News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by kumarski on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:16AM (#25198595)
5 Billion Cubic Meters of Oil are produced Annually by humanity.

30Bn Tons of CO2 generated.

60% is un-sequesterable because it is small and/or mobile.

40% is sequestrable and large scale/stationary.

12 Billion Cubic Meters of CO2 are thus sequestrable.

You must liquefy CO2 before putting it into the ground.

50% -70% efficiency in converting it to a liquid that we can shove into the ground.

6 to 8.4 Billion Cubic Meters of Liquefied CO2 are thus Sequestrable.

Shoving 6 to 8.4 billion cubic meters of liquefied CO2 into ground is no small matter.

Think about it this way, humanity built an entire industry focused on an annual extraction of 5Bn Cubic Meters of Oil over a time span of 100+ years with refineries and complex processes spanning multiple countries, geographies, regulations, wars, and land rights.

Also, who’s going to buy sequestered carbon?

The reality is that something like this will require spinning up an entire Trillion dollar market.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by watertom on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:22AM (#25199243)
Don't forget that the permafrost is thawing and it's starting to release massive amounts of CO2, much more than previously thought. The thawing is releasing massive amounts of Methane, and Nitrous Oxide which are far more impactful than CO2.

Due to warming temperatures more ice is melting and it's raising the temperature of the oceans and it's causing them to be more acidic, both of which is bad for phytoplankton populations, which have already declined steeply. Phytoplankton is the basis for the entire marine ecosystem.

Like most collapses, a declines happen gradually then suddenly it crashes, my fear is that the phytoplankton population will crash soon, and when it does we're in deep trouble. 20% of the atmosphere's oxygen comes from phytoplankton, more than all the world's rain forests combined.

The ocean is responsible for somewhere between 50-80% of the atmosphere's oxygen, there is no telling what happens when the phytoplankton population crashes. We could see a huge drop in oxygen levels in the atmosphere very quickly.

30% of the world's population relies on the oceans for their primary source of protein, and about the same number of people rely on the marine ecosystem for their livelihood, when the phytoplankton population crashes, those people will be in serious, serious trouble.

Reducing our carbon output isn't enough, slowing an increase still means we are increasing concentration levels, we need to be removing more than we are releasing, and I don't see any possible way to achieve that with any known technology.

I don't think we can stop, or even slow what we've started. The earth is now seeking it's new equilibrium state, it's hard to say if we are part of that equilibrium state.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by flyGuyOnTheSly on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:42AM (#25199429)
I too thought that we need the oceans and trees etc to breath... And then this article blew my mind wide open. [0]

I am definitely not advocating for the destruction of our ecosystems or cheering on their decline, just thought this was a great article.

tl;dr we do not rely on photosynthesis or any active living thing to produce the oxygen that we breath. It in fact mostly comes from decay/death.

[0] https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/08/amazon-f...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by bluegrownlife on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:29PM (#25201367)
Great article, and glad you brought this up. Just want to expand on the "decay/death" since it's referred to in 2 different ways in the article:

1) The decay/death of photosynthesizing organisms feed carbon to non-photosynthesizing organisms (ex: humans) and essentially neutralizes any net gain in atmospheric O2. Therefore the typical lifecycle of trees/phytoplankton doesn't add more O2 to the atmosphere than the current level.

2) In the rare instance that the decay/death of phytoplankton is quickly buried underground (ex: deep-sea mud), there is a net gain in atmospheric O2. Over the course of millions years, this process has led to ~21% atmospheric O2.

So, everyday decay/death of life doesn't "produce" O2 in the way photosynthesis does, but it does when photosynthesizing organisms get buried underground.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by rayiner on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:32AM (#25199339)
The permafrost tipping point theory is not accepted science: https://earther.gizmodo.com/climate-scientists-debunk-point-...

Also, oxygen levels would not drop rapidly. It would take millions of years: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/destructive-amazo...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Diederich on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:45AM (#25199451)
Correct, it's not currently widely accepted. In many ways, science is more 'conservative' than so-called 'conservative' political parties, which is probably a good thing.

However, there's a lot of emerging that supports the concept that there will be a large amount of methane release from the arctic over the next few decades. Very large.

If this happens, and I truly hope it does not, then the impact will be enormous and devastating.

While such a release isn't sure, the combination of possibility and impact is more than enough for us to deeply consider it during policy considerations.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gizmo686 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:18PM (#25200533)
Is there a difference between a drop in oxygen levels and a rise in CO2 levels?

My understanding of the oxygen cycle is that O2 gets removed from the atmosphere by being bound to carbon in CO2. Further, since most of the oxygen is O2, while most of the carbon is currently biomass; any notable drop in O2 levels would be a disasterous rise in CO2 levels.

Specifically, O2 is about 200,000 ppm, while CO2 is about 400ppm.

As I understand it, a 1% drop in O2 levels would put us at about 2,400 ppm of CO2; at which point we are looking at significant cognitive decline; and I don't even know how to speculate on the grean house effect.

