But contrast, a metric system in base 12 should still keep the niceties of the metric system - units of volume should correspond to units lengths of the side of a cube, units of weight should correspond to units of volume of water etc. And there should be a single rule for conversions, with standardized names for sub divisions.
These are the things that make the metric system superior, not its being in base 10. And these advantages far outweigh the advantage of being able to divide a sixth of a foot in a whole number of inches - particularly in the era where we carry arbitrary precision calculators in our pockets.
Only thing I hate about system is kilogram... The French... Couldn't do it properly. I really wish we would use grav instead...
While I'll agree that a base 12 system would be better, the American system would still be a bizarre hodgepodge.
Let's look at distance. First, a thou, or a thousandth of an inch. Breaking everything there. Then twelve inches to a foot, where things work. Then three feet to a yard? Twenty two yards to a chain, ten chains to a furlong and finally eight furlong to a mile.
And if you're wondering, yes I had to look up everything besides inch, foot, yard, and mile.
With C, sure 0C is cold, but tons of people experience colder on a regular basis; and I've had situations where 20C feels a bit too cold, but 21C feels a bit too warm. Most thermostats denominated in C trigger on half a degree difference, not a full degree.
You're pointing out how useful it is when doing science with water. Sure. And since science is important, and it doesn't make much sense to keep two systems around, then yeah, let's go with celsius as the standard. But let's not lose sight fo the fact that we actually are giving up a more human-focused system when we gain this scientifically-focused system.
(68 is a comfortable temperature for men wearing suits... a better more general temperature is probably 72.)
Zero F with no wind can feel like a nice day compared to zero C with tons of wind.
The reality is that metric is a standardizing measurement. There is one base unit, changes in scale merely involve a factor denoted by a prefix, it doesn't try to be smarter than absolutely necessary and just sticks to decimal.
Smaller nations have no problem changing everything. The marginal benefit is too small for a giant to turn on a dime.
A lot of things in US are already both ANSI/Metric:
- Electronics and PCB manufacturing (accepts both, but its a bit messy). Headers are 0.1" but BGA pitch is 0.4mm for example.
- Hardware stores have both standard and metric sizes for fasteners
- Liquids (both oz/ml has to be printed by law)
- Car speed gauges (both mph/kph printed by law)
- Food items are all metric. A Coke can has 42 grams of sugar. There is no oz printed in nutrition labels.
It's kind of a hybrid system.
However, there are exceptions for the follow which are still stuck:
- Temperature, weather is always in Fahrenheit. Even in recipes.
- Paper sizes are not adopted to ISO standards.
- Pressure is almost always in psi
Every other nation seemed to manage it. It's just the usual American exceptionalism. There's nothing special about the USA that makes it harder to implement. There's just just a stubborn belief that there is, which becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy. A bit like all the other policy issues which the rest of the world has solved but the US still argues about.
The stubbornness you speak of is actually more to do with not willing to accept the costs of the change. World’s largest economy can’t just change it all at once even though majority of the people support it.
No one in the US argues that the Metric system isn’t superior. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that multiples of 10 in a base 10 system of numbers makes everything easy.
In fact, the superiority complex comes from non-US folks thinking “look at those dumb Americans and their stupid units”.
Certain people think “Americans just don’t get it”.
Are you content that US and majority of the countries drive on the same side? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-_and_right-hand_traffic
Per the law 21 CFR 101.9(b)(5)(viii) [0]:
> (viii) For nutrition labeling purposes, a teaspoon means 5 milliliters (mL), a tablespoon means 15 mL, a cup means 240 mL, 1 fl oz means 30 mL, and 1 oz in weight means 28 g.
In reality:
* 1 fl. oz. ≈ 29.57 mL [1] (the volume measurements all build off of one another so I won't bother converting more than one)
* 1 oz. ≈ 28.35 g
In other words, volume and mass measurements are legally required to be off by ~1.4% and ~1.3% respectively.
[0]: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/cfr...
I don't think it is the size of the US that is the problem, I think the real problem is the US political culture.
The most successful approach to metrication is (a) do it in a big-bang, all at once, not gradually (b) make it apply uniformly nation-wide (c) make it apply across as many industries/sectors as possible, with as few exceptions as possible (d) take a predominantly mandatory rather than voluntary approach to metrication. If the US had followed that formula, it would very likely have succeeded, but it never had the political will to go down that path. Instead it opted for a piecemeal, voluntary approach, which was never likely to be a great success
In a parliamentary system such as the UK, Canada, Australia, etc, cabinet decides on a policy, and then the government usually has the numbers in the legislature to enact whatever policy cabinet decides. By contrast, in the US, the executive (President and cabinet) and the legislature (Congress) are two arms-length branches of government, with far less coordination, and it becomes much harder to push policies through unless strong interests are backing them.
