No, it was given to them to encourage them to engage in "good-faith" censorship of things that the government doesn't like by not making such censorship move them from the relatively weak distributor-liability regime where they were only liable based on a responsibility to stop distributing content once they had notice of its unlawfulness to the any-oversight-is-on-you publisher liability regime.
It wasn't to "help them grow", which it was assumed they would do anyway, it was to encourage them to try to restrict "bad" content as they grew (it is the one surviving part of the internet censorship Communications Decency Act, and like the rest of that act was, in fact, directed at promoting internet censorship.)
I do not think the government should be intervening on content decisions. I think;
(1) publishers & platforms should be legally responsible for content they host if they are going to editorialize on it
(2) from a 'net neutrality' standpoint, that utilities and platforms should be mostly blind and entirely blameless for the packets they carry, and
(3) we should allow some level of packet and/or content classification in the middle of #1 and #2 without making the utility/platform fully liable for the packets/content they are carrying, if that classification is based on fairly protecting the network/platform from "attack".
The only reason I can see for a fairness doctrine would be based on a theory of anti-trust. To the extent that Twitter, Facebook, Apple, Google, etc. are monopolies, their ability to censor non-obscene viewpoints on their platforms should be limited... and that's a spectrum not a binary switch.
Personally, I don't have a problem with publishers engaging in publishing. So I wouldn't support that.
But there is a large, philosophical difference, IMO, between a publisher and a platform.
And our laws need to be changed to further clarify this.
Sure. They have those right, just like a newspaper has those rights.
But these companies and newspapers are also liable for their speech.
And the companies that are not liable for the speech, are companies like phone companies.
Phone companies are required to follow certain restrictions, and the courts have found them to be perfectly legal.
> What is the large, philosophical difference that separates them?
Take the phone network, as an example. The courts already treated the phone network, differently than they do a newspaper.
what happens when I want to run CatTalk.com and, and its against the rules to talk about Dogs, and someone comes in talking about Dogs? Shouldnt you have the ability to run and moderate and host the content on your site that you decide?
That means you have a responsibility for that content; the same legal liability that newspapers and magazines have when publishing articles and editorials.
Maybe you prescreen every comment but you make a bad call and something defamatory gets through. Or maybe someone sues you under bad faith and you have to pay to defend it or settle.
This is a very bad future for the internet. It's an internet where the powerful, who have the full support of publishers, will get to have their voices heard loudly. And the less powerful, who do not have teams of lawyers willing to fight on their behalf, will have a very hard time getting their voices heard.
No, that’s only the standard I want to apply if they are editorializing the content that’s being posted.
Is that the world you want?
It's hard to see how you could run a site that provided near real time broadcast communication to the general public if you had to do that level of vetting of each post to make sure nothing slipped through that might get you sued.
But that's the thing. Section 230 doesnt really have anything to do with moderation. In fact, it allows websites that has user generated content to exist without moderation.
I think/hope we agree that its completely reasonable and normal for websites to moderate the content on their sites. For example, I want Twitter to take down child pornography posted. Literally hate speech - calls for genecides and violence against people - websites should have the legal ability to remove that from their sites. I do not think there should be any consequences towards the websites for wanting to remove this content.
If you remove 230 protections from websites, it forces the sites that are able to survivce to moderate more by making them legally liable for the content published.
For example, one could post about drug deals or something in a thread that mods might not read, then hold them legally responsible for enabling drug deals on their site.
I, for one, appreciate the current status quo where I generally don't have to deal with neo-Nazis spouting nonsense uncontested on my Facebook wall (and if that arrangement bothers me, I could go to some other site).
I'm happy to do so. I'm also happy the platform has some base-level standards so I don't have to block and contest quite so much.
> Social media companies lean left, the government should ensure they remain neutral by following the First Amendment.
Is there anything in particular about social media, as a technology, that causes all companies engaging in it to "lean left?" If not, this is a problem the market can solve.
Doesn't matter if the government itself posted that article. Doxxing info is immoral and should be blocked.
What about more nuanced cases? Who will be arbiter of "neutral" then?
That's true. Like much of the Constitution, the text is pithy and doesn't specify its definitions. The current legal interpretation of the First Amendment and free speech rest on a particular philosophical traditions that the court adopted in the last century, and especially after the 60s.
A lot of people have absolute faith in the functioning of a "marketplace of ideas," but it's not at all clear to me that a such a market can work well when it's flooded by disinformation, just like a market of goods can't work well when it's flooded by counterfeits.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/13/magazine/free-speech.html
I also think this would result in a mad dash for anonymous, distributed, decentralized communication methods, i.e. things that can't be the target of a subpoena.
