News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by nostrademons on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:28PM (#23823933)
There's a pretty key quote in here and an attendant logical fallacy:

"If five years from now everyone in the world has become a bitcoin user, that could only be because something very very bad has happened to the regular monetary system ... Surely no bitcoiner would actually want such a dark future."

That statement is absolutely true, as a conditional. But the logical fallacy it represents is "If X happens, that would be unthinkably bad. Therefore, X will not happen." (Similar thinking is behind coronavirus-denial and climate-change denial.)

I think that most hardcore Bitcoin aficionados (the group that's still in it, even now that the bubble has burst and you can't get rich off of it) would accept the above premise. If Bitcoin becomes successful, something seriously bad has happened to the monetary system.

The difference is that most hardcore Bitcoin investors also accept the premise that something seriously bad is going to happen to the monetary system. There's a very heavy overlap between folks who hodl Bitcoin and folks who believe that the Fed is going to continue to debase the dollar, we'll get hyperinflation, the government will collapse, and we'll all end up pledging allegiance to a variety of crypto-anarchist communes that conduct commerce through cryptocurrency. Many of them also include guns, stockpiles, and bug-out bunkers in their contingency planning. If you accept that premise, the goal is not "How do I get rich?", it's "How do I minimize the impact of this collapse to myself and give myself a leg up in the post-collapse world?"

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by harryh on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:43PM (#23824116)
You know what's definitely going to be valuable in a post collapse world where people are making heavy use of bug-out bunkers stashed with food and guns? A digital currency that requires a sophisticated global computer network to function.

Ya. That makes a lot of sense.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by cft on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:33PM (#23825286)
In Argentinian or Russian style currency defaults the computer networks continued to function. We are talking about the dollar no longer being the world reserve currency here, not a total societal collapse. It will happen when a more attractive alternative is found by the global markets.

Currently the excess dollars created are absorbed by the foreign economies. This keeps the US from inflation caused by this creation. For example, Brazil has to buy dollars with its goods to then use them for purchases of IT equipment from China. At some point Brazil and China will find a direct medium of exchange.

Here is what Ray Dalio has to say: https://youtu.be/7WxfQ2zKXeA?t=1076

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by martinald on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:01PM (#23826063)
This idea has been going on for literally decades, with no real progress. Iran started allowing Euro trades for oil (keep in mind the EU imports way way more oil than the US) in 2003. Result = everyone still trades oil in dollars.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by cft on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:15PM (#23826174)
The first effect maybe that the increasing dollar creation rate needed to sustain the functioning of American economy may exceed the ability of foreign countries to absorb them.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by three_seagrass on Monday July 13, 2020 @07:49PM (#23827006)
This is just more of the usual "The Fed has really done it this time and here comes it's inevitable collapse".

There will likely be inflation but it's considered better than the alternative right now which is stagflation.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by shadowgovt on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:31PM (#23826336)
The space between "The dollar is no longer the world's reserve currency" and "total societal collapse" is very narrow, given how many countries rely on the dollar to back-stop their own currencies.

I think there's a decent risk that in the interim, people run out of money to pay for telecommunications links and BTC-farming datacenters.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by zxcmx on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:18PM (#23824491)
A more charitable approach would be to consider that bitcoin and "bug out bags" can be things you have for separate or related contingencies.

We live in wonderfully complex societies and history shows us there are a lot of failure modes well short of apocalypse.

To be clear I'm not a "bug out bag" kind of person but I do believe that some disaster preparation is useful. I also believe that there's a modest chance of serious financial turmoil in the medium to long term future.

Bitcoin is likely to hold some value in the event of a localised financial collapse.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by bioipbiop on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:50PM (#23824878)
What’s the advantage of bitcoin against holding a diversified bundle of global equities or foreign currency in the event of a localised financial collapse?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Taek on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:20PM (#23825182)
Bitcoin can be sent and received anywhere in the world needing no than a raspi's worth of computing power.

Not many banking hoops to jump through, sanctions aren't at play, very difficult / impossible for a non-superpower country to exert control.

Greece and Venezuela are both recent examples of countries where people who owned Bitcoin faired substantially better than their peers who did not.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by tim58 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:32PM (#23826343)
Did people in Greece and Venezuela fair substantially better than peers that had holdings of multiple foreign currencies?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by DarthGhandi on Monday July 13, 2020 @09:24PM (#23827573)
Yes, easily, though the crisis in Greece started about the same time Bitcoin was created and lasted a few years after that.

The capital appreciation on this basket of global currencies has not moved an inch, interest rates worldwide are even lower today.

