News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Section 230 Explained by klyrs on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:51PM (#24804375)
Would you also advocate that we bring back the FCC's Fairness Doctrine, so that news sources would be required to present contrasting viewpoints? Arguments against that were based on the first amendment; that a free press should have complete editorial control over the content that they distribute.
Re:Section 230 Explained by zaroth on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:57PM (#24804434)
I think that libel laws could be eased just a bit. As it stands, to sue a newspaper for libel you need to prove that they knew what they were reporting was false, or that they showed a "reckless disregard" for the truth. It's a very high standard, but occasionally you will see cases settle (e.g. Covington High student).

I do not think the government should be intervening on content decisions. I think;

(1) publishers & platforms should be legally responsible for content they host if they are going to editorialize on it

(2) from a 'net neutrality' standpoint, that utilities and platforms should be mostly blind and entirely blameless for the packets they carry, and

(3) we should allow some level of packet and/or content classification in the middle of #1 and #2 without making the utility/platform fully liable for the packets/content they are carrying, if that classification is based on fairly protecting the network/platform from "attack".

The only reason I can see for a fairness doctrine would be based on a theory of anti-trust. To the extent that Twitter, Facebook, Apple, Google, etc. are monopolies, their ability to censor non-obscene viewpoints on their platforms should be limited... and that's a spectrum not a binary switch.

Re:Section 230 Explained by stale2002 on Friday October 16, 2020 @05:22PM (#24805180)
> that news sources would be required to present contrasting viewpoints

Personally, I don't have a problem with publishers engaging in publishing. So I wouldn't support that.

But there is a large, philosophical difference, IMO, between a publisher and a platform.

And our laws need to be changed to further clarify this.

Re:Section 230 Explained by klyrs on Friday October 16, 2020 @05:29PM (#24805233)
I'd love to see the Citizens United ruling overturned. It would be great for our society to not treat corporations as people. But as it stands, corporations are found to have free speech rights. Social media companies are both publishers and platforms. Many news sites now have comments sections, too -- they're both publishers and platforms. What is the large, philosophical difference that separates them?
Re:Section 230 Explained by stale2002 on Friday October 16, 2020 @05:44PM (#24805340)
> But as it stands, corporations are found to have free speech rights

Sure. They have those right, just like a newspaper has those rights.

But these companies and newspapers are also liable for their speech.

And the companies that are not liable for the speech, are companies like phone companies.

Phone companies are required to follow certain restrictions, and the courts have found them to be perfectly legal.

> What is the large, philosophical difference that separates them?

Take the phone network, as an example. The courts already treated the phone network, differently than they do a newspaper.