News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Imnimo on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:05PM (#24623513)
In other words, people are not willing to pay enough money for the service DuckDuckGo provides to afford a spot on the list, and also DuckDuckGo's service is unable to attract as many users as they would like without the aid of the list.

I'm generally very sympathetic to anti-trust measures, but this strikes me as a situation where DuckDuckGo needs to stand on its own two feet. If your position is that privacy is more valuable to consumers, then you should compete in the auction. If your position is that it's not about the money, and privacy is an inherent good even if it can't compete monetarily, then you should be able to attract and retain your users without free advertising. But if your position is that your product cannot compete monetarily and also cannot compete without the advertising that money buys, then it might just be that you don't have as desirable a product as you think you do.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by harry8 on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:58PM (#24624036)
Who is being paid in this "auction"? What percentage of customers of search know precisely what they are paying? The latter I'm putting at "so close to zero as makes no difference" which makes "price competitive" outcome a little on the absurd side.

I'd phrase it as "DDG claim they unwilling to rob their customers as much as industry norms to be able to afford the fee" (a fee they're paying to who?) to be on the list.

Customers are not consulted at any point. Customers are largely unaware of what Google have done to them via surveillance. Customers never agreed in any meaningful way to what google have done with their massively succesful surviellance bait and switch strategy.

Controlling the sales infrastructure and selling in that infrastructure is a thing that would be exceedingly difficult for it not to be anti-competitive.

It's been a problem in this industry at least since Microsoft were known as the death star and anyone successful in software found out they had just done microsoft's market reseach for them. Maybe longer?

Doesn't matter how long, it's gotta go. Beyond a small size you do distribution and nothing else or you use that distrubution to get sales. You got big? Splin off one of those parts and sell it while counting the money from your immense success. There's no way the current system is better for anyone other than those that want market power rather than producing high quality stuff.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by notriddle on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:10AM (#24624340)
> Who is being paid in this "auction"? What percentage of customers of search know precisely what they are paying? The latter I'm putting at "so close to zero as makes no difference" which makes "price competitive" outcome a little on the absurd side.

Honestly, most of the people I've talked with know about Google's business model. They give answers ranging around here abouts:

* I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide.

* DuckDuckGo are probably a honeypot; they gather as much or more information as Google, and lie about it.

* Even if I switch search engine, they'll probably get all my info some other way anyhow, and I don't have the skill or time to try to find everything that could be leaking information.

* Google supplies a better search engine, so it's worth it.

* Using DuckDuckGo as my search engine, when I'm using Android as my OS, seems like a waste of time, and I'm not buying a new phone.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by jfoster on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:43AM (#24625104)
"I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide."

Can I offer a variation of this one? I care about privacy. I wouldn't want a human to be looking over my searches. That said, if they're just using the data to serve me relevant ads and it's all either automated or aggregated so that I'm never personally identified, then I'm cool with it at the personal level.

I say "at the personal level" because I think there's still a practical problem when it comes to politics. It seems too easy to sway elections using it. Not even necessarily by shaping the results in any way. Simply by being able to identify the groups of users who will vote a particular way in particular electoral divisions, and then seeking to lift their voting rate above the average. (eg. by prompting/reminding them to vote)

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by louiskottmann on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:41AM (#24625650)
There is another problem, beyond the initial ads-based business. This information gathered about you, albeit anonymously, is correlated. This helps train models about groups of people, in order to derive value from group information. It can then be sold to insurances, banks, etc.

Derived information may look like: "Clojure programmers buy a new computer every 3 years on average" "Women in medium socio-economic groups tend to have kids at 31 years old"

But maybe I'm a programmer that cares about waste, and use the hell out of my computers, until it is completely unusable, making them last way longer. Maybe I'm a woman with trouble getting pregnant, and I won't have kids until much later.

Nevertheless, insurances and banks will use that information against me.

This information grouping you take part of, is de-humanizing. Humans are infinitely complex, ever-evolving creatures and categorizing us is profitable business. I do not want to be treated through the lens of the probability of a group I belong to, no matter how small the box.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by rrobukef on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:08AM (#24625822)
The smaller the box, the more invasive it feels. But even general (codified in law) categorisations such as gender already feel discriminating in our modern society.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Siira on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:19AM (#24627434)
Banning discrimination based on correlatory truths has its own costs as well. There is no simple solution to this.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by moksly on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:20AM (#24625910)
DuckDuckGo is nothing but an annoyance for me, but only when I set it as my standard search engine. Because 90% of my searches are practical, currency conversions, calculations that I could’ve done in a calculator but didn’t, maps locations, directions, public transportation times, and, opening hours. DDG is absolutely terrible at this in my country. Google isn’t, and that’s why it’s probably going to remain my standard search engine for some time to come.