Hence, in the US, it is basically impossible to get any controversial policy implemented unless either it has corporate lobbying behind it, or else it is some kind of emotional issue which attracts the attention of activist groups. Corporate lobbyists don't support mandatory metrication (it will cost business money, at least in the short term); metrication doesn't induce the kinds of emotions that issues like abortion or racism do, so there is little activist energy pushing it.
Also, the US historically has a much more hostile attitude to technocratic bureaucracy than most other Western countries do. In other countries, the scientific/technological elite consensus is "this way is better", and the government endorses it, and so the general public falls into line behind the government. In the US, there has always been much more resistance among the general public to those kind of elite proposals. (That said, I think in more recent years the rest of the English-speaking world is becoming more like the US in this regard; I think the Internet has helped export that US culture of distrusting technocratic elites to the rest of the English-speaking world.)
And some smaller nations (the UK, for example) have never changed "everything" and likely never will.
Probably some portion hope to revert completely when they do.
Probably some portion hope that they rejoin the EU with another vote; and in the process get dragged the rest of the way to the engineering age measurements in the process.
https://resources.realestate.co.jp/buy/guide-to-japanese-apa...
> The size of a Japanese-style room is measured by the number of tatami mats:
>> Four mat room = 6.12 square meters = 66 square feet
>> Six mat room = 9.18 square meters = 98.8 square feet
> Most Japanese-style rooms in modern apartments are four or six mats in size.
Even though today only a minority of apartment rooms are actually used with tatami it is still customary to give all rooms in mat units and usually in m^2 too.
BTW that's similar to how non SI units are still used in other countries nowadays, e.g. (metric) pounds and half-pounds are still used in context of groceries in colloquial German.
That would make trade deals with the EU impossible.
10/2 = 6
10/3 = 4
10/4 = 3
10/6 = 2
That's two more whole number fractions than 10 (decimal) which is only divisible by 2 and 5.
E.G.
The speed of light is 299,792,458 meters per second.
The speed of light is 299,792.458 KM per second.
The speed of light is about 300 M meters per second.
10/5 in Base 12 is 2.49724972497...
Or binary (Base 2)
1011/101 = 10.0011001100...
Duodecimal metric system would have the same features that you’re talking about (which have nothing to do with the base).
It makes more sense to YOU because you've used it since early life, so you have created an mental model for it. Countries with metric system, people have done the same.
As one example, In a recent after-work conversation, some one mentioned the stupidity of the "stone" measurement, upon the Italian, Canadian, Japanese, American, Swedish, Mexican, Chinese and the Russian all agreed it was the most non-intuitive stupid thing they have ever heard. Except the Brit at the place, who (in vain) tried to explain how it made sense and made "more sense to humans"
These "intuitiveness" arguments are silly. It's whatever you're used to. So with that realisation, we may as well choose the more universally self-consistent and useful system, which is indisputably metric.
Careful, that's a British pint. An American pint is closer to 400mL.
I do not disagree with the above, I can totally see that being done (hell, when we didn't have a measure out while hiking with my friends we used "5 iPhones long" as a temporary measurement)
Problem is of course, that I can't see how that measurement can ever scale well beyond one medieval towns market place as a measurement, let alone a country, kingdom or a territory without confusion. It is ambiguous. Just as the example you said, it is easy for a fraudster to pick up any rock and claim that one to resemble the standard rock unit and get some unfair trading advantage. It is too easy to trample with. The purpose of measurement is exactly to REMOVE ambiguity, and establish a STANDARDS just as we established common languages for communication.
And on a side note, usage of the "stone measurement" was officially prohibited for commercial use in 1985 in UK. It is apparently still used for body-weight, but I guess there ambiguity can be preferred ;)
Updating measurement unit according to societal needs is only natural, and the purpose of the Stone story in my comment was that, even among so many different national (with different culture, language, metric system) they thought the Stone measurement made no sense today. Except the Brit that had a mental model for it. Which was the point: sometime mental model can seem like an good argument, but as the Canadian and American also thought stone was dumb, (While everyone else in the room thought imperial units were dumb) they kind of proved that their argument for imperial units was also not found on good basis.