Meanwhile BTC has averaged 250% gains annually.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by dharma1 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:57PM (#23825481)
Not necessarily anything, but collapse of the dollar would have systemic impact, it wouldn't localised. And I suppose there is always some counter party risk with bank accounts or brokerage accounts, unless you hold the gold - or private keys
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by bioipbiop on Monday July 20, 2020 @09:18PM (#23903507)
Why would bitcoin be spared this systemic impact?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by wglb on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:01PM (#23824974)
I am trying to imagine how you can fit bitcoin in a bugout bag.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by pps43 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:15PM (#23825115)
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by wglb on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:19PM (#23825166)
My (poorly worded) point is that without the internet, bitcoins in your bag don't have any immediate value.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by pps43 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:27PM (#23825242)
One can expect the internet to eventually come back, maybe even in form of ham radio (in a post-apocalyptic world there would not be FCC to enforce ban on encryption).
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by shadowgovt on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:33PM (#23826349)
Of course, in a post-apocalyptic world there would also not be an FCC to enforce bans on signal jamming...
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by murrayn on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:35PM (#23826383)
The bitcoin protocol isn't encrypted. You can use the protocol over Ham radio as it is now.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by pixelperfect on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:13PM (#23824445)
The world reserve currency can collapse without all of society collapsing to the extent you are suggesting.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Taek on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:17PM (#23825147)
One of the things that makes Bitcoin so interesting is that you don't actually need that much sophistication to keep it going. In theory you should be able to run all of Bitcoin on a bunch of raspi's connected to HAM radio towers. As long as you can get blocks around the world, those raspi's should be enough to keep it running.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by croddin on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:47PM (#23825391)
If the bitcoin network were ever reduced to that, there would be significant risk of a dedicated miner coming online being able to do a 50% attack.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by thinkloop on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:23PM (#23826252)
Why? If the attacker can get that much hash then so can the miners.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by qes on Monday July 13, 2020 @07:14PM (#23826734)
> In theory you should be able to run all of Bitcoin on a bunch of raspi's

If suddenly the computing power available in the world was reduced to a bunch of raspi's, the Bitcoin network would be dead because it would take an inordinately long amount of time to reach the next difficulty adjustment. Only a hard fork could survive.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Darvon on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:53PM (#23824899)
There's a few pretty far along mesh network projects that are designed to keep internet/crypto functional over portable radio networks.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by tw04 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:22PM (#23825194)
And you think the average non-technical person is going to trust that over... trading for actual goods like food/fuel/livestock? On what planet does the government-backed virtual currency fail and then non-technical people suddenly trust a darknet currency backed by... imaginary computer algorithms that they don't understand and don't want to understand?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by WanderPanda on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:45PM (#23825382)
Its not like all people understand the monetary system. If something works over some period people will build trust and use it
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by muzika on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:32AM (#23828841)
Some day every phone may have a bitcoin “wallet” that connects to nearby towers using the phones antennas. Everything will “just work” as far as regular users are concerned. You would be able to pay for good just by scanning a QR code on the other party’s phone, for example.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by mintone on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:22PM (#23825202)
I would imagine that that the point is less the practicalities of how it would than exist rather that commodities will become (as they always have done) the mechanism of trade. Before there was money there was just normal trade. In apocalypse land who are you going to let into your group of survivors, the guy with 10,000 bitcoin on a usb stick or the guy with 10ton of rice?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by tim58 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:35PM (#23826374)
The neat thing about 10,000 bitcoins is that it can exist in your pocket.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by csomar on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:26PM (#23824594)
> A digital currency that requires a sophisticated global computer network to function.

That's stretching it a bit. While Bitcoin looks sophisticated to the average Joe, it is actually a very simple protocol and require very little bandwidth. It's possible to run mining operations from all over the world on very limited connection (in fact you might need to connect only a few times per day). Processing transactions also consume very little bandwidth.

The crypto-folks have come up with something for you: https://blockstream.com/satellite/

So now even if your local infrastructure burned, you can still transact in bitcoin. Granted, there should be some guys somewhere doing the mining to ensure that the network is secure enough.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by three_seagrass on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:31PM (#23824651)
They're not saying that bitcoin is sophisticated (it's not), but the entire backbone of the internet is.

In some post-apocalyptic dystopia, people aren't going to be using their phones and laptops to make payments with bitcoin, they're going to use whatever is backed by the local authority.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by nostrademons on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:43PM (#23824795)
Mesh networks over HAM radio, to tie it back to the article. ;-)
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by three_seagrass on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:54PM (#23824913)
That requires electricity, which is spotty in a dystopia. Best to stick to encrypted smoke signals.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by zelly on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:53PM (#23824901)
Ham radio fixes Bitcoin
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by csomar on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:36PM (#23824719)
Venezuela/Brazil/North-Africa disagrees with this.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by three_seagrass on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:38PM (#23824752)
Over half the transactions in Venezuela are in US Dollar cash now, not Bolivar or Bitcoin. That's not an example of a dystopia switching to Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by bioipbiop on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:57PM (#23824938)
Do you think those satellites stay in their proper orbit without any intervention? Do you suppose they will not need to be replace? Starlinks, for instance, will have a life span of 5 years. Further, do you suppose people will expend precious energy powering mining rigs rather than cooking food and lighting their mud huts?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by 0x0 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:05PM (#23826094)
I am struggling to imagine a bitcoin mining operation going anywhere without connecting at least once per minute, lest its tiny share of global hashpower is entirely wasted on futile progress on outdated side chains.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by dpc_pw on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:26PM (#23826279)
You can passively listen to new blocks via satellite or ham radio. You only ever need to connect actively to broadcast your own blocks.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by 0x0 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:32PM (#23826346)
Without global connectivity providing the opportunity to cross-check a sampling of independent nodes' ideas of the latest blocks, this sounds like a loser's game. Either you need a million independent satellites and HAM stations in range, or you are just begging to be spoon-fed malicious and/or outdated blockchain data. No way any mining operation can be competitive in such an environment.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by j2kun on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:37PM (#23824743)
Bartering would be far simpler, given the certainty that if the US financial system collapses, the impact on the effective price of bitcoin would make it unusable for practical matters.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:40AM (#23828582)
I think that most hardcore Bitcoin aficionados (the group that's still in it, even now that the bubble has burst and you can't get rich off of it)