What annoys me about google though, isn’t the personalised advertising, it’s the personalised results. Google obviously knows I play Blood Bowl and collect various things for it, but as a result, my first two google page results are nothing but advertisements. Even if I was actually searching for information. A couple of years ago I don’t think I had ever clicked beyond page 1 on google, these days I find myself turning to direct forum searches. Searches on DDG or even directly on HN, FB or Reddit because all google wants to do is link me to sale sites.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by jfoster on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:19AM (#24626781)
> What annoys me about google though, isn’t the personalised advertising, it’s the personalised results.

That's true. It's almost subconscious for me now go incognito prior to searching or visiting a website if it's something I'm aware that I'm only temporarily interested in, in order to avoid it becoming part of my profile.

I don't think personalisation is a completely bad idea, but I would like to have some way to interface with it.

1. "Google, what are the things you think I'm into?"

2. "Google, I'm actually not interested in _____."

3. "Google, you should know that I'm into _____."

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Theodores on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:44AM (#24626481)
The thing is that DDG does not give people the privacy they want.

Some people do not want privacy. They are on every social media network sharing everything about their life anyway.

Some people do want privacy but are not tin-foil hat about it. These people get their expectations of privacy met by other means, not being on every social network being one of them. Then there are the practical measures of running ad-blockers and other browser tools to prevent tracking. These tools are generally unobtrusive even if lifting the ad-blocker for a page is a daily occurrence.

People in this category get the privacy concessions they want and are probably okay with Google knowing what it does. They are not going to go full tin-foil hat with some Tor onion browser on the end of a VPN. Using DDG takes you into this territory. Everyone knows their search results are just different, not the standard Google fayre. The secret sauce is just this claim to privacy that people are able to get enough of with other means, such as running ad-blockers.

With the limited offering that DDG is there has to be an overlap between those who are obsessed about privacy (tin-foil hat and probably 'preppers'...) and the DDG user base. They need to get out more and add to the internets.

I would like to see a search engine that offers people the option to raise their HTML game by using the semantic elements for content structure that Google and Bing ignore. Content matters but so does HTML. This could be easy to game with people getting rid of div style HTML to replace it with articles, headers, sections, navs, asides and footers, with inline elements such as dfn and abbr, but I would be quite happy if the web was written that way. Even better if there was a search engine that worked with it.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by bishalb on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:58AM (#24625176)
Most people and I mean upwards of 98% (even the tech savvy ones) don't care much about privacy as much as the HN bubble seems to(or pretends to).
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dx034 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:34AM (#24625606)
It's also hard to argue against it. In the end, Google uses all that data to make more money with ads. And having relevant ads for your taste isn't necessarily bad for many.

The amount of data collection is truly bad for people living in totalitarian regimes or have sensitive jobs but that's not the majority of friends for most of us. For the rest, the lack of privacy has no negative impact on their life and is unlikely to have in the near future, so there's no reason to change.

Wanting change to benefit all of us is what we try (and fail) with preventing climate warming.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:58AM (#24625177)
I understand your point but from my perspective I care a lot. Things do not stop there; it's the nature of companies to take more and more for entirely rational reasons (money), but those reasons eat deeper into the boundary between them and you.

If one allows them the thin end of the wedge, one will get the rest, slowly, and slowly accept it a la boiling frog, rationalising it all the way (maybe not you specifically, but many will. Why? It's the easiest thing to do).

You've already mentioned the problem of politics, in effect you've just acknowledged the rest of the wedge will appear. There will be other reasons.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by harry8 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:14AM (#24624353)
Everything you say there underlines and reinfoces the point that the percentage of customers who know precisely what they are paying is so close to zero as makes no difference.

That's a problem for a market.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:19AM (#24624377)
Another read of the situation is that the transaction does not cost these folks anything they value. You may want them to value it (whatever you think "it" is, I'm not sure) but they don't.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by harry8 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:37AM (#24624457)
>the transaction does not cost these folks anything they value.

Absolutely and you can say that about literally everyone who gets caught by a confidence trickster and some do.

It really hasn't worked out for too many indigenous cultures where that was used as the precise justfication, for example. Usuary is another one you can defend that way and people do. It's not so commonly held anymore by those not profiting from it.

