News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:42PM (#24804283)
I agree with this. From a libertarian stand point, the gov stepped in to help (rightfully, sometimes we need it) but it was originally written in a way that is now being abused. I don't see a problem changing it so that if you a companies gets to decide what they want to show and not show, they should be liable just like news sites.

I'm open to hearing the opposite side if anyone has any arguments on why it shouldn't change

Re:Section 230 Explained by dlp211 on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:49PM (#24804355)
Well they aren't news sites. They are private entities providing general platforms. Speech, per the US legal system, is more than just what one says, but also the actions one takes. These companies have not only a right, but a duty as publicly traded companies to protect their platforms as they see fit.

I fail to see how moderators on vBulletin boards in 2002 are any different then moderators/admins/algorithms on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc in 2020. The scale is different, sure, but you are not entitled to the amplification of these platforms just because they are bigger the same way you weren't entitled to the amplification on those old vBulletin board systems.

Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:32PM (#24806029)
So where do you stand on 230? Are private entities responsible for the content they host? If we repeal 230 and someone posts something falsely defaming me, who do I sue?
Re:Section 230 Explained by dlp211 on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:56PM (#24807113)
> So where do you stand on 230?

I generally support 230. There may be some tweaks that could be made that I would support, but the general concept behind 230 is correct.

> Are private entities responsible for the content they host?

Generally no. Private entities are responsible for the content that they publish, not for the content that they host. An example being the comment section on a news site versus the news article on a news site. The latter is content that they published, the former is content that they host.

> If we repeal 230 and someone posts something falsely defaming me, who do I sue?

IANAL but I would imagine if 230 is repealed and some one libels you, you sue the platform and the content creator.

If 230 isn't repealed you sue the content creator and ask for an injunction against the platform to remove the content.

Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Saturday October 17, 2020 @04:16AM (#24808361)
So if the government is stepping in here and moving the liability from the platform to the content creator as a favor to the company, shouldn't the company be required to not be allowed to selectively allow posts (assuming it is legal content and related). I.e. why cant The New York Times call themselves a platform and just post whatever they want? Where would you draw the line?
Re:Section 230 Explained by dragonwriter on Saturday October 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#24811771)
> So if the government is stepping in here and moving the liability from the platform to the content creator as a favor to the company, shouldn't the company be required to not be allowed to selectively allow posts (assuming it is legal content and related).

That's what the law was before 230, except that it essentially applied to illegal content, as well, because of the company tried to actively moderate even for just illegal content then it became liable for all content (it had to be 100% right if it tried to moderate illegal content.)

Being liable for only known illegal content is distributor, not publisher, liability, which is what it superficially looks like 230 does on its face (courts have applied 230 to provide no liability, not even distributor liability; expressly imposing distributor-style liability would be a modest reform.)

Re:Section 230 Explained by dlp211 on Saturday October 17, 2020 @01:47PM (#24811721)
> I.e. why cant The New York Times call themselves a platform and just post whatever they want?

Because the NYTimes pays staff to create it's content and exercises complete editorial control over said content, and thus is fully liable for the content published as news articles on its site. The NYTimes however is not liable for the content in the comments section on said news articles, though, they are allowed to remove comments that they do not wish to appear on their commenting platform.

Twitter is also liable for content that it publishes, eg: what the Twitter support account posts. But it is not liable for the content that I, dlp211, post to Twitter. Twitter still retains the right to moderate their platform as they see fit.

This applies to not just Twitter, but to every platform on the internet, from the Twitters and Facebooks and YouTubes to the MyNicheVBulletinBoard to Palor, 8Chan, and 4Chan.

Now I have mentioned previously that I am open to tweaks. While I haven't thought deeply about it, I would be open to considering a tweak along the lines that the platform becomes a publisher when it promotes content via human or computer decision making. This may or may not be a good idea after I think about it more deeply and discuss it with others, but the point is that I am not of the opinion that 230 is the end all be all but I am also of the opinion that I would rather live in a world with 230 than without it. I say that as someone that believes that their politics would be greatly benefitted by the repeal of 230.

Re:Section 230 Explained by davorak on Saturday October 17, 2020 @08:28AM (#24809472)
> I.e. why cant The New York Times call themselves a platform and just post whatever they want? Where would you draw the line?

IANL even if they called themselves a platform they would still be acting as a publisher and the law would treat them as such. For example they would be editing and curating content, paying for content from writers, and making the material available under their own name.

Re:Section 230 Explained by TameAntelope on Friday October 16, 2020 @04:40PM (#24804816)
Can you help me understand why selectively removing content from a privately owned website is considered "abuse"?
Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:33PM (#24806035)
So if the company hosts false information against me (that a user posted), I can sue them?
Re:Section 230 Explained by TameAntelope on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:53PM (#24806149)
I think you can sue the individual, based on my reading of Section 230, but I'm no lawyer.

I don't see how that explains why it's "abuse" for a company to selectively remove content from their website, however.

Re:Section 230 Explained by roywiggins on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:48PM (#24804343)
From a libertarian standpoint, the government regulating "neutrality" is a nightmare.

Should Hacker News be required to treat all links the same? If not, exactly how do you think a government "neutrality" mandate would work?

Because such a mandate means that if the HN moderators are a little biased, the whole shebang would become liable for any defamatory comments posted here. That's a government-mandated sword of Damocles hanging over every single moderation decision made here.

Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:35PM (#24806043)
If you falsely slander me, doesn't 230 make it so that Hacker News can't get sued? If the government is protecting the company here, then the government should be able to also enforce rules that come with that benefit right?
Re:Section 230 Explained by roywiggins on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:08PM (#24806918)
Maybe, but they can't condition a benefit on "neutrality." Conditioning makes it viewpoint discrimination, which is unconstitutional.
Re:Section 230 Explained by triceratops on Friday October 16, 2020 @06:45PM (#24805731)
From a libertarian standpoint forced "neutrality" (scare quotes intended) is an infringement on the property and free speech rights of the platforms. You are not entitled to use my property against my will to endorse viewpoints that I disagree with, and the government should not force me to comply.
Re:Section 230 Explained by nahtnam on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:33PM (#24806032)
So in that case are you against 230? If someone falsely defames me, who do I sue?
Re:Section 230 Explained by davorak on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:18PM (#24806965)
> If someone falsely defames me, who do I sue?

You would sue the person who defamed you today.