Um… you do know Bitcoin is up 75% since mid-March, right? You certainly could haven gotten rich from that [1].

There doesn't have to be catastrophic collapse… the US government is doing devaluing the dollar all on its own. The dollar has lost 40% of its value since 1985 and 80% since 1970 [2].

And now with COVID-19, we’re printing trillions of dollars to keep the country and the global economy afloat. The pandemic is out of control in large chunk of the US; we're hitting new daily infection rates nearly everyday.

If you look at the big picture, we're experiencing a slow-motion economic collapse. The Fed and the other central banks are trying to land this 747 without crashing while the plane is on fire and and the equipment ain't working so good.

Meanwhile, the only asset that can't be manipulated or inflated is Bitcoin and that's going to be looking pretty good once we land… remember, any landing you can walk away from is a good one.

[1]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-06-12/jpmorgan-...

[2]: https://seekingalpha.com/article/137051-the-dollars-20th-cen...

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by xiphias2 on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:22PM (#23824545)
,,If Bitcoin becomes successful, something seriously bad has happened to the monetary system.''

I'm a hardcore Bitcoin believer, and I believe something similar, although not exactly the same:

Something seriously bad happened to the monetary system (in 1971), therefore I believe Bitcoin will become successful (in the next 10-20 years).

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:50PM (#23824877)
As a bitcoin believer, what do you think about Tether, and the reports that the run-up of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies in 2017 was essentially due to price manipulation via the injection of billions of dollars worth of faked value into the system?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by lmpostor on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:27PM (#23826293)
Tether is probably not backed 1:1, but at the same time I believe it is closer to 1:1 than it is to 0:1 just because the entity that runs it is literally a money-printing machine (Bitfinex is extraordinarily profitable) and there is evidence for some large quantity of people using Tether (they had 500m seized no?)

End of the day imo crypto is still a small fish when we look at the absolute numbers comparative to stocks. Manipulation is expected to a certain degree but I still lean towards a positive correlation in perceived value and price. Also I believe it is treated the same as every other market, fake it until you make it or implode.

I mean I view it very much like Tesla in that in only gets is value from the "possible end state", but the reality is that BTC doesn't need much capital in the schema of the financial world to multiple even at current levels.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by xiphias2 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:02PM (#23826068)
The best explanation for the timings of the bubbles that I know of is the stock to flow model by PlanB (which suggests that the next one is coming soon, as Bitcoin is getting almost as valuable as gold, and in 5 years more valuable as a scarce store of value).

Regarding Tether I think the amount of Tether is really manipulated (and not 100% backed by real USD), but that Bitcoin's 2017 bubble has nothing to do with that. To me it was similar to previous bubbles that I experienced, with similar rollercoaster feelings (though I was much calmer and was much more used to it).

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by marcell on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:24PM (#23825730)
Not OP, but I would say:

(1) Tether is largely orthogonal to bitcoin. It's a way to trade USD more quickly over the internet, which isn't really related to bitcoin, besides the underlying technology is similar.

(2) I don't know much about the 2017 run-up in terms of price manipulation. I think Ethereum was more impacted than bitcoin, but of course both experienced price surges and crashes. Is there any public info available on this?

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by amznthrwaway on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:51PM (#23825975)
Tether is largely used to run pump scams on BTC. It's other uses are marginal at best.

It is common for Coiners to remain willfully ignorant about the price manipulation, because y'all don't want to admit how small, fragile, and wildly corrupt your ecosystem is.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by marcell on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:34PM (#23826360)
I'm just not clear on how Tether usage specifically increases the bitcoin price. My understanding is it's used to transfer money between exchanges, and possibly to fund ICO's. Neither of those really lead to an increased bitcoin price.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @09:52AM (#23831944)
It goes something like this:

1. Tether was announced as a "USD equivalent" - i.e. 1 tether == 1 USD which would be deposited somewhere in a bank accouont

2. Billions of dollars worth of tether were created with no USD backing, injecting fake value into the system

3 These tethers were used to buy BTC, thereby giving an artificial value to BTC since it was assumed thes BTC/Tether transactions could be treated as BTC/USD transactions.

Essentially a lot of fake demand was created for BTC, thereby inflating the price massively, and luring retail investors to spend real money for BTC since they saw it as a rapidly appreciating asset.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by marcell on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:06PM (#23834605)
That makes sense, but is there evidence this is actually happening?