When there is a tradeoff between what is good fo soceity at large being the people who live in it and what is good for for a big company's market dominance the latter is meant to come absolutely last and be tolerated if it doesn't infringe anything much else of value to the people. I can't see that as being the case here. No doubt Zuckerberg disagrees because he's convinced anything good for him and his company is pefection for society by the definition that he wants to do it.

Nobody understands what they are paying. Nobody understands their liability. Google et al all desperately hide it and have done a bait and switch to make it happen.

There is _NO_ informed consent to the contract and the contract is invalid.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:10AM (#24626705)
>Absolutely and you can say that about literally everyone who gets caught by a confidence trickster and some do.

No, you cannot. Because with a confidence trickster there is usually an element of regret afterwards. The folks we are talking about have generally been using Google for years and years. If the other shoe is going to drop it's sure taking its time.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by tangjurine on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:16AM (#24625884)
Well said
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by rrobukef on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:59AM (#24625767)
For me, I cannot put a value to the transaction. I have done enough searches that can embarrass me, label me, or hurt me. Maybe some were illegal; I probably am on a lot of lists. Political searches are enough to alienate a lot of people. How do you estimate how my searches affect my income for the coming years?

Privacy and ads are an unequal marketplace where the consumer lacks information. And looking at VPN incidents, perhaps it is fundamentally unequal. A consumer can never verify if information freely given is stored or abused.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:30AM (#24627563)
> For me, I cannot put a value to the transaction. I have done enough searches that can embarrass me, label me, or hurt me. Maybe some were illegal; I probably am on a lot of lists. Political searches are enough to alienate a lot of people. How do you estimate how my searches affect my income for the coming years?

Probably zero, because absent a search warrant they aren't ever revealed to anyone but you.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by rrobukef on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:54PM (#24666438)
The first value is definetly not zero, enough companties profit from selling ads. The second, I'd like to remind you of the Target pregnancy story (possible hoax) or, more real, the Ashley Madison leaks.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by etripe on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:46AM (#24628458)
> Probably zero, because absent a search warrant they aren't ever revealed to anyone but you.

Are you unaware of parallel construction or do you think it poses no real danger?

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:10PM (#24629566)
I think it poses minimal danger to the vast, vast majority of people. For people who are doing crime, though, probably it's best not to use search while logged in or from their own IP.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by crazypython on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:24AM (#24626840)
"* I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide."

Do you have things you would rather not explain? Do you want to be someone great? What about someone who stands up to these companies? If so, do you want to be doxxed, deepfaked, and your psychological weaknesses probed by your enemies, who can purchase your information from an unscrupulous Google employee? Do you want rich kids to be able to get your information, like someone did to an Instagram account via a facebook employee?

I agree that Google is a better search engine.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by fsflover on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:06AM (#24626239)
> * DuckDuckGo are probably a honeypot; they gather as much or more information as Google, and lie about it.

You should suggest https://searx.me to such people.

> * I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_to_hide_argument

> * Even if I switch search engine, they'll probably get all my info some other way anyhow

Even if you make it just harder to them, it's a big deal on such scales, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defence_in_depth

> * Using DuckDuckGo as my search engine, when I'm using Android as my OS, seems like a waste of time, and I'm not buying a new phone.

Same as above.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ivanche on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:05AM (#24625465)
> * I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide.

I find that those people change their attitude immediately when responded with "OK, if you have nothing to hide give me your Facebook/LinkedIn/Instagram/email username and password." All of a sudden, they do have something to hide.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dx034 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:31AM (#24625594)
Because with password you could impersonate them. If you asked them for their profile infos most are probably willing to give those. There are few people who are really careful about what they share on social media. So that argument doesn't really count.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by swilliamsio on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:21AM (#24625914)
Yea. A better analogy is asking for receipts, payment card history, search history, etc. All things that tech giants know about you that isn't publically available for anyone to see.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ivanche on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:21AM (#24626319)
Fair point, although impersonating them was the last thing on my mind.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by monkpit on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:40AM (#24628366)
> I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide.

Everyone latching on to this and providing counter-arguments in the HN comments section misses the point.

Most of the HN crowd realizes that this is a fallacy. You don’t need to prove your point here.

It doesn’t change the fact that (outside of HN) it is a very commonly held belief.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by amelius on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:41AM (#24626991)
"I don't care about privacy; I have nothing to hide."

