fully-diluted cap table and terms of dilution and many other terms and conditions are also hidden from non-founders/investors at most startups I've read about. I've heard so many stories of shares getting diluted right out from under employees immediately before a liquidity event that it has become a trope. IMHO that's not investing into a startup; that's buying a lottery ticket.
What am I missing here about typical startup stock options where the same terms and conditions founders and investors see are not accessible to employees?
It is the same as acting and sports -- people look the handful of winners, ignore the field of dropouts, and think they too can become a winner. They see AirBNB and think their startup is the next AirBNB.
Also much like acting and sports, there are a constant stream of new entrants who have not learned the lessons.
I want to be fair here -- I work at a startup and I love it. But I value my equity at zero and nothing more. I chose to work at a startup because I get to do cross-functional work rather than get stuck into a silo of a silo at a large company. I took a significant paycut from a large company salary and a significant upside cut from when I was a founder in exchange for more accelerated learning and exposure to all parts of the company.
That sounds like the general software startup industry has built their own version of video game industry goggles; glamorize the startup lifestyle and culture so much millions of kids will compete with each other into a race to the bottom. There's probably some succinct German compound word for this dynamic and if there isn't, I hope some German speakers can suggest some here so I can add it to my lexicon.
There is always the chance you’ll get super lucky, but investors and founders have become experts at extracting the maximum possible portion of the value created. To the point where there isn’t a whole lot left for anyone else. Workers included.
Anecdotally, in the Software field there is a lot of "price anchoring" where a large employer decides that a software engineer makes ~125k, and both smaller/peer employers decide that a software engineer makes 125k +/- 10%.
From past experience the base "going rate" in a given market doesn't seem to change all that much unless a large employer decides to change the going rate because a higher or lower price point better suits their business - other companies will set their salaries to the baseline. Big Tech has recently been dragging wages up across the board by both hiring in volume, and paying more than everyone else.
I'd be curious if anyone has a formal study on price anchoring in wage negotiations.
Even at the low end, six months of tooling work from a $100k coder can often put a handful of $50k/year white collar employees permanently out of work (or make them twice as productive as before). If one company doesn't realize that, another eventually will. It's not too tough to pull in ~50-100k/year running a SaaS business or freelancing
Things in the USA are really broken in the retail sector. Companies pay the absolute bare minimum that will keep them in business, and make up for a lot of the terrible morale issues that come along with that using Orwellian management systems
If you combine this with one employer bordering on a monopsony for buying a particular category of labor - then pay won't move in proportion to productivity.
Could achieve financial independence in 2 years
The unfortunate consequence of the taboo of salary discussions is young software engineers not knowing how much they can actually make.
I wouldn’t be surprised if one of the reasons you simply can’t survive on one person per household working, as in the 60s and 70s, is simply that two people are willing to work now and spend all their free cash on mortgage payments.
No one talks about this. I’d love to hear the debates. I’d love to be proved wrong.
It seems to be completely FUBAR to me. In Japan, housing ISN'T a glamorous investment, and I think that helps the house pricing situation a lot.. You can get a nice apartment in the fanciest part of downtown Tokyo for cheaper than a dangerous hole in the wall in San Jose
[1] Raze, rebuild, repeat: why Japan knocks down its houses after 30 years: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusabl...
You can't live in a share of stock, though it may appreciate faster than a house. (You also generally speaking can't use leverage to purchase shares). But even if shares appreciate faster than homes, they don't feed into conspicuous consumption: and that matters to some segment of the population.
I wouldn't say it has no influence, but it's probably difficult to state with much precision how great the effect is.
Why would you love that? It's 100% a factor. One of the key drivers of house price increases has been two-income households, with the nice double personal tax allowances, that allow much higher offers. Additionally in the UK I think it became illegal for mortgage companies to offer a lower multiplier on the second income, so it's a huge boost.
Are you insinuating it has nothing to do with executive wages ballooning (CEO compensation growing nearly 1,000% since the 1970's) and is instead because women are working?
For example Tim Cook earns 133M/yr which is $976 per employee. ... and this probably massively overstates the figure due to contractors.