There was an xkcd comic with lists of ready-to-go mental models about metric units for people who grew up without them:
Juice is also bought by the liter, usually in 2L bottles for a family dinner, or 500mL bottles for one person alone.
Strange what you say about milk though - I've usually seen the 2l form factor anywhere westerners are common. Could be a local convention?
Different European countries produced different fruits (citrus, apples etc), but I've not noticed that e.g. apple juice is in larger containers in Britain, and orange juice in Spain. If anything, the trend is to smaller containers, for variety and health.
https://ec.europa.eu/growth/single-market/goods/building-blo...
In most countries you could go your whole life without having to know what a "gallon" is or even hearing the word.
I do understand that it is hard to adjust intuitions from one system to the other, but I can't imagine how someone can think that people have problems using the measurement system they learned in primary school.
Most people in the world just buy their petrol per liter directly and it's priced at <currency amount> / liter, there is no conversion needed, the "gallon" is just an arbitrary measure.
Actually that is the "official" way of measurement (what you see on the car specifications or what the on board computer tells you), in speaking it is more common to say that you made 22 Km/liter (or 18, etc.) than to say you used 4.55 liters/100 Km (or 5.56 liters/100 Km).
So you had (say) 30 liters needed to refill and travelled for 450 Km, now is it easier to divide 30 by 450 and multiply by 100 ( or divide 30 by 4.5) or divide 450 by 30?
Besides the difference between (say) 18 and 19 Km/l is (IMHO) easier to visualize/appreciate than the difference between 5.56 and 5.26 l/100 km.
It depends.
Here (Italy) most petrol stations are self-service/with automated machine for payments.
If I buy in cash I buy gasoline "per money", i.e. 20 Euro or 50 Euro, you don't have any alternatives if not multiples of the bills.
If I buy paying with a card then I still try (roughly) to meet the amount.
I am not really aware that today 50 Euro will give me (say) 27.476 liters while last week (still say) it gave me 27.187 liters.
One desirable property with the SI system is how compatible they are: a cube with 10cm sides is a liter, so it’s easy to imagine the space requirements for a 40 liter tank. A gallon is 231 cubic inches, which is much less natural to work with.
Say, I walk into a bar. I order a beer. Here (in The Netherlands), since I didn't specify, I get a small beer of whatever's on tap. A small beer is 250ml-350ml, depending on the establishment. I could also order a half liter (500ml) or ask for a pitcher. So, just as in the US you don't order "can I have 128 fluid ounces of beer" you don't order "250ml of beer" in the rest of the world. Also, the fact that it 'sounds exotic' says more about you than about the system... and 'guaranteed not as exact'? Really? Let's say you have to measure a gallon of water, and I have to measure a liter. I just whip out a digital kitchen scale and measure 1000 grams. Which is EXACTLY the same amount as 1000 milliliters. Cause, you know, metric units are interchangeable. I double dare you to come up with a more exact measurement in Imperial units using simple kitchen tools.
Traveler beware: Just because it's true that a Dutch "vaasje" glass is 230-330ml[1] the actual volume of beer you get is at best 80% of that. The Dutch pouring practice of handing patrons a glass of beer with up to 1/4 receding foam on the top would cause a riot across the channel.
> [...]and measure 1000 grams. Which is EXACTLY the same amount as 1000 milliliters[...]
No, not exactly. Not even under standard conditions. It's one of the unfortunate warts of the modern metric system that the actual value drifted from exactly 1000, almost, but not exactly[2].
You order a quart when you want a quarter of a gallon in the US.
You order a "Viertelliter" (quarter of a Liter" when you want a quarter of a Liter in Germany.
How is one quarter less precise / more exotic than the other?
Most places, I think, most people don't talk in precise units at all. Give me a glass of water. Put in a pinch of salt. One scoop of coffee. Handful of peanuts. It is my personal experience that this tracks pretty well across any culture. In my opinion, having these oddball measuring units is an easier mental model. A couple tablespoons is human sounding. 30ml is not, even if you have a 15ml spoon. A cup of water sounds human, a quarterliter does not. I'm not trying to insult you or your system, I'm just expressing my own opinion, which as pointed out, probably comes from my own education and experience.
And the litre isn't? Sorry, I fail to see your argument here.
To take the example of the F150 there's a 26 gallon fuel tank, but then the engine size in in liters, transmission fluid is in quarts, windshield washer reservoir in liters etc.
Even on the most popular American-made car in the US you need to deal with an absolute mess of different measurement systems, on e.g. a German-made car all of these would be metric.
