You can see the common sense ship has sailed.
In the past power supplies and spinning disc hard drives would fail much more often.
It’s basically a solved problem, outside of extremely mission critical, 5 nines kind of stuff, that we all forgot because of AWS.
HN ran, and may still run, on a single bare metal server.
I bet HN wouldn't do a 10 hours high-risk operation for moving their servers because they can't afford an outage. (But well, running stuff on a single bare-metal server is expensive enough that even if they could, I expect they don't.)
What would that company do if a pipe broke inside the datacenter? Besides, if you never restart your servers, you are guaranteeing that the one time when the power goes off on the entire city, they won't come back online.
HN is probably not business-critical and could probably affort a 10 hour downtime without much hassle.
While I don’t think they informed them of this in good-faith, it is a nice heads-up. In this case, it meant Consultant2 consulting RefusingConsultant that probably knew the IT better.
I hope there wouldn't be a correlation, but I wouldn't be all that surprised if a somewhat loose one was found.
Though it was likely easier to find than that Novell Netware server that was sealed behind some drywall, with only a stray network cable leaving any clue as to where it was.
I once only half jokingly suggested finding a missing data closet in a two million square foot distribution center by pinging a known IP from three or four aggregator switches across the building and triangulating the location on a floor plan. Sadly the people crawling around the ceiling found it before I could put my idea into practice.
Good job they found it!
Turns out a door was closed and a new one built to a hallway to another hallway and not properly labeled on the updated drawings. Had one of the boxes running a conveyor belt not have died, we'd never have looked.
Also, that doesn't cover other problems mentioned here, like natural disasters, ISP problems, etc.
Also cost does come in play as well. Multiple physical links in would be very expensive for what sounds like internal services. Likewise a natural disaster might cause bigger issues to the company than those internal services going down. They might still have offsite back ups (I'd hope they would!) so at least they can recover the services but the cost of having a live redundancy system off site might not justify those risk factors.
The customers requires are definitely unreasonable though. I'd hope those systems are regularly patched, in which case when is downtime for that scheduled and why is that acceptable but not when you're physically moving the server? I doesn't really make much sense; but then "not making much sense" also quite a common problem when providing IT services for others.
In general, we don't know much about this case. It's a post on Reddit, might not even be true. As is, it doesn't make much sense, but we don't know all the details, so maybe we jumped to conclusions.
Mainframe is not just a server. You can hot plug RAM on these things.
Single server and "can't tolerate any downtime" are mutually exclusive.
I've came across old AWS account (startup have been using AWS for the longest). All the network traffic or VPN goes through a single instance with 3 years of uptime.
If a function is super critical to business, it also deserves to have some thought put into the blast radius of its failure.
The sort of places that would insist on rolling a live server 700 ft across a parking lot probably don't have any real disaster recovery plan.
There's SMART for disks... what else?
HN also has downtime fairly often.
Some circuits might average 5 to 7 nines of uptime over a year, but the next year is dump truck time... You can never truly be certain.
Whether it's smart and good for your business/reputation is a different question.
Second thing is having multiple machines for server. In theory it might help in increasing the availability but in practice I haven't seen any random issue due to machine which occurs just based on probability. I think almost all failure modes that exist, they are correlated between machines. eg suppose you have data loss on one machine, you could more likely than not, blame it on code and it would be similar across machines.
Re: multiple servers. Power supplies fail, memory modules fail, cpus fail, fans fail, storage drives fail. Sometimes those are correlated --- the HP SSDs that failed when the power on hours hit a limit (two separate models) are going to be pretty correlated if they were purchased new and stuck into servers at a similar time and then on 24/7. Most of those failures aren't that correlated though. Software failures would be more likely to be correlated though, of course.
The key thing is to really think about what the cost for being down is, how long is acceptable/desirable to be down, and how much you're willing to spend to hit those goals.
I can't understand this. I think transferring servers would be the the least of problems. Its the transferring of database and maintaining consistent version of databases in both the locations. Moving the snapshots after every X minutes doesn't maintain consistency. I would like to read about any company that is able to do this, as honestly it sounds really hard to me. Is there any writeup of IBM thing you mentioned?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23471698
TLDR is connectivity to and from the IBM cloud datacenters (which includes softlayer) was generally unavailable, globally, for a couple hours. If you were in multiple IBM datacenters, you were as down as if you were in only one (mostly, I was poking around when it was wrapping up, and some datacenters came back earlier than others).
> Its the transferring of database and maintaining consistent version of databases in both the locations. Moving the snapshots after every X minutes doesn't maintain consistency. I would like to read about any company that is able to do this, as honestly it sounds really hard to me
The gold standard here is two-phase commit. Of course, that subjects every transaction to delay, so people tend not to do that. The close enough version is MySQL (or other DB) replication, monitor that the replication stream is pretty current and hope not a lot is lost when a datacenter dies. There's room to fiddle with failover and reconciliation; I recommend against automatic failover for writes, because it gets really messy if you get a split brain situation --- some of your hosts see one write server available and others see another, and you may accept conflicting writes. A few minutes running like that can mean days or weeks of reconciliation, if you didn't build for reconciliation.
And then charge for those 5 hours for good measure.
In general, this stupid trend of wanting 0 downtime makes no sense to me. If you're not NASA, police or other emergency service you 100% can afford a few hours of downtime with scheduling it be forehead.
The main IT guy went on holiday and one of the cover guys from another office decided to tidy up. He unplugged the server and thought (and told me after his thought process) "if anyone was using it, they'll let us know".
This was the one, single box for the whole website - no one else was monitoring (even though the central office had a proper, dedicated web team) and the assumption was I was sysadmin.
An hour later I'm sprinting down the corridor to find out what the hell happened and why I can't even SSH into the box.
We put a sticker on the case saying not to unplug it after that...
If your mainframe had only one CPU, you did have to turn it off in order to service it. But you could upgrade the OS without turning it off. While they aren't cool tech now, mainframes are a marvel of hardware engineering.
(archive.org link because ibm.com apparently isn't hosted on a mainframe.)
What if a technical failure happen? What if there's a fire in the server room? What if there is an earthquake and the building collapses? What if... many things can happen that can result in a long, long downtime with this tactics.
If uptime is so crucial, the system should be setup in such way that moving one server should be a peace of cake, not a spec-ops mission.