Or Sundar Pichai with $86M/yr which is $676 per employee (again... not counting contractors).
Obviously it's more if you include more executives, but the number of top executive companies is basically a constant and at large companies it still ends up being not very large per employee.
This isn't to say that it isn't a concern but I don't see how to justify the belief that the executive compensation at large companies is a major factor in the overall wage market.
Its US women vs the global S&P list, but it is interesting to compare, now that you mention it.
[1]https://aflcio.org/paywatch
[2]https://www.catalyst.org/research/womens-earnings-the-pay-ga....
[3]https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-in-the-workforce-uni....
That is $7 billion to CEOs vs $3.5 Trillion for women.
In the USA, there has been a (relative) decrease in labor supply due to women leaving the work force. Women's participation in the labor force by percentage has decreased over the past twenty years.
I don't think the point has anything to do with the complexity of the wages, but how workers are generally hired and paid, and how work is now structured, compared to the 70s, e.g. nowadays there are more contractors than ever, taking a good chunk of the wages as they act as intermediaries between customers and the workers who, otherwise, would have to be hired directly by the customers themselves.
I'm curious though about why would you think that illegal immigration is driving wages down. Undocumented immigrants make barely for 3% of the total US population [1], and that does not account for those who cannot work (elderly, children, disabled, etc.) Same goes for women, as the general issue is that household income is in decline, in relative terms to the economy [2].
Automation should also be making consumer products cheaper and more available, but prices are not going down at the same speed as wages need to go up.
[1] https://www.brookings.edu/policy2020/votervital/how-many-und...
[2] https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Featured%20Insight...
If you were born before between 1935 and 1955, this might have affected your career progression. Maybe. Because the more workers meant a bigger economy and therefore more jobs overall. If you were born before 1925 or after 1975, it had zero effect.
I think the damning thing is that it has. Just not for the workers. wages for high level executives for example not only kept up, it's gone so high that they can't even invest their money anymore. they're complaining about the lack of got investment opportunities instead, sitting on their billions which destroys their society even more by keeping the money from circulation.
I think you meant "wages started decoupling ...", right?
Even if my guess is that YC partners are well intentioned, doing something this radical would make many enemies in the VC ranks, and damage YC in the long run.
I don't know... Perhaps a "revolution", like you're saying.
Only temporarily. Energy today, adjusted for inflation, is actually quite a bit cheaper now than it was even before the early 70s oil crisis.
Lord grant me the confidence of a HN commentor talking about economics :/
https://inflationdata.com/articles/charts/inflation-adjusted...
So, not "Nope".
Also, crude oil is not all there is to "energy". Here are a couple of other charts:
Electricity prices 1960-2011:
https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/annual/showtext.php?t=p...
I was somewhat off about the peak due to the "energy crisis", it was actually in 1983.
Gasoline prices 1929-2015:
https://www.energy.gov/eere/vehicles/fact-915-march-7-2016-a...
This comment section is nothing if not predictable.
Well, sure, but not durably so; the most dramatic examples being a pair of transitory geopolitical events producing short-term supply shocks.
Productivity is a ceiling for wages. "Decoupling" implies that, for various reasons, there's been a surplus in the labor market since the 70's.
I’m sorry gig workers, contractors, Amazon warehouse workers, startup workers, but there’s not much to see here. We’ll try to be better later if we get lucky enough to get a whole new industry again.
I had never considered it this way in the past, but in the 70’s, productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains.
I.e. the best people at finance (meritocracy) figured out how to capture all the new earnings relative to the workers (who didn’t know this game was going on).
This has snowballed into a situation where the financial meritocracy is competing with itself and could now never imagine a situation where non-finance people are being paid more in proportion with their value relative to baseline productivity gains.
This article would fit that narrative as a symptom of one-upmanship gone amuck.
How do we exit this brutal cycle? It requires a generation of new blood that is actually concerned about societal stability and recognizes the connection between instability and leaving 99% of folks behind as games are fought in ‘the ivory cloud’.
Will this be dealt with sans revolution? Who knows...