Funny, most people don't even share information about their salary or their bank balance with their friends.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by doublesCs on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:07AM (#24625219)
> I'm generally very sympathetic to anti-trust measures, but this strikes me as a situation where DuckDuckGo needs to stand on its own two feet. If your position is that privacy is more valuable to consumers, then you should compete in the auction.

If you're very sympathetic to anti-trust measures, then this shouldn't be decided in an auction. Obviously the most profitable companies will win the auction. And those are the same companies that you should be taking measures against (not because they're profitable in itself, but because by being profitable they can kill competitors).

So saying: "search engines should compete on a lawless free market" vs "search engines have to compete on an auction for users" is more or less the same thing. Anti-trust measures try to make the outcome slightly less sensitive to profitability.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by MiroF on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:20PM (#24623600)
Aren't anti-trust laws meant to benefit the consumer?

I fail to see how the remedy proposed by the EU (this bidding/auction method) is benefiting me, the consumer, when the most popular Google alternative is eliminated from the options because they don't monetize as aggressively.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ehsankia on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:06AM (#24624323)
There's only two solution that come to mind

1. Give it to the highest bidders (current method)

2. Give it to the highest ranking sites

From what I see, #2 is even worse for newcomers. Do you have a different suggestion that's better?

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by z3t4 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:15AM (#24624635)
Randomize the order. Mark the highest ranking as "popular".
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by josefx on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:27AM (#24625572)
Enter Microsofts browser ballot screen that they were required to show in Europe. Broken randomness and half a dozen IE skins to game the requirement. Main requirements should be: do not let the fox guard the hen house.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ehsankia on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:22PM (#24629750)
Is there some threshold? Can any fork of Chromium make it on there? Can a company make 10 different forks to increase their chance? What if someone gets a really bad roll and sees 5 really shitty ones they don't know or like? How is that putting the user first?
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by MiroF on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:54PM (#24630145)
> Can any fork of Chromium make it on there?

Chromium is a browser.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ehsankia on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:25PM (#24653681)
Wow, for a second I really blanked there and I was totally thinking of the Microsoft ballot. Good catch.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by rrobukef on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:12AM (#24625856)
Reverse the order, mark the lowest ranking as popular!
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by blue_devil on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:57AM (#24678325)
Question is: why restrict the # of providers shown at all?

They could show a semi-random segmented ranking: - split all companies into X buckets by ranking - pick the top from each bucket from 1 to X, then the second best from each bucket etc.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by sct202 on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:01PM (#24623792)
The winners of the Q4 auction has a lot of companies I've never heard of like PrivacyWall, info.com, and GMX mixed in with Bing, Yandex and DDG, so it does seem like the way it's set up does introduce some variety. Like Yahoo is the #3 search engine, but doesn't even show up in the list.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by crazypython on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:31AM (#24626895)
Can you send the Q4 winner list, or where we can find it? I'm interested in seeing the list. Maybe one of these small search engines will be better in some way.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by sct202 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:25AM (#24627510)
https://www.android.com/choicescreen-winners/

I'm kind of very curious about some of the small names on it. Like how do they have more money than DDG. PirvacyWall seems to be using the Bing API like DDG, so I just don't see how they'd be about to outspend DDG so easily.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by MiroF on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:37AM (#24629117)
> PirvacyWall seems to be using the Bing API like DDG, so I just don't see how they'd be about to outspend DDG so easily.

They probably are private-equity/venture-funded and are a bet on trying to capture some of the market which they can monetize for more than they spent on the auction.

e: well they appear to be a class B corp, so actually perhaps not

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by vin047 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:57AM (#24629387)
Some more info on info.com and PrivacyWall

https://qz.com/1783096/what-are-info-com-and-privacywall/

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by lgats on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @02:00AM (#24636071)
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by paxys on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:25PM (#24623623)
There are two different problems at play. The anti-trust one (Google using its dominance in mobile to boost its own search product) is solved by forcing them to offer alternative defaults. The other problem you are alluding to (user privacy I assume?) is unrelated to this, and there are already laws like GDPR in place to address that.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Abishek_Muthian on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:27AM (#24624415)
I absolutely agree with your comment.

Every time I set DDG as my default search engine, I return back to Google after two weeks because I get fed up of using !g to get proper search results.

If I know the site where I can get what I seek e.g. Reddit, SO, HN then bangs on DDG are useful but when I don't know which site would get me the information I seek, DDG fails me 9/10 times in giving me a proper result and I have to resort to !g.