I think for this chain of logic to be true, there would have to be cases of people attempting to convert Tether into USD, and failing. That did happen with Mt Gox, so it’s certainly possible.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:29PM (#23835790)
There is a credible study[0] on the subject.

But your condition does not have to hold for this manipulation to work. Assuming Bitfinex made billions of real dollars in this scheme, they could easily cover the liquidity of cashing out anyone who wants to exchange Tether for USD.

[0]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/large-bitcoin-player-manipulate...

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by marcell on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:23PM (#23838785)
Interesting. If the study is indeed correct, and half the previous run-up to ~$20k was due to Tether, then the market has since correct as the price is a little below half that value. Of course there have been a lot of ups/downs since then, with bitcoin hitting as low as $5k recently.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @01:05AM (#23841552)
I mean, the fact that the price of this asset has been heavily manipulated in the past and the price has since come down a bit would not be evidence that there is not still manipulation happening, or that the price has reached it's "fair market value"
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by mD5pPxMcS6fVWKE on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:58AM (#23828987)
Except there was no faked value injected anywhere, all tethers are 100% backed by USD in the bank. The reports are fake news. If it were not so, the freely traded tether/USD value would be below 1, but it isn't, it's traded at exactly 1.
[dead]
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by mD5pPxMcS6fVWKE on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @01:05PM (#23848117)
This is extremely flawed reasoning, and I'm sad to see a comment of this low quality on HN. Tether's valuation is based on free market trade. If an insider knew they are not 100% backed, he has a billion dollars incentive to short the trade and then drop the bomb. However that has not happened.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by narrator on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:39PM (#23824762)
"That statement is absolutely true, as a conditional. But the logical fallacy it represents is "If X happens, that would be unthinkably bad. Therefore, X will not happen." (Similar thinking is behind coronavirus-denial and climate-change denial.)"

This is called "Appeal to Consequences"

"Appeal to consequences, also known as argumentum ad consequentiam (Latin for "argument to the consequence"), is an argument that concludes a hypothesis (typically a belief) to be either true or false based on whether the premise leads to desirable or undesirable consequences."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_consequences

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by netcan on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:09PM (#23825050)
I agree with you, but I don't think the author made a "therefore, X will not happen" claim, at least not a strong one.

The ham radio analogy is quite good, up to a point. Bitcoin as an alternative, backup technology kept alive by enthusiasts. When disaster strikes, bitcoin will be there. It has a good sized market cap. There are some services. It could be used to pay for things or get your salary, it just isn't today because regular money. No need for ham radio while cellphones work, unless you're an enthusiast with your own reasons.

I also think he has a point about narrative. Ham radio is ready to step up when disaster strikes. Bitcoin is ready to cash in. Make what you will of this normatively, but there's truth in the comparison.

Where the analogy breaks down (and where I agree with you) is what happens next. Monetary systems have a history of collapsing, and then being constituted under new rules. Progress, such as it is, proceeds from one disaster to the next. Whether that's currency pegs, gold standard, whatever. Change happens in the wake of failure. If Bitcoin can be such a change, it will need an appropriate disaster.

I do think it's worth examining narratives. Bitcoin has carried a heavy payload of narrative since day one. One such narrative was an organic, "disruption" trajectory. Bitcoin would gradually be adopted for transactions and build up. Maybe online shopping. Maybe remittances. There was much discussion of the roles of money: denomination, value transfer, etc. Bitcoin had a disintermediation narrative, potentially replacing CCs, retail banks and demonopolizing the space. Are these narratives still relevant?

In retrospect, bitcoin's first decade narrative is "speculation." That's what drove interest, market cap, enthusiasm & price. Most users don't need a bitcoin wallet, they just their bank to make it an investable asset like an etfs.

Other than making bitcoin owner rich, what does bitcoin want, these days?

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:57AM (#23828672)
Short answer: lots of people wanted Bitcoin to be decentralized PayPal… but those people lost.

Bitcoin is a store of value; it's base money. It's the rainy day stash for when things go to shit. Not necessary a global economic collapse but bad nonetheless.

Here's a rational prodcast description of the store of money vs. payment rails: https://stephanlivera.com/episode/185/

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by tw04 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:19PM (#23825163)
>The difference is that most hardcore Bitcoin investors also accept the premise that something seriously bad is going to happen to the monetary system.

If something seriously bad happens to the monetary system what on earth makes you think bitcoin will even be a thing? If civilization collapses, who is going to keep the electricity flowing? What on earth makes you think anarchists won't attack that first? Without electricity, what use is bitcoin?