On the other hand, climbing to the top of the eifel tower (1000 ft) corresponds to a drop of about 4% in the partial pressure of oxygen.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by marcus_holmes on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:35PM (#25200744)
> Is there a difference between a drop in oxygen levels and a rise in CO2 levels?

Yes.

These are two independent gases in the atmosphere. A drop in one does not equate automatically to an increase in the other.

There's a process involved in converting carbon to CO2. To make CO2 levels rise by 6x, the process of converting would need to be running at 6x too. The entire of human industry over ~100 years has contributed to increasing CO2 levels by 1x (so doubling them). So we're not in any imminent danger of 6x.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by pfdietz on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:17PM (#25204169)
Oxygen is also removed by reaction with other reducing species, like sulfide and ferrous iron. And of course in reaction with organic matter water is produced also, not just CO2.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by imglorp on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:30PM (#25200691)
There are also ocean floor methane klathrates. As the water warms those will also release vast amounts.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by anonuser123456 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:57PM (#25202383)
Oceanic clathrate release is not projected under even the worst warming estimates. The timeline for oceanic clathrate release is measured in thousands of years.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by soperj on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:46AM (#25200136)
We know that CO2 levels have been much higher in the past. Why do you think that Phytoplankton population will crash when they didn't in the past?
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by j-pb on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:24PM (#25201308)
In the past these things have been slow gadual processes taking hundreds of thousands if not millions of years.

The phytoplankton back adapted to the high acidity. The phytoplankton we have today evolved to fit our current acidity.

They are two entirely distinct sets of species that evolved to optimally adapt to the conditions of their time.

But now we're changing the acidity of the oceans at a much faster pace. In a matter of years, not millennia.

The plankton does not have the time to adapt to these conditions and will thus die. Just like we've already seen in coral reefs.

The population will rebound eventually, but that again, will probably take millennia.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by soperj on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:49PM (#25201583)
>In the past these things have been slow gadual processes taking hundreds of thousands if not millions of years.

How is that actually true, but at the same time the melting of the permafrost will result in very large releases of CO2, NO and Methane? One of these must be false.

Phytoplankton also live for very short periods of time, no more than a few days, they would likely adapt more readily to change than longer lived organisms.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by j-pb on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:56PM (#25203991)
Even with the high reproduction rate, even 100 years with lower oxygen levels would be devastating.

Also, the gases in permafrost accumulated of milennia of decay processes. So I don't get your point.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by soperj on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:12PM (#25204134)
The point is that if there is a trigger that releases them that will cause devastating knock on global warming, that will have also occurred in the past, and it's not a slow gradual process that life has millions of years to adapt to.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by j-pb on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @02:50AM (#25206856)
a.) co2 fluctuations might have never been large enough to trigger the effect.

b.) there have been plenty off mass extinctions in the past, the question is: do you want to be in one

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by hollerith on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @08:32AM (#25208997)
co2 levels in the air have been higher in the past million years than they are now or will be in 50 years.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by philipkglass on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:26PM (#25212458)
Atmospheric CO2 levels are currently higher than they have been in the past 3 million years.

https://e360.yale.edu/digest/co2-concentrations-hit-highest-...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by soperj on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @05:45PM (#25215124)
From your article: >The last time CO2 levels were this high was during the Pliocene Epoch, 5.3 to 2.6 million years ago, when the Earth was several degrees warmer, sea levels were an estimated 50 feet higher than they are today, and forests grew as far north as the Arctic.

Doesn't really point to phytoplankton populations crashing as being a likely scenario.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by j-pb on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:08AM (#25228398)
Like I said. The phytoplankton of that time, is not the same phytoplancton we have today.

There are evolutionary drivers that push lifeforms towards efficiency.

A thick, protein rich, acid resistant shell is much more expensive, than a thin, calcium rich one.

Well... until the day a new outlier species comes along and turns back the clock by 3 million years, in 100.

To put that into perspective, it's like asking you on vacation to the bahamas giving 7 days to pack your stuff, and when the time to leave arrives I yell: "Surprise! We're actually going to siberia, time to pack your winter coat, the plane leaves in 20 SECONDS!"

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by IronRanger on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:14AM (#25199152)
There are still countries around the world which subsidise fossil fuels. Not indirect subsidies like exporation writeoffs for corporations, but actual incentives for consumers to consume in the form of below-market pricing.

https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/value-of-foss...

And even without subsidies, petrol and diesel are undertaxed in almost every country.

Properly taxing fossil fuel is surely a more cost-effective preliminary step compared to schemes like CCS.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sudosysgen on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:15AM (#25199772)
While this is true, there is a reason why so many poor countries have to subsidize fossil fuels.

In those countries, if you are middle class or below, without those subsidies, you might not be able to heat your house, go to work, or fuel your tractor.