Thus e.g. a 245/45 R17 tire has a diameter of around 26 inches. As you can deduct from the "simple" formula of:
245/10*45/100/2.54*2+17 =~ 25.7
I.e. the width is 245mm, the cross section of the tire is 45% of that, or ~110mm, multiply that by 2 and add the 17 inches and you've got the outer tire diameter.1. https://www.moderntiredealer.com/8644/understanding-tire-dim...
I'm guessing that why they were sold in those amounts vs some other choice. It's just my experience though.
The US pint is 16 ounces, vs the Imperial pint of 20 ounces. That's because no one really wants that much American beer.
In Australia, standard beer glass size varies from state to state -- here in NSW we have a schooner (at 425ml) or if you're after something smaller, a middy (285ml).
Using metric does not mean you need to always and only drink 1 litre of beer, drive at 100km an hour, constantly stoop so you're 1m tall, etc.
Good for them.
> In Australia, standard beer glass size varies from state to state -- here in NSW we have a schooner (at 425ml) or if you're after something smaller, a middy (285ml).
I know. You can buy a yard of ale in the UK at participating outlets. None of that has any relevance to whether a pint is more convenient than a litre. A schooner is more convenient than a litre.
> Using metric does not mean you need to always and only drink 1 litre of beer, drive at 100km an hour, constantly stoop so you're 1m tall, etc.
I'm arguing against dogmatism, not for it.
But one pint versus one litre doesn't have relevance to anything, does it?
It seems you've heard the suggestion to adopt a sensible, integrated, and (much more) widely used measurement system -- and are choosing to argue against specific numbers / quantities of things.
Originally you said 'a litre [of beer] is too big as you'll end up with a flat beer'.
Metric doesn't mean you must sell, buy, or drink beer in round numbers.
And by "pint of beer", do you mean an Imperial pint (568 mL) or a US liquid pint (473 mL)?
Using a conversion as a justification just isn't a fair comparison.
The error has nothing to do with units of measurements chosen. You cannot measure exactly 1.(0) gallon [1.0000000000… gallon with infinite number of zeroes] of liquid with absolute accuracy either.
In engineering this would be resolved with something like 500 ± 10 mL.
In consumer goods there are either regulations or you get, say, 505 mL so you have nothing to complain about. And you would never be able to tell the difference.
By the way, ML is megaliter. Milliliter is mL.
[1] unfortunately https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tun_(unit) leaves me no wiser as to what volume the unit "shit tun" might measure.
I'm pretty sure this is an attempt at humor. Or I'm not sure but I hope.
Converting between the units is a pain: not because the conversion is hard (the conversion ratios are usually whole numbers), but rather because there's a lot of units and it's difficult to remember how they relate to each other (e.g. what's the relation between a pint and a gallon?).
A US gallon is 3.785 litres. A UK gallon is 4.546 litres.
Which if these is more human-sized?
The US gallon since they've got more people per capita.
Meaning, the phrase "gallon of milk" is ever so slightly easier to say/verbalize than "four liters of milk." Or alternatively, "half gallon of milk" vs "two liters of milk."
Likewise: "pint of beer" vs. "<half liter/5 deciliters> of beer", "1 cup of flour" vs. "<quarter liter/250 mL/25 centiliters/120 grams> of flour".
The duodecimal system is unique to the fact that the number 12 has more divisible factors than anything else that's manageable to count.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duodecimal
Inches/Feet are based on Duodecimal system, but since we use Arabic numerals (base 10), it's obvious why inches/feet aren't the way to go and why Metric system wins.
There are still things that the rest of the world use Base 12 for - hours/minutes/seconds, 360 degrees, point font units, etc.
The reason why America hasn't adopted Metric system despite of it being the official system in the law is the same reason why the rest of the world hasn't gotten around to changing time/degrees into a decimal equivalent. It takes a tremendous amount of effort to turn the ship, the US being a giant ship to turn. America also leads in determining standards for Metric system around the world - NIST with collaboration from European counterparts work together to establish these standards. Universities in US, semiconductor industry, medical industry, etc. use metric units. Engineers in the US know and use the metric system.
If we didn't have Arabic numerals in Base 10, the American system is better :) *
But since we are all stuck with arabic numerals, the Metric system is better!
Edit: * I realized that its not that simple. Conceding this point, see responses. I was under the impression that most US units were consistent with base 12, but they're not - 1 lb = 16 oz (not 12) for example. A base 12 metric system would be ideal.