DDG needs to be a better search engine first than anything else if it needs to survive, just advertising Privacy wouldn't cut it, Hypothetically If Apple announces a search engine tomorrow most of DDG customer base would shift even if Apple had a poor search engine just because 'Apple sells Privacy better'.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by inetsee on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:57AM (#24624541)
My experience has been that DDG produces satisfactory results 95+ percent of the time and Google produces more ads that crowd out the results 100 percent of the time.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dx034 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:37AM (#24625629)
It depends very much on where you live. Localized results outside of the US suck with DDG. Yes, you can set a language but you always have to set/unset it and even then it's not great at providing results that are relevant to a specific location, even if specified in the search query.

On the other hand that's no wonder, from all search traffic I've seen, Google tends to crawl 5-10x as much as Bing (DDG bot is basically non-existant). Google's index is much broader and more current than others because they crawl basically the whole web constantly. It's no wonder that Bing lags behind Google if they crawl everything apart from the most popular pages irregularly.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by tasuki on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:34AM (#24624720)
I've been using DDG for a couple of years. It produces satisfactory results as long as I describe what I'm searching for thoroughly. Google knows me well and is able to surmise a lot from a much shorter query.

In the same vein, if I want unbiased results, DDG is strictly superior to Google.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Zenbit_UX on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:52AM (#24626539)
> In the same vein, if I want unbiased results, DDG is strictly superior to Google.

And if you want good results, without dumping every buzzword you know about your search, Google is strictly superior to DDG.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by int_19h on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:54PM (#24630892)
That used to be true, but Google search result quality diminished significantly in the past couple of year, because it started to get too creative with keyword dropping and substitution. I often see the single most important keyword in my query dropped to produce more results, or replaced with a more generic category (e.g. "Linux" replaced with "Unix"), or even replaced with something that's not actually a correct substitute at all (e.g. "FreeBSD" replaced with "Linux").
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by mad182 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:14AM (#24624630)
This is my experience as well. If DDG gave me the same quality of results as Google, I might use it. Until then, I don't care. Privacy alone isn't going to cut it, if I only cared about privacy and not the results, I would send my queries to /dev/null instead.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by nottorp on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:23AM (#24625928)
Define 'proper search results'. I guess you only search for common things that Google has optimized for.

In my experience, Google now stuffs the results with everything they can think of that's even remotely related (or even unrelated). There's so much noise that specific searches are useless.

On the other hand yes, if you want to find a pizza near you, Google is still best. I guess they should rebrand to 'restaurant finder'.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ohmaigad on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:10AM (#24626267)
Term BMW - in Google, 2nd result is the local site while in DDG there is no local result at all. Sure, i can check the Region option and it will show up, however the region option completely messes up search results for different terms because when i search for a different thing half of results are from Japanese sites and not even English (i am not close to Japan). Another Google thing that i like is that there is a date for posts which DDG doesn't seem to have unless i am missing it in the settings.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by nottorp on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:04AM (#24627254)
As a lot of other people said, Google still wins for local info. But nothing else IMO.

Try searching the model of your TV + review on Google. Tell me what page the first actual review comes in. If there's any, and not only stores trying to sell it to you or machine generated pages.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dingaling on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:36AM (#24635982)
My locale is FR but if I search for "BMW UK" in DDG it gives the UK sites immediately.

DDG doesn't have accumulated personal knowledge of you, so you have to be explicit. I don't see that as a high cost given the benefits.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by giomasce on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:33AM (#24624444)
Really? In my experience, when DDG doesn't find what I need it rarely happens that Google does.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Abishek_Muthian on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:42AM (#24624475)
Perhaps it has to do with search behaviour, perhaps what I search for has better results on Google (even though the quality of search results on Google have degraded extensively over past several years in favour of sites hosting large volume of content).

Every time I don't get a result I seek from a search engine, I think about making note of it for a 'search engine wall of shame', but I never acted upon that as the urge to solve problem at hand takes precedence. I will try to start making it a habit here on, so that I can provide some facts for such future discussions.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by romanoderoma on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:41AM (#24625098)
> g to get proper search results.

the difference being, for me, that DDG produces deterministic results, I can share search terms and get the same list.

With Google that's impossible

I also guess Google learns from my g! searches on DDG to rival with it and give the impression it knows better

Repeat the same search on another computer or with another user and complete different results appear, usually not better than DDG plus ads

DDG real weakness is localized content. Content in my language is way worse than what Google picks up.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Zenbit_UX on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:49AM (#24626512)
I agree DDG is not good enough to replace Google, but that doesn't mean I want them to die off because of some bullshit auction. They provide a good enough product for some, clearly and I hope it continues to improve so I can benefit from it too one day.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by toper-centage on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:41AM (#24624752)
Private search engines, by definition, must make less money than others. The ads are less targeted and worth less, and user data and search habits are not sold. To be outbit by other smaller players, you have to wonder: what is their business model.

