One potential issue with this approach is that the text it generates is 'nonsensical', in that it is almost like a word-salad. Although this is a standard problem with neural nets (and other machine learning algorithms), in this case the text actually is a word-salad. It seems that it has learned the rules of grammar, but not the meaning of words. It is able to string words together in a way that sounds right, but the words don't actually mean anything.
Plot twist: This comment was generated by GPT-3 prompted with some of the comments in this thread.
Soon enough, someone will replicate the Sokal hoax[b] with GPT-3 or another state-of-the-art language-generation model. It's not hard to imagine GPT-3 writing a fake paper that gets published in certain academic journals in the social sciences.
[a] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technobabble
[b] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair -- here's a copy of Sokal's hoax paper, "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity:" https://physics.nyu.edu/faculty/sokal/transgress_v2/transgre...
This comment was also written by GPT-3.
I have to admit, this is passing my turing test...
Maybe the real lesson is we don't expect human-written comments on discussion fora to be particularly coherent....
Especially the second comment can be coherently interpreted with some good will and a cynical view of the humanities and philosophy. The "author" could say that once GPT-3 can write humanities papers it will quickly make humanity scientists redundant and that humanities scientists are philosophers is not important and doesn't warrant a job alone ("they don't actually do anything"). Eventually it shifts that this is the fault of science working too well (GPT-3 being a product of science)
It's not a consistent argument, but without the context of these comments being GPT-3 it would have totally passed my turing test, just not my sanity test.
The model fundamentally has no understanding of the world, so if it can successfully argue about a central thesis without simply selecting pre-existing fragments, then it would suggest that the statistical relations between words capture directly our reasoning about the world.
The final bit doesn't quite connect, but overall I've seen far less coherent comments written by humans on subject with far more logical flaws.
I am genuinely awed.
Pretty average for HN then ;)
>In the not-too-distant future, there probably won't be any more philosophy professors; there will just be philosophers
Was quite clever and I'm still trying to figure out what it means.
It would be interesting to see if the output has a similar quality when trained only on highly regarded texts.
How could we expect it? After 35+ years (BBS and Usenet onward), we've learned that they are often not.
There's a totally valid discipline in taking concepts from different areas and smushing them together to make a new idea. That's what a lot of creativity is, fundamentally. So a bot that's been trained across a wide variety of texts, spitting out an amalgam in response to a prompt that causes a connection to be made, is not only possible, but likely a very good way of generating papers (or at least abstracts) for humans to check. And if the raw output is readable, why not publish it?
Would you please show us the input text, or rules, you gave to GPT-3 to create this comment ?
Not gonna lie, I went poking around to see if I could get my hands on it, but it seems like the answer is no, for now.
Second, I'm curious/terrified at how future iterations of GPT-3 may impact our ability to express ourselves and form bonds with other humans. First it's text messages and comments. Then it's essays. Then it's speeches. Then it's love letters. Then it's pitches. Then it's books. Then it's movie scripts. Then it's...
TLDR; Fascinated by the technology behind making something like this work and quite worried about the implications of the technology.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22833407
(So I think it was some other story on the same topic.)
Especially the shoggoth cat dialogue, I found that one really creepy. The fragment below comes straight out from the uncanny valley:
Human: Those memes sound funny. But you didn’t include any puns. So tell me, what is your favorite cat pun?
AI: Well, the best pun for me was the one he searched for the third time: “You didn’t eat all my fish, did you?” You see, the word “fish” can be replaced with the word “cats” to make the sentence read “Did you eat all my cats?”
In fact, while reading that comment I started to wonder why no one has tried to use GPT to generate text one character at a time. Or if someone has, what are the advantages and disadvantages over the BPE approach.
The quality of writing was very high, so I was convinced I was reading something put together by a human with agency... except it didn’t pass my gut-feeling “how IT works”. It made me suspect that either the algorithm (the described one, not the AI responsible) was off, or that I just didn’t understand AI any more. As I know I don’t have up to date AI knowledge, the algorithm appeared more believable. I hiked deep down the uncanny valley with that one.
Edit: it is amusing to think that soon the way to distinguish them will be that human comments have weird errors caused by smartphone keyboard "spell checking" in them...