So unless you want revolts, it's not going to be possible to remove those subsidies unless massive investment at a world-wide scale in nuclear, hydro, and other types of renewables, as well as a serious ramp up of cheap (3000-9000$) EV production, actually makes it possible for the average Joe there to survive without fossil fuel subsidies.

There are also other countries that are richer in which this doesn't apply, for which there is no excuse.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by IronRanger on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:16PM (#25200507)
That is the political justification but several studies have found that the benefits flow mostly to the wealthy. If you are poor in a 3rd world country, you cannot afford a car.

This study from 2012 shows the top 20% get 43% of the benefit, the bottom 20% only 7%:

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2012/05/09/real-co...

Moreover these subsidy schemes are hugely expensive, and the money is better used elsewhere - eg. education, family planning, clean infrastructure.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sudosysgen on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:43PM (#25200817)
It's not true that if you are poor in a third world country, you cannot afford a vehucle. A lot of poor people in third world countries instead use and indeed share incredibly old cars from the 60s-70s, or motorcycles. It is often literally a matter of life and death - if you get stung by a scorpion in the Atlas mountains, unless your family or village have a car and fuel for it, you're just not getting medical care, which is why you'll see many such very old cars there. This is a real issue - the micro-village in the mountains where part of my family lives had one of my aunts die as a baby because a scorpion bit her and she couldn't be brought to a hospital due to a lack of transportation. They bought a Citroën 2CV after, and it's still used up to this day.

Now, of course, like all non-progressive subsidies, they benefit the wealthy disproportionately, because they make disproportionate amounts of money. But for the bottom 20%, those 7% of the subsidies are a lot, because they often make less than 7% of the income.

So a workable solution would be to make these subsidies progressive, tied to income and consumption, but unless you've lived there it's difficult to understand just how bad removing them altogether would be. It could literally lead to revolts.

Also, that study is hugely problematic because it takes the entirety of the world together, instead of operating at national scales. I already agreed that for richer countries this should be phased out, and subsidies are likely to be much higher in richer, often non-producing countries, than in poor countries.

Also, before they got solar panels and batteries around 8 years ago, they were still reliant on kerosene for lighting.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by CyanBird on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:24PM (#25201319)
> It could literally lead to revolts.

Forget the third world altogether, it has already led to revolts in France, the entire movement of the yellow vests is based on rural low middle class people revolting against the state for an increase in fuel taxes along several older other sticking points

But, if you want to sell this idea to the people, give it the nationalist spin, say that the country is suffering as a consequence of dollars escaping from the country per the subsidies, and subsidies have to be changed/reformatted to help the nation itself, etc, etc

Anyhow you are completely right when it comes to the vehicles bit, saying it as someone from a third world country

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by 908B64B197 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:54PM (#25212841)
> Forget the third world altogether, it has already led to revolts in France, the entire movement of the yellow vests is based on rural low middle class people revolting against the state for an increase in fuel taxes along several older other sticking points

It's also that they aren't offered any alternative to using fuel (good luck finding public transit in these rural regions; the population density simply makes it impossible).

And where's the money from the fuel tax going? Financing alternatives for these people or is it funneled into some civil servant's retirement funds?

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:43AM (#25200096)
Changing those subsidies to income tranfers of money would be cost neutral and strictly better or equal for everyone and save on emissions.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sudosysgen on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:55PM (#25200965)
It wouldn't be. Governments in such poor countries often buy fossil fuels below international market prices as they produce them, and directly giving money is problematic because a lot of people do not have bank accounts, and that fraud and embezzlement is a huge issue.

I agree that they should be made progressive and thus reduced immediately and phased out as soon as possible, but it's just not feasible the remove them completely immediately.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:36PM (#25202141)
Getting fossil fuels below market prices sounds like a way to fund the transfers to me.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sudosysgen on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:55PM (#25202363)
In theory, yes, but it's often more complicated than that. Often those agreements don't allow the governments to actually sell them internationally at below market prices.

Also, you completely glossed over the rest of the comment, which complicates things even more.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:26AM (#25206260)
These agreements sound curious as they're tantamount to foregoing fuel sales income to the counterparty. Are you really free favours that the governments are getting?

Re bank accounts and embezzling, these are no worse problems, subsidized fuel is also vulnerable to smuggling abroad and other kinds of corruption and systems of exchange other than gasoline are well known technology in history of human societies, however attractive the mad max model is...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sudosysgen on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @02:28AM (#25206760)
Governments of oil-producing poorer nations often ask of companies producing fossil fuels that they give some part of their production at a profitable, but under market prices, in order to be allowed to operate.

My point wasn't just embezzling, it was just distribution. A large section of your population might just not have a bank account.