And then you have non profits like Ecosia. Is it fair that Ecosia has to pay untold amounts in a secret auction to Google? That money could have gone to pay trees but instead is going to line Google's pockets and strengthen their dominance...

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Barrin92 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:24AM (#24624404)
it's an entirely circular argument because the basis for a service like DDG to be able to compete on product quality is having more users in the first place.

It's a classic case of network effects, one of the main reasons for Google's accurate results is the amount of data they have available, and that in turn depends on their userbase.

Quality of the product and popularity are correlated when it comes to most internet firms, so just appealing to consumer choice means little. Do we need to argue if Facebook without ads and more privacy would be better? Of course it'd be better, did anyone ever go "gosh I miss my Facebook ads"? The damn issue is that the value isn't in the product, but in the users already on the platform.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by 52-6F-62 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:38AM (#24628348)
While I generally think Google can do as it pleases here, I don't think

> But if your position is that your product cannot compete monetarily and also cannot compete without the advertising that money buys, then it might just be that you don't have as desirable a product as you think you do.

is really true. A free option not taking in great amounts of money, but offering substantial privacy just won't be as visible—especially when it's actively being drowned out by companies with for-profit motives.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by pb7 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:09PM (#24629556)
If substantial privacy was as valuable as you suggest, it would be more popular. People love getting something for nothing, so why isn’t it happening more easily?
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by 52-6F-62 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:17PM (#24630421)
The most valuable things are not always the most popular. I wouldn't conflate the two.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by jariel on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:26AM (#24625565)
"I'm undecided about DDG with regard to its relevance for my search behaviour. "

This is a misunderstanding of the economics.

Every dollar you spend on something is a dollar of value taken away from you in value - 'low price' means more surplus and value to the consumer, all other things being equal.

A crapy search engine with 10 000 customers will make more money than a great search engine that is essentially free - but which one is better?

There are other factors at play here, especially concerning scale, whereupon a smaller upstart, with a product 10x better would never be able to compete just on the basis of the cost of customer acquisition, which is arbitrary.

And of course, that search is free, it's a strategic investment on everyone's part to begin with.

'In Other Words' - the search engine with the most, crappiest ads, is going to get top place, but the search engine with 0 ads, supported by open source ... nobody would find out about?

They need to remove the auction, it makes the whole exercise pointless.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by ssorallen on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:33AM (#24624169)
+1

I have tried multiple times to use DuckDuckGo over the years but used !g so often for programming queries that I questioned why I was forcing myself to use a plainly underperforming (for my use case) product. In other David vs. Goliath stories like Firefox vs. Chrome the competing product had verifiable advantages for me. For DDG the only edge is an unverifiable claim that the company doesn’t track me? Other than that I am resolving myself to a product that performs less well for my use case.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by nottorp on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:26AM (#24625954)
> used !g so often for programming queries

Funny, I find google useless for programming queries lately.

Although, if you go past the beginner questions, all searches become useless. You want something exotic and android specific? Good luck wading through 3000 pages explaining you how to use Android. Even though you specified 'programmatically' or 'in code'. And 90% of the rest are SEO "tutorial" pages that don't answer your question either.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by bussierem on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:54AM (#24627133)
A million times this.

I recently had the misfortune of trying to learn Android app development and oh my GOD I can't describe how SEO-ridden it is. Basically any search that Google can surmise as being related to Android development (no matter if I'm searching for the fix for some error message, etc), I get almost a full page of results that are SEO'd "Android App Dev Tutorial For Beginners" that are all basically:

- 25 minute read of "how to install Android Studio"

- "Okay now that you have that, you can go off and start writing Android apps! Have fun!

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dhimes on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:30AM (#24626887)
Yeah; what the hell happened? Not just programming, but other technical things too. It's like everybody is gaming search so hard that search is going back to the days of AltaVista and Lycos.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by squiggleblaz on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:44AM (#24628421)
I am in this box too. When I first started using ddg, I added !g to programming queries because it was better. Nowadays, I try ddg first and I'm disappointed, so I append !g and I still get sfa.

It would be nice if some decent entrepreneurial academics could create a web browser that was better than the SEOers and would aim to do no evil. Sigh. One can dream.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by marcosdumay on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:07AM (#24627967)
Links stopped mattering after Google killed blogs.