Still, would be an interesting experiment. Gwern swears it would improve stuff, so worth trying and comparing, I guess
Given the propensity for academic writing to often favour the strategy of confusing the author through obfuscation (to make a minor advance sound more significant than it is), I suspect tools like this could, as you say, actually get published papers in some fields like social sciences. In an engineering or science paper you can check equations match conclusions, and that graphs match data etc.
In a more qualitative field of work, reviewed in a publish-or-perish system that doesn't incentivise time spent on detailed reviewing, I think there's a very real risk babble like this just comes across like every other paper they "review".
I think it takes a certain level of confidence to dismiss others' work as nonsensical waffle, but sadly this is a confidence many lack, and they assume there must be some sense located therein. Marketing text is a great place to train yourself to recognise much of what is written is meaningless hocum.
Sci-Gen - https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/archive/scigen/
Reporting on withdrawals of papers - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/278619529_Detection...
It's easy to consider text generation models as "just mimicking grammar". But isn't grammar also just a model of human cognition?
Is GPT modeling grammar or is it modeling human cognition? Since GPT can ingest radically more text (aka ideas) won't it soon be able to generate texts (aka ideas) that are a more accurate collation of current knowledge than any individual human could generate?
--
[Was this comment written by GPT-3?]
I am impressed though nobody dared to guess in 2 weeks.
I don't really understand why we're trying so hard to build models that can generate coherent texts based on having predigested only other texts, without any other experience of reality. Their capabilities appear already superhuman in their ability to imitate styles and patterns of any kind (including code generation, images, etc.). It feels like we're overshooting our target by trying to solve an unsolvable problem, that of deriving the semantics of reality from pure text, without any other type of input.
You can also publish a lot of nonsense in certain chinese journals that optimize for quantity in quality, in whatever field you want.
Some say this has already happened. Nobody has ever seen the Social Text editors and Mochizuki in the same room together, have they?
This kills the forum.
Seriously, once this is weaponised, discussion of politics on the internet with strangers becomes completely pointless instead of just mostly pointless. You could potentially convince a human; you can't convince a neural net that isn't in learning mode.
We might end up with reputation based conversations.
That could have consequences for their reputation, though.
(Reputation is a lot more controversial and complicated than it sounds)
Quite the opposite, I suspect.
Eventually, to engage in the most persuasive conversations, the AIs will develop a real-time learning mode.
Once that is weaponised, the AIs will be on track to be in charge of running things, or at least greatly influencing how things are run.
What the AIs "think" will matter, if only because people will be listening to them.
Then it will be really important to discuss politics with the AIs.
The result is that worthwhile public discussion is dying. We have to transition now to secure verified communication.
Either that or the bots fork off a new cultural discourse and we treat them like a new form of entertainment.
GPT-3 isn't AGI, but it's weapons-grade in a way that GPT-2 wasn't.
I guessed it was fake before getting to the end, not from the content, but from the fact that all the sentences are roughly the same length and follow the same basic grammatical patterns. Real people purposely mix up their sentence structure in order to keep the readers engaged, whereas this wasn't doing that at all. Still very impressive though; if not for the fact that the post was about computer generated content I probably wouldn't have noticed.
Lots of examples I've seen have phrases like "see table below". Of course there's no table and it's hard to imagine how there could be.
But GPT is trained on internet content and the internet is full of terrible writing that never gets to the point. I doubt there's any way to know how much is "not actually understanding the subject matter" vs. "learning bad writing from bad writers". I'm inclined to believe the majority is the former but there's got to be a little of the latter sprinkled in.
One thing I learned was it has detailed knowledge of the world of Avatar: The Last Airbender, seemingly through fanfics. It was fun having it to teach me the lost arts of pizzabending ("form your hands into the shape of a letter 'P'" and so on, and needing to practice by juggling rubber pizzas) and beetlebending ("always remember that to beetle bend it helps to like beetles," my wise uncle suggested). Each of these tended to precipitate a narrative collapse.
The writing style was surprisingly homogeneous, and it reminded me of young adult novels. It would definitely be interesting to see it with other writing styles, beyond the occasional old poetry.
> The man walks away and starts undressing. You shrug and keep following him. Soon, you find yourself naked.
So this morning he heard about an animal, it was kind of a lion. But with bat's ears, it lives in Africa. It looks like it's a rock, but it's actually not, it's rock shaped but has tiny legs. And it's gray and hard. Its face... It doesn't really have a face. It lives up in trees where it eats bamboo and apples. It has these huge fangs like sabertooth tigers, you know?