Also, it's way harder to embezzled fuel that money, and I'm baffled that you'd think some kind of government official could steal an appreciably high volume of fuel to be worth enough for the risk without involving a large number of accomplices and thus exponentially more risk. It's really incomparable.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by ivirshup on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:18PM (#25200530)
The countries that I can think of which subsidize oil also produce it. Plus, it's easier to embezzle money than oil – so better to keep that.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gibspaulding on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:47PM (#25201554)
> a serious ramp up of cheap (3000-9000$) EV production

I really can't wait to see electric trickle down to the budget market. I get Tesla's approach of making EV's sexy with self driving/ludicrous mode/etc and I know the cost of batteries is a limiting factor right now, but I'd love to see how cheaply you could build an electric car.

It seems like with virtually no moving parts, and battery production getting better, you aught to be able to build an EV for a good deal less than an equivalent ICE vehicle.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by elindbe2 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:25PM (#25202046)
Kandi was already planning to sell an $8000 electric car in California. I believe that includes subsidies and the car only gets 59 miles of range, but it's a start.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by bit_logic on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:59PM (#25201011)
What you described can be the path to fast action on climate change. Only a few more steps are required:

* Cover every rooftop, every parking lot, every desert with solar panels as much as we can. Cover every windy plain with wind turbines. Take all the excess power and instead of building expensive batteries, use it to power this CO2 -> synthetic liquid fuel process.

* Carbon tax on any "fossil" fuel sources (anything from the ground). Make it expensive so the synthetic fuel is competitive. There's other ways too (like requiring X% mix of carbon neutral synthetic fuel, just like they do now with ethanol). Slowly increase the percent over time.

* All the old infrastructure (existing cars, gas power plants, ships, trains, buses, airplanes, etc.) becomes more and more carbon neutral as the fuel becomes more synthetic.

Even with the most optimistic EV car adoption projections, there will still be millions of gas cars out there. Other old carbon fuel based infrastructure (such as power plants) are hard to replace because solar/wind are not steady sources of power.

This path addressees the weaknesses of solar/wind (how to store excess energy) and how to quickly transition existing infrastructure to carbon neutral.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by firebaze on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:44PM (#25202240)
> Cover every rooftop, every parking lot, every desert with solar panels as much as we can. Cover every windy plain with wind turbines

You'd extract quite a significant amount of energy from the weather system, assuming we'd globally and optimally achieve this. What could be the consequences? Winds could locally diminish, thermal convection could be reduced, lots of effects could happen we don't understand yet.

In which way would this interact with local climate? Would this cause local temperatures to rise?

Just pointing out potential unintended consequences this could have without offering a solution. My takeaway from past good ideas (automobile, chemistry, electricity, globalization, ...) is that there is at least one _big_ unintended consequence of action.

I'd rather try to reduce our environmental and thermal footprint altogether by reducing our energy consumption, trying to keep up the standard of living people are used to. Just my opinion, but the uprising of populist parties suggests we should not overdo good intentions.

Also, if a radical approach like the proposed one would fail, populist parties would exploit that failure to the fullest amount possible.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by jbotz on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:58PM (#25203431)
I think in the big picture the effects you are talking about are really small in the same way that the heat dissipation of all our energy use (from whatever energy sources) is negligible relative to daily incoming/outgoing solar radiation. Greenhouse gases affect these much larger energy flows (which is our problem right now), but the energy "produced" or "used" (i.e. transformed into entropy) by civilization barely even registers on that scale, and that's what you're talking about when you say "energy extracted from the weather system".

Of course if we keep doubling the size of our economy (and thus energy use) every 25 years, then we will start having to worry about the heat dissipated by it all in a couple of hundred years even if all of it comes from perfectly green fusion reactors!

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by throwaway5752 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:31PM (#25201388)
This is pretty much what Al Gore et al. proposed 20+ years ago. The historical lessons are more interesting than the technical ones, and everyone should be aware of those so they understand the fight they are fighting.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by hutzlibu on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:42PM (#25202804)
"Cover every rooftop, every parking lot, every desert with solar panels as much as we can"

Some context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertec#/media/File:Fullneed....

Theoretically, only a very small area of dessert land would need to be covered with solar panels.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sbierwagen on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:06PM (#25202454)
>Cover every rooftop, every parking lot, every desert with solar panels as much as we can. Cover every windy plain with wind turbines. Take all the excess power and instead of building expensive batteries, use it to power this CO2 -> synthetic liquid fuel process.

This makes our current infrastructure carbon-neutral, yes. But that doesn't solve global warming? Atmospheric CO2 levels are already too high. We're at 413ppm, and we need to go back to 350ppm. Doing that requires carbon sequestration, which by definition makes no useful product.

The scale of the problem is thus: every kilogram of coal that has ever been dug up needs to be unburnt and buried, and every barrel of oil ever pumped out of the ground needs to be put back. That's the only way you can get to 350 ppm.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by firebaze on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:24PM (#25202623)
Adding to your points, CO2 is also consumed by biological and geological processes (plants, algae, absorption in water etc.).

Expanding on this, we could support the natural CO2 reducing mechanisms by for example stopping deforestation and supporting local tree planting initiatives.