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by harikb on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:33PM (#23823999)
There is a way for people who have imagination like you to get rich in the current world though - turn this into a Netflix movie or series :)
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by BbzzbB on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:56PM (#23825475)
I'm not a crypto aficionado, but BTC is back to 10k USD which isn't that much worse then individual stocks going thru hard times (albeit very volatile against broad stock indexes). The balloon has deflated but it's far from being to the ground (albeit it did achieve scary lows for bagholders, which could be said of many riskier assets and stocks).
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by cmoscoso on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:51PM (#23825968)
I experienced hyperinflation and the government did not collapse nor did the population become anarchist, just poorer.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by RichardHeart on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:12PM (#23825642)
You said: "can't get rich on it anymore" All of Bitcoins bubble bursts have been great opportunities. So far Bitcoin has been up 2,000,000x from $0.01. Yet it's dripped 94.29%, 93.7%, 80.91%, 86.08%, 84.07% and 71.51% in 10 years.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:32AM (#23828843)
It's up 75% since mid-March of 2020; you certainly could get rich from that.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @01:34AM (#23841710)
It's generally easy to find two time points for a volatile asset with a wide price disparity. You could also get rich playing roulette, but to do so reliably would require some mechanism for predicting future values.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by devalgo on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:21PM (#23824532)
What's the minimum number of bitcoin nodes needed for it to continue operating and is it reasonable to think that post collapse that many PCs will remain online?

Seems unlikely to me.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by friendzis on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:39PM (#23824755)
Minimum? 1.

That is, however, not the problem. The problem is that in the event of sudden loss of significant fraction of compute power block times skyrocket, because significantly reduced compute power still has to solve problem of previous difficulty. As a consequence block times become so high that transactions are effectively blocked and the only solution to keep the network functional is a fork. Unless you imagine a scenario where everyone goes offline except for a small group and everyone slowly reconnects to the small group, most likely there would be highly partitioned network with its own bitcoin fork with enough of transaction history that a reconnect would mean collapse of local-economy.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by hanniabu on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:42PM (#23824783)
The difficulty will adjust for the reduced compute power
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by friendzis on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:59PM (#23824948)
1. Block times adjust, but there is an upper limit to adjustment per block. Low-pass filter, sort of. 2. In the event of compute power loss, prior to adjustment you still have to mine blocks of previous difficulty. 3. In the event of compute power loss, block times increase and there is no other solution than to wait it out or fork. 4. In the event of sudden and significant compute power loss block times increase to such a level that running the network under previous difficulty and waiting it out becomes impractical, therefore the only practical solution is a fork.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by ulrikrasmussen on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:47PM (#23824849)
AFAIK it adjusts after a fixed number of blocks have been mined. So if 99.999% of your compute power is gone, you won't be mining enough blocks to adjust the difficulty for a very long time.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by monokh on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:54PM (#23824905)
The adjustment happens every 2 weeks. It's unlikely that miners would go offline simultaneously across the globe to the extent that it would completely grind the network to a halt.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by 0x0 on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:12PM (#23826146)
No, the adjustment happens every 2016 blocks. If you lose 99.99% of global hash rate, those 2016 blocks will take a million years, instead of two weeks, to compute.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by monokh on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:13AM (#23829058)
Good point, I had taken the mechanism for granted.

So the scenario is that miners drop off at a pace where you don't reach the next adjustment?

Taking that into account, the "mining death spiral" theory doesn't seem too far fetched? In bad circumstances, if the network drops a substantial amount of hash rate early in the adjustment, and price took a hit, you could see some major disruption from the miners following suit.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by sv0 on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:59PM (#23828388)
It will take about 400 years to adjust difficulty in such case, but not a million years.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by hanniabu on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:55PM (#23826569)
Like Unbreakablecoin lmao
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by dragonwriter on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:16PM (#23826181)
> The adjustment happens every 2 weeks.

...assuming very slow change in hash rate, yes. A rapid increase makes it happen sooner, a rapid loss can stretch it out.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by monokh on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:35PM (#23824711)
2 powered raspberry pis and a moderately functioning internet is the answer.

The network adjusts it's requirement for power based on the total power thrown at it. This is called "difficulty adjustment". Beyond total world collapse that would set society back a century, I cannot imagine a scenario where you couldn't continue running Bitcoin as long as a few people had the motivation.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Sebb767 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:15PM (#23825119)
If they had the motivation, yes. However, why would the have the motivation instead of simply using well-known limited physical currencies, such as cigarettes, gold etc? Especially since you'd need to make the money using power and if power is sparse, you'd probably need the bit you get for refrigeration or cooking.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by exdsq on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:49PM (#23824865)
Solar flare?
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by drtillberg on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:46PM (#23825390)
If the hypothetical crisis divides up the Internet so, for example, U.S. users only can connect to U.S. nodes, and connect to U.S. miners -- and the same is true for Iceland and China and South Africa etc., it would become extremely perilous to trade value for the currency anywhere in the world, right? Because the geographically-separate chains cannot synchronize in any reasonable way.

A breakdown of the Internet by geography is definitely a crisis that should be on radar screens, and it wouldn't require anything like a total societal breakdown.

Then HAM TOR and whatever else would become essential to keep the network stable.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:29AM (#23828826)
If the hypothetical crisis divides up the Internet so, for example, U.S. users only can connect to U.S. nodes, and connect to U.S. miners

You know that's not how TCP/IP works, right? It originally was a defense department research project that had the requirement of surviving a nuclear attack. Unless every undersea cable is severed and every satellite up-link destroyed, the internet will continue to operate in the event something bad happens.