It's glorious.
My smallest kid has a habit of telling stories about himself that actually come from whatever he heard recently, e.g. "once I was Godzilla..", or claims about things in reality that come from stories or misunderstandings all mixed up "did you know, there are three pigs, but they are not pigs, they are wolves and a hunter came and killed them but they weren't wolves they were dragons..."
It's actually very GPT-3-ish now that I think of it.
Maybe. Right now this reads like a glorified shopping list. It's coherent, but actually sounding human also requires a theory of mind.
E.g. I explain here why it's possible for written statements to be objectively insightful, informative, interesting, or funny, but objectively in a way that's relational to other information or beliefs. The implication being that statements are only going to seem subjectively funny or insightful (or whatever) to others who have that knowledge or those beliefs, which means that you can't reliably create those subjective experiences in a reader without having some sort of theory of mind for them.
I guess you can create content that's funny or insightful relative to that content itself, but that's not especially useful. It's entertaining at the time, but the experience is more like seeing a movie that you laugh a lot during but then leave and are kind of like what was the point? It's an empty experience because it wasn't transformative.
I definitely don't think it's impossible, but I also don't think it's a matter of just adding a couple more if-else statements.
https://alexkrupp.typepad.com/sensemaking/2010/06/how-writin...
I'm going to call this goalpost shifting. This article is better writing than some % of humans, theory of mind or otherwise. The AI has comfortably surpassed Timecube-level writing and is entering the pool of passes-for-a-human.
'Sounds human' is a spectrum that starts with the mentally ill and goes up to the best writers in human history.
That's completely fair. On the other hand, without a theory of mind it can't really educate or inspire people, the only thing it can do is maybe trick them about the authorship of something. But once people learn the techniques for identifying this kind of writing, it can't even do that anymore. To me this is like the front end of something, but it still needs a back end.
Don't get me wrong, it's super cool research and seems like a huge step forward, and I'm excited to see where it goes. But I also don't see this AI running a successful presidential campaign or whatever, at least within the next couple years.
And that got me thinking about what I could do with this thing, whether I should, what I wanted to try out...
So the BS random ideas were still inspiring a bit.
I wouldn't agree with that, either. How often have we heard of someone gaining useful insights by considering ideas that were misapplied or just plain wrong? Entire branches of physics have evolved that way. As far as successful presidential campaigns are concerned... well, let's not even go there.
If there's such a thing as a 'theory of mind', it applies to the reader, not the writer.
For example, I delayed in writing this comment because the cat was on my lap, and I couldn't fit the laptop and the cat both. You get that. I know you do, even if you don't own a cat, and even if you're reading this on a phone or a desktop.
GPT-3 does not understand about the cat. To GPT-3, they're just words and phrases that occur in the vicinity of each other with certain probability distributions. As a result, it can't write something and know that there's something there in your mind for it to connect to.
Cyc would handle the bit about the cat differently. It would ask "Did you mean cat-the-mammal, cat-the-Caterpillar-stock-symbol, or cat-the-ethernet-cable-classification?" It has categories, and some notion of which words fit in each category, but it still doesn't understand what's going on.
But you the human understand, because you have a lap, and you've at least seen a cat on a lap.
You really think GPT-3 never came across a comment about a cat in lap? 50% of all the pictures on the internet are cats sitting on people. GPT-3 doesn't need to understand it to echo this common knowledge.
Airplanes don't look like birds at all but they do fly.
I would like to see a GPT model where training data is weighted by credibility / authority (e.g. using Pagerank).
What if the ultimate theory of mind turns out to be that consciousness is an illusion and nothing separates us from a sufficiently sophisticated markov process.
Conscious experience would still exist (see cogito ergo sum, Chalmers, etc). If we were to be shown we're just Markov processes, that wouldn't disprove the existence of conscious experience. Just like confabulation, a misleading experience is still an experience.
What it would disprove is any sense of agency.
I certainly do, don't you? When I read a blog post and it's full of poorly-integrated buzzwords that make it seem like it was churned out by a non-English speaker being paid very poorly per word, I stop reading and move on.
I recently read a few pages of a book someone had recommended to me and stopped reading because of the writing style.
Heck, you can read a few pages of, say, a Dan Brown novel, and based on the writing style might choose not to read it, since the style tells you a lot about the kind of book it is.