Given the toxic influence of both social media on society, and the severe centralization we're operating under... both of those things look very tempting.
Goodbye Mastodon (every Mastodon instance is liable for all toots). Goodbye Internet Archive (can't host content that might be defamatory, they'll be liable). Goodbye GitHub pull requests (Git would be liable for any defamation contained in them). And so on.
It's not that I don't understand the value of those things, its that I see the value of not having information in society be controlled by a few companies as having far larger value.
The only people able to blog, for instance, would be people who have the technical chops to completely self-host. Everyone else would be reduced to handing out flyers on the corner like the bad old days.
The behemoth old-media companies would be fine, because they can afford lawyers to go over everything they publish.
Not only would it not be worth it, repealing section 230 would consolidate behemoth media companies' control, not break it. It would do the absolute opposite of what you want.
They don't have special status for their editorializing. If Facebook or Twitter or any other interactive computer service produces editorial content that, say, libels someone, they could be sued over that and would not have a section 230 defense.
Given that all are judgement calls, I'd say it's impossible for it to not be. There's a difference between merely removing something and giving your opinion on the contents.
That rules could include biases like "no news that favor Trump reelection", but they should be in their terms of service explicitly.
I'm open to hearing the opposite side if anyone has any arguments on why it shouldn't change
I fail to see how moderators on vBulletin boards in 2002 are any different then moderators/admins/algorithms on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc in 2020. The scale is different, sure, but you are not entitled to the amplification of these platforms just because they are bigger the same way you weren't entitled to the amplification on those old vBulletin board systems.
I generally support 230. There may be some tweaks that could be made that I would support, but the general concept behind 230 is correct.
> Are private entities responsible for the content they host?
Generally no. Private entities are responsible for the content that they publish, not for the content that they host. An example being the comment section on a news site versus the news article on a news site. The latter is content that they published, the former is content that they host.
> If we repeal 230 and someone posts something falsely defaming me, who do I sue?
IANAL but I would imagine if 230 is repealed and some one libels you, you sue the platform and the content creator.
If 230 isn't repealed you sue the content creator and ask for an injunction against the platform to remove the content.
That's what the law was before 230, except that it essentially applied to illegal content, as well, because of the company tried to actively moderate even for just illegal content then it became liable for all content (it had to be 100% right if it tried to moderate illegal content.)
Being liable for only known illegal content is distributor, not publisher, liability, which is what it superficially looks like 230 does on its face (courts have applied 230 to provide no liability, not even distributor liability; expressly imposing distributor-style liability would be a modest reform.)
Because the NYTimes pays staff to create it's content and exercises complete editorial control over said content, and thus is fully liable for the content published as news articles on its site. The NYTimes however is not liable for the content in the comments section on said news articles, though, they are allowed to remove comments that they do not wish to appear on their commenting platform.
Twitter is also liable for content that it publishes, eg: what the Twitter support account posts. But it is not liable for the content that I, dlp211, post to Twitter. Twitter still retains the right to moderate their platform as they see fit.
This applies to not just Twitter, but to every platform on the internet, from the Twitters and Facebooks and YouTubes to the MyNicheVBulletinBoard to Palor, 8Chan, and 4Chan.
Now I have mentioned previously that I am open to tweaks. While I haven't thought deeply about it, I would be open to considering a tweak along the lines that the platform becomes a publisher when it promotes content via human or computer decision making. This may or may not be a good idea after I think about it more deeply and discuss it with others, but the point is that I am not of the opinion that 230 is the end all be all but I am also of the opinion that I would rather live in a world with 230 than without it. I say that as someone that believes that their politics would be greatly benefitted by the repeal of 230.
IANL even if they called themselves a platform they would still be acting as a publisher and the law would treat them as such. For example they would be editing and curating content, paying for content from writers, and making the material available under their own name.
I don't see how that explains why it's "abuse" for a company to selectively remove content from their website, however.
Should Hacker News be required to treat all links the same? If not, exactly how do you think a government "neutrality" mandate would work?
Because such a mandate means that if the HN moderators are a little biased, the whole shebang would become liable for any defamatory comments posted here. That's a government-mandated sword of Damocles hanging over every single moderation decision made here.
Section 230 isn't in the Bill of Rights. It's a legislative gift that was given to internet companies to help them grow by granting them a special legal shield for all the highly problematic content that they host and monetize.
If they want to editorialize on the back of that content, then I don't see why they should have such special status.
We do not need to eliminate Section 230. But the definition of 'Good Samaritan' blocking and 'good faith efforts' should explicitly not include the editorial decisions of a publisher.