I'm not sure it is helpful to support the narrative we're all lost already - we won't ever put all our produced CO2 back into earth. We should give a positive spin on the potential ways out from my point of view. At least I didn't ever hear someone object against planting trees :)

I know this wouldn't be enough to keep up with CO2 emissions, but it definitely wouldn't hurt and it could give momentum to environmental protection initiatives.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by aaomidi on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:10PM (#25203545)
We NEED carbon capture that's fast and efficient. Potentially biologically modified algea or something can speed this up too.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by dredmorbius on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:09PM (#25204108)
Engineer bogs.

Per unit area, wetlands sequester more carbon than any other terrestrial habitat. Some ocean habitats maay do better.

Constructed freshwater or saltwater bogs might be the most effective way forward. Existing and novel wetlands.

Side effects are interesting to contemplate.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by anthropodie on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:10PM (#25201144)
> cover every rooftop ..

What about the carbon we add doing this? I mean manufacturing, transport and all such indirect sources of carbon.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by bit_logic on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:26PM (#25201337)
Everything currently requires fossil fuel sourced energy to create it. So the question is, over the expected lifespan of the object, will it create more energy than was required to produce it? Solar panels expected lifespan is about 30 years. Installation, transport, etc. are all a fixed initial carbon cost. Studies and analysis have already been done (google search for studies from NREL) and the initial carbon cost payback is about 3-4 years of a typical 30 year solar panel lifespan. So 27 years of effectively carbon negative power generation.

But also consider the downstream effects. Once you have a carbon negative power source like solar in place, the carbon cost to create other things drops as well (since they use less and less power from fossil fuel sourced power).

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by dredmorbius on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:13PM (#25204139)
Solar panels expected lifespan is about 30 years.

Nearer 20, due to numerous degredation pathways.

Meaning that one possible avenue to reduced impact would be an extended-life PV (or other solar) array. It's a ccomplex prtoblem, and one for which present financial methods (NPV, future vaalie discounting) work strongly against.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by CyanBird on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:15PM (#25201213)
> What about the carbon we add doing this?

That's why OP is talking of decarbonificating the oil production itself, so as things start to decarbinify they will continue accelerating on that road as other processes become more decarbonized

The entire aluminum production on Iceland for example is already decarbonized

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by arrosenberg on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:16PM (#25201227)
Instead of destroying all of our deserts and creating a transmission problem, we could probably just swap in a few dozens nukes to backstop renewables. That addresses the shortcomings of wind and solar and provides plenty of overprovisioning for carbon capture without the poor land use.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by triceratops on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:08PM (#25202480)
Why not do both, just to be safe? We can get solar and wind going immediately so let's get started on that stat, while we work on permitting and design for new nuclear. It doesn't have to be either or.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by missosoup on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:59PM (#25202398)
> Cover every rooftop, every parking lot

'renewables' are not a viable option for the energy requirements of large scale carbon capture. It's a massive rollout of nuclear (ideally fusion but fission is good enough), or nothing. The political unwillingness of western nations to roll out nuclear power is one of the biggest obstacles to realistically tackling climate change on timelines where it matters.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by GhostVII on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:26AM (#25199279)
People will buy sequestered carbon if there is a market for it. Some kind of cap-and-trade system for emissions would make it profitable to do carbon capture once cheaper methods of reducing emissions have been exhausted.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by baq on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:48AM (#25199479)
> Also, who’s going to buy sequestered carbon?

the free market doesn't apply here, because the climate doesn't have buying power, nor does it care. it's a political decision on a world level.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by DesiLurker on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:15PM (#25201209)
>climate doesn't have buying power though I agree with the conclusion thats a bad argument, people do have buying power and they do care IF theymake the connection. that said even if it does not makes financial sense we should still do it because 1) survival of biosphere should trump survival of economic system. 2) people are ignoring the potential to create new market here and the possibility of creating an entirely new industry is quite enticing.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by baq on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:21PM (#25202599)
our climate situation fits pretty much perfectly to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons. given that, i see no way forward other than a coordinated policy change world-wide (otherwise everybody who can count money will move their polluting assets to places which don't accept the policy).

the one way we could sort of proceed is to make being climate-friendly have financial sense. this is the job of taxes and incentives, i.e. regulations. people with money hate changing regulations that got them money and they have money to prevent changing these regulations. countries without money look at countries with money and ask why they have to suffer if those guys could pollute how much they wanted and got rich in the process. the challenge to get a compromise here is unprecedented and the clock is merciless.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by DesiLurker on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:42PM (#25212662)
yes there is no simple solution around tragedy of the commons.. so much so that at times I have felt that it might be our great filter. essentially the kind of survivalist, individualistic thinking that leads to one to innovate out a solution also becomes THE problem when you come close to exhausting the resource limit. Is there a distributed/decentralized solution out of this? I am not sure, basically any attempt at adjusting the underlying pricing structure to reflect carbon prices again has to be global and have some sense of fairness built in for newcomers & guess what they dont hold the power to force rich countries to adapt. so we are back to TotC just at the national level. and even if they do or there is a sudden moment of clarity for the rich & powerful countries any voluntary adjustments will only last till there is a real recession then another DJT will be there to spin an 'alternate fact'.

