Effectiveness isn't the measure, exactly, it's how replaceable the CEO is, and the same is true of any employee. If everyone is more educated (and education may be nothing to do with what's required, incidentally), then people are still just as replaceable.
I have no good answers, as I definitely think there are pros and cons to modern executive teams, but it starts with replaceability.
The key takeaway is that that boards set the compensation based on the average compensation CEOs at peer companies, but performance isn't equally distributed. Essentially, the highest performing CEOs pull up the mean, and so the average and below average CEO compensation goes up.
[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/ceo-pay-and-performance-dont-ma...
You can't do a Tesla without PayPal exit level of money, you can't do a PayPal without zip2 exit money and you can't make a zip2 without a real estate agent footing the initial bills
It's financial levers all the way down
In that case even if all CEOs are equivalent getting hired is a lottery ticket
Has been there been any detailed breakdown of how much more effective the median CEO in 2020 is over the median executive in 1970? I am certain they are doing things better, have more data, etc but what scale are we really looking at here?
Because, just thinking out loud here, the bulk of the workforce in the United States is more educated and has more hard skills than their predecessors did in 1970s. Firms demanded technology skills, for which they provided little or no training, and their workforce was able to acquire the necessary skills.. and yet the "upside" was nothing more than possibly being able to keep their job.