I live in New England; I'm closer to Iceland than I am to California for network purposes.

Every full node has copy of the entire blockchain going back to the genesis block created on January 3, 2009. The blockchain may fork, but the longest chain wins and the majority of the mining power will pick that and bitcoin keeps on going. Full nodes will continue to verify those blocks.

Nearly all miners are in data centers with redundant power and networking, so many of them will stay online. Many of them are using hydroelectricity, so unless rivers stop flowing, most of them should be good to go.

Bitcoin already has a peer-to-peer exchange running on Tor; folks will still be able to exchange Bitcoin for fiat, to the extent that remains useful [1]. I’d imagine the software would be modified to support things other than fiat that would be useful to exchange. With a link-local IPv6 "subnet", you could have thousands of machines on a make-shift mesh network and all you'd need is an uplink to the internet to transact.

[1]: https://bisq.network/

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by steerablesafe on Monday July 13, 2020 @03:14PM (#23824453)
> "If X happens, that would be unthinkably bad. Therefore, X will not happen."

or "If X happens, that would be unthinkably bad. Therefore planning for X is futile."

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by johnrgrace on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:39AM (#23828577)
Could the bitcoin network actually be used by everone in the world in five years? No. At seven transactions per second, and 157,680,000 seconds, the network doesn't have enough capacity in a five year period for every person in north america and europe to do one transaction.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:49AM (#23828637)
No. At seven transactions per second, and 157,680,000 seconds, the network doesn't have enough capacity in a five year period for every person in north america and europe to do one transaction.

There's plenty of capacity to transact via the Lightning Network—over 13,000 nodes and 37,000 channels: https://1ml.com/statistics

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by fossuser on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:37PM (#23824036)
I agree on the fallacy, but arguably that also aligns with some of the HAM radio community?

Maybe this stereotype isn't true, but I thought at least a part of the HAM radio community was preparing for the collapse of civilization/communication networks.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by nostrademons on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:44PM (#23824126)
I think it does apply to much of the HAM radio community. Probably not all though.

Also, their preparedness actually has paid off in past natural disasters - 9/11, Hurricane Katrina, the Andaman Islands tsunami, and Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico all had robust HAM radio community responses.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by NovemberWhiskey on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:07PM (#23826107)
But ham radio is independent of infrastructure, in a way that internet technologies are not.

For HF radio over large distances (hundreds of kms at least), all you need is for the physical properties of the ionosphere to remain constant, and a smallish amount of electrical power.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by usrusr on Monday July 13, 2020 @07:29PM (#23826854)
The preparedness of "I'll be able to help if that situation happens" is a very different kind of preparedness than "I'll be rich if that happens". There may be a few people that are interested in bitcoin for reasons that are similar to those found in HAM radio, but it's impossible to disentangle bitcoin from the associated greed.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Melting_Harps on Monday July 13, 2020 @08:07PM (#23827133)
There are a lot of fallacies in this thread, that I could not address even if I wanted to expend the time, as most HN users are convinced of their belief the equates Bitcoin, and perhaps all of Cryptocurrency, to some nefarious end that challenges their way of Life. All while undermining that some of the prominent people in this Space are Jack Dorsey and the Winklevoss twins, not to mention some other well known VCs.

To that end, I think this is worth challenging:

> I think that most hardcore Bitcoin aficionados (the group that's still in it, even now that the bubble has burst and you can't get rich off of it) would accept the above premise. If Bitcoin becomes successful, something seriously bad has happened to the monetary system.

I'm that 'aficionado' and I disagree with this premise: I do, however, think something has gone terribly wrong with the monetary system; not just in the US but in regards to all fiat currencies for a very long time. There was a time I was proponent of the PM backed State sanctioned systems back in my Mises book thumping days, but I've come to realize that it's just an archaic model and doesn't suit the 21st century model of how commerce is conducted at best, and that Fiat is a system with a disastrous inevitability at worst, which is the most common outcome as most fiat currencies have an average lifespan of 40 years when Nation-States are involved in managing a currency. The Internet has enabled a much larger collective of Humanity to come together than any other time in History, and while that may have some horrible implications (the cesspool that is Social media comes to mind) it also has a large Freedom enhancing component that most cannot actualize as they're limited in finding ways to obtain financial autonomy in doing so, which is why the Internet needs a Native currency irrespective of irrelevant things like Nationality, Gender or political identity.

With that said, I think you're undermining something very significant here, that is, the amount of transactions in global commerce that Square currently handles could all operate on the back-end on Bitcoin's LN for faster settlement, and require less security measures, like payment holdings for those customers deemed 'higher risk.' And this could be further increased as Jack [1] has made a commitment to reside in Africa to address this onboarding challenge.

This is a real usecase, that I personally have very intimate knowledge of as I did Fintech in the Industrial Hemp space and used Bitcoin to overcome the egregious financial censorship they faced before the Farm Bill made Hemp 50 State legal in the US.