this is why I feel creating another parallel industry of carbon capture may be the only way out of this mess. that too imho will work when fear starts to take hold. the big question is how much time we as a species will have to react before it becomes SHTF.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by mhh__ on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:10PM (#25200442)
The free market doesn't apply in that sense, but it is clearly the way forward in the sense that Carbon Taxation/Pricing and other schemes are clearly going to be more effectively than government intervention.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by baq on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:19PM (#25200543)
oh i think we are in agreement - carbon tax and/or carbon dividends are political decisions, after all. the market will adapt to regulations, hopefully with benefit for the climate. it's just not easy to get there, apparently politicians are too afraid and/or have too much money from kickbacks from fossil industry.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by cogman10 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:46AM (#25199460)
I think research still needs to be poured into carbon sequestration, but I agree with your overall analysis.

Carbon sequestration is like ocean desalination. Sure, it can be done, but it's a lot easier and a lot more efficient to start with a non-salty body of water.

Stopping carbon emissions is a lot more important in the short term.

Long term, I can see carbon capture being used as an alternative to push for a carbon neutral or negative economy. We'll likely need captured carbon for shipping, airplane travel, and plastics.

A positive of carbon capture is that you can pretty much set it up anywhere. You may be able to setup a capture facility at major fuel hubs to cut down on transport costs.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:34PM (#25200729)
So, in eons past, carbon was sequestered naturally via calcium carbonate (CaCO3) if I'm following your math we'd need 4B tons of Ca / yr to sequester that yes? Of course, that's vastly more than we produce a year, but it is the 5th most abundant element. Could we scale up CaCO3 production to sequester carbon?
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by jackdeansmith on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @07:08PM (#25204524)
The term you're looking for is "enhanced weathering"
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by ip26 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:14PM (#25201203)
My mind wanders to farming calcifying zooplankton. I wonder how hard it is to remove them from the carbon cycle.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:30PM (#25203198)
You also have to consider that as the oceans absorb more co2, they become more acidic, making it harder for plankton to form shells and sequester carbon.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by jartelt on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:00PM (#25201019)
And... spinning up that trillion dollar market would likely be worth every penny if it prevents continued warming, prevents further significant sea level rise, prevents migration crises due to flooding/droughts/etc, and prevents further ocean acidification.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by m463 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:06PM (#25201099)
A better rule of thumb is 1 gallon of gasoline is ~20 lbs of C02. That puts things on a more personal level.

Another one is 1 lb of C02 per kwh of electricity. That one is subject to obfuscation or confusion because it is dependent on the source of electricity.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by AbrahamParangi on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:52AM (#25198919)
I did some napkin math at one point and I believe the limiting factor is energy. You need more energy than can be generated using contemporary sources.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by marcosdumay on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:53AM (#25199530)
You need to burn about 10kg of oil to get enough energy to liquefy a ton of it.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by kiliantics on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:20AM (#25199822)
Sounds like a good scheme for global redistribution of wealth. Get the richest countries to put an annual trillion dollar budget together for buying carbon, divided up by country based on their GDP. Obviously, no one with the power to do so will really want that redistribution to happen though.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by snarf21 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:01PM (#25200329)
Humans are selfish and just don't care. Once mother nature kills off most of our population, carbon will slow sequester itself and the earth will heal but it will take centuries. The earth just can't sustain food and energy for 8B people. My guess it is more like 2B max.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by anonuser123456 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:01PM (#25202413)
I would wager the earth can sustain 100 billion people and will eventually do so with technology.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by snarf21 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:07PM (#25203003)
Could you expound? Is this something you think possible in 20 years? 50? 1000?
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by anonuser123456 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:28PM (#25204254)
Sure.

1. Robotics will make the world rich enough.

2. Synthetic food (bioreactors) will make it cheap enough.

3. DT fusion + solar will power it.

The technology part is less than 100 years away at scale. Probably less.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by otikik on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:37PM (#25200765)
> can't sustain food and energy for 8B people

It totally can. What it can't sustain is 8B people not working together.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by snarf21 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:37PM (#25201450)
That is exactly my point. Humans are selfish. We have a history of destruction even at our own expense. I wish it were otherwise but wishing it doesn't make it so. I was merely saying at 2B the earth is okay despite us not caring or working together.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by EGreg on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:29AM (#25198695)
What about planting TREES?

Also - nature seems to be doing it in the north.

https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2436/co2-is-making-earth-green...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sergeykish on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:51AM (#25199508)
> It takes about 1,025 trees to offset the average American's emissions [1]

That's half of dry land area:

    earth population * 1 hectare / person / sum earth continent area
    0.516 (2019 estimate) [2]
that's fertile half:

    world arable land
    ≈ 0.46 × land area on the earth ( 1.4912×10^8 km^2 ) [3]
Insufficient.