That said, the content of the computer-generated parts doesn't make much sense even for a Bitcoin-influenced article (what would be the point of paraphrasing your previous post in a forum on a regular basis, and how does this not get one very quickly banned?), but the grammar is far far better than previous attempts - it reads like Simple English wiki.
It sounds to me like you must be an academic, or someone with good habits for being efficient at reading articles.
I agree, responses are almost as interesting as GPT-3. And this place has always felt like one of the better when it comes to people reading past the titles!
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/348vlx/what_bot_...
* GPT-3 is trained on one
However that makes one wonder if it can also learn to generate emphases, and if so, how would it format? With voice generation it can simply change its tonality but with text generation it has to demarcate it in some way--does the human say "format the output for html", for instance?
I agree. The environment - as the source of learning and forming concepts, is the key ingredient of consciousness, not the brain.
Basically the brain and "consciousness" isn't as fancy as we think?
I currently work on synbio × web archival.
Some of us are cooking up futuretech aimed at storing all of IA (archive.org) in a shoebox. Others are working on putting archival tools in more normal web users' hands, and making those tools do things that people tend to value more in the short-term, like help them understand what they're researching, rather than merely stash pages.
My ambitions for web archives are outsized compared to other archivists, but I'm fine with that. I'm looking beyond web archives as we currently understand them toward web archives as something else that doesn't quite exist yet: everyday artefacts, colocated and integrated with other web technology to an extent that they serve in essential sensemaking, workflow, and maybe security roles.
Right now, some obvious, pressing priorities are (a) preserving vastly more content and (b) doing more with the archives themselves.
A: The overwhelming majority of born-digital content is lost within a far narrower time-slice than would admit preservation at current rates, and data growth is accelerating beyond the reach of conventional storage media. So, for me, the world's current largest x is never the true object of my desire. I'm after a way to hold the world that is and the world to come.
Ideally, that world to come is one where lifelong data stewardship of everything from your own genome to your digital footprint is ubiquitously available and loss of information has been largely rendered optional.
This, of course, requires magic storage density that simply defies fundamental limitations of conventional storage media. I'm strongly confident that we're getting early glimpses of the first real Magic contenders. All lie outside, or on the far periphery of, the evolutionary tree that got us the storage media we have today. For instance, I'm running an art exhibition that involves encoding all the works on DNA.
B: Distributed archival that comes almost as naturally as browsing is well within reach, and with that comes some very new potential for distributed computation on archives. One hand washes the other.
One important thing to realize here is that, in many cases, you can name a very small handful of individuals as the reason why current archival resources exist. GPT-3 is cracking the surface by training on data produced by one guy named Sebastian, for instance.
…i'm sorta tired and have to respond to something about every twitter snapshot since June being broken, though, so I'll pick this back up later.
I could use… what's the word? I think it's more funding.
But you are right, it can't be both in the context of this article :)
Now, I’m not so sure :)
Saying that, I briefly saw the first sentence of your comment and went to read the article with the idea that trickery was afoot, specifically guessing correctly the nature of the article. And yet, even then, on the back foot... it fooled me. Incredible.
It was relatively good, although I began to suspect it was GPT3 generated about halfway through (partially because the style felt a bit stiff but also just out of a shayamalan-what-a-twist 6th sense of mine that was tingling)
I agree with you. I suspect few people have read until the end to realize that, in fact, ...
I then reread it and it indeed read like a weird, rambling, incoherent article. Looking at it closely, it had a good many contradictory, meaningless and incoherent sentences.("It is a popular forum with many types of posts and posters.")
The headline, however, seemed about right.
It's true the nonsense in this article is a bit different than the nonsense of a GPT-2 article. But the thing GPT-2 paragraphs sound pretty coherent 'till they suddenly go off the rail. This is more like an article that was never quite on the rails and so it's slightly more internally cohesive. But not "better".
Maybe the article just reflects the author's style. Anyone have a GPT-3 test site link?
Having read to the bottom, the quality of text generation there absolutely blew me away. GPT-2 texts have a somewhat disconnected quality - "it only makes sense if you're not really paying attention" - that this article lacks entirely. Adjacent sentences and even paragraphs are plausible neighbours. Even on re-reading more closely, it doesn't feel like the world's best writing, but I don't notice major loss of coherence until the last couple of paragraphs. I am now really curious about the other 9 attempts that were thrown away. Are they always this good?!
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canary_trap#Barium_meal_test