Bank account seizures were the norm and having all your savings or operating capital taken from you because of a perceived threat can be entirely mitigated in a system that is fully audited by default, that is to say, you cannot incur the losses of a charge-back scam if/when you swipe your CC for a purchase you're on-boarded onto the LN and you're none the wiser of what just took place as you received your goods-services just as you would with any CC transaction made elsewhere. And this is just one of the benefits of using the LN to transact on, the others being instant settlement times, and near 0 tx fees, as opposed to Main-net costs and transactions settlement times (new block).

I think that is what is likely to happen with Square/CASH, as Jack has been one of the main investors in Lightening Labs. This alone disproves the notion that the World would have had to collapse to achieve the goal that goal--something that has admittedly kept me awake at night, and I have spoken to several developers and entrepreneurs about throughout my time in Bitcoin.

After nearly 9 years in this space, and that time has flown by, I think it's a Crypto Nerd's wet-dream/panacea to think that everyone wants to be their own Bank, or simply be unbanked because those that need it the most are almost entirely unfamiliar with the concept entirely, and they will some how decide to run their own nodes they run on a meshnet based protocol and are using a Blockstream satelite to verify and update the Blockchain with.

It's theoretically possible but entirely unrealistic because its far more time and effort than most people want to expend, and the reality is many would prefer to make MANY compromises to just have system that 'works' without worrying about the mechanics of it all and have the guesswork taken out and have a turn-key solution.

I equate to how people are almost entirely unaware of how an ICE works, or electricity running through the wires runs and powers all of the devices in their homes. It's up to entrepreneurs and engineers to not just create a superior product in this case a monetary system, which I would argue we have had for some time, but also to create an interface that ensures the least amount of friction to onboard the rest of the 'non-initiated,' and I argue we've been in this phase since about 2016 or so.

Bitcoin will have truly succeeded and fulfilled it's true potential for the masses when it's users are entirely unaware they are using it is my new benchmark for success, because for the initiated its already pretty damn seamless from where it was 8-9 years ago if you're already within it and that was just scratching the surface of what it's capable of doing within a very small, albeit determined demographic, which has had significant disruption all over the World already. I'm excited of the World(s) it could create (as Bitcoin remain one of the few viable options for a Multi-planetary monetary system) and is one of the main reasons why I remain optimistic despite all the calamity we see in the World.

1: https://www.cnn.com/2019/11/29/tech/jack-dorsey-africa-futur...

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by alwillis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:48AM (#23828938)
This is probably the most coherent, well thought out post I've read about Bitcoin in a long time.

When I was in high school, to make an icon or a sprite, I had to make what was called a shape table on the Apple II [1].

You had to use graph paper, then translate it to hex and then either use a series of POKE statements to stick it in memory or go into the 6502 monitor, sorta like the command line for entering assembler op codes [2].

Eventually, we got programs that did all of this grunt work for us.

Bitcoin is just leaving the Apple II entering hex op codes by hand phase. Certainly some of the Lightning Network client are quite slick and a lot closer to mainstream fintech apps like Venmo and PayPal. Just for buying and selling Bitcoin, Cash App is great.

There will be a point when all of the bells and whistles Bitcoin offers—n of m multisig, pre-signed transactions, the ability to use mixing services, etc. will be accessible to regular people.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_table

[2]: http://www.easy68k.com/paulrsm/6502/MONREF.HTM

[dead]
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by goblin89 on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:48PM (#23825946)
Whenever I come across the “hate the rich” sentiment (usually expressed in veiled forms, but sometimes not so much), I can’t help but read “I hate the rich and so-called successful people, because if I accept that system that would make me a loser”.

It’s hard to imagine how things would go differently if people who currently possess a lot of capital (social, monetary—quote-unquote “control the world”) get replaced by people who have accumulated a lot of capital in cryptocurrency.

Both enrich their networks (“buying prestige” among their connections), profit off leasing property, would stoop to price gouging, got rich by arbitrary criteria, try to maintain/expand their area of control and paint those who stand in the way as scammers, etc.

The fundamental socioeconomic patterns remain the same. The mere virtue of being affiliated with either type of capital doesn’t say as much about a person as destructive hate towards.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by lmpostor on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:39PM (#23826412)
Great analysis

It's like he forgot that one of the major "features" of cryptocurrency is a quality that proliferates the sphere with scammers.

I say this as someone with a very optimistic outlook, edge case usage is both the pinnacle and the opposite of virtue, we would do well to not forget the dark side.

We need to keep it at "hopefully will solve problems" and leave it at that.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by cryptica on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @11:29AM (#23833083)
>> because if I accept that system that would make me a loser

Exactly. Why would I participate in the mainstream system as a loser when I can be a winner in an alternative system? Especially when that alternative system has more skilled, more hard-working people than the mainstream system.

The mainstream system rejects an alarming number of highly skilled people for arbitrary reasons. There are many cracks to fall through. These people need to join an alternative system which will value their skills and monetize them.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by goblin89 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:30PM (#23834016)
So you want to address those fundamental behavorial pitfalls by coming up with a new system that places you in the small group of rich and in-control?

If some individuals are incapable of seeing the world around them as anything other than losers vs. winners and want to have a way of measuring worth that makes them rank higher, I couldn’t care less—as long as they don’t try impose it on others.