[1] https://savingnature.com/offset-your-carbon-footprint-carbon...

[2] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=earth+population+*+1+h...

[3] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=world+arable+land

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Traster on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:05AM (#25199646)
I would assume that the average American is emiting way more than the average human, so you can't just multiply it up by earth's population.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by sergeykish on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:08PM (#25200418)
And forests are different:

> Northeast, maple–beech–birch forests

> 25 year old forest: 1,760 lbs of CO2 per acre per year

> Northeast, white and red pine forests

> 25 year old forest: 9,826 lbs of CO2 per acre per year [1]

With global CO2 emissions [2]:

    35 billion t / (2000 lbs / acre)
    1.561×10^8 km^2 (square kilometers)
    ≈ land area on the earth ( 1.4912×10^8 km^2 ) [3]
maple–beech–birch forests would not cut.

    35 billion t / (10000 lbs / acre)
    3.123×10^7 km^2 (square kilometers)
    ≈ 0.46 × total area of crop land on Earth (2012 estimate) ( ≈ 2.62×10^7 mi^2 ) [4]
pine if used on half of crop land. That's managed forest, no wild forests allowed.

[1] http://medcraveonline.com/FREIJ/FREIJ-02-00040.pdf

[2] https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions

[3] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=35+billion+t+%2F+%2820...

[4] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=35+billion+t+%2F+%2810...

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by mhh__ on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:13PM (#25200478)
https://ourworldindata.org/per-capita-co2

It's true. The USA's Carbon Emissions are horrific (I was going to say borderline genocidal) compared to even the rest of the west.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by jasonlaramburu on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:48AM (#25198875)
There are challenges with tree planting as well. Tree plantations tend to be monocultures which crowd out native species. Also the carbon stored in trees is typically only stable for 40-50 years due to fire, tree death and decomposition.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Valgrim on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:11AM (#25199121)
Do they have to be? I remember that a lot of people in the last 50 years or so have been trying to apply permaculture principles on forestry (like the Fukuoka food forest).

As for the carbon stability, the forest renews itself, so if you plant trees in an area where there were none before, the carbon captured the forest itself is pretty permanent. If you want to further capture carbon, you can always cut the trees and use them for timber, and eventually pyrolyse the wood to prevent decomposition and put it in the ground (which can increase soil quality).

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by rtkwe on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:19PM (#25201260)
I think combining peat bogs with plantation forests might provide a workable solution. Trees sequester best early in their lives when they're growing fastest iirc then cut them down and place them in a bog where they don't decompose.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Melting_Harps on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:48PM (#25200877)
> There are challenges with tree planting as well. Tree plantations tend to be monocultures which crowd out native species. Also the carbon stored in trees is typically only stable for 40-50 years due to fire, tree death and decomposition.

That's a very limited view on a system that is regenerative by design. You're right that most are planted as mono-cultures which present some issues, and their individual life cycle spans that much time on average. But the idea is that a living ecosystem/forest that is not only able to sequester carbon via tress but also allow for other life to thrive (moss, grass, flowers etc...) throughout its entire existence is a net positive, and has much more efficacy than creating some rigged Market as seen with carbon credits that obscure the scam through layers of obfuscation. We've seen how quickly Nature can correct itself when Human activity is significantly curtailed, it stands to reason that with some adjustments to commerce and the labour market we can enhance this with such undertakings with efficient C3/C4 or CAM plants to accommodate the environment its planted in. Graham Handcock in his book 'America Before' argues that the Amazon was the planned undertaking of Ancient people that not only provided them with sustenance and medicine, but as a result of it and unbeknownst to them would serve as the lungs of the Earth for millennia after their collapse.

I've come to the conclusion that while Market based solutions are favourable means where ever possible, the reality is when it comes to Climate Change and Environmental factors Humans are just to myopic to have it as the sole basis for solutions.

Everyone involved just ends up colluding with one another for personal gain and only a fraction of the progress is made while still being touted as a monumental success when in reality if Nation-State actually fulfilled their supposed purpose they'd see it as a matter of National Security and allot a significant portion as a deterrent to unsustainable population influxes.

Humanitarian crises from environmental disasters and the displacement that follows takes a massive toll on its infrastructure and economy, not to mention the resentment from the local populace that has to deal with the increase in poverty and crime to the their community that often follows from these hapless people's plight. The mass migration to the EU from Africa was devastating to see first hand, so many people lived in the parks and other public spaces because the country that would take them in could not accommodate them in a humane manner in time or at all and they slipped through the cracks and tried to make due however possible. Many just ended up succumbing to substance abuse and crime after the trauma and stress of their lives being in shambles, often through no fault of their own as a victim of war and environmental damage (Syria, Yemen, Libya, Egypt, Somalia, Bangladesh).