Now there is no mass of people verifying the quality of random sites, and search engines lost they anchor.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dredmorbius on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:28PM (#24631274)
The now-defunct Advogato approached the question of reputation by having explicit reputation sources, with its founder the ultimate source.

Raph now works for Google AFAIA.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by marcosdumay on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:33PM (#24631951)
Reputation is a lousy replacement for page popularity. When Google started to apply their metrics over an entire domain, they already lost a lot of niche information.

Yes, it's better than nothing, but don't expect it to keep the same quality of results we got earlier. Google killed the golden goose when they decided do concentrate their results on the large sites only, and it will be very hard to make similar algorithms work that well again.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dredmorbius on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:46PM (#24632084)
Pagerank is explicitly a reputation measure. It's proved somewhat manipulable and unreliable.

Levien's reputation graph needn't be slavishly followed, though it does suggest an alternative.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by squiggleblaz on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:45AM (#24628437)
Don't sites like reddit, stackoverflow and twitter have an equivalent effect? (And I recall Google coming about before blogs. How did Google kill them?)
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by marcosdumay on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:07PM (#24630297)
Google was founded on the answer on how do you deduce the value of a site based on an ecosystem of personal pages around it. (Blogs are simply what replaced personal pages later.)

Have you ever seen any study like that for reddit and twitter? Those have completely different characteristics. (SO looks similar enough, but it's not comprehensive.)

On how did Google kill blogs, looks like you haven't noticed they decided to concentrate their search results on a small number of sites a few years ago.Google just does not lead people to them anymore.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by maxekman on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:05AM (#24624895)
It can also be that employees are willing to have a lower salary because they are feeling they contribute to something meaningful.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by rv-de on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:26AM (#24625568)
When using DDG I also tend to fall back on !g but in my idealistic fantasy I imagine this to be okay because I provide DDG with search terms they can use to optimize their engine.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by dtrailin on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:01AM (#24624563)
Would be interested in what that salary range is. I assume a larger part of their comp is RSU and options.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by roenxi on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:30AM (#24625586)
I see a slightly different argument here for why this is an antitrust issue. The DDG position is that they have lower ability to bid because they are offering a cheaper but superior (in terms of privacy) user experience.

If Google's only priority was the best outcome for the Android platform they'd probably consider cutting DDG a deal. However, because Google also gets the top slot by default they have an incentive to fill the rest of the list with poor-user-experience search engines.

So the antitrust issue would be Google freezing out DDG from the exposure, giving it instead to search engines that Google doesn't feel threatened by. This situation only exists because Google has technical control of both the list of search engines and the first search engine that appears on the list.

I'm not a huge fan of antitrust, being a hardened capitalist. But I can see why if antitrust is a thing then this is a case where it would apply. The market maker also being the major competitor in the market is pretty seedy.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by toper-centage on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:41AM (#24626453)
DDG's User research on 9k users in 3 main markets shows people don't mind scrolling through a long list of search options. Most people will still pick Google even if it's the last option. But their research also shows that about 20% of Google users would choose a different provider if given a chance. Google created fake scarcity by limiting the number of search providers to 4.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by appleflaxen on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:13AM (#24627371)
I am unable to follow your line of argument. What does your position on privacy have to do with fighting a monopoly?
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by drivebycomment on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:37PM (#24623961)
I don't think it's that simple. It's not as simple as DDG makes it out to be.

As a society, what do we want to see for the default search choice box on your smartphone ?

DDG's proposal is:

> Alternative search engines with the most market share in each market are shown on the first screen, randomly ordered. The remaining alternative search engines are available by scrolling, also randomly ordered.

Do we want to cram that with hundreds of random sites that want to be ? That amounts to a meaningless choice (nobody has really time to look through them all and compare). If people are willing to suffer that much through, they can certainly customize after the initial setup to pick whatever they want. So I think beyond the first screen is probably not a good idea - just put a search box or something.

Then, do we just put top N ? What would that N be ? Do we let the screen size dictate the number ? Do we use some fixed N ?

If you picked some fixed N, what the order should be ? From purely immediate utilitarian perspective, you'd want it to be according to the market share - to minimize the effort for people to pick what they want (with the assumption that the market share reflects the user's choice). DDG supports "random" order on the first screen - random would put them as the top choice more often than their current market share. This is not an unreasonable choice if you want to take advantage of "nudge" (of putting as the first choice) to "even out" the market share. As far as nudges go, this isn't THAT obstructive when looking from the lens of a single user, but this would still be a very direct intervention on people's choice and what companies can do - it's roughly equivalent to mandating grocery stores to pick top 5 soft drinks and display them in a random order on the top shelf. Generally we're bad at writing laws and regulations at this level of detail, so we try to rely on market to sort this kind of things out. But this question arises due to monopoly concerns in the first place, which is exactly about market distortion, so maybe this kind of intervention is OK ?