From empirical observation, holding cryptocurrency does not suddenly make people more altruistic, knowledgeable, ethical or anything else positive. It triggers the usual patterns of behavior associated with power and wealth (first of which being “do everything you can to maintain those”).

Of course, most of those currently in possession of significant capital will not have much trouble converting it to any new form that comes along. People who would get hurt are the middle class—folks who do not rule the world, but have things to lose. So, most people.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by rorykoehler on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:34PM (#23824012)
Very good insight. I agree 100%. My hypothesis is that the massive injection of new cash into the stock market during the pandemic response is a foundational play for the end of the US dollar. I'm not sure of the steps between the cash injection and the adoption of cryptocurrency/ies as the de facto currency/ies but I am certain that this is a calculated attempt to debase the US dollar in order to disarm the unprepared and grab power through the creation a right-libertarian techno dystopia. This is exactly the type of play Steve Bannon would make.

FWIW I hold no crypto so I'm not coming at this from the crypto-bro skin in the game angle.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by save_ferris on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:39PM (#23824067)
> but I am certain that this is a calculated attempt to debase the US dollar in order to disarm the unprepared and grab power through the creation a right-libertarian techno dystopia

What makes you think this is more plausible than the Fed printing money to keep millions of people from starving/getting evicted and businesses to stay afloat amid one of the worst financial crises in history?

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by rorykoehler on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:41PM (#23824092)
Because 1) of who got the money and 2) how it was spent. If they were serious about what you describe they'd provide a basic income directly to the people.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by nostrademons on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:46PM (#23824147)
That's kinda what they did - they gave $600/week to every unemployed American, on top of what the state was giving them. Problem was, a lot of it just went into the stock market, and from there into the pockets of wealthy stockholders.
Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by Rallerbabs on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:17PM (#23826184)
Author is trying to convince noone else but himself.

I've added him to my crypto revenge bookmarks, which is full of toxi maxis, salty nocoiners and other crypto nay sayers.

Will taunt in a few decades once bitcoin has successfully eaten the world.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by dnprock on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:40PM (#23825330)
Not all bitcoiners are crazy. The crazy ones will eventually leave Bitcoin. I think Bitcoin can succeed without world collapse. Bitcoin has been a niche currency. The missing piece is adoption. There're proposals to address this problem. Lightning Network is one. But the hype dies down quite a bit.

I think one missing piece is inflation. I focus my effort in this direction. Check out my project:

https://bitflate.org/

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by skohan on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @01:59AM (#23841838)
> The missing piece is adoption

Here's the thing, in 2014 I was playing around a bit with Bitcoin, and at that point adoption seemed better than it is today. I could buy a cup of coffee with it, and many reputable online storefronts were already experimenting with accepting it as payment option. Later, long transaction times and high fees made it almost impossible to actually use BTC as a currency.

My perception is that Bitcoin used to be a serious currency project, but got co-opted by speculators, miners and scammers wishing to use it to accumulate fiat currencies quickly.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by guiomie on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:30PM (#23825791)
I've got a problem lightning, I used to very bullish on the technology, but after trying wallets and reading about, the following make me think it can't succeed:

Easy fiat onboard do not exist, and none seem to be coming. All of them you need to do KYC and interact with the main chain, its super unuser-friendly, or require debit cards.

Taxable events get triggered when transacting with bitcoin. Really hard to manage and a really undesirable side-effect for a consumer.

The need for watch towers and inbound-outbound capacity make the technology hard to understand not usable by mainstream.

The lightning network seems to be heading toward centralization, then what it the point? Is the delta of Credit card transaction fees with lnd fees that big that it warrants it? especially if credit card fees drop with time.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by dnprock on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:20PM (#23826222)
I think there will be centralization on 2nd layers like the Lightning Network. Bitcoin's mainchain is slow. Running full node is expensive. Decentralization comes with tradeoffs.

Lightning tries to live up with Bitcoin's ethos. It's designed with decentralized nodes. We end up with 2 decentralized networks trying to talk to each other. The result is a very complicated 2nd layer. I think centralization can simplify a lot of things. As a user, I don't have a problem with it. Exchanges are already centralized. We just need more options to choose.

I'm excited about 2nd layers. I think they would enable Bitcoin to interact with other technologies. I created Bitflate based on Bitcoin. We can mix Bitflate and Bitcoin to create hybrid coins. Some level of centralization is fine. It's a tradeoff for lower cost and better UX.

Re:Bitcoin is more like ham radio than the early internet by thinkloop on Monday July 13, 2020 @06:34PM (#23826365)
> The lightning network seems to be heading toward centralization, then what it the point? Is the delta of Credit card transaction fees with lnd fees that big that it warrants it? especially if credit card fees drop with time.

There is a massive difference between temporary centralization for convenience vs. fundamental centralization. See email. Gmail basically has the entire market, but that is a world of difference from email being a proprietary private Google protocol. People can switch at any time. If a provider misbehaves they can be abandoned. The users have the power. The same holds for complaints against coinbase, the internet in general, etc.