I'm totally for open borders, as we should view ourselves as Human beings before anything else; but the nation-state model has proven itself to be entirely inadequate at handling COIVD, why should it be in charge of regulating something like this without succumbing to the same corruption we've seen in stock market, banking sectors?

At this point we should see this as an opportunity to give many young students and young adults afflicted by ever diminishing opportunities in the traditional labor market some much valuable and applicable work experience and the opportunity to get involved in massive environmental undertakings that will be necessary and commonplace in their lifetime to help combat the affects of Climate Change from previous generations. Investing as much as needed to that end will play dividends for the entire Earth that will outlive most nation-states (~200 years for the most prosperous ones and much less for the rest), and the truth is you can do a lot with limited resources with the right motivation, these movements really lacked effective Human Capital just as much, if not more, than monetary Capital.

I did it in my 20s, and it really helped me learn a great deal and it refined my skill set which allowed me to be able to move into several Industries that I took interest in but couldn't break into because of a specialized university education.

I was at a food drive where the goal went from feeding 10,000 families to 20,000 in a matter of days, it was a logistical nightmare and was not really planned very well with not much structure to it besides some COVID screening, and a time to show up. So I thought I'd put some of my previous experience as a manager in large scale events like this and in logistics in the automotive Industry to the test while applying some of the theoretical six sigma/lean methods I learned from my Supply Chain courses this year and all it took was a ~3 hours into my time on the assembly line before we 5x our output when I arrived. We went from 20 something people running at an unsustainable pace being burned out to make 1/5 of the output due to inefficient assembly lines and methods to about 35 strategically placed people on that line and just streamlining the process and clearing up the workflow area to yield a 5x increase.

It was hard, and it took a toll on my body as I could feel all the injuries and the experience earned from years before, but I could tell it was worth it when we not only met the goal but had actually exceeded the target and had enough excess to donate more than expected due to a reduction of loss according to the event organizers.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by kumarski on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:34AM (#25198735)
I don't know.

I'm not bullish on the "just plant trees, it will fix everything about CO2 emissions" movement....I have my doubts.

Most countermeasures seem irrelevant as long as 1/3rd of the world relies on lignite ash and brown coal as primary energy sources.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:45AM (#25199446)
There is no one thing that will "fix everything".

This will be solved by many small things adding up.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Retric on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:40AM (#25198792)
It’s a question of scale, if you want to actually make a difference you need to cut them down and store the wood underground, then grow new trees and repeat. Doing that takes real effort which then needs to be paid for.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by snicker7 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:50AM (#25198898)
> takes real effort which then needs to be paid for

Verses the many climate change options that are free and without any effort?

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Retric on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:03AM (#25199050)
Again orders of magnitude.

Investing in solar and wind essentially pays for itself. Programs like Energy Star leverage market forces to make enormous changes essentially for free.

Directly taxing carbon and adding it to general revenue would make a huge difference without spending that money on climate. Directing that revenue to carbon sequestration however requires continuously paying 100’s of thousands of people and building infrastructure etc. The benefit is definitely there, but the cost benefit ratio is vastly harder to justify.

After a 90% reduction in CO2 emissions sequestering the last 10% of CO2 might be more economically viable. But, for now better options exist.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Qwertious on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:56AM (#25199551)
Energy star doesn't necessarily reduce emissions - it improves efficiency, but that makes people less worried about wasting electricity and so they use it more often.

Jevon's Paradox was basically this but applied to coal.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Retric on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:54AM (#25200244)
Jevon’s Paradox would suggest an increase in the US electrical energy use over time, but that stalled out.

Take a step back and consider what using electricity means. Home heating for example doesn’t benefit from increasing indoor temperatures to 100f. 100” TV’s use more energy than 40” TV’s, but they also cost a lot more to buy. Essentially people only have so much money and significant improvements in efficiency mean other costs become more important. They might be able to heat a larger house, but they can’t afford the house to be heated.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by polytely on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:22AM (#25199232)
Or topple the trees and cover them with something that blocks air but which the next layer can be planted atop of? Seems like an extremely difficult problem.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by xyzzyz on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @12:35PM (#25200735)
We don’t have nearly enough land area for that, and even if we did, we’d need to cut and bury these trees underground, if we want the sequestration to be more than temporary. Seems silly to do that while digging up coal at the same time.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by adrianN on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:50AM (#25198900)
You would need to fell and bury more trees than we dig up coal. That is quite difficult.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by Pfhreak on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:51PM (#25202318)
That's true, but you don't need to bury the whole tree. You can fell the tree, gassify it, and get a steady stream of fuel and pure carbon. The process is exothermic and produces enough energy to be self sustaining and produce excess fuel.

Bury the carbon and use the gas to produce energy and you have a forest that is a net reducer of carbon and a net positive energy producer.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by snicker7 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:51AM (#25198915)
Bamboo can sequester considerably more carbon per acre-year.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by batushka3 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:00AM (#25199023)
Planting trees you won't create faux sector for CC, fueled by taxes and subsidies, where business could strive.