DDG also implies other search engines can bid more because they have higher profit margin due to sacrificing privacy. But this ignores two important aspects: 1) people are willing to trade off privacy for more "return" in the form of more features and free services (companies with higher profit tend to develop more, better stuff than companies with less profit) 2) companies who can't auction higher might be fundamentally less efficient than competitors, thus has higher cost structure. In that case, as a society we do generally want to use more efficient one.

So, at least part of DDG's request is not unreasonable, and does merit some discussion, but it's not as straightforward, and the answer likely will depend on how comfortable you are with how deep and detailed intervention you're willing to have the government / regulatory body decide.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:16AM (#24624107)
>Do we want to cram that with hundreds of random sites that want to be ? That amounts to a meaningless choice (nobody has really time to look through them all and compare)

90% of the users will pick a site on the first screen, those that don't actively want that glut of choice. I don't understand how anybody would be suffering from this, maybe people who have never used a search engine before?

> In that case, as a society we do generally want to use more efficient one.

The money spent on these auctions is advertising money, and it's hard to argue that the companies spending the most on advertising are the most efficient.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by drivebycomment on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:55AM (#24624526)
> The money spent on these auctions is advertising money, and it's hard to argue that the companies spending the most on advertising are the most efficient.

There's no direct metric that would measure "efficiency", as no single metric would be able to capture such complex question in a very meaningful way. As far as ways to choose, auction isn't that bad of a method to maximize the efficiency of resource allocation. That's why e.g. spectrum gets auctioned off. It's not just to generate more money - it's one of the easiest ways to ensure a relatively efficient resource allocation.

Auction does have downsides, but "advertising money" is not a convincing one.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:10AM (#24625489)
>Auction does have downsides, but "advertising money" is not a convincing one.

It has nothing to do with auctioning. As your point about how random distribution of those slots being unfair towards DDG shows, those slots are advertisements.

When buying a tangible resource at auction, like part of the spectrum, what you said is more likely to be true. Being willing to spend the most in advertising does not make it likely you're providing more features and services, and it doesn't mean you're an efficient company. It means you're able to generate more revenue per person, and a company that respects your privacy will be unable to compete in that metric.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by drivebycomment on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:18PM (#24632463)
> It means you're able to generate more revenue per person,

No. It means they are able to generate more profit. And that is an indirect reflection of efficiency.

> a company that respects your privacy will be unable to compete in that metric.

That's a common opinion, but I think this remains to be proven - see e.g. https://apenwarr.ca/log/20190201. The choice quote:

"That's a lot about profiling for ad targeting, which obviously doesn't work, if anyone would just stop and look at it. But there are way too many people incentivized to believe otherwise. "

I think there's a lot of truth behind that - that I suspect targeting adds small, marginal difference, not existential difference, and thus it's entirely possible that the advantage is all or mostly due to factors other than privacy.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:30PM (#24633249)
>No. It means they are able to generate more profit. And that is an indirect reflection of efficiency.

The result of this would mean all the most profitable companies are the ones that spent the most on advertising, which just isn't true.

It doesn't matter if targeting ads is actually worthwhile, as long as people are willing to buy tracking data a company that ignores your privacy will be able to generate more pee view.

Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by toper-centage on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:43AM (#24626475)
Your comment unfortunately shits on non profit orgs. Several search engines are not meant to turn a profit.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by mlindner on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:38AM (#24625636)
I used to like DuckDuckGo but that was because it used Bing which was relatively uncensored at the time. Bing has become heavily censored now in it's search results (similar to Google) and now DuckDuckGo doesn't find accurate search results for many terms on more edgy or politically incorrect or risque topics.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by Zenbit_UX on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:55AM (#24626565)
I find it shocking people want more Bing results in DDG. If it was 100% Google I wouldn't have ditched it.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by chris_f on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:23AM (#24626827)
Runnaroo and Startpage are both privacy focused and use Google as the base for organic web results. I am the creator of Runnaroo.
Re:Google’s Search Preference Menu Eliminates DuckDuckGo by aembleton on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:11AM (#24626271)
What do you use instead?