I like to think I am as well. How do you balance this when moving from Apple to Android, where Apple (seems) to be much more privacy-focused and basically at zero for open-source/freedom, where Android is basically the reverse? I think there are ways to make it better (custom ROM, alternative app stores), but you give up a lot of functionality (Play Store, Google Pay, etc.), and I'm not sure you can entirely eliminate all concerns.
I like the freedom of Android, so as long as I understand what I'm giving up privacy-wise I don't mind the trade-off. I have at least tried to make it a little harder for Google, using DuckDuckGo, but I'm guessing it only makes a dent with the other massive amounts of data they can still glean from the various services running on the phone, Gmail, Maps, etc.
With a Pixel phone, you can go further, unlock the bootloader and install a third party OS that does not even include Google services installed at all.
Of course, on the other hand, you could sign up for every google service, load all their apps, and consent to all their tracking, in which case you give away everything. Google makes it very easy to do this.
But either way, it's at least your choice. Unlike Apple, which thinks it certainly knows best what code should be allowed on your computer and how it should be placed there.
But depending on how far you're willing to go to get around it, there's a solution: MicroG [0].
It's basically an open-source Google Play Services implementation and it supports a number of different location providers like Apple and Mozilla.
There are a bunch of ways to install it but the easiest is probably their LineageOS ROM [1].
[0]: https://microg.org/
I'm not saying that this is what most people are going to do, and I'm certainly not trying to openwash Android-as-marketed-by-Google. Just pointing out the path exists if you'd like to go down it. It helps to have an extra device, to be less tempted to compromise [with] your main one.
https://myactivity.google.com/activitycontrols
You can configure it to delete after a certain period of time (eg 3 mo) or to never store it. You can also view and delete specific bits of data.
Of course, I am sure there are loopholes and bugs that result in some information remaining on Google services, but for privacy conscious users who rely on some Google services, it's worth experimenting with and spreading.
Its cash and profitability relative to the market give it a ton of negotiating power with investors who might see things differently when it comes to business decisions.
Apple makes money by focusing on its customers and brand. Investors have learned to let it do that.
Meanwhile every iteration of Android is getting more locked down because of "security". No more external cameras etc..
The future look bleak until we get a true open source alternative running on open hardware.
Where can I go to buy these? I typed "buy PinePhone" and got a wikipedia page with supported hardware made by other companies.
Librem5 - https://shop.puri.sm/
Maybe a fork like LineageOS will take over eventually. An open hardware device is really needed though.
Woah; this would affect me, but I can't find any reference for it... can I convince you to expand a bit?
https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/08/20/android-11-camera-a...
https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/20/21376391/google-android-1...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24205479
While this is a regression for user choice, it is still better than iOS/iPadOS, which always defaults to Apple's Camera app and never had a camera picker in the first place.
I added the update shortcut to homescreen to go straight to updates
You can then add the shortcut to your home screen, run it from the shortcuts widget, via search, etc.
He also has a list of links for the Settings app here: https://www.macstories.net/ios/a-comprehensive-guide-to-all-...
1. I use the store only for free apps
2. I use Blockada which blocks ads even inside apps https://blokada.org/ Download it from F-Droid, not from the Play Store. Google doesn't allow the full functionality version on its store.
Yes, those are absolutely ads, they're explicitly labelled as such. And they're not very subtle, there's another double-tall row of them every other page when scrolling through the Play Store. There are also ads for other apps on every app page, and ads for search results. The search result ads are egregious - e.g. if I search for a major bank app, the first several results are for competing banks, they're barely differentiated from the legitimate results, and they're explicitly not what I'm looking for. I feel like I'm at an awful bazaar where I know what I want but slimy merchants keep yelling at me and getting in my way to shove their junk in my face.
I'd pay $10/m just to get rid of ads on the Play Store and Google Maps.
> The only videos are after clicking an app and then they have never ever started playing automatically.
There's a Play Store setting for controlling autoplay of videos.
> Neither my OnePlus or Google phones have it.
Play Store is a Google App, phone manufacturer has no impact.
Play store is needed for buying apps. Can't do that from aurora store without a risk of your Googz Account getting banned.
You could buy apps from a desktop browser and just configure the account details in Aurora for the paid apps? I haven't heard of anyone getting banned.
The aurora dev's account gets frequently banned. Look into is telegram group.
Google Play services track nearly everything on the device with system level access.
I switched to an iPhone a few years ago to get further from Google, but the crap with the App Store is getting so out of hand now. My next device will probably be a Pine Phone.
As a long time iPhone user I'm on the same boat. I do hope there will be a somewhat beta level Pine Phone soon. I'm already thinking should I get my old Nokia n900 from the storage box and start using that. Not comfortable with Androids and the latest Apple actions are making me feel a bit unsure on the direction they are taking.
There’s a bunch of neat little things like that you get on Android if you use Google, but you can get on iOS with any server backend.
I hope Apple opens up a bit because there really needs to be serious competition in this space.
The easiest way to install it is their LineageOS build. If one isn't available, NanoDroid [2] provides flashable ZIPs that work with Magisk. If you're not okay with either of those but you can spend a bit of time, you can add it to your own AOSP builds.
If you really really care about security and don't care too much about all the apps in the world working, there's also GrapheneOS for Pixel devices [3]. The cool thing about Pixel devices is that they allow you to add your own verified boot key and re-lock your device with a third-party ROM installed. GrapeheneOS supports this and a variety of other security-focused features like reproducible builds [4].
And final honorable mention goes to RattlesnakeOS [5] which allows you to set up your very own AOSP build system complete with OTAs and ROM signing. It also allows you to add MicroG [6].
[0]: https://microg.org/
[1]: https://lineage.microg.org/
[2]: https://gitlab.com/Nanolx/NanoDroid
[4]: https://grapheneos.org/build#reproducible-builds
I've got some bad news for you about Google Services
This means you can't use any Google apps like Maps, Photos, etc, right? What Google alternatives do you use?
Photos works just fine without an account too.
Downsides are that they don't contain such a wealth of place info as Google Maps does, and surely do some tracking too (from which you should be able to opt out thanks to GDPR).
I'm curious what your views are on the Play store services, and binary blobs needed for 4g/5g chips and what not. I believe Lineage is an attempt at "un-googling" Android and there's f-droid for APK's. Have you gone that route at all?
You can send an .apk to any android user and they will be able to install it. That's the opposite of a walled garden.
> At least in this context play store terms is not more developer friendly than app store in ios.
You don't have to pay Google $100 every year.
Your app is published within 30 mins.
You can deploy pretty much any app that runs on Android (other browsers, other stores, etc).
You can sell stuff on your app or even put a button to your website to buy stuff.
Etc.
I'm not aware of any instances where google forced a developer to monetize an app.
Indeed, unlike apple, google is fine with you using a 3rd party payment provider (i.e. not paying the 30% cut) if the product purchased can be used outside the app (which is clearly the case for a domain name.)
>> Payment is for digital content that may be consumed outside of the app itself (e.g. songs that can be played on other music players). [0]
[0] https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...
I absolutely do not trust any third party - there are some insane apps like LinkedIn that tries to sell your privacy at every corner.
That said, Apple should allow Jailbreaking to aficionados who want to mess around with it. But, there should be significant impedance to that - your average joe working as a bartender doesn't have a clue of how to keep his iPhone secure. Apple should make it explicitly clear - hey! ALL BETS ARE OFF WHEN YOU JAILBREAK OUR DEVICE. CLICK AGREE.
1. https://www.wired.com/story/apple-app-store-malware-click-fr...
Apple's whole game is to make profit from hardware and their services, not ads.
Even if Apple charged - $50/month privacy fee to keep things secure, I am fine with it.
I'd pay twice as much for an iPhone - at $2000 even - something that keeps everything about my life secure - I have no problems paying for it.
You would probably pay a $500.00 a month privacy fee.
Your choice in mobile is walled castle or forest full of thieves.
I suppose there are open source phones around but I don't personally find them that useful yet. The main things I want to do with a mobile device is interact with services like Uber, Lyft, Netflix, etc., and get directions. I suppose directions exist via OpenStreetMap but can you reserve an Uber on a Linux phone?
Yes. https://m.uber.com
But when a friend told me that Samsung just ruin Android [1] and I should try an actual Google phone, I bought a Pixel and it's honestly great.
I can install apps I build myself very easily without Google's input at all, although I don't even need to build apps since their PWA's can do almost anything I'd want.
I highly recommend people who are sick of this Apple crap, to try a Google Pixel. I haven't even needed to sign up for a Google account since using it (although I have to use an alternative app store).
I've already moved three family members over and after a few days they basically don't notice a different.
Between moving to my Pixel and a Purism laptop I'm pretty much free from Apple, apart from my work laptop, which isn't my choice.
1. Disclaimer! I am very privacy, open-source, freedom orientated so if you don't mind a bunch of binary blobs that track you maybe